Here - ArtSites

Transcription

Here - ArtSites
S
trata
Revue d‘histoire des étudiants diplômés de l‘Université d‘Ottawa
University of Ottawa Graduate Student History Review
Volume 3
Septembre 🍁 September
2011
Strata
Revue d‘histoire des étudiants diplômés de
l‘Université d‘Ottawa
University of Ottawa Graduate Student
History Review
Volume 3
Septembre 🍁 September
2011
Département d‘Histoire, Université d‘Ottawa
Department of History, University of Ottawa
Strata
La revue d‘histoire des étudiants diplômés de l‘Université d‘Ottawa
University of Ottawa Graduate Student History Review
c/o Département d‘Histoire / Department of History
Université d‘Ottawa / University of Ottawa
155 Séraphin-Marion
Ottawa, ON K1N 6N5
Canada
http://www.artsites.uOttawa.ca/Strata
[email protected]
ISSN 1918-9540 (En librarie / Print)
ISSN 1918-9567 (Français en ligne)
ISSN 1918-9559 (English Online)
© Strata: La revue d‘histoire des étudiants diplômés de l‘Université d‘Ottawa / University
of Ottawa Graduate Student History Review, 2011
Art de la couverture :
Cover Image:
Vue de côté de la concession du chef Mouktélé de Baldama dans les monts
Mandara du Cameroun. Photo prise le 1er février 2009 par Melchisedek
Chétima.
Side view of the concession of the Baldams‘ headman Mouktélé in the
Mandara Mountains of Cameroon. Photo taken on February 1, 2009 by
Melchisedek Chétima.
Administration
Rédacteur-en-chef
Editor-in-Chief
Aaron Boyes
Soumissions et rédaction français
French Submissions and Editing
Caroline D‘Amours
Soumissions et rédaction anglais
English Submissions and Editing
Sean Graham
Rédactrice des comptes rendu
Book Review Editor
Mira Goldberg-Poch
Directeur des communications
Communications Manager
R. Daniel Pellerin
Comité de rédaction
Editorial Board
Lori Jones, Madeleine Kloske, Erin Luxe
Eric MacDonald, Michael J. Thompson
Comité d‘honneur
Professional Advisory Board
Prof. Damien-Claude Bélanger
Prof. Jeffrey Keshen
Merci beaucoup
Special Thanks
Bureau VP Recherche / Office of the VP Research, Tanya Daley,
Patrick Fournier, Alexandra Goldstein, Deanna Matity, Katie Rollwagen
Table des matières
Table of Contents
———————
Lettre du rédacteur-en-chef
Letter from the Editor.....................................................................................vi
Mission....................................................................................................................viii
Articles
Sources orales et contribution à l‘histoire des peuples
montagnards du Cameroun (Monts Mandara). Une
expérience personnelle de terrain
MELCHISIDEK CHÉTIMA............................................................................1
Synthesizing Current Research: Women‘s Higher Education
and the World Wars
ANNE M. E. MILLAR..................................................................................24
A Difference in Sixteenth-Century French Violence
REX BARNES................................................................................................55
Military Revolutions and Revolutions in Military Affairs:
Accurate Descriptions of Change or Intellectual Constructs?
MICHAEL J. THOMPSON............................................................................82
iv
Not Here by Choice: Canada‘s Importation of Child
Labourers
LORI JONES................................................................................................109
Comptes rendu
Book Reviews
Lynn Abrams, Oral History Theory
KIM MADSEN............................................................................................137
Donica Belisle, Retail Nation: Department Stores and the Making
of Modern Canada
MADELEINE KLOSKE..............................................................................140
Nancy Christie et Michael Gauvreau, Christian Churches and
Their Peoples, 1840–1965: A Social History of Religion in Canada
ÉMILIE PIGEON........................................................................................144
Jonathon Glassman, War of Words, War of Stones: Racial
Thought and Violence in Colonial Zanzibar
ROBERT NATHAN.....................................................................................148
Andrew Rossos, Macedonia and the Macedonians: A History
JULIAN BROOKS........................................................................................151
Andrew Smith, British Businessmen and Canadian Confederation:
Constitution Making in an Era of Anglo-Globalization
MICHAEL COMMITO................................................................................154
v
Lettre du rédacteur-en-chef
—————————————
Chers lecteurs,
C‘est avec plaisir que nous vous présentons le troisième numéro de Strata. À
l‘intérieur, vous y trouverez un vaste choix d‘articles et de comptes rendus de
lecture faisant état de la richesse et de la diversité de la recherche historique au
Canada. Ces articles et comptes rendus sont le résultat du travail d‘étudiants de
partout au Canada et nous en sommes fiers.
Comme à l‘habitude, nous acceptons de nouveaux articles et comptes
rendus de lecture pour le quatrième numéro prévu pour l‘automne 2012. Si vous
êtes intéressés à contribuer à Strata ou si vous êtes intéressés par l‘édition du
périodique, contactez-nous à [email protected]. De plus, visitez notre site web
pour obtenir plus d‘information ainsi qu‘un tour d‘horizon de Strata :
http://artsites.uOttawa.ca/Strata/fr/.
Je voudrais remercier et faire part de mon appréciation à l‘ensemble du
comité d‘édition pour leurs efforts continus et pour leur détermination, qui ont
permis de finaliser ce numéro. Des remerciements sont aussi dus à tous ceux qui
ont contribué pour leur excellent travail. Je voudrais aussi reconnaître la
participation de l‘AEDH de l‘Université d‘Ottawa pour leur support de Strata,
tout particulièrement pendant le colloque Pierre Savard. Enfin, l‘ensemble du
comité voudrait exprimer sa gratitude au Département d‘Histoire qui a permis de
réaliser toute cette entreprise.
Profitez bien comme j‘ai pu le faire de ce troisième numéro de Strata,
Aaron Boyes, MA
Rédacteur-en-chef
Étudiant au doctorat
Département d‘Histoire
Université d‘Ottawa
vi
Letter from the Editor
———————————
Dear readers,
We are pleased to present issue three of Strata. Within this issue is an array of
excellent articles and book reviews that represent the rich diversity of historical
study in Canada. These articles and reviews were received from students from
across Canada, something about which we are delighted.
As always, we are accepting new articles and book reviews for issue four,
due out in Fall 2012. If you are interested in contributing to Strata or would like
some editing experience, please contact us at: [email protected]. Also, please
visit our website for more information and an overview of Strata:
http://artsites.uOttawa.ca/Strata/en/.
I would like to express my appreciation to the entire editorial board for
their hard work and determination in making this issue possible. A much deserved
thank you, as well, to all the contributors for their excellent work. I would also
like to recognize the HGSA at the University of Ottawa for their continued
support of Strata, specifically during the annual Pierre Savard Conference. Finally,
the entire board would like to express its gratitude to the Department of History
for helping to make this possible.
Sit back, relax, and enjoy issue three of Strata; I know I did.
Aaron Boyes, MA
Editor-in-Chief
PhD Student
Department of History
University of Ottawa
vii
Mission
————
Strata est une revue électronique pour les étudiants diplômés, bilingue et dont
les articles sont révisés par les pairs. Cette revue offre une tribune pour un
débat ouvert parmi les historiens de niveau universitaire qui leur permet de
développer des compétences professionnelles par le biais du processus de
publication. Strata est une initiative gérée par des étudiants, avec le soutien du
Département d‘histoire de l‘Université d‘Ottawa, afin d‘offrir une expérience
où il y a des occasions d‘apprendre, de publier, et de se développer à titre de
chercheurs. Strata encourage les discussions et les débats historiques sur un
ensemble de sujets historiques dans les deux langues officielles du Canada. En
collaboration avec le personnel administratif et les évaluateurs étudiants, Strata
s‘efforce d‘aider les étudiants des cycles supérieurs à perfectionner leur art de
présenter intellectuellement des idées et des entretiens stimulants.
🍁
Strata is an online, bilingual, peer-reviewed graduate student journal that
provides a forum for open debate among graduate-level historians which
fosters the development of professional skills through the publishing process.
Strata is a student-run initiative and, with the support of the University of
Ottawa Department of History, provides a peer-focused experience with
opportunities to learn, publish, and develop as scholars. Strata encourages
historical discussions and debates on a variety of historical topics in both of
Canada‘s official languages. In collaboration with the administrative staff and
student reviewers, Strata strives to assist graduate students in perfecting their
craft of presenting intellectually stimulating ideas and conversations.
viii
Articles
————
Sources orales et contribution à l‘histoire des peuples
montagnards du Cameroun (Monts Mandara). Une
expérience personnelle de terrain
MELCHISEDEK CHÉTIMA
Résumé
Le bassin tchadien fut le théâtre de grands mouvements humains provoqués
par l‘émergence et le développement des royaumes esclavagistes entre les
XIVe et XVIIIe siècles. Il s‘agit notamment du Kanem, du Baguirmi, du
Bornou et du Wandala. Le peuplement des monts Mandara du Cameroun
serait lié à la fuite devant les razzias perpétrées par ces royaumes dans les
territoires dits « païens ». Ce passé servile fait qu‘aujourd‘hui, les populations
locales restent méfiantes vis-à-vis des étrangers, et réticentes à livrer certaines
informations sur leur histoire et sur leur culture. Cela rend contraignant le
processus de collecte des données sur le terrain. Dans ce travail, je ressors les
problèmes que j‘ai rencontrés lors de mes enquêtes de terrain dans le cadre de
mes travaux académiques (maîtrise et DEA), et de la démarche
méthodologique employée pour les contourner.
Abstract
The Chad basin was the scene of great human movement caused by the
emergence and the spreading of the proslavery kingdom between the 14th and
18th Centuries. These include Kanem, Baguirmi, Bornu and Wandala. The
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
settlement of Mandara Mountains is supposed to be due to the outflow of
people before the raid perpetrated by those kingdoms in the territories
designated by ―pagan territories.‖ Due to this past servile and trafficking they
have undergone, local people are mistrustful and reluctant to give some
information on their culture and on their history. What probably makes the
collection of data binding in that area. This paper highlights the problems
encountered during my fieldwork in the context of my academic research
(Master‘s and DEA‘s degree) and the methodological approach adopted to
circumvent them.
🍁
Introduction
Les recherches anthropologiques dans les monts Mandara ont généralement
porté sur trois principales ethnies que sont les Mafa, les Mofu et les Kapsiki.
Quant aux autres groupes ethniques tels que les Podokwo, les Minéo, les
Gemzek, les Zoulgo, les Mada ou encore les Mouraha, ils ont été simplement
négligés, voire même ignorés par la plupart des chercheurs. S‘ils apparaissent
dans certains ouvrages généraux, seulement quelques lignes leur sont
consacrées1. Même en ce qui concerne les ethnies couramment étudiées, la
plupart des auteurs ne fournissent aucun détail sur leurs informateurs ni sur
leurs méthodes de collecte et d‘analyse de données2. En plus, certains travaux
présentent la région et son patrimoine culturel d‘une manière stable et figée
1. Voir par exemple : Antoinette HALLAIRE, Les paysans montagnards du NordCameroun. Les monts Mandara, (Paris, ORSTOM, 1991) ; Christian SEIGNOBOS, Montagnes et
Hautes terres du Cameroun, (Paris, Parenthèses, 1982); Jean BOUTRAIS, La colonisation des plaines
par les montagnards au Nord-Cameroun (Monts Mandara), (Paris, ORSTOM, 1993).
2. Voir par exemple : Jean BOULET et al., Nord-Cameroun. Bilan de dix ans de recherches,
(Paris, ORSTOM, 1979) ; Jean-Yves MARTIN, « Etude des communautés villageoises et
démarches sociologiques », Communautés rurales et paysanneries tropicales, (Paris, ORSTOM, 1976),
pp. 147–158.
2
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
sans une prise en compte de leur dimension changeante et évolutive3. Si ces
travaux constituent une source incontournable en ce qu‘ils sont les premières
données écrites sur les monts Mandara, il est, en revanche, difficile d‘établir
leur fiabilité en raison de leurs imprécisions méthodologiques.
Quelques chercheurs ont cependant indiqué avoir utilisé l‘enquête
intensive et l‘observation participante dans leurs recherches. C‘est le cas, par
exemple, de Jeanne-Françoise Vincent4 qui, grâce à la mise en œuvre de la
méthode qualitative (entrevues, observation participante), a réussi à recueillir
d‘intéressantes données, et à mettre en exergue les aspects culturels et
historiques longtemps ignorés. Ses nombreux travaux sur les Mofu m‘ont
amené à opter pour la méthode qualitative dans le cadre de mes travaux de
DEA. Mon objectif était d‘apporter une contribution à la connaissance de
l‘histoire de la chefferie d‘Oudjila, un village podokwo connu pour l‘«
authenticité » de ses traditions et fréquenté par de nombreux touristes.
Cependant, la chefferie d‘Oudjila fait partie des localités sur lesquelles il
n‘existe encore aucune véritable étude scientifique.
Dans ce travail, je présente premièrement les spécificités de la région
des monts Mandara pour, ensuite ressortir les problèmes d‘utilisation des
informations orales. Deuxièmement, je rends compte de mon expérience
personnelle dans le cheminement méthodologique, en évoquant notamment
les techniques mises en œuvre pour contourner lesdits problèmes.
Sources orales et problèmes d’utilisation dans les monts Mandara
Les sources orales occupent une place primordiale dans la rédaction de
l‘histoire des peuples vivant dans les monts Mandara en raison de la rareté des
données écrites. Elles offrent une possibilité de combler ce vide dans les écrits
3. Voir par exemple : Bernard, JUILLERAT, Les bases de l‘organisation sociale chez les
Mouktélé (Nord-Cameroun). Structures lignagères et mariage, (Paris, Mémoires de l‘Institut
d‘Ethnologie, 1971) ; Antoinette HALLAIRE, 1991.
4. Voir : Jeanne-Françoise VINCENT, Princes montagnards du Nord-Cameroun. Les MofuDiamaré et le pouvoir politique, (Paris, L‘Harmattan, 1991), pp. 15–30.
3
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
historiques, et aident à reconstituer l‘histoire sociale telle que vécue par les
populations elles-mêmes5. Cependant, la scientificité d‘une histoire écrite sur la
base des sources orales a longtemps été remise en cause au vu de nombreux
écueils qu‘elles présentent, notamment leur caractère fluide et fragile. Des
auteurs, à l‘instar de Hegel, en sont d‘ailleurs venus à nier l‘historicité de
l‘Afrique ; l‘histoire n‘étant alors réservée qu‘aux nations possédant l‘écriture.
Dans son ouvrage intitulé « La raison dans l‘histoire », Hegel écrivait ceci :
L‘Afrique n‘est pas une partie historique du monde. Elle n‘a
pas de mouvements, de développements à montrer en elle
[…]. Ce que nous entendons par l‘Afrique est l‘esprit
ahistorique, l‘esprit non développé, encore enveloppé dans
des conditions de naturel et qui doit être présenté ici
seulement comme au seuil de l‘histoire du monde6.
Il a fallu de rudes combats pour réhabiliter l‘histoire de l‘Afrique et
pour reconnaitre la validité des traditions orales comme matériaux
indispensables à la reconstitution de son passé. La plupart des intellectuels
africains et africanistes reconnaissent néanmoins l‘existence de certains
facteurs susceptibles de rendre malléables les sources orales7. Claude-Hélène
Perrot développe deux de ces facteurs à savoir : le poids des intérêts à
défendre dans le présent qui peut orienter le contenu des récits historiques, et
le « travail de la mémoire » rejetant certains matériaux et ajoutant des
p. 46.
5. Voir : Donatien DIBWE, « La collecte des sources orales », Civilisations 54, (2006),
6. Friedrich G. W. HEGEL, La Raison dans l‘Histoire, (Paris, Plon, 1965 [1822]), p.
269.
7. En dépit de ces facteurs, ils soulignent unanimement l‘indispensabilité des sources
orales pour palier à l‘absence des documents écrits. Pour plus de détails, le lecteur pourra se
référer à : Laya DIOULDE, (dir.), La tradition orale. Problématiques et méthodologie des sources de
l‘histoire africaine, (Abbeville, Imprimerie F. Paillart, 1972) ; Jan VANSINA, Oral tradition as history,
(London, James currey 1985) ; Ibrahima THIOUB (dir.), Patrimoine et sources historiques, (Dakar,
Presse Sénégalaise de l‘Imprimerie, 2007).
4
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
significations nouvelles à d‘autres8. En plus de ces deux facteurs, je voudrais
ressortir d‘autres problèmes spécifiques à la région des monts Mandara du
Cameroun qui constitue mon terrain d‘étude. J‘évoque ainsi des enjeux liés au
refoulement de la mémoire de la traite, des enjeux liés à la pratique de l‘activité
touristique, des enjeux liés à la réappropriation de la mémoire servile dans le
contexte de l‘ouverture démocratique et enfin, des enjeux liés à l‘absence d‘un
cadre chronologique pour situer les données collectées.
Problèmes liés au refoulement de la mémoire de la traite
La traite humaine qui a marquée l‘histoire dans les abords sud du lac Tchad
découle du prosélytisme islamique des grandes hégémonies politiques du
bassin tchadien9. Du Kanem (XIIIe–XIVe siècle) au Wandala (XVIIIe–XIXe
siècle) en passant par le Bornou (XVe–XVIe siècle), les cours royales étaient
remplies d‘esclaves capturés au sein des populations dites « infidèles10 ». Plus
que les conquêtes territoriales, les razzias esclavagistes constituaient l‘objectif
principal de l‘armée, et c‘est en nombre de serfs que l‘on évaluait la grandeur
de ces royaumes. La chasse effrénée aux esclaves amène de nombreux peuples
à fuir vers des zones de refuge (montagnes, fortifications végétales, etc) pour
assurer leur sécurité. La plupart des auteurs s‘accordent pour situer le
peuplement des monts Mandara dans ce contexte11.
8. Claude-Hélène PERROT (dir.), Sources orales et histoire de l‘Afrique, (Paris, CNRS,
1993), p. 12.
9. Issa SAÏBOU, « Paroles d‘esclaves au Nord-Cameroun », Cahiers d'Études Africaines
179-180, (2005), p. 854.
10. Les populations des monts Mandara ont été ainsi appelées, non pas seulement en
raison de leur refus de s‘islamiser, mais surtout pour légitimer leur assujettissement en tant
qu‘esclaves. Par le concept d‘« infidèles » ou de « païens », les souverains des royaumes
esclavagistes d‘antan désignaient, à la fois, ceux qui ne pratiquaient pas la « vraie religion », c‘està-dire l‘Islam, et ceux qui sont « réductibles en esclavage ». Voir à ce sujet : Issa SAIBOU, p.
854.
11. A titre d‘illustration, voir : Jean BOUTRAIS, p. 109 ; Antoinette HALLAIRE, p.
30 ; Christian SEIGNOBOS et Olivier IYEBI-MANDJECK, p. 46.
5
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
L‘expansion du royaume du Kanem vers le XIIIe provoque, d‘une
part, l‘absorption du vieux fond de peuplement sao dans le bassin tchadien, et
d‘autre part, le refoulement de certains rameaux. Plusieurs clans vivant dans
les monts Mandara feraient partie de ces refoulés. Les Podokwo, par exemple,
affirment descendre des Sao et situent leur origine à Waza ; une localité située
non loin de la région jadis contrôlée par le Kanem. Mais les traditions orales
podokwo, elles, précisent que Waza ne fut qu‘une étape d‘une longue
migration en provenance des régions beaucoup plus septentrionales. Par la
suite, l‘apogée du royaume du Bornou au XVIe siècle et les raids esclavagistes
qu‘il mène repoussent davantage les « ethnies païennes » dont quelques-unes
trouveront refuge dans les monts Mandara. Seignobos et Iyébi-Mandjeck12
soulignent que c‘est précisément à cette époque que le peuplement des massifs
Mandara devient continu.
Outre le Kanem et le Bournou, le royaume du Wandala va jouer un
rôle majeur dans la configuration ethnique actuelle des monts Mandara.
Quoiqu‘étant au départ animiste, ce royaume présentait un grand intérêt pour
le Bornou en raison de sa proximité avec les populations des monts Mandara.
Les Wandala avaient ainsi pour rôle d‘organiser des razzias parmi les
montagnards et de les livrer aux Bornouans. Cependant, abandonnés à euxmêmes et profitant des dividendes tirées du commerce d‘esclaves, les Wandala
durent s‘affranchir de la domination bornouane et embrassèrent la religion
musulmane au début du XVIIIe siècle. Leur islamisation leur permettait
d‘interdire légalement et juridiquement les Bornouans de venir capturer les
esclaves parmi eux. De plus, ils pouvaient lancer à leur propre profit des
razzias contre les « païens » en se prévalant des motifs de guerre sainte. Pour
les populations des monts Mandara par contre, l‘islamisation du royaume du
Wandala signifiait l‘avancée de l‘islam dans leur direction et donc, des
incursions esclavagistes plus fréquentes et plus cruelles dans leurs montagnes.
12. Christian SEIGNOBOS et Olivier IYEBI-MANDJECK, Ibid.
6
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
Cela va, dès lors, renforcer leur attachement à leurs sommets montagneux, et
créer une attitude de méfiance à l‘égard des étrangers13.
Il faut cependant noter que les traditions historiques des différents
peuples montagnards occultent le contexte d‘insécurité et d‘asservissements
qu‘ils connurent. Les stratégies d‘occultation de cette mémoire servile
s‘expriment, d‘une part, par le refus de sa transmission et, d‘autre part, par la
construction d‘une mémoire alternative avec pour objectif de supplanter le
côté honteux de l‘esclavage. Candau résume bien ce travail de la mémoire en
écrivant :
Dans le rapport qu‘elle entretient avec le passé, la mémoire
humaine est toujours conflictuelle, partagée voire déchirée
entre un adret et un ubac : elle est faite d‘adhésions et de
rejets, de consentements et de refoulements, d‘ouvertures et
de fermetures, d‘acceptations et de renoncements, de lumière
et d‘ombre ou, plus simplement, de souvenirs et d‘oublis14.
La mémoire servile constitue donc un sérieux handicap pour le
chercheur qui utilise les données orales dans la mesure où elle est faite de
refoulement et de contournement. Par conséquent, en se basant
essentiellement sur les sources orales, il y a un risque d‘aboutir à l‘écriture
d‘une histoire biaisée, si non complètement tronquée.
Problèmes liés à la pratique de l’activité touristique
La région des monts Mandara offre l‘un des plus beaux et des plus fascinants
paysages du Cameroun. Elle est une suite de panoramas des monts
volcaniques surplombant les plaines sahéliennes et parsemée
d‘impressionnants éboulis de pitons rocheux aux formes plutôt étranges. Les
p. 65.
13. Christian SEIGNOBOS, p. 24.
14. Joël CANDAU, Mémoire et identité, (Paris, Presses Universitaires de France, 1998),
7
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
massifs entièrement striés en terrasses, le spectacle de danse traditionnelle, la
poterie, la forge, l‘artisanat, les célèbres cases traditionnelles au toit pointu et
accrochées à flancs des collines sont quelques-uns des éléments culturels
locaux15.
En vertu de ces caractéristiques, les monts Mandara ont été
considérés par les premiers administrateurs coloniaux comme étant le berceau
de l‘authenticité culturelle16. Ce discours sur la tradition et l‘authenticité sera
repris par de nombreux autres visiteurs à l‘image d‘André Gide qui, émerveillé
par la beauté du paysage kapsiki, l‘a qualifié de l‘une des régions les plus belles
au monde17. Dans cette avenue, L‘État camerounais mettra en œuvre, à partir
de 1960, une politique de promotion touristique des monts Mandara par la
création des infrastructures routières, d‘hébergement et de restauration. Par
ailleurs, des voyagistes s‘activent dans la production des guides et brochures
touristiques, reprenant à leur compte le concept de l‘authenticité culturelle de
la région pour attirer de nombreux touristes18.
Le développement de l‘industrie touristique a cependant conduit à la
refonte et à la mise en scène du paysage culturel local dans le but de le rendre
davantage pittoresque, séduisant et propre à la consommation touristique. En
effet, parce que les populations d‘accueil estiment que les touristes recherchent
tout ce qui est exotique, elles simulent certaines manifestations culturelles,
falsifient leurs listes généalogiques et leurs traditions historiques. Si le
chercheur ne développe pas une grande sensibilité d‘écoute lui permettant de
déceler les informations « folklorisés » de celles qui sont réelles, et s‘il n‘a pas
une bonne connaissance ethnologique de la société étudiée, les résultats de ses
15. Melchisedek CHETIMA, « Patrimoine naturel et culturel des monts Mandara
(Cameroun) : Potentialités touristiques et contraintes », dans Pierre KANDEM et Mesmin
TCHINDJANG (dirs), Repenser la promotion touristique au Cameroun. Approches pour une
redynamisation stratégique, (Paris, IRESMA-Karthala, 2011), p. 162.
16. 1AC/5141, Rapport du Capitaine Maronneau, Chef de la circonscription de
Mokolo, 1934.
17. André GIDE cité par Mamadou SECK et Philippe TOUZARD (dir.),
L‘Encyclopédie de la République Unie du Cameroun, (Abidjan, Dakar, Lomé, Ed. NEA, 1981), p. 196.
18. Jean-Rémi ZRA, Traditions Kapsiki et Mafa du Nord-Cameroun (Monts Mandara),
(Paris, ORSTOM, 1993), p. 15.
8
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
recherches ne pourront être que plus ou moins biaisés quoique, illustrées par
des photos convaincantes.
Problèmes liés à la réappropriation de la mémoire servile dans le
contexte de l’ouverture démocratique
On utilise généralement le terme « Kirdi » pour désigner les populations vivant
dans les monts Mandara. Ce terme qui serait d‘origine baguirmienne
signifierait, selon Juillerat, « infidèle » ou « non musulman »19. Seignobos et
Tourneux, par contre, lui trouvent une origine arabe et viendrait du vocable
« quird » qui veut dire « singe »20. Tout compte fait, l‘expression « kirdi »
désignait de façon méprisante les populations des monts Mandara en raison de
leur fuite devant les campagnes d‘islamisation. Dans cette avenue, il n‘était pas
commode pour elles d‘afficher leur identité ethnique dans les lieux publics
(marché, école, centre de santé, etc.).
Cependant, à partir des années 1990, période à laquelle le Cameroun
s‘ouvre à la démocratie et au multipartisme, on assiste, à la fois, à une sorte de
victimisation et à une sorte d‘idéalisation de l‘identité ethnique kirdi. En
s‘affichant comme des peuples victimes de l‘esclavage, les montagnards
revendiquent une certaine justice sociale qui devrait, selon les élites locales, se
traduire par leur accès dans les rouages du pouvoir politique, ce d‘autant qu‘ils
constituent un des groupes majoritaires au plan démographique21.
Contrairement aux années d‘avant 1990 où les populations avaient honte
d‘évoquer leur passé servile, le terme « kirdi » est aujourd‘hui intégrée au
discours politique local et national22. Les élites montagnardes en ont fait un
concept politique – la « kirditude » – qui traduit bien leur prise de conscience
19. Bernard, JUILLERAT, p. 7.
20. Christian SEIGNOBOS et Henri TOURNEUX, Le Nord-Cameroun à travers ses
mots. Dictionnaire de termes anciens, (Paris, Karthala, 2003), p. 154.
21. Patrice BIGOMBE LOGO, Construction de l‘ethnicité et production du politique au
Cameroun septentrional. Logiques hégémoniques musulmanes et dynamiques de résistance des Kirdi, (Yaoundé,
GRAP, 1993), p. 243.
22. Ibid., p. 253.
9
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
de leur poids politique dans le contexte actuel de la démocratisation23. Ainsi,
Jean Baptiste Baskouda, une élite locale écrit :
Je suis kirdi et me glorifie de ce nom. Sur ma face on a jeté ce
mot avec maladresse. Me voici homme-parjure, hommecrachat qui se redresse ; avec courage j‘ai décidé de le
ramasser tendrement, en me revendiquant comme tel, sans
rancune, sagement. Et pourquoi ? (Pourquoi donc ces
lugubres lamentements) ? Pourquoi soudain ces hypocrites ?
Ces sombres indignations ? Les maîtres-créateurs pouvaientils oublier qu‘importe le lieu où vous jetez le fumier, tôt ou
tard, il fertilise et fait germer […]. Moi, le Kirdi, je suis fier de
ma chanson de sagesse ; fier de la sagesse de mon combat ;
fier du combat pour ma survie24.
Un informateur rencontré à Oudjila souligne, lui aussi, la réappropriation de la
mémoire servile dans le contexte actuel :
A une certaine époque, nos parents avaient honte de ce qu‘ils
étaient et de raconter leur passé. Ils cherchaient à se dissocier
de leurs origines à cause de la traite qu‘ils ont connue.
Aujourd‘hui, nous n‘avons pas honte de raconter notre passé.
Au contraire, nous sommes tous conscients de la force que
nous représentons dans le débat politique actuel25.
S‘il permet de disposer de certaines données historiques auxquelles on
ne pouvait pas avoir accès avant 1990, la réactivation de la mémoire servile
23. Kees SCHILDER, « La démocratie au champ. Les présidentielles d‘octobre 1992
au Nord-Cameroun », Politique Africaine 50, (1993), p. 119.
24. Jean-Baptiste BASKOUDA, Kirdi est mon nom, (Yaoundé, Imprimerie Saint-Paul,
1993), pp. 74–80.
25. Anonyme, entrevue du 11 avril 2007 à Oudjila (traduction personnelle).
10
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
n‘est pas sans poser de problème au chercheur dans son processus de collecte
de données. En effet, elle est davantage une reconstruction continuellement
actualisée du passé qu‘une restitution fidèle de celui-ci. Nora exprime bien cet
enjeu de la mémoire lorsqu‘il écrit: « La mémoire en effet est un cadre plus
qu‘un contenu, un enjeu toujours disponible, un ensemble de stratégies, un
être-là qui vaut moins par ce qu‘il est que par ce que l‘on fait »26.
Problèmes liés à la chronologie
Le chercheur qui veut étudier l‘histoire des populations des monts Mandara se
rend vite compte du fait qu‘il n‘existe pas de spécialistes de la connaissance
historique. Les populations locales ne s‘intéressent pas à l‘histoire au sens
classique du terme, à savoir la fixation des faits majeurs, leur déroulement et
leur transmission orale et fidèle. Dans cette région, il n‘existe pas des griots et
d‘autres spécialistes de la tradition orale comme c‘est le cas avec les Dyeli du
Mali, les Biru du Rwanda ou encore les griots mandingue qui sont de
véritables professionnels de l‘histoire. Dans cette avenue, il devient difficile
d‘assurer la mise en ordre temporel des faits qui sont décrits par les
informateurs.
Les seuls matériaux auxquels les chercheurs font recours pour établir
la chronologie sont les renseignements généalogiques. Cependant, le nombre
de générations ne remonte guère au XVIIIe siècle, et il y a beaucoup de
discordances au niveau des informations qui sont fournies. Soit les généalogies
des villages-fils dépassent celles des villages-pères; soit les noms oubliés sont
très fréquents. De plus, les généalogies fonctionnent dans les monts Mandara
comme un « social charter » dont le but est d‘expliquer et de sanctionner le
système clanique, ou d‘indiquer les rapports de force entre les groupes
sociaux.
VIII.
26. Pierre NORA, (dir.), Les lieux de mémoire, Tome I, (Paris, Gallimard, 1984), p.
11
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
Au regard de ces problèmes, il y a lieu de se demander si une histoire
des monts Mandara écrite sur la base des sources orales peut être fiable. Si oui,
dans quelle mesure?
Sources orales et accès à l’histoire dans les monts Mandara
Dans le processus de collecte des données en vue de la rédaction de mon
mémoire de maîtrise qui a porté sur le patrimoine architectural des
Podokwo27, j‘ai rencontré tous les écueils sus-évoqués. Je n‘oublierai jamais ce
vieillard qui, au départ, ne manquait pas de fournir des données intéressantes
sur certains aspects de mon étude. Cependant, ma tentative d‘aborder les
questions liées à la mémoire de l‘esclavage eut un effet amnésique immédiat.
Plusieurs tentatives auprès des autres informateurs eurent les mêmes effets.
Face à ce vide historique, mon premier reflexe fût d‘abandonner l‘étude de
l‘aspect mémoriel de l‘architecture pour uniquement m‘appesantir sur sa
dimension technique et matérielle. Je manquais en effet de pré-requis
méthodologiques nécessaires pour vérifier la validité de mes données orales.
Après l‘obtention de ma maîtrise en novembre 2006, je fus
sélectionné par le CODESRIA (Conseil pour le développement des sciences
sociales en Afrique) pour participer à un atelier méthodologique qui était
organisé à Douala (Cameroun) entre le 21 et le 25 mai 2007 sur le thème :
« Terrains et théories de l‘enquête qualitative ». Cette formation m‘a permis de
mieux conduire mes enquêtes de terrain dans le cadre de mon mémoire de
DEA consacré à l‘étude de la Concession du chef d‘Oudjila (monts
Mandara)28. Cela m‘a permis d‘aborder, sur fond architectural, des sujets aussi
complexes que les migrations, la mémoire de la servilité, l‘identité ethnique,
etc. Dans les paragraphes qui suivent, je présente les démarches adoptées dans
la collecte et l‘analyse de mes données de terrain.
27. Melchisedek CHETIMA, Patrimoine architectural des monts Mandara entre permanences et
mutations (XIXe–XXe siècle), Université de Ngaoundéré, mémoire de Maîtrise en histoire, 2006.
28. Melchisedek CHETIMA, Concession du chef d‘Oudjila (Monts Mandara) entre histoire,
mémoire et patrimoine, Université de Ngaoundéré, mémoire de DEA en histoire, 2007.
12
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
Choix de l’approche méthodologique : Qualitative et exploratoire
Le terme « recherche qualitative » désigne l‘étude « des phénomènes sociaux
dans leur contexte ordinaire, habituel, […] (et vise) à faire éclore des données
nouvelles et à les traiter qualitativement »29. Elle favorise la description en
profondeur des dimensions oubliées d‘un phénomène étudié, et permet de
mettre en scène les « principaux acteurs tels qu‘ils sont réellement et pour ce
qu‘ils font concrètement »30. Selon Ellis par exemple, l‘approche qualitative est
une approche pertinente et judicieuse, car elle met l‘accent sur les individus et
sur le contact direct avec le terrain. C‘est ainsi qu‘il écrit :
L‘approche qualitative nous aide à comprendre les gens dans
leur interaction dans différents contextes sociaux et à définir
la réalité sociale à partir de leur propre expérience,
perspective et signification plutôt qu‘à partir de celles du
chercheur [...]. Elle permet de soulever des questions non
posées jusque-là et dont les réponses aident à mieux
comprendre comment et pourquoi les personnes participent
comme elles le font dans une variété de processus31.
J‘ai privilégié l‘approche qualitative pour ma recherche dans la mesure
où elle accorde une importance à l‘induction et aux descriptions en
profondeur. Aborder les questions relatives aux migrations, à la mémoire
servile ou encore aux identités nécessitait en effet l‘usage des outils moins
rigides, car plus susceptibles de rendre compte de ces « dimensions oubliées »
29. Jean-Pierre DESLAURIERS et Hermance POLIOT, Les groupes populaires à
Sherbrooke: pratique, financement et structure, (Université de Sherbrooke, coll. « Recherche sociale »,
1982), p. 20.
30. Emmanuel KANDEM, « Itinéraire de recherche qualitative sur les temporalités
en Afrique », Recherches qualitatives 8 (2010), p. 62.
31. Pinzler, ELLIS, « Methodologies for doing research on women and
development», Women in development: Perspectives from the Nairobi conference, (Ottawa, IDRC, 1986),
p. 138.
13
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
dont parle Kandem32. Par ailleurs, puisque la plupart de mes informateurs
n‘étaient pas scolarisés, le recours aux entrevues structurées et au
questionnaire n‘était pas approprié. Dans le contexte des monts Mandara, le
questionnaire ne rend pas aisé le contact avec les populations qui voient
derrière chaque chercheur un agent de l‘Etat les forçant à payer leurs impôts.
J‘ai donc opté pour l‘entrevue semi-structurée afin de permettre à mes
répondants de s'exprimer de la manière qu'ils le désirent, tout en centrant leurs
propos sur certains thèmes concernés par ma recherche. Les informations
fournies ont été enregistrées dans des fiches d‘enquête qui étaient les seuls
outils d‘enregistrement utilisées. Lors de mes travaux de terrain en maîtrise, la
plupart de mes informateurs s‘étaient montrés méfiants à l‘usage du
magnétophone.
Un autre aspect de la recherche de type qualitatif est le fait qu'elle ne
s‘appui pas forcément sur des hypothèses, mais plutôt sur une démarche
exploratoire pouvant déboucher sur des interprétations33. Dans cette
perspective, mon objectif n‘était pas de confirmer à tout prix mes hypothèses
de départ, mais d‘utiliser intelligemment les matériaux recueillis sur le terrain.
Le troisième aspect de la recherche qualitative que j‘ai utilisé est
l‘observation participante. Deslauriers la définie comme une « technique de
recherche […] par laquelle le chercheur recueille des données de nature
surtout descriptive, en participant à la vie quotidienne du groupe, de
l‘organisation, de la personne qu'il veut étudier34». L‘observation participante
m‘a permis de recueillir les données tout en partageant le quotidien de mes
informateurs. J‘assistai régulièrement aux travaux de construction (taille des
pierres, extraction de l‘argile, élévation des murs des cases, confection des
toitures, etc.), et aux travaux agricoles en leur compagnie.
32. Emmanuel KANDEM, p. 62.
33. Robert MAYER, et Francine OUELLET, Méthodologie de recherche pour les
intervenants sociaux, (Montréal, Gaëtan Morin, 1991), p. 479. Voir aussi : Madeleine GRAWITZ,
Méthodes des sciences sociales, (Paris, Éditions Dalloz, 1996), p. 505.
34. Jean-Pierre, DESLAURIERS, Recherche qualitative: guide pratique, (Montréal,
McGraw Hill, 1991), p. 47.
14
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
L‘observation participante m‘a surtout permis d‘avoir accès à des
données beaucoup plus fiables. En effet, les divers informateurs rencontrés
me livraient au départ des données manipulées dans le but d‘accentuer le
caractère exotique de leur passé et traditions, et de susciter l‘émerveillement du
chercheur que j‘étais. C‘est seulement grâce à un séjour répété dans leur
localité et en usant d‘accointances amicales que j‘ai eu droit aux données
beaucoup plus crédibles. Certains informateurs m‘expliquèrent par la suite que
les informations qu‘ils fournissent habituellement aux touristes et aux autres
chercheurs sont volontairement tronquées pour accroitre l‘achalandage
touristique de leur village. Dans certains cas, c‘est à l‘issu de longues
conversations, plusieurs fois répétées avec les uns et les autres, que certaines
répondants sont allées au-delà des versions arrangées pour me livrer quelques
pans de l‘histoire réelle de la chefferie d‘Oudjila.
Si la méthode qualitative constituait la pierre angulaire de mon étude,
je fis par moment usage de l‘approche quantitative et extensive pour enrichir
les résultats de ma recherche. Quelquefois, l‘enquête extensive me servait de
préalable à l‘enquête intensive.
Du choix de la méthode d’échantillonnage au choix des informateurs
Conscient des défis que posent l‘exploitation des sources orales dans les
monts Mandara, je me posais continuellement la question de savoir la
méthode à adopter pour construire mon échantillon d‘enquête et pour choisir
mes répondants.
Il existe, en général, deux méthodes de construction d'un échantillon :
la méthode probabiliste ou aléatoire, habituellement associée à la collecte et à
l‘analyse de données quantitatives, et la méthode non probabiliste ou non
aléatoire, fréquemment associée à la collecte et à l‘analyse de données
15
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
qualitatives35. Dans la mesure où ma recherche se voulait qualitative, j‘ai opté
pour la méthode non probabiliste. Celle-ci suppose un échantillonnage plus
orienté et plus délibéré qui ne s'appuie pas sur la théorie des probabilités36.
Cette approche m‘a permis de prélever un échantillon selon certaines
caractéristiques précises de la population étudiée. J‘ai ainsi ciblé quatre
catégories d‘informateurs en fonction des trois critères suivant : âge, sexe et
connaissance sur le sujet.
Dans la première catégorie se rangent les personnes du troisième âge
(60–80 ans) en raison de leur connaissance suffisante de l‘histoire locale. En
effet, il est couramment admis qu‘en Afrique, les véritables détenteurs du
savoir historique sont les vieillards. « Un vieillard qui meurt est une
bibliothèque qui brûle » disait Hamadou Ampathe Bâ. « La bouche du vieillard
sent mauvais, mais ce qui en ressort est agréable » stipule un autre proverbe
africain. Il faut tout de même noter que, dans le contexte des monts Mandara,
les vieillards, s‘ils ne sont pas réticents à livrer une information, sont par
contre d‘habiles manipulateurs des données. Le défi était donc de distinguer
les vraies informations de celles qui sont pétries.
Dans cette perspective, il était important que j‘accorde une
importance à d‘autres types d‘informateurs le plus souvent négligés par les
chercheurs. J‘ai ainsi intégrer dans mon échantillon des plus jeunes. En effet,
le savoir détenu par les vieillards leur progressivement est transmis dans des
scènes réelles et quotidiennes. Contrairement aux vieillards qui livrent au
chercheur des informations parfois biaisées, les plus jeunes ont tendance à ne
donner que ce qui leur a été enseigné et transmis.
Le troisième groupe d‘informateurs était constitué des femmes.
Celles-ci n‘étaient pas habilitées à donner des informations en présence de
35. Francine OUELLET et Marie-Christine SAINT-JACQUES, 2000, « Les
techniques d'échantillonnage », dans Robert MAYER, et al., Méthodes de recherche en intervention
sociale, (Boucherville, Ed. Gaëtan Morin, 2000), pp. 80–83.
36. Matthew B. MILES et A-Michael HUBERMAN, Analyse des données qualitatives.
Recueil de nouvelles méthodes, (Bruxelles, De Boeck, 1991).
16
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
personnes de sexe masculin. Il fallait les rencontrer en toute discrétion pour
glaner quelques données utiles à ma recherche. Elles ont, en revanche, révélé
certains pans de l‘histoire que je n‘ai pas pu obtenir chez les informateurs
masculins pourtant considérés comme les seuls détenteurs du savoir
traditionnel. Si les hommes étaient plus habiles à fournir les informations sur
les questions d‘ordre politique (successions dynastiques, conflits et mécanisme
de résolution des conflits), les femmes étaient, quant à elles, détentrices d‘un
type particulier de savoir lié aux thèmes économiques ou se référant au
quotidien.
La quatrième et la dernière catégorie était constituée des informateurs
étrangers vivant dans les régions frontières. Il fallait recueillir des témoignages
historiques dans toutes les sociétés voisines avec lesquelles les gens d‘Oudjila
ont entretenu des relations. Ces informations ont servi à compléter les
données recueillies à Oudjila, particulièrement celles qui traitaient des rapports
amicaux ou conflictuels avec les peuples voisins.
En dépit de la rigueur que l‘on peut se fixer dans la collecte des
sources orales, certaines informations tronquées ne manquent pas de passer
inaperçues. Pour réduire le risque d‘aboutir à l‘écriture d‘une histoire biaisée,
j‘ai fait appel à ma connaissance de la culture matérielle étudiée dans le cadre
de mon mémoire de Maîtrise, et j‘ai pu, par ce biais, vérifier certaines
informations.
Des sources matérielles au service des sources orales
Dans les monts Mandara du Cameroun, les données matérielles représentent
un lieu privilégié de la conservation et de la transmission du savoir. Au-delà de
leur pouvoir de socialisation, les objets matériels se positionnent dans
certaines ethnies en tant qu‘objet patrimonial et mémoriel.
L‘architecture se présente comme la meilleure source d‘information
sur les itinéraires migratoires et sur l‘installation des différentes ethnies dans
les monts Mandara. Certaines maisons contiennent en leurs seins divers objets
matériels (décorations, pots ancestraux, tombes des premiers fondateurs de la
17
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
concession…) qui permettent de dater approximativement l‘installation dans
les massifs. En plus, les populations justifient certains traits architecturaux
(site en altitude, murailles, plan intérieur, système d‘ouverture des cases…) par
l‘évocation du contexte d‘insécurité ayant précédé l‘occupation des monts
Mandara. L‘obscurité est partout recherchée dans les maisons elles-mêmes
entourées d‘un système de défense en pierre et/ou en végétaux. Dans toutes
les ethnies, les montagnards attachent une grande importance à leur
architecture et expliquent, en s‘y référant, leur passé instable et mouvementé.
Dans cette logique, la concession du chef d‘Oudjila était, non seulement mon
objet d‘étude, mais également une source que j‘ai exploitée pour orienter mes
entrevues.
Comme je l‘ai souligné plus haut, les populations locales font
régulièrement usage des mises en scène culturelles pour faire de leur village
une destination touristique par excellence. Elles ont réduit leurs cultures
locales (rituels religieux, rites traditionnels, manifestations coutumières, etc.)
au folklore pour attirer une grande clientèle. Par exemple, la plupart des
répondants ont expliqué que la concession du chef d‘Oudjila est restée
indemne pendant près de quatre siècles sans subir de modification. Pour
vérifier cette information, j‘ai réalisée une étude sur quelques objets matériels
contenus dans ladite concession, en particulier les tombes ancestrales et les
pots ancestraux. Cela m‘a permis de reconstituer la liste généalogique et de
situer la construction de l‘actuelle maison du chef plutôt dans l‘intervalle de
150 à 200 ans. Par la suite, j‘ai repris l‘entrevue avec mes informateurs qui,
finalement, expliquèrent que la concession du chef était auparavant située sur
les premiers escarpements surplombant les plaines de Mora. Avec
l‘implantation du royaume du Wandala à Mora et son islamisation au XVIII e
siècle, les gens d‘Oudjila abandonnent cette concession pour construire
l‘actuelle, située en pleins massifs. Cette délocalisation était importante dans la
mesure où le royaume du Wandala avait pour rôle de capturer les esclaves
parmi les montagnards et de les vendre au royaume du Bornou37. Le caractère
37. Jean BOULET et al., p. 211.
18
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
accidenté du relief montagneux empêchait désormais la cavalerie musulmane
de faire des incursions dans les massifs.
Une autre information infirmée par les sources matérielles porte sur le
nombre impressionnant des épouses du chef : une cinquantaine selon la
plupart des auteurs. Lors de mes enquêtes de terrain, les données recueillies à
ce sujet divergeaient en fonction des informateurs. Les guident touristiques, le
chef et les personnes du troisième âge (50–80 ans) avançaient un chiffre allant
au-delà de 50. Les épouses du chef ont, quant à elles, affirmé que ce nombre
relevait avait pour but de répondre à la quête d‘exotisme et d‘altérité des
touristes. Pour davantage être précis sur cette question, j‘ai interrogé la
concession du chef elle-même.
Chez les gens d‘Oudjila en effet, la concession est organisée en deux
domaines : le quartier de l‘homme et le quartier des épouses. Chaque épouse
possède son propre domaine architectural constitué d‘une cuisine, d‘une case à
coucher et de deux greniers. L‘organisation de la concession est telle qu‘on
peut identifier les différents domaines réservés aux femmes. Toute nouvelle
construction dans le quartier d‘épouses suppose donc la venue d‘une nouvelle
femme dans la concession. J‘ai dénombré au total 18 domaines réservés aux
femmes. En plus de cela, il existait deux cases préalablement réservées aux
reines-mères, occupées par deux nouvelles épouses. Ce qui suppose que le
nombre total des femmes du chef au moment de l‘enquête (2007) était plus ou
moins égal à 20.
En raison des divergences entre les données recueillies et mes propres
découvertes sur le terrain, j‘ai réorienté l‘entrevue avec mes informateurs
concernant le nombre réel des épouses du chef. Quand ils se rendirent compte
de ma connaissance des principes traditionnels régissant l‘organisation
intérieure de la concession, ils avouèrent que certaines informations étaient
destinées à séduire les touristes, et me supplièrent de ne pas divulguer la vraie
information.
19
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
Du choix du modèle d’analyse des données
Globalement, les informations que j‘ai recueillies ont présenté trois niveaux
consécutifs d‘analyse. Le premier niveau concernait ce que je peux appeler
« traitement des données ». Il consistait à retranscrire, coder et catégoriser les
données collectées dans le but de mieux les organiser.
Le deuxième niveau portait sur l‘analyse qualitative de chacune des
entrevues qui ont constitué le corpus de ma recherche. Cette analyse, que j'ai
appelée « verticale », avait pour but de condenser les résultats par l'entremise
de résumés descriptifs. Cela m‘a permis de passer en revue les thèmes et les
sous-thèmes abordés avec chaque informateur et d‘étudier les logiques qui
sous-tendent leur énonciation. Pour cela, je me suis inspiré du modèle
d‘analyse qualitative proposé par Glaser et Strauss38 à savoir le modèle de la
théorisation ancrée ou « grounded theory ». Ce modèle propose des allers et
retours entre la collecte des informations sur le terrain et leur analyse 39.
J‘alternais ainsi le travail de réflexion sur les données déjà collectées et la mise
au point de nouvelles stratégies pour en collecter d'autres.
Le troisième niveau d‘analyse des informations que j‘ai appelé
« analyse transversale » avait pour but d‘interpréter et de discuter les résultats
des enquêtes orales, de les confronter à d‘autres sources (matérielles, écrites)
afin d‘en dégager les points de convergence et de divergence. Cette phase
pouvait donner lieu à de nouvelles enquêtes sur le terrain lorsque cela s‘avérait
nécessaire. C‘est à ce prix seulement que j‘ai pu reconstituer l‘histoire de la
concession du chef d‘Oudjila, et de son implantation sur le site actuel.
38. Voir: Barney GLASER et Anselm STRAUSS, The Discovery of Grounded Theory:
Strategies for qualitative research, (Chicago, Aldine, 1967).
39. Voir : Matthew B. MILES, et A-Michael HUBERMAN, 1991, p. 85 ; Pierre
PAILLÉ, « L'analyse par théorisation ancrée », Cahiers de recherche sociologique 23, (1994), pp. 147–
181.
20
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
Conclusion
A l‘issu de cette étude, il ressort clairement que l‘utilisation des sources orales
en contexte africain présente un certain nombre de défis. Cela est davantage
vrai pour le cas précis des monts Mandara dans la mesure où les populations
ont connu, au cours de leur trajectoire historique, des périodes traumatisantes
(traite et esclavage, colonisation) que la mémoire collective a tenté de refouler
et de contourner. Si le développement du tourisme et le contexte actuel
d‘ouverture démocratique ont facilité le resurgissement de ce passé servile, ils
ont en revanche conduit à sa sacralisation et à son idéalisation. Sa réactivation
s‘est en effet accompagné d‘un discours très idéologisé dans l‘objectif
d‘obtenir, en tant que groupe victime de l‘esclavage, des « réparations » de la
part des pouvoirs publics.
Cependant, les problèmes et défis évoqués ne doivent pas enlever
toute la valeur que représentent les sources orales dans l‘écriture de l‘histoire
des peuples africains. Si la tradition orale n‘est pas l‘histoire – tout comme
l‘informateur ne saurait être confondu avec l‘historien, – les ressources de la
tradition orale sont tout de même porteuses « d‘historicité »40. Pour le cas
particulier des monts Mandara, il est impossible d‘écrire ou de récrire l‘histoire
de certaines ethnies sans avoir recours à ces précieux matériaux au regard de la
rareté des données écrites et de leur validité incertaine.
En conclusion, on pourrait dire que le véritable défi ne se trouve pas
au niveau des sources elles-mêmes, mais davantage au niveau de la démarche
qu‘entreprend le chercheur dans leur collecte et leur traitement. La tradition
orale, bien exploitée et confrontée à d‘autres types de sources (écrites,
matérielles), peut mettre à jour les chapitres ignorés de la passionnante histoire
africaine. Dans cette logique, les sources orales doivent être soumises à un
traitement méthodologique rigoureux et appropriée, allant de leur
diversification à leur confrontation avec d‘autres matériaux. De solides thèses
40. Doulaye KONATE, Travail de mémoire et construction nationale au Mali, (Paris,
l‘Harmattan, 2006), p. 114.
21
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
sur différentes périodes de l‘histoire africaine ont été faites en grande partie
sur l‘exploitation desdites traditions orales.
En raison des enjeux de l‘utilisation de l‘oralité et de mon expérience
personnelle de terrain, il semble plus opportun de faire appel à une approche
méthodologique mixte ou la « mixed-methods approches41» pour la collecte
des données dans les monts Mandara. Si pendant longtemps la thèse de
l‘incompatibilité entre l‘approche qualitative et l‘approche quantitative a
dominé la recherche en science sociale, les auteurs s‘accordent aujourd‘hui sur
leur complémentarité42. De même que chaque type de source comporte ses
forces et ses faiblesses, chacune de ces deux méthodes comporte des forces et
des faiblesses. Il serait donc bénéfique, dans une recherche comme la mienne,
de les combiner pour associer leurs forces respectives, et compenser leurs
faiblesses et limites particulières.
41. John W. CRESWELL, Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Methods
Approaches (Thousand Oaks, Sage, 2009).
42. Sur le bien-fondé de la méthodologie mixte, se référer à Alan BRYMAN,
« Integrating qualitative and quantitative research: How is it done? », Qualitative Research 6, 1,
(2006), pp. 97–113.
22
Strata
Melchisidek Chétima
Melchisedek Chétima est candidat au doctorat à l‘Université Laval à Québec,
en même temps qu‘il occupe le poste d‘Assistant au département d‘histoire de
l‘Ecole normale supérieure de Maroua (Cameroun). Il est titulaire d‘une
maîtrise et d‘un Diplôme d‘étude approfondie (DEA) en histoire obtenus à
l‘Université de Ngaoundéré (Cameroun). Ses champs de recherche et
d‘enseignement portent, entre autres, sur l‘architecture vernaculaire, la mémoire
servile, l‘anthropologie du tourisme et la société civile.
Melchisedek Chétima is a doctoral candidate at Laval University in Quebec
City, while he held the position of Assistant to the Department of History at
the École normale supérieure of Maroua (Cameroon). He holds an MA and a
Diploma of Advanced Studies (DEA) in History from the University of
Ngaoundere (Cameroon). His research and teaching interests include
vernacular architecture, servile memory, anthropology of tourism and civil
society.
23
Synthesizing Current Research: Women‘s Higher
Education and the World Wars
ANNE M. E. MILLAR
Abstract
This paper considers the extant scholarship on the impact of the First and
Second World Wars on women‘s higher education in Canada. No published
monograph examines this topic, a reflection of the wider lack of scholarship
on women‘s world war experiences in this country. In order to synthesize
existing research, scholarship from military history, women‘s history, and the
history of higher education is assessed.
🍁
Despite the extensive historiography on both the First and Second World
Wars, a number of areas remain unexamined by Canadian historians. Many
topics, notably the impact of war on women and the family, have garnered
attention only recently, in large part due to the influence of social history and
second wave feminism. Concentrated in the last forty years, scholarship on
wartime women has been predominantly concerned with analyzing the impact
of the world wars. Scholars initially emphasized the ways in which these
conflicts opened up traditionally male spheres to women and the role this
played in bringing a change in gender norms. Women‘s historians, in
particular, have focused on the impact of wartime mobilization on women‘s
labour, while more recently, historians of higher education have added to
these discussions by exploring women‘s entrance into the professions, and by
extension, women‘s access to professional training.
There is still much missing from this analysis. To date, there is no
published full-length monograph examining Canadian women in institutions
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
of higher learning during wartime. American studies have come closer, but
there exists a similar lack of scholarship.1 Unpublished M.A. and Ph.D. theses
from both countries are more widespread. Influenced by the availability of
archival materials and access to university records, a significant number of
graduate students have written histories of their respective universities and
colleges, many of which explore female students during either war.2
Scholarship on women, higher education, and the world wars is, as
would be expected, primarily dispersed amongst the fields of women‘s and
military history and the history of higher education. Many of the works deal
more generally with other subjects, but in the various methods and forms
these studies take, they all shed light on the topic. The main purpose of this
essay is to discuss and assess the extant scholarship addressing the impact of
the world wars on women‘s higher education, and, where appropriate, its
relationship to wider scholarship. In so doing, the arguments of this essay will
be twofold. First, the work on women during wartime needs to be revived and
expanded to include the multitude of women‘s wartime experiences. Second,
scholars arguing for interdisciplinarity need to be reminded that the sharing of
work within disciplines is equally, if not more, important. Fields of historical
study have come to overlap in their references to this specific topic and will
continue to do so as historians focus more intently on the social history of war
and conflict. Work is needed to synthesize and coordinate the scholarly
research of these three fields.
1. J. Hillis Miller and Dorothy V. N. Brook‘s 1944 work was the first American study
connecting the two fields. More recently, Willis Rudy examined the impact of the world wars on
Britain, France, Germany, and the United States. See J. Hillis Miller and Dorothy V. N. Brook‘s
The Role of Higher Education in War and After (New York: Harper and Bros., 1944); Willis Rudy,
Total War and Twentieth-Century Higher Learning: Universities of the Western World in the First and
Second World Wars (Rutherford: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press / London and Toronto:
Associated University Presses, 1991).
2. See Nancy Kiefer, ―The Impact of the Second World War on Female Students at
the University of Toronto, 1939–1949‖ (M.A. Thesis, University of Toronto, 1984); Lee Jean
Stewart, ―The Experience of Women at the University of British Columbia, 1906–56‖ (M.A.
Thesis, University of British Columbia, 1986); and Mary Ellen Tingley, ―The Impact of War:
Wolfville Women 1914–1918‖ (M.A. Thesis, Acadia University, 1983).
25
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
This historiography is separated into discussions of relevant
scholarship in each field—women‘s history, military history, and the history of
higher education—and is organized generally chronologically in each section.
The first two sections examine the growth of interest in this topic, exploring
developments in the fields of women‘s and military history to explain the
roots of this focus. Moreover, they situate discussions of women during the
world wars within the larger focus that dominates much of the scholarship.
The third examines the field of higher education and the groundbreaking work
done by a comparatively small group of historians on the history of women
and higher education. These scholars address the influence of the world wars
on women‘s higher education more directly, often in case studies of specific
institutions. It is only by synthesizing the work from these three subfields that
one can begin to understand the relationship of the world wars to women‘s
higher education and professional training.
I: Women’s History
The trend towards social history converged with the feminism of the late
1960s and 1970s to influence a new wave of historical writing concerned with
the position of women in North America. Scholars detailed the history of the
struggle for women‘s rights and in so doing identified periods and contexts
that were particularly oppressive or egalitarian for women. Indirectly, the
world wars were at the centre of this history. Scholars identified in the wars
two critical turning points in the history of women in Canada: first, the
achievement of the two major goals of the first wave women‘s movement—
prohibition and suffrage—during the First World War; and second, the
massive entry of married women into the paid labour force during the Second
World War, regarded as essential to the liberation of women from the
26
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
patriarchal divisions of labour.3 In this context, scholarship on women and the
wars during the 1970s and 1980s was largely framed by a discussion of their
impact, a debate which Joan Wallach Scott termed the ―watershed‖ theory.4
According to Scott, historians either affirmed or denied that the world wars
were major turning points in the history of women and this, she argued,
constitutes the central debate in the historiography.5
Canadian scholarship was intent on documenting women‘s expression
of a ―feminist consciousness‖ and delineating the emergence of a political and
public female voice.6 Thus, in the 1980s, historians began looking at the First
World War period and women‘s roles in opposition and pacifist movements,
as well as their wider participation in politics.7 They were particularly
interested in analyzing the period after the winning of the vote in an effort to
explain why first wave feminism did not achieve gender equality.8 Early
scholarship attributed the winning of suffrage to society‘s acknowledgement
of the indispensable work done by Canadian women during the war, but
others, including military historians, cautioned that at least in part, suffrage
3. Alison Prentice et al., Canadian Women: A History (Toronto: Harcourt Brace
Jovanovich, 1988); and W. Lynn, From Working Girl to Working Mother: The Female Labor Force in
the United States, 1820–1980 (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1985).
4. Joan Wallach Scott, ―Rewriting History,‖ in Behind the Lines: Gender and the Two
World Wars, ed. Margaret Higonnet et al. (New Haven and London: Yale University Press,
1987), 23–25.
5. Ibid., 23.
6. This corresponds to studies of American and European women during war and
conflict. See Mary Beth Norton, Liberty‘s Daughters: The Revolutionary Experience of American
Women, 1750-1800 (Boston: Little, Brown, 1980); Anne Firor Scott, The Southern Lady (Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 1970); R. McNair Wilson, Women of the French Revolution (New York:
Kennikat Press, 1970); and Darline Gray Levy, Harriet Brandon Applewhite, and Mary Durham
Johnson, eds., Women in Revolutionary Paris, 1789–1795 (Urbana: University of Illinois Press,
1979).
7. See Barbara Roberts, ―Why do Women do nothing to end the War?‖ Canadian FeministPacifists and the Great War (Ottawa: Canadian Research Institute for the Advancement of
Women, 1985); Linda Kealey, A Not Unreasonable Claim: Women and Reform in Canada, 1880s–
1920s (Toronto: Women‘s Press, 1979); and Linda Kealey and Joan Sangster, eds., Beyond the
Vote: Canadian Women and Politics (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1989).
8. See Carol Lee Bacchi, Liberation Deferred (Toronto: Univeristy of Toronto Press,
1983), 146, 7, 12, 148.
27
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
had to be explained in relation to the conscription crisis of 1917 and the
political manoeuvrings of Borden‘s union government.9 Viewing higher
education as central to women‘s independence, and recognizing the
importance suffragists placed on higher education, historians measured
women‘s access to higher education as a means of assessing the success of
first wave feminism. For instance, Veronica Strong-Boag demonstrated that
women made significant gains in university enrolment after the First World
War and that during the 1920s, women‘s organizations and clubs on campuses
flourished. Yet, she also documented a decline in the percentage of women
enrolled in male-dominated fields between 1920 and 1940 and argued that
misogyny and ―anti-woman feeling‖ pervaded Canadian campuses,
―undermining intellectual confidence and self-esteem‖ among women.10
Worse, she argued, women‘s hopes for education quickly shattered during the
economic collapse of the 1930s. Rather than directly linking these gains and
losses to the First World War, however, Strong-Boag explored their relation to
suffrage and explained women‘s losses in higher education to declining
feminism.11
Analysis of the impact of the First World War was intertwined with
an assessment of the impact of suffrage and feminism, but when turning their
attention to the Second World War, historians focused on women‘s paid
labour. The influence of Marxism and neo-Marxism on historical study
combined with interest in the ―women‘s question‖ to produce a number of
studies on working-class women in the late 1960s, shifting focus away from
9. See Catherine Lyle Cleverdon, The Woman Suffrage Movement in Canada (Toronto:
University of Toronto Press, 1950), 11.
10. Veronica Strong-Boag, The New Day Recalled: Lives of Girls and Women in English
Canada, 1919–1939 (Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman, 1988), 23, 26.
11. In her study of Canadian female doctors, Strong-Boag also connected the decline
in feminism to an emerging ―conservative approach‖ amongst the majority of female doctors
and explored the impact of professionalism and maternal feminism on female doctors in the
early twentieth century. See Veronica Strong-Boag, ―Canada‘s Women Doctors: Feminism
Constrained,‖ in A Not Unreasonable Claim: Women and Reform in Canada, 1880s–1920s, ed. Linda
Kealey (Toronto: Women‘s Press, 1979).
28
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
―women worthies.‖12 The contemporary context of this scholarship provided
further impetus for exploring Canadian topics on gender and labour as the
decade witnessed revisions to provincial legislation concerning equal pay and
federally guaranteed pay equality under the 1977 Canadian Human Rights Act.
According to Hugh Armstrong and Pat Armstrong, an increasing awareness of
the gender inequalities of the Canadian labour force emerged in the late 1960s,
establishing a literature which provided an analytical framework for scholarly
analyses of the disparities in the marketplace.13 For Canadian and American
scholars of women‘s history, as well as labour and economic history, this
burgeoning interest developed into a massive—and intertwined—field on
women and work in the twentieth century, which emphasized the Second
World War as a crisis in the history of women and labour.14
A few studies emerged during the Second World War establishing the
war as a ―watershed‖ in the history of women and labour. Charlotte Whitton‘s
Canadian Women in the War Effort, published in 1942, and Helen Baker‘s
American study Women in War Industries of that same year, drew attention to
the number of women entering into war-related work.15 In 1943, Evelyn Steele
12. English Marxist historians such as Eric J. Hobsbawm and Edward Thompson
were extremely influential in the late 1960s and early 1970s, helping to give rise to the new
labour history. Instead of focusing on the history of trade-union movements, this new history
primarily examined working-class history and applied a bottom-up approach to the study of
labour. This field also began to integrate questions of gender and race into analyses of class and
labour.
13. Hugh Armstrong and Pat Armstrong, ―The Segregated Participation of Women
in the Canadian Labour Force, 1941–71,‖ The Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology 12, no.
4 (1975): 370.
14. There has been similar, albeit less, interest in the effects of the First World War
on women and labour. See Mary MacLeod, ―Canadian Women War Workers Overseas,‖ The
Canadian Magazine 52, no. 3 (1919): 737–751; Ceta Ramkhalawansingh, ―Women during the
Great War,‖ in Women at Work: Ontario 1850–1930, eds. Janice Acton, Penny Goldsmith, and
Bonnie Shepard (Toronto: Canadian Women‘s Educational Press, 1974); and Linda Kealey,
―Women and Labour during World War I: Women Workers and the Minimum Wage in
Manitoba,‖ in First Days, Fighting Days: Women in Manitoba History, ed. Mary Kinnear (Regina:
University of Regina, 1987): 76–99.
15. Helen Baker‘s study is particularly interesting because it argued that women were
being utilized more effectively in Canadian war work and proposed that American women
29
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
examined women‘s entrance into careers in science and engineering.16 These
accounts were optimistic. Take, for example, a portion of Steele‘s work:
The prejudice against women in the realms of science and
engineering is disappearing and they are being given the
opportunity to come into their own as professional scientists
and engineers...the government is urging women to train in
science and engineering. Industry, in co-operation with
colleges and universities, is offering wide opportunities
designed to train women for immediate technical jobs, jobs
which had all the potentialities of developing into permanent,
postwar careers.17
Wartime and immediate postwar emphasis on the workforce advantages for
women led Glen Cain to caution in 1966 against exaggerating the war‘s
influence.18 The response by American scholars was immense. Arthur
Marwick and Gordon Wright argued women‘s lives were profoundly altered
for the better during the Second World War because of the need for women‘s
labour and the role of the state in encouraging women to enter into war
work.19 Chester W. Gregory‘s study alleged that not only did women enter
into the workforce but that this led to greater equality between the sexes. The
could be put to better work assisting the government and private organizations. See Charlotte
Whitton, Canadian Women in the War Effort (Toronto: Macmillan, 1942) and Helen Baker, Women
in War Industries (Princeton: s.n., 1942).
16. Evelyn Steele, Careers for Girls in Science and Engineering (New York: E. P. Dutton,
1943) and Wartime Opportunities for Women (New York: E. P. Dutton, 1943).
17. Steele, Careers for Girls in Science and Engineering, 15, 19.
18. Glen Cain, Married Women in the Labor Force: An Economic Analysis (Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 1966).
19. Arthur Marwick, Britain in the Century of Total War: War, Peace, and Social Change
1900–1967 (London: Macmillan, 1968); and Gordon Wright, The Ordeal of Total War, 1939–1945
(New York: Harper Torch Books, 1968). The academic and popular persistence of the view that
the war positively impacted women is evident in later work. For example, see Costello, Virtue
Under Fire: How World War II Changed Our Social and Sexual Attitudes (Boston: Little, Brown, &
Co., 1986).
30
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
war implanted new ―seeds of social change‖ and ideas which nearly ―created a
new woman.‖ 20 In his pioneering work on changes in twentieth-century
American women‘s status, William H. Chafe documented the opportunities
opened up to women by wartime shortages in male labour—better jobs,
higher wages, and unionized industries—and argued that the changing work
habits of women made the 1940s ―a turning point in the history of American
women.‖21
In the early 1970s, American scholars began to frame the debate in
terms of the long- and short-term impact of the Second World War and
questioned whether these included a change in conventional attitudes
regarding the role of women in society. Eleanor Straub challenged the notion
of female agency, arguing that manpower policies sidelined women and that
the expertise of female leadership was largely disregarded by organized
labour.22 Scholars such as Joan Ellen Trey, Sheila Tobias, and Lisa Anderson
believed women were used as a reserve labour force and cast off when their
interests did not suit the needs of the government.23 Juanita Kreps, D‘Ann
Campbell, Alan Clive, and Leila Rupp added to these discussions with various
20. Chester W. Gregory, Women in Defense Work during World War II: An Analysis of the
Labor Problem and Women‘s Rights (New York: Exposition Press, 1974).
21. In addition, Chafe suggested that the unprecedented proportion of married
women in paid labour altered their perceptions of themselves and helped break the division
between the public and private spheres. Paralleling the interpretations of women activists during
the First World War, Chafe argued that while wartime gains did not persist into the postwar
period, the contradiction between women‘s changed perceptions and desire to work and
society‘s intensified prescriptions about women‘s domestic role helped facilitate the second
wave feminist movement. See William H. Chafe, The American Woman: Her Changing Social,
Economic, and Political Role, 1920–1970 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1972), 8. A revised
version of this work was published in 1991: Chafe, The Paradox of Change: American Women in the
Twentieth Century (New York: Oxford University Press, 1991).
22. Eleanor F. Straub, ―United States Government Policy toward Civilian Women
during World War II,‖ Prologue 5 (1973): 240–254.
23. Joan Ellen Trey, ―Women in the War Economy – World War II,‖ Review of Radical
Political Economics 4, no. 3 (1972):40–57; and Sheila Tobias and Lisa Anderson, ―What Really
Happened to Rosie the Riveter? Demobilization and the Female Labor Force, 1944-47,‖ MSS
Modular Publications, Modular 9 (1973): 1–36.
31
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
topical discussions.24 Quantitative evidence pointed to the decline of women,
particularly married women, in the workforce in the postwar years, but
scholars debated the methods by which women were exited from the labour
force; forced lay-offs, discrimination, manipulation by the media, and the
ideology that re-established a new feminine ideal in the postwar period were
some of the explanations put forth. In 1980, an anthology on women and war,
Women, War, and Revolution, edited by Carol R. Berkin and Clara M. Lovett,
analyzed the expectations that were raised in women by war and revolution in
a range of conflicts from the eighteenth to the twentieth century. These
contributors shifted focus away from government policy and statistics to
concentrate on the responses conveyed in women‘s experiences.25
In Canada, there was significantly less scholarship. Armstrong and
Armstrong‘s 1979 article, ―The Segregated Participation of Women in the
Canadian Labour Force, 1941–1971,‖ provided a general context for women‘s
work during the 1940s.26 They challenged American scholars who posited the
world wars as pivotal in women‘s struggle for equality and argued that the
growing number of women workers during the war ―camouflaged‖ the
relatively static occupational segregation of women‘s labour. Moreover, they
drew attention to the period‘s growing disparity between female and male
incomes. Jean Bruce‘s 1985 Back the Attack was the first book to examine
Canadian women‘s experiences during the Second World War. The chief
themes were positive and the work emphasized that labour opportunities were
24. Juanita Kreps, Sex in the Marketplace: American Women at Work (Baltimore: Johns
Hopkins Press, 1971); D‘Ann Campbell, ―Wives, Workers, and Womanhood: American
Women during World War II‖ (Ph.D. diss., University of North Carolina, 1979); Alan Clive,
―Women Workers in World War II: Michigan as a Test Case,‖ Labour History 20 (1979): 44–72;
Leila Rupp, ―Women, Class and Mobilization in Nazi Germany,‖ Science and Society 43 (1979):
51–69; and Leila Rupp, ―‗I don‘t call that Volksgemeinschaft:‘ Women, Class, and War in Nazi
Germany,‖ in Women, War, and Revolution, eds. Carol R. Berkin and Clara M. Lovett, (New York;
London: Holmes and Meier, 1980).
25. Berkin and Lovett, eds., Women, War, and Revolution.
26. Armstrong and Armstrong, ―The Segregated Participation of Women in the
Canadian Labour Force, 1941–71.‖ Research from this article was later used in their book
Double Ghetto: Canadian Women and their Segregated Work (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1979).
32
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
welcomed in the aftermath of the Great Depression. A mixture of
photographs and personal interviews makes the book a valuable record of the
war period, but in the context of earlier articles and pioneering American
monographs, it is severely lacking in its analysis.27
The following year emerged Ruth Roach Pierson‘s pioneering fulllength study. ―They‘re Still Women After All‖ remains the most influential work
on Canadian women in war.28 Pierson‘s research began during the mid-1970s
as the watershed debate deepened in the United States.29 Influenced by the
scholars discussed above, Pierson articulated, and responded to, many of the
themes they addressed by looking at and comparing the Canadian context to
American and British evidence. Her final conclusions were bleak. She
disparaged the claims that war brought gains for women, argued the Canadian
government viewed women as a labour reserve to be tapped as needed,
suggested women‘s place remained in the home during and after the war, and
demonstrated that child care and other special provisions for women workers
were inadequate and temporary. In short, the war did little to alter the lives of
women for the better. More so, a backlash to the war‘s temporary changes in
gender roles resulted in an intensified political and ideological conservatism in
the postwar period that diverged even from prewar conventions. Pierson‘s
work added to North American scholarship by highlighting aspects of the
Canadian experience which differed from that of the American, notably the
registration of all potential women workers, a tax law encouraging wives to
work, and a campaign to recruit women as part-time labourers. But her
analysis lacked a more specific focus on the range of women‘s experiences
27. Jean Bruce, Back the Attack! Canadian Women during the Second World War – at Home
and Abroad (Toronto: Macmillan, 1985).
28. Ruth Roach Pierson, ―They‘re Still Women After All:‖ The Second World War and
Canadian Womanhood (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1986).
29. Pierson published an article and pamphlet prior to the publican of her book. See
Ruth Roach Pierson, ―Women‘s Emancipation and the Recruitment of Women into the Labour
Force in World War II,‖ in Neglected Majority: Essays in Canadian Women‘s History, ed. Susan M.
Trofimenkoff and Alison Prentice (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1977); and Ruth Roach
Pierson, Canadian Women and the Second World War (Ottawa: Canadian Historical Association,
1983).
33
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
during the war. Her defence was that her focus was on ―the larger patterns in
government policy and gender ideology that map the determinants to
women‘s social existence,‖ but this ignored the role of women in perpetuating
or rebelling against gender conventions.30 In particular, by ignoring women‘s
entrance into higher education, Pierson neglected to examine one of the
central means by which women struggled to obtain equality and a level of
social mobility.
Despite the possibility to explore many other aspects of women‘s
lives during the Second World War, following Pierson‘s study Canadian
women‘s historians largely lost interest in the topic. Few scholars responded
to her work or challenged her conclusions, evidenced in the still frequent
referencing of Pierson‘s interpretation.31 American historians, on the other
hand, began exploring the complexity of female wartime experiences in
comprehensive monographs during the 1980s and 1990s. Karen Anderson‘s
Wartime Women moved analyses of the Second World War out of the
economic sphere—and by extension the work of labour and Marxist
historians—to look at the diversity of women‘s experiences during the war,
including in her study, for example, an analysis of the experiences of AfricanAmerican women.32 This led to explorations of lesser known wartime
developments for women, including changes in women‘s higher education.
Susan Hartmann‘s book, for example, examined women‘s experiences in the
military, employment in the government, legal status, familial trends,
participation in politics, and educational achievements. Synthesizing the
conclusions drawn during the 1970s, Hartmann outlined a central concept in
the debate: the war impacted the position of women ―for the duration‖ of the
30. Pierson, ―They‘re Still Women After All,‖ 219.
31. Only two works have directly challenged Pierson‘s conclusions: Diane Forestell,
―The Necessity of Sacrifice for a Nation at War: Women‘s Labour Force Participation, 19391945,‖ Social History / Histoire Sociale 22, no. 4 (1989): 333–347; and Jeffrey Keshen, ―Revisiting
Canada‘s Civilian Women during World War II,‖ Social History / Histoire Sociale 30, no. 60
(1997): 239–266.
32. Karen Anderson, Wartime Women: Sex Roles, Family Relations, and the Status of Women
during World War II (Westport, CT: Greenwood, 1981), 155.
34
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
war. She established that war had an ambiguous impact on women‘s entrance
into higher education and the type of studies women pursued. While it
temporarily promoted greater opportunity for female study in traditionally
male areas, Hartmann found that war also contributed to the withdrawal of
women from both secondary and post-secondary institutions because of new
and better-paying jobs. She acknowledged that new educational opportunities
opened to women but her data confirmed that women‘s educational
attainments declined relative to men in the postwar period and that college
preparation continued to emphasize women‘s roles as wives and mothers
rather than career women. Nonetheless, Hartmann pointed to some lasting,
positive achievements for women in institutions of higher learning. Unlike
Strong-Boag‘s study which found that women‘s participation in the
professions declined in Canada in the post-First World War period, Hartmann
found that between 1940 and 1950, American university women broadened
their participation in the professions, specifically journalism, engineering, and
law.33 A variety of scholars added to Hartmann‘s discussion, including
Margaret Randolph Higgonet, Rochelle Gatlin, and Elaine Tyler May. They
illustrated the complexity of the war‘s impact on women, maintaining that case
studies were crucial to understanding how the wars altered women‘s lives.34
An assessment of this work is crucial to the furthering of work addressing the
Canadian context.
Several key themes were established by women‘s historians and are
worth reviewing. First, North American women entered institutions of higher
learning in higher numbers during the world wars. Second, female enrolment
increased in numbers in both post-war periods but declined in percentage
despite the loss of young men. Third, women were concentrated in Arts
programs but during the wars they achieved small gains in academic programs
33 Ibid., 23, 103–104, 101, 114.
34. Margaret Randolph Higgonet et al., eds., Behind the Lines: Gender and the Two World
Wars (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1987); Rochelle Gatlin, American Women
since 1945 (Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1987); and May Elaine Tyler, Homeward
Bound: American Families in the Cold War Era (New York: Basic Books, 1988).
35
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
that were male-dominated, including the professions. This, however, was
countered in the postwar periods and has been explained by a variety of
factors, including women‘s entrance into new areas of study in the university,
such as household science, and a decline in feminism. As part of a broader
effort to explain the impact of a variety of social trends on women in North
American society, scholarship in the field of women‘s history was facilitated
by an interest in women and work which precipitated studies of women‘s
vocational training.35 Nonetheless, by and large, interest in women and work
postponed scholarship on women‘s higher education.36
II: Military History
For Canadian historians, and particularly its military historians, the world wars
were key turning points in the nation‘s history. The historiography of the First
World War is shaped by the notion that Canada became a nation in April 1917
at the Battle of Vimy Ridge. It is the forgetting of this and other key events in
Canada‘s history, argued J. L. Granatstein, one of Canada‘s preeminent
military historians, which has led to a crisis of national identity. ―The war
mattered to Canadians,‖ he wrote, ―and it gave them a sense of nationhood
that has helped to define this country ever since.‖37 In their work on the
Second World War, Norman Hillmer and Granatstein argued that ―Canada
emerged from the crucible of war strengthened‖ and Robert Bothwell wrote
that a ―visitor seeing Canada for the first time since 1939 might well conclude
35. See Ruby Heap, ―Schooling Women for Home or for Work? Vocational
Education for Women in Ontario in the Early Twentieth Century: The Case of the Toronto
Technical High School, 1892–1920,‖ in Gender and Education in Ontario: An Historical Reader, ed.
Ruby Heap and Alison Prentice (Toronto: Canadian Scholars‘ Press, 1991): 197–245.
36. The interest of women‘s and feminist scholars in women‘s paid labour persists.
Joan Sangster‘s recent publication, for example, examines women‘s labour in the post-war
period. Like earlier scholars, Sangster does not examine women‘s professional labour or
education, or education more generally. See Joan Sangster, Transforming Labour: Women and Work
in Postwar Canada (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2010).
37. J. L. Granatstein, Who Killed Canadian History? (Toronto: HarpersCollins, 1998),
132.
36
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
that Canada, even more than nations devastated by war, has become another
country.‖38 Despite analysis of the internal divisions at the centre of the
conscription debates, military historians emphasized that war created a
stronger, prouder, and more independent Canada.39 The roots of this
emphasis can be traced to the early official histories written by men such as
Lord Beaverbrook, A. F. Duguid, and G. W. L. Nicholson.40 As Tim Cook
recently explored, official historians were charged with the momentous task of
writing the history of the world wars in contemporary times, and as such were
under pressure to write laudatory narratives that memorialized the heroism of
the Canadian forces.41 Histories of Canada‘s role in the world wars told a
general narrative of the nation‘s wartime experiences, largely ignoring class,
gender, religious, and ethnic differences.42 Treatment of women before the
influence of women‘s history in the 1970s and 1980s depicted women as
―auxiliaries,‖ even while expounding upon their virtues and describing the
selfless efforts of volunteers, nurses, and women of the Canadian Women‘s
38. Norman Hillmer and J. L. Granatstein, Empire to Umpire (Toronto: Copp Clark
Longman, 1994), 181; Robert Bothwell, Canada since 1945 (Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 1989), xi.
39. In Canada‘s War, Granatstein argues that the Second World War was a key
moment in Canadian nation-building. He depicts the war as one that allowed the nation to grow
stronger, wealthier, and more independent. He emphasizes the role the war played in bringing
the nation out of the Great Depression and in providing full employment; second, the broad
consensus that the war was just and necessary; and finally, the solidification of the welfare state.
This juxtaposed the human sacrifices of the wars with the social, economic, and political gains.
See J. L. Granatstein, Canada‘s War: The Politics of the Mackenzie King Government, 1939–1945
(Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1975).
40. See Lord Beaverbrook, Canada in Flanders (London and Toronto: Hodder and
Stoughton, 1916); A. F. Duguid, Official History of the Canadian Forces in the Great War, August 1914
to September 1915 (Ottawa: King‘s Printer, 1938); and G. W. L. Nichsolon, Canadian Expeditionary
Force, 1914–1919: The Official History of the Canadian Army in the First World War (Ottawa: Queen‘s
Printer, 1962).
41. Tim Cook, Clio‘s Warriors: Canadian Historians and the Writing of the World Wars
(Vancouver: UBC Press, 2006).
42. The exception to this was the treatment of French Canadians during the war,
although even this field has garnered more attention in recent years.
37
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
Army Corps. By the same token, few military historians mentioned Canadian
universities.43
In the last thirty years, however, our understanding of military history
has changed significantly. The influence of social history led to the creation of
the ―new military history‖ which, among other things, examines the effects of
war on society and the civilian population.44 One of the distinguishing
characteristics of the new military history is that it includes a discussion of the
impact of the world wars on women. In Canada, this has been fairly recent,
emerging in the mid- to late-1980s.45 The lack of published work on the
impact of the world wars on women and higher education in part must reflect
the lack of scholarship, and its relatively recent treatment, on the total
experience of Canada during the wars. Still, it must also be acknowledged that
analysis of women is lacking depth and scope.
Like the work of women‘s and feminist historians, studies of the new
military history examining wartime women were initially optimistic. This is
partly due to the conventions of the field. Despite the new focus on the home
front, books and articles retained some of the earlier frameworks for analyzing
the impact of the world wars. Scholars held onto narratives that depicted the
wars as harbingers of positive change, or, at the very least, as periods of
intense turmoil that transformed the nation and facilitated the construction of
the modern state. In this context, changes in the position of women were used
43. The exception to this was the early work of Wilfrid Eggleston, which discussed
the scientific research undertaken by universities during the Second World War. See Wilfrid
Eggleston, Scientists at War (Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1950) and Canada‘s Nuclear Story
(Toronto: Clarke, Irwin, 1965).
44. See Don Higginbotham, ―The New Military History: Its Practitioners and Their
Practices,‖ in Military History and the Military Profession, ed. David A. Charters, Marc Milner, and J.
Brent Wilson (Westport, CT: Praeger, 1992); Richard Preston, ―Canadian Military History: A
Reinterpretation Challenge for the Eighties,‖ American Review of Canadian Studies 19, no. 1 (1989):
102–3; and Edward M. Coffman ―The New American Military History,‖ Military Affairs 48, no.
1 (1984): 1–5.
45. For example, Jeffrey Keshen‘s Propaganda and Censorship during Canada‘s Great War
(Edmonton: University of Alberta Press, 1996) was the first comprehensive examination of the
Canadian home front in the First World War.
38
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
as further evidence of the war‘s wide and lasting impact. Thus, the new
military history emphasized the role the First World War played in women
getting the federal vote in 1918 and pointed out that it was during the Second
World War that women were allowed to vote in the Quebec provincial
election.46 In discussions of the impact of the Second World War, military
historians quoted the numerous studies being done on women and work,
initially siding with the American women‘s and labour historians who
emphasized the positive influence of the war on women in the workforce.
Women, they argued, were entering the workforce in unprecedented numbers
and into traditionally ―male‖ occupations. In Canada and the Two World Wars,
for example, Granatstein and Desmond Morton wrote that ―the world wars
were catalysts for every imaginable reform, from women‘s suffrage in 1918 to
the right of workers after 1944 to bargain collectively and to share the wealth
they had helped create.‖47 Women were referenced as supporting arguments
for a larger thesis emphasizing the transformative aspects of the world wars
and the wartime factors that facilitated the growth of the modern Canadian
nation. This is not to diminish the work that has been done by military
historians; rather, it points to a problem in studies of wartime women
undertaken by military historians. Additionally, the treatment of women
remains largely separated from the larger discussion and in being relegated to a
single chapter or topic of the discussion—work, family, home life, nursing—
women are not integrated into these histories.
Despite developments in the new military history over the last thirty
years, where military historians disagree with the ―progress narrative‖ of the
46. The controversial Wartime Elections Act passed by the Borden government in
1917 enfranchised women who were serving in the forces or who had close relatives in the
armed services. In response, the National Council of Women petitioned the federal government
to grant all women the federal franchise. This led to the Women‘s Franchise Act of 1918, which
gave the federal vote to all women twenty-one and over. Women won the provincial vote in
Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and Alberta in 1916; Ontario in 1917; Nova Scotia in 1918; New
Brunswick in 1919; P.E.I. in 1922; and finally Quebec in 1940.
47. J. L. Granatstein and Desmond Morton, Canada and the Two World Wars (Toronto:
Key Porter Books, 2003), xiv.
39
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
impact of the wars on women, they have deferred to the pioneering and
innovative analyses of women and war done by women‘s historians, the work
of Pierson in particular. While an attestation to the value of some of the
groundbreaking studies on women and the wars, by not undertaking their own
studies, the treatment of women by military historians has become dated.
There are notable exceptions, however, that provide insight into the war‘s
impact on women. Recent community-level studies by historians such as
Robert Rutherdale and Serge Durflinger have yielded more detailed accounts
of women‘s wartime experiences.48 Keshen‘s Saints, Sinners, and Soldiers
integrated the diverse experiences of women into an analysis of Canada during
the Second World War and attributed many positive developments in
women‘s positions to wartime exigencies.49 He chronicled the entrance of
women into the workforce, the development of tax breaks for working
couples, and legislation for state-run child care. Keshen pointed out that
during the war women ―came to constitute a larger proportion of the student
body: in 1945 28.6 percent of all undergraduate degrees in Canada were
conferred upon women, up from 21.3 percent in 1939.‖ The number of
female students obtaining Bachelors of Science degrees also increased. Not
only were there developments on campuses, Keshen argued, but female
graduates had greater opportunities to gain employment, particularly students
with scientific and technical training.50
48. Robert Rutherdale, Hometown Horizons: Local Responses to Canada‘s Great War
(Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2004); and Serge Durflinger, Fighting from
Home: The Second World War in Verdun, Quebec (Vancouver: UBC Press, 2006). In the latter,
Durflinger argued that analyses of local responses to the war complement national studies and
help create a fuller picture of the world wars and their impact. By focusing his analysis on
Verdun, Quebec, Durflinger presented a more balanced image of the impact of the Second
World War on women.
49. A quick review of the index alone reveals the difference in Keshen‘s treatment of
women and that of other studies. There are pages of headings that direct the reader to
discussions on women, while in Granatstein and Morton‘s treatment of the world wars there are
only a handful. See Jeffrey Keshen, Saints, Sinners, and Soldiers: Canada‘s Second World War
(Vancouver: UBC Press, 2004).
50. Ibid., 148.
40
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
Military historians have proven more adept at integrating the study of
higher education and, at times, this focus includes analysis of developments in
women‘s higher education. Most notable is Desmond Morton and Glenn
Wright‘s work on the reintegration of Canadian veterans after the First World
War.51 As part of their study, Morton and Wright analyzed the government‘s
response to veterans and the development of programs for their reestablishment. They argued that the development of treatment services for
disabled soldiers influenced women‘s training in new health sectors. Morton
and Wright were the first Canadian historians to connect postwar government
planning for veterans to the evolution of training programs in new health
fields that were largely populated by women. The influence of their work must
be emphasized: it encouraged historians of higher education to look more
closely at the development of university health programs, such as physical and
occupational therapy, and precipitated further research on veteran policies.
Peter Neary and Granatstein‘s 1998 study of the Veterans‘ Charter
examined the impact of the government‘s post-Second World War veterans‘
policies. This legislation provided veterans with, among other benefits, free
vocational training and university education.52 Neary and Granatstein
documented a rise in male enrolment in Canadian universities in the
immediate postwar period; but, they did not analyze the impact of this
legislation on female enrolment, despite the findings of the earlier work of
Shaun Brown and Neary. Both Brown‘s dissertation and his 1995 article coauthored with Neary addressed the impact of the Veterans‘ Charter on female
servicewomen.53 In his dissertation, Brown used statistics from the
51. Desmond Morton and Glenn Wright, Winning the Second Battle: Canadian Veterans
and the Return to Civilian Life, 1915–1930 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1987).
52 Similar legislation was passed in the United States under the G.I. Bill.
53 Peter Neary and J. L. Granatstein, The Veteran‘s Charter and Post-World War II
Canada (Montreal: McGill-Queen‘s University Press, 1998); Shaun Brown, ―Re-Establishment
and Rehabilitation: Canadian Veteran Policy, 1933-1946‖ (Ph.D. diss., The University of
Western Ontario, 1995); and Peter Neary and Shaun Brown, ―The Veterans Charter and
Canadian Women Veterans of World War II,‖ in The Good Fight: Canadians and World War II, ed.
J. L. Granatstein and Peter Neary (Toronto: Copp Clark, 1995).
41
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
Department of Labour for ex-service personnel in the year of the greatest
demand for veterans benefits (1945-1946) to demonstrate that more female
than male veterans were enrolled at university that year. Comparing this with
other statistics, such as unemployment percentages of veterans in the same
year, Brown concluded that female veterans participated in Post Discharge
Rehabilitation Order programs at a higher level than male veterans. More
women enrolled in university programs (6.1 percent compared to 5.8 percent)
and there was a striking contrast between the percentage of women and men
pursuing vocational training (21.3 percent compared to 8.3 percent). He also
noted that the university programs of female veterans diverged from those of
civilian women. In 1946 in New Brunswick, for example, 24 percent of female
veterans enrolled in home economics and arts, 33 percent in nursing science,
15 percent in social work, 6 percent in physical education, and 4 percent in
science. While female veterans enrolled in programs that were predominantly
labelled ―female,‖ there was a difference between the programs they chose
and that of the civilian population of women where 63 percent enrolled in arts
and science, 8.6 percent in public health nursing, and 7.2 percent in social
work.54 This analysis examined female veterans in higher education during the
postwar period, and while the conclusions are central to an understanding of
the impact of the war on women‘s access to higher education, there has been
little analysis of the immediate effect of war on women‘s higher education.
There are many areas in the new military history that offer
opportunities for future research. Recent interest in the Second World War
has resulted in fewer hometown studies of the First World War, leaving a need
to integrate women‘s experiences into the larger history of the First World
War. Research can also be directed to filling the gaps in already published
studies. For example, Michael Stevenson‘s study on the National Selective
Service (NSS) examined a number of sectors of society that were mobilized
during the Second World War, including university students. He explored the
process by which university students were conscripted for home service and
54. Brown, 265–267.
42
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
the conditions by which students were granted deferments. According to
Stevenson, the National Conference of Canadian Universities was largely
responsible for determining what students would be granted deferments and
developed ―a scientific and measurable standard for students deferments‖ that
allowed for the exemption of students enrolled in specific disciplines.55 This
standard enabled officials to grant exemptions based on a perceived need to
continue graduating skilled individuals for the civilian economy and the armed
forces. Thus, they limited the number of male students in Arts courses and
granted exemptions to science, professional, and technical students.
Stevenson, unfortunately, did not explore the impact of student deferment
policies on female students at Canadian universities. A discussion of how
these policies opened up specific areas of academic study to women while
continuing to restrict other programs would shed more light on the impact of
wartime mobilization on women‘s higher education.
The scholarship on women undertaken by military historians has
often relied too heavily on the original research done by women‘s historians;
therefore, gaps in the scholarship are echoed in both fields. The watershed
debate heavily influenced the treatment of women by military historians.
Scholars initially quoted the studies on women and work, siding with the
American women‘s and labour historians who emphasized the positive
influence of the Second World War on women in the workforce. In this
context, women were evidence of larger, national developments. Yet, by and
large, the positive impact of war on women has been criticized by military
historians in the last twenty years. In the words of Michael Stevenson, ―it is a
telling sign of the embryonic nature of Canadian social history that Pierson‘s
pioneering study, published in 1986, remains the principal account of the role
55. According to Stevenson, there were eleven programs that qualified for special
deferment status: ―Medicine, Dentistry, Engineering or Applied Science, Architecture,
Agriculture, Pharmacy, Forestry, Education, Commerce, Veterinary Science, and specialized
courses in mathematics, physics, chemistry, biology, and geology.‖ See Michael D. Stevenson,
Canada‘s Greatest Wartime Muddle: National Selective Service and the Mobilization of Human Resources
during World War II (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen‘s University Press, 2001), 65, 195.
43
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
of women in society between 1939 and 1945.‖56 More extensive studies of the
role and status of Canadian women during the world wars have been
prevented by a lingering dependence on Pierson‘s monograph and thus
original research on women is scarce in the field.
III: Higher Education
Before the influence of social history, historians of higher education wrote
primarily institutional histories. James Cameron, Walter H. Johns, John G.
Reid, James Talman, and P. B. Waite portrayed Canadian universities
positively and expounded upon the virtues of these institutions.57 Like military
historians, their narratives placed a premium on progress. Discussion of the
world wars seldom received extensive or penetrating treatment and usually
constituted only a single chapter or more commonly, a few paragraphs.58
Some universities commissioned histories of their wartime contributions, but
these customarily documented the raising of university battalions and often
doubled as commemorative albums. The student body is largely absent.59 The
field has since grown in ―spurts‖ of activity. Large institutional histories are
56. Ibid., 176.
57. James D. Cameron, For the People: A History of St. Francis Xavier University,
Montreal: McGill-Queen‘s University Press, 1996); Walter H. Johns, The History of the University of
Alberta 1908–1969 (Edmonton: The University of Alberta Press, 1981); John G. Reid, Mount
Allison University: A History, to 1963 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1984); James
Talman, ―Western‖ 1878–1953 (London: University of Western Ontario, 1953); and P. B. Waite,
The Lives of Dalhousie (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen‘s University Press, 1994).
58. A forthcoming volume on universities in war promises to provide some of this
work. It includes a contribution from Paul Axelrod and Charles Levi comparing higher
education in Canada and Britain during the First and Second World Wars as well as a chapter by
Sara Burke on the impact of the First World War on women‘s higher education. The latter
argues that scholars have magnified the impact of the war on women‘s education and that the
roots of change should be posited in the pre-war period. See Paul Stortz and E. Lisa
Panayotidis, eds., Cultures, Communities, and Conflict: Histories of Canadian Universities and War
(Toronto: University of Toronto Press, forthcoming).
59. There are some exceptions, for example W. P. Thompson‘s work examined
student and academic life on campus during the war. See W. P. Thompson, Yesteryears at the
University of Saskatchewan, 1937–1949 (Saskatoon: University of Saskatchewan, 1969).
44
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
still published, made possible by university alumni associations, but they now
focus on understanding the student experience. This shift was fuelled by an
effort to establish the field within the emerging social and cultural histories of
the 1960s and 1970s.
In the late 1970s, new scholars, often Marxist in orientation, began to
examine the social function of higher education, arguing that the priorities of
universities reinforced class hierarchies and capitalism.60 In particular, they
looked at the process by which universities were increasingly given economic
purposes, taking note of the function of the university during the world wars.
The re-evaluation of the role of the university in society challenged previous
narratives that emphasized the history of higher education as a linear
progression, replacing the tracing of the emergence of egalitarian institutions
of higher learning with questions about the relationship between the state,
business, and the university. Paul Axelrod pioneered a dialogue around the
societal role of Canadian universities and directly linked the objectives of the
state to support for higher education.61 In doing so, he and other scholars reexamined the traditional conception of the ―ivory tower‖ and connected
developments and changes at the university to larger socio-political and
economic development. This included examining more thoroughly the
changing student population and student experiences on campus in relation to
larger trends and developments, such as the wars. The institutional histories
by Frederick W. Gibson and C. M. Johnson and John Weaver reflect this
change, examining student and academic life on campus during wartime.62
A.B. McKillop‘s Matters of Mind was deeply influenced by social history and
60. See R. W. Nelsen and D. A. Nock, eds., Reading, Writing, and Riches: Education and
the Socio-Economic Order in North America (Kitchener: Between the Lines, 1978) and Stephen
Schecter, ―Capitalism, Class and Educational Reform in Canada,‖ in The Canadian State: Political
Economy and Political Power, ed. Leo Panitch (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1977).
61. Paul Axelrod, Scholars and Dollars: Politics, Economics, and the Universities of Ontario,
1945–1980 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1982).
62. Frederick W. Gibson, Queen‘s University, vol. 2, 1917–1961: To Serve and Yet Be Free
(Montreal: McGill-Queen‘s University Press, 1983); and C. M. Johnson and John Weaver,
Student Days: Student Life at McMaster University from the 1890s to the 1980s (Hamilton, ON:
McMaster University Alumni Association, 1986).
45
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
provided a solid chapter on the experience of Ontario universities between
1939 and 1945.63 Despite the strengths of this scholarship, both the larger
institutional histories and the smaller histories of a university‘s wartime
contributions largely ignored the impact of the wars on opening up the
university to a larger number of female students.
Historians of higher education and feminist educational historians did
not begin to explore women‘s access to higher education until the early 1980s.
Feminist scholarship on women and higher education was slow to infiltrate
the field, but when it did, it initiated a more thorough examination of
university demographics.64 In Canada, trailblazing studies such as Sandra
Gillett‘s We Walked Very Warily and Lee Stewart‘s ‗It‘s Up to You‘ challenged
historians to analyze more fully university demographics and enrolment
trends.65 Covering periods that included both world wars, Gillett and Stewart
drew a central conclusion regarding the impact of the wars on women:
university and government policy benefitting women did not always stem
from intentions to create equal opportunities for women. For example,
Stewart found that while the University of British Columbia opened up the
first combined hospital nursing training with a university degree program, it
did so because of growing public pressure for higher standards in public
health and hospital care after the First World War, rather than out of concern
for the advancement of women‘s education and their professional mobility.66
Contemporary studies on female students encouraged scholarship on
the history of women and education. In the early 1990s, interest in girls‘
primary- and secondary-school education exploded on an international scale.
63. A. B. McKillop, Matters of Mind: The University in Ontario, 1791–1951 (Toronto:
University of Toronto Press, 1994).
64. Research by American scholars Barbara Solomon, Lyn Gordon, Geraldine
Clifford, and Patricia Graham preceded the work of Canadians. Much of this work illuminated
discriminatory policies of past university administrators.
65. Margaret Gillett, We Walked Very Warily: A History of Women at McGill (Montreal:
Eden Press Women‘s Publications, 1981); Lee Stewart, ‗It‘s Up to You‘: Women at UBC in the
Early Years (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 1990).
66. Stewart, 61.
46
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
In the United States, the American Association of University Women created
a media frenzy with the 1992 publication of How Schools Shortchange Girls. Three
publications on similar topics followed fast in 1994: Myra Sadker and David
Sadker‘s Failing at Fairness, Peggy Orenstein‘s Schoolgirls, and Mary Pipher‘s
Reviving Ophelia. 67 Largely concentrated in the field of sociology, this interest
led to a larger popular discussion about the socialization of boys and girls
which emphasized the role of education. While sociologists did not focus their
studies on higher education, they pointed to the small ratio of female students
enrolled in math- and science-based programs at the university level as
evidence of an earlier gendered education at the primary- and secondaryschool levels. Interest in the Canadian context has been similar as academics
from faculties of education, sociology, history, and women‘s studies have
addressed the topic of gender and education and the topic is not losing
momentum, widening to examine studies at the university level.68
In the last two decades, historians of women and higher education
have been interested in the professionalization of both traditionally ―male‖
and ―female‖ occupations. They began exploring the connection between
women and the professions, and while frequently only touching upon the
direct impact of the wars on women‘s higher education, they nonetheless
recognized that professional developments occurred due to the impact of
wartime or postwar necessities and policies. In particular, the work on women
and science during the twentieth century paid attention to wartime advances.
By the same token, developments in certain fields have garnered more
attention, such as nursing and medicine. Most of this literature examined the
67. Myra Sadker and David Sadker, Failing at Fairness: How America‘s Schools Cheat Girls
(New York: C. Scribner‘s Sons and Toronto: Maxwell Macmillan Canada, 1994); Peggy
Orenstein, Schoolgirls: Young Women, Self-Esteem, and the Confidence Gap (New York: Doubleday,
1994); and Mary Pipher, Reviving Ophelia: Saving the Selves of Adolescent Girls (New York: Ballantine
Books, 1994).
68. See Lesley Andres and Maria Adamuti-Trahce, ―You‘ve Come a Long Way, Baby?
Persistent Gender Inequality in University Enrolment and Completion in Canada, 1979–2004,‖
Canadian Public Policy 33, no. 1 (2007): 93–116.
47
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
impact of both wars, first and foremost because of the time periods explored
by scholars.
By far the most comprehensive and influential study was Margaret W.
Rossiter‘s two volume Women Scientists in America.69 In the first volume,
Rossiter argued that the professionalization of scientific fields towards the end
of the century redefined educational standards, making women‘s access to
employment more difficult.70 She did not believe that the First World War
opened up new opportunities for women; rather, she argued that by the 1910s,
a pattern of hierarchical gender segregation already characterized scientific
employment. The postwar picture offered more hope: between 1920 and
1940, Rossiter noted that there were emerging opportunities for female
scientists in universities and government agencies. In her second volume,
Rossiter identified several conditions during the Second World War and the
post-war period that facilitated the increase of women workers in scientific
labour: large scientific research projects and a commitment to technological
research, diminished funds, available and educated women, and the absence of
men. Yet, she argued that women did not benefit from the expansion of
science and technology in universities. While statistics pointed to a dramatic
increase in women scientists during the war years, Rossiter discredited these
sources. Moreover, despite manpower shortages, there was an ―ambivalent
encouragement‖ of women‘s scientific education and women scientists were
herded into jobs as research or technical assistants. Worse yet, the immediate
69. Margaret Rossiter, Women Scientists in America: Struggles and Strategies to 1940
(Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1982); and Margaret Rossiter Women Scientists in
America: Before Affirmative Action, 1940–1972 (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1995).
It is important to note that Rossiter‘s definition of what constitutes scientific work is generous
in its inclusiveness. Work in the natural sciences, social and behavioural sciences, engineering,
and nutrition are included.
70. Similar arguments are made about the professionalization of medicine. See Mary
Roth Walsh, ―Doctors Wanted, No Women Need Apply:‖ Sexual Barriers in the Medical Profession,
1935–1975 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1977).
48
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
postwar years saw women scientists demoted and replaced by returning
soldiers whose jobs were secured under the G.I. Bill.71
Much of the work pertaining to women‘s higher education can be
found in anthologies.72 Challenging Professions, published in 1999, chronicled the
challenges that women faced in the professions and also the ways in which
women challenged and facilitated changes to the structures and approaches
that marginalized them.73 It included a number of topical articles that are
important to a historiography of women‘s higher education during the world
wars. Meryn Stuart‘s ―War and Peace‖ argued that Canadian nurses in the
First World War ―parlayed the heroic, dutiful image and their unique frontline experience into new careers in public-health nursing.‖ Due to the field‘s
prominence, ―university education became a limited, although ultimately
compromised, reality for these women.‖ In exploring the lasting effects of the
war on women in nursing programs, Stuart found that the war created ―many
of the social conditions necessary for public-health nursing to flourish,‖ but
the Great Depression interrupted this ―momentum‖ and delayed the
expansion of certificate programs into full baccalaureate nursing programs
within the universities. She argued that universities ―were unwilling to give
degrees to nurses because of the status of nursing as a menial, if romanticized,
71. There has been a great deal of scholarship on the American G.I. Bill (officially the
Servicemen‘s Readjustment Act of 1944) which among other assistance provided returning
soldiers with free post-secondary education and employment. See Keith W. Olson, The G.I. Bill,
the Veterans, and the Colleges (Lexington: University of Kentucky Press, 1974); Michael D.
Gambone, The Greatest Generation Comes Home: The Veteran in American Society (College Station:
Texas A&M University Press, 2005); and Robert Francis Saxe, Settling Down: World War II
Veterans‘ Challenge to the Postwar Consensus (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007).
72. There have also been some influential articles. Of note is Nicole Neatby‘s study
of Queen‘s University women during the post-First World War period discussing developments
in education. She argued that changes in women‘s higher education signalled improvement in
the status of women and concluded that Queen‘s women entered the university with the
expectation of employment following graduation, suggesting a departure from traditional
attitudes towards women‘s higher education and paid employment during the 1920s. See Nicole
Neatby, ―Preparing for the Working World: Women at Queen‘s During the 1920s,‖ Historical
Studies in Education / Revue d‘histoire de l‘éducation 1 (1989): 68.
73. Elizabeth Smyth et al., eds., Challenging Professions: Historical and Contemporary
Perspectives on Women‘s Professional Work (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1999).
49
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
occupation,‖ further exacerbated by nursing leaders who ―were ambivalent
about degrees because they did not see them as a goal for all nurses.‖74
Contributors also noted that war impacted the relationship between the
university, government, and students. Linda J. Quiney‘s article on wartime
voluntary nursing during the First World War, for instance, found that the
creation of the Voluntary Aid Detachment workers (VADs) was perceived as
a threat to the status of the permanent nursing profession. Quiney argued that
this perception was not ungrounded. The public role of the VADs and their
lack of training compared with that of the trained graduate nurses
―legitimized‖ the ―wartime interpretation of nursing as both maternal and
patriotic‖ and revived the notion of casually trained nurses, ultimately
challenging the professional aspirations and job security of Canada‘s nurses.
Quiney argued that the establishment of the VADs signalled to the Canadian
nursing associations that they had to complete the national registration
process; thus, the establishment of the VAD program during the First World
War played a ―critical role in Canadian nursing‘s quest for professional
status.‖75
There are also a number of contributors who cover developments in
women‘s higher education during both world wars, for example, W.P.J. Millar
and R. D. Gidney‘s ―Medettes: Thriving or Just Surviving?‖ The contributions
of this work were two-fold. The authors compared female and male medical
students on the basis of their socio-economic and academic background,
progress through their schooling, and professional careers. They drew a
number of conclusions, one of which is that while during both wars women
―crowded into the medical school...as space opened up by the departure of
male students for war service and by the demand for more doctors,‖ the
74. Meryn Stuart, ―War and Peace: Professional Identities and Nurses‘ Training,
1914–1930,‖ in ibid., 171, 172, 187.
75. Linda J. Quiney, ―‗A Certain Education:‘ Wartime Voluntary Nursing and the
Challenge to the Professional Ideal, 1914–1922,‖ in Learning to Practice: Professional Education in
Historical and Contemporary Perspective, ed. Ruby Heap, Wyn Miller, and Elizabeth Smyth (Ottawa:
University of Ottawa Press, 2005), 93–98, 114–115.
50
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
interwar years witnessed fewer opportunities for women in the medical
college. On the other hand, during the 1950s, female entrants into the medical
school had higher records of academic achievement than men. Miller and
Gidney concluded that women studying medicine at the University of
Toronto in the first half of the twentieth century did not thrive or survive;
rather, their experience ―lay somewhere between.‖ They also advised that
women‘s education cannot be analyzed using data alone and must include
other biographical details.76 This is a similar conclusion suggested by the
research of women‘s historians of feminism and women‘s wartime labour.
Combining quantitative and qualitative analyses has produced some of the
more balanced literature on the subject.
Lastly, Ruby Heap‘s discussion of the growth of household science at
the University of Toronto argued that the First World War marked ―an
important turning point‖ in the careers of three women tied to the program:
Annie Laird, Clara Benson, and Violet Ryley. The war ―provided Annie Laird
with a golden opportunity to provide the vital importance of food as a
therapeutic and cost-effective agent in the treatment of sick and wounded
soldiers, and thereby to boost the emerging field of dietetics in Canada.‖
Benson and Ryley were able to capitalize on wartime needs, with the former
―setting the accepted techniques for analysis [of explosives] in munitions
laboratories‖ and the latter becoming appointed as general organizing dietician
for the Military Hospitals Commission. The First World War, Heap suggested,
led to an expansion of hospital dietetics, in turn encouraging the growth of the
household science program and providing employment for graduates. In
conclusion, Heap briefly argued that developments in food chemistry during
the Second World War encouraged men to enter the field and fostered a focus
on university research, leading to the professionalization of the field and the
76. W. P. J. Millar and R. D. Gidney, ―Medettes: Thriving or Just Surviving? Women
Students in the Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, 1910–1951,‖ in Challenging
Professions, 228–229.
51
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
relocation of the faculty within the male-dominated Faculty of Medicine in the
1970s.77
A second anthology, Learning to Practice, published in 2006, contained
two articles central to a discussion of the Second World War‘s impact on
professional schools and the student body. ―Just One of the Gang,‖ authored
by Heap and Ellen Scheinberg, documented the compelling narrative of the
women in the Faculty of Applied Science and Engineering (FASE) at the
University of Toronto from 1939 to 1950. Slightly different than trends found
for women and work which noted declining numbers of female workers
immediately following the war‘s end, Heap and Scheinberg found that
women‘s enrolment became more pronounced between 1939 and 1945 and
did not sharply decline until the 1950s.78 The second article, by Wyn Millar,
Heap, and Bob Gidney, documented the changing demographics of students
in the Faculties of Medicine and Dentistry and FASE at the University of
Toronto from 1910 to the 1950s. Arguing that the socioeconomic
composition of the student body significantly broadened after the Second
World War, this analysis raised important questions, including whether these
changes symbolized a democratization of higher education at the University of
Toronto.79
While these studies provide insight into the impact of the world wars
on women‘s higher education, they are largely specific case studies. Canadian
research has yet to produce the much-needed larger national analyses and
comparative studies. Linda Eisenmann‘s Higher Education for Women in Postwar
America, 1945–1965, published in 2006, provides a good framework for a
77. Ruby Heap, ―From the Science of Housekeeping to the Science of Nutrition:
Pioneers in Canadian Nutrition and Dietetrics at the University of Toronto‘s Faculty of
Household Science, 1900–1950,‖ in Challenging Professions, 151, 154, 158, 162, 163.
78. Ruby Heap and Ellen Scheinberg, ―‗Just One of the Gang‘: Women at the
University of Toronto‘s Faculty of Applied Science and Engineering, 1939–50,‖ in Learning to
Practice.
79. Wyn Millar, Ruby Heap, and Bob Gidney, ―Degrees of Difference: The Students
in Three Professional Schools at the University of Toronto, 1910 to the 1950s,‖ in Learning to
Practice.
52
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
future undertaking of a synthesized study on higher education for Canadian
women in the world wars. Eisenmann examined much of the literature on
postwar higher education and found, like this study has demonstrated, that
traditional historians of higher education did not examine women in their
analyses of the postwar period. Where women appear, Eisenmann argued,
little attention was given to their education.80 While Eisenmann‘s book looks
at the postwar period, her research synthesizes the scholarship undertaken by
American historians on women during the world wars. Furthermore, she
draws on a range of scholarship, recognizing that enough work has not been
undertaken in one specific subfield of history and, that presently, the
scholarship needs to be combined to fully illuminate developments in
women‘s education. Canadian scholars can combine the approaches of
military history, women‘s history, and the history of higher education and
apply Eisenmann‘s methods and conclusions specifically to a study of the
impact of the world wars on women‘s higher education.
IV: Conclusion
An understanding of the changes to women‘s higher education during the
world wars is not possible without weaving together pieces of scholarship
from a variety of fields. Canadian scholarship on the topic is scattered, in part
due to the specificity of the topic but also because of developments in each
field. While the work of women‘s historians has been referenced in a number
of recent studies of the new military history, in some ways, the merging of
women‘s history with military history has been unsuccessful. Women‘s
experiences must be integrated into studies of the world wars, rather than
given ―token‖ treatment. By relying on the original research of women‘s
historians, military historians have largely reproduced existing historiography
on wartime women, accentuating the gaps in the scholarship on women and
80. Linda Eisenmann, Higher Education for Women in Postwar America, 1945–1965
(Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2006), 5.
53
Strata
Anne M. E. Millar
war. There is a need to re-evaluate the conclusions of Pierson and American
scholars. There is also a need for larger, comparative studies of higher
education. Scholars of the history of education should make use of military
and women‘s history to help contextualize and frame their discussions. This is
not to diminish the extensive primary research done by historians of higher
education. To improve our understanding of the impact of war on Canadian
women, the extensive quantitative and qualitative studies on education need to
be incorporated, alongside the work presently being done by European
historians on war and gender. The latter will help provide an ideological and
intellectual framework for studying women and conflict. An important
question remaining to be answered is whether or not ―war‖ was a key variable
in changing women‘s access to higher education and professional training.
The new military history, women‘s history, and new studies of higher
education have been growth fields in the last thirty years. The synthesis of
these fields, as is evident in this examination of the scholarship concerned
with women‘s higher education during the world wars, has posed problems
for historians. The challenge for future historians, and the challenge inherent
in this topic, will be to encourage dialogue between these fields.
Anne M. E. Millar est candidate au doctorat au département d‘histoire de
l‘Université d‘Ottawa et détentrice de la bourse du CRSH. Elle détient un
baccalauréat combiné en anglais et en histoire ainsi qu‘une maîtrise en histoire
de l‘Université de Western Ontario. Ses recherches s‘attardent sur les
universités canadiennes au cours des deux guerres mondiales.
Anne M. E. Millar is a PhD candidate and SSHRC fellow in the Department
of History at the University of Ottawa. She received a combined honours BA
in English and history and a MA in history at the University of Western
Ontario. Her dissertation examines Canadian universities during the world
wars.
54
A Difference in Sixteenth-Century French Violence
REX BARNES
Abstract
This article considers the implications of both Catholic and Calvinist types of
violence during the Reformation of mid- Sixteenth-Century France. Historical
texts and academic discourses exhibit the extent to which French Catholics
tended to enact physical torment on their Huguenot victims, whereas French
Huguenots typically assaulted their Christian counterparts through iconoclasm
and symbolic desecration of sacred objects. From these perspectives, my
interest is in the multiple violent acts, which were not sadistic or pathological
attempts to inflict agony on religious opponents, but were initially
fundamental concerns for establishing and maintaining religious uniformity
and orthodoxy through purgative actions. Analysis of such historical violence
through individual Christian writings at this time is conducive to
understanding attempts at Church reform in France, especially with
consideration of the religious dynamics on the part of both Catholics and
Protestants. These actions culminated in political, social and religious
transformations and confrontations that have come to designate the European
Reformations.
🍁
I. Introduction
In John Calvin‘s first Latin edition of Institutes of the Christian Religion (1536
CE), he attached a dedicatory epistle to the French king, Francis I, with the
request of a fair investigation into the cause of the French evangelicals. In the
Strata
Rex Barnes
first paragraphs Calvin wrote: ―For this reason, most invincible King, I not
unjustly ask you to take a full inquiry into this cause, which until now has been
handled with no order of law and with violent heat rather than judicial
gravity.‖1 While it is well known Calvin strove to convince Francis I of the
movement‘s Christian legitimacy in France, the passage quoted above
specifically demonstrates Calvin‘s concern for political and legal justice during
the onset of rampant violence in the 16th century. The violence Calvin refers
to emphasizes religious animus—on the part of political authorities and lay
communities—against early reformers in France. This animus largely involved
persecutions and bodily inflictions often resulting in death or various forms of
physical maltreatment towards perished evangelicals. For Calvin and the
reformers the duty of the king of France was to endure toleration of reform
groups and protect them in the face of harsh enmity because they were valid
Christian subjects submitting to legal rule under the king. As such,
membership in the kingdom included defense against criminal acts (i.e.
persecution). In view of what Calvin would call ―villainy‖ on the part of
violent anti-reform fomenters, historical accounts attest to the multiple
massacres and seemingly savage persecution of French Calvinists, also known
as Huguenots, taking place during the French Reformation. For example, the
slaughtering of Huguenots at Vassy and on St Bartholomew‘s Day are fairly
infamous events attesting to incidents of brutality at this time. Yet, the
violence suffused in French society was not as one-sided as it may have
seemed.
Calvinist iconoclasm in the 16th century was also prominently violent
and comparable to the killings enacted by Catholic crowds and authorities in
France. The pervasive destruction of religious property included burning,
1. John Calvin, Institution of the Christian Religion, trans. Ford Lewis Battles (Atlanta:
John Know Press, 1975), Dedicatory Epistle #2, p. 2. I use this quote to exhibit an initial
Protestant/Calvinist awareness of violence against those who would later be labeled
―Huguenots‖ in France. The epistle predates the French Wars of Religion, but importantly
displays what developed into a common idea of legal justice for their cause. Calvin is referring
specifically to the ―Affair of the Placards‖ (discussed below) and his fears of further Catholic
violence.
56
Strata
Rex Barnes
urinating, defecating, smashing, and ripping as well as the annihilation of
sacred relics, statues, the Eucharist, paintings and churches. Moreover, French
Protestants targeted Catholic priests with aggression as key Catholic figures
perpetuating Roman Catholic rituals. These actions incorporated symbolic
(and physical) attacks on Gallican (French Roman Catholic) communities
entrenched in the beliefs and practices of the medieval church. In one
instance, a Huguenot was said to have, ―just as the priest was holding up the
precious body of Christ to show it to the people, grabbed it [the Host] and
crushed it under his feet.‖2 Through modern eyes, such an example might
evoke understandings of milder violence in comparison with corporal assaults,
but early modern society—those vehemently devoted to the precepts of the
medieval church—recognized these acts as sacrilege against the Christian God
as well as the body of believers as a whole. That is to say, iconoclasm, from a
16th century Catholic‘s point of view, was often emphasized as more
detrimental to one‘s Christian eschatological existence because it was believed
such an assault might provoke the wrath of God. In addition, the monarch
represented an authoritative station reflecting divine sanction and uniform
values with the French Church of the Middle Ages. Therefore, nobles,
ecclesiastics, Catholics and the king considered iconoclastic behavior an
affront against the Church and the unique relationship between the kingship
and the kingdom as one Catholic body.
From these perspectives, I wish to consider the implications of both
Catholic and Reformed types of violence. In particular, my interest is in the
multiple violent acts, which were not sadistic or pathological attempts to
inflict agony on religious opponents, but were initially fundamental concerns
for maintaining religious uniformity and orthodoxy through purgative actions.
Analysis of such historical violence is conducive to understanding attempts at
reform in France, especially with consideration of the religious dynamics from
both Catholics and Protestants. Furthermore, these actions also accentuate the
2. Quoted in David Potter, ed. and trans., The French Wars of Religion: Selected Documents
(New York: St. Martin‘s Press, 1997), 64.
57
Strata
Rex Barnes
eventual development of two disparate perspectives: the duty of the king to
uphold legal rights (for the Huguenots) and the king‘s promise to extinguish
heretical challenges (for the Catholics); both of which culminated in political,
social and religious transformations and confrontations. Put another way,
while both kinds of violence exhibit religious concerns for the health and
institution of Christian beliefs and practices, an important difference emerges
between Catholic unease over the state of the Catholic Church vis-à-vis the
body politic and Calvinist calls for a criminal justice system under the existing
political authorities.
In order to interpret the scope of Christian violence at this time I
begin this paper with a general examination of religious and political power,
values and authority during the 16th century. Thereafter I look at the
correlation between mainstream Roman Catholic and Reformed viewpoints
concerning physical and symbolic violence before and during the French Wars
of Religion. The final impetus of my work will then broadly consider the
performance of ritualistic violence during the multiple massacres from 15621572. Such horrific events, I argue, exemplified the pinnacle of hostile
demonstrations for Catholics endeavoring to unify French society, but were
representative of an influential change in Calvinist notions of civil justice
taking precedence over religious differences. This was a result, in particular, of
Huguenot expectations that the French king should have acted legally on their
behalf, despite Catholic/Calvinist differences. In other words, Calvinists
tended to voice concerns over social membership after Vassy and St.
Bartholomew‘s Day as an alternative outlook in early modern conceptions of
conventional political unity, instead of solely proffering oppositional
theological perspectives.
This paper is historiographically positioned as a survey and
culmination of various scholarly works. Following Natalie Zemon Davis‘
article, ―The Rites of Violence‖ (1973), I intend to exhibit the extent to which
the French Wars of Religion were significantly about religion, among a wide
array of other factors. While Davis was the first to emphasize the role of
religion—rather than solely economic and political concerns veiled by
58
Strata
Rex Barnes
religion—in the French Wars of Religion, academics, such as Barbara
Diefendorf, Philip Benedict, Mack Holt, Denis Crouzet and David Potter,
have since underscored the interplay of religious actors in their own contexts
struggling to maintain the kingdom of France and its relation to the ―sacred‖
therein. To this end, my intentions in this paper are to introduce readers to
many of the scholarly understandings of the civil wars in France during the
16th century. Furthermore, we shall see a range of responses to Davis‘ famous
work that extend her ritual perspective of religious violence to legal ―rights of
violence‖, as labeled by Mark Greengrass. Examination of such historical
perspectives on Catholic and Calvinist conflicts at this time considerably
contributes to our body of knowledge concerning the rise of Protestantism in
early modern France. More importantly, the arguments presented below usher
understandings that take seriously the role of religious dynamics in
conjunction with political and economic factors during this period.
II. Gallicanism and the French body politic
The political and religious atmosphere of France in the High Middle Ages
through the 16th century represented an absolutist government tied to the
regional ecclesiastic authorities within the Roman Catholic Church. The term
―Gallicanism‖ is often attributed to the unity between the French church and
state, which the Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church (2005) defines as: ―The
collective name for the body of doctrine which asserted the more or less
complete freedom of the RC [Roman Catholic] Church, esp. in France, from
the ecclesiastical authority of the Papacy.‖3 On the whole, Gallicanism
consisted of a privileged position of the French king in relation to the papacy,
as well as a Church government that collectively minimized the authority of
the pope. The basis of religious, legal and political power and authority in
France was located primarily in the station of the king and partially in his
3. The Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005),
s.v. ―Gallicanism.‖
59
Strata
Rex Barnes
subsidiaries.4 It is relevant that within the Gallican political framework,
religion—French Catholicism specifically—interacted directly with the
monarch in a symbiotic relationship wherein both the religious and political
spheres mutually benefited from their authority and legitimacy. As Frederic
Baumgartner, a professor of History at Virginia Tech, affirms: ―The adage
‗One Faith! One Law! One King!‘ sums up the essence of late medieval
French kinship: the king was both head of the French Church and the
embodiment of French law.‖5 Medieval and early modern French monarchy
was for all intents and purposes a divine office ruling the temporal and
spiritual orders as one combined unit.
A good example of the spiritual investment bestowed upon the
French kingship is seen in the royal rituals and ceremonial procedures
performed during coronation. The king was required to swear an ecclesiastical
oath attesting to the monarch‘s ―holy‖ station: ―I shall protect the canonical
privilege, due law, and justice, and I shall exercise defense of each bishop and
of each church committed to him.‖ Continuing on, the sovereign finally
pledged:
To this Christian populace subject to me, I promise in the
name of Christ: First, that by our authority the whole
Christian populace will preserve at all times true peace for the
Church of God. . . Also, that in good faith to all men I shall
be diligent to expel from my land and also from the
4. France‘s other authorities, including members of the nobility and ecclesiastics, who
were often one and the same, generally swore fealty to the king. The papal treaty known as the
Concordat of Bologna (1516) significantly granted the French king the right to levy tithes on
clergy and appoint church leadership. Therefore, the Concordat assured, to a considerable
extent, the fidelity of nobles, bishops, clergy, etc. See Carter Lindberg, The European Reformations,
2nd Edition (UK: Wiley-Blackwell, 2010), 261.
5. Frederic Baumgartner, France in the Sixteenth Century (New York: St. Martin‘s Press,
1995), 9.
60
Strata
Rex Barnes
jurisdiction subject to me all heretics designated by the
Church.6
Towards the end of the oaths and ceremony the archbishop also anointed the
new king with consecrated oil and adorned him with the expected royal
vestments, scepter and crown. Thereafter the king finally partook of the
Eucharist—both the host and wine—which publically established his priestly
nature over that of an ordinary layman.7 The significance of the monarch‘s
contribution and participation in both the body and blood of Christ cannot be
stressed enough. This eminent gesture exemplified the unique stature of the
king as holier than any individual in the kingdom, thereby emphasizing the
importance of the Eucharist as the ritual sanctifying the king. In this way,
French kings were both consecrated and crowned in their ascension to the
throne where ―the ceremony itself was called a sacre in France, emphasizing
consecration rather than coronation.‖8
The examples of oaths and ceremonies serve to highlight the
deliberate collection of language, symbols and gestures directed to honouring
the French king. The royal ceremony gave prominence to a sacred monarchy
and also represented the relationship between the king and his subjects. On
one hand, the political sovereign‘s authority was asserted over all other figures
in which law and justice were understood as instruments for maintaining
peace in the kingdom. The law and right to enforce punishments or measures
in the interest of France culminated in the recognition of the king as the
supreme ruler. On the other hand, the entirety of the coronation paid homage
to the new earthly lord whose promises to defend the Gallican Church from
heretics were officiated in the mass. If the Church and its members felt
threatened by ―acts of heresy,‖ it was the political (and religious) duty of the
monarch to protect the body politic. Therefore, the subjects of France
6. Mack P. Holt, The French Wars of Religion, 1562–1629 (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1995), 8. The preceding citation is included.
7. Ibid, 9.
8. Ibid, 8.
61
Strata
Rex Barnes
legitimated the crown‘s political and divine status through their participation
in the coronation and religious investment in the king as a protector of the
people.
Furthermore, French historian, R. J. Knecht has also shown ―By
virtue of his [the archbishop‘s] anointing the king of France, who bore the title
of ‗Most Christian King‘, was deemed to possess thaumaturgical powers, that
is to say powers of healing the sick.‖9 The king would touch victim‘s sores or
visible maladies with his bare hands, make the sign of the cross and say: ―The
king touches you and God cures you.‖10 Again, religious belief bolstered the
king‘s ―divine‖ authority through his elevated status, which was considered
close to godly. The power of healing accentuated the sacrality of the king‘s
body and royal position. It is of course difficult to say definitively how many
of the king‘s subjects believed in his ability to heal.11 Nevertheless, this ritual
was practiced periodically throughout each king‘s reign and large numbers of
French subjects turned to the monarch in hopes of curing ailments.12 These
factors are relevant to interpreting the religious legitimacy attributed to the
king‘s already powerful status, but also in comprehending Christian devotion
to the king. From these perspectives, the anointing from the archbishop, the
king‘s consecration in his coronation, the partaking in both the blood and
body of Christ in the mass and his thaumaturgical powers all strengthened the
crown‘s influence within his kingdom and served as a bulwark for Christian
9. R. J. Knecht, The Rise and Fall of Renaissance France: 1483–1610 (London, Fontana
Press, 1996), 14–15.
10. Ibid, 15.
11. The religious and political uniformity outlined here is not meant to essentialize
the lived realities of all French communities at this time. There were religious movements, such
as the Waldensians (and the Cathars before them), who sought alternative modes of religious
expression. Likewise, it is impossible to state all nobles and laity completely supported the
Gallican system. It is, after all, within this context that Reform ideas clashed with Gallicanism,
and reformers and Catholics disputed notions of religious and political conformity. I am only
pointing out that the codified political and religious framework tended towards immense
degrees of uniformity.
12. Mack P. Holt, ―The Kingdom of France in the sixteenth century‖ In Renaissance
and Reformation: 1500–1648, ed. Mack P. Holt, 5–26 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002), 9.
62
Strata
Rex Barnes
unity under the monarch. These rituals were all significantly indicative of a
dynamic relationship between the church and the state led by the king, as well
as the kingdom‘s support of the monarchical institution. We can thus see how
French monarchs were a combination of emperor and pope as the
embodiment of a religious and political leader.
This survey of the nature and influence of Gallicanism within early
modern France exhibits notions of authority and legitimacy, both political and
religious, which were substantially rooted in the establishment of the monarch,
as well as in society‘s support of the king‘s eminent status. It should not be
altogether surprising then that the advent of Reformist, Calvinist and
Lutheran ideas in France ―threatened the perception of nation forged by both
king and subjects, because the king‘s own coronation oath required him to
protect and defend his realm and subjects from heresy.‖13 The station of the
king had been sanctified and officiated through the Gallican Church; and its
members constituted the majority of French subjects in the kingdom. In turn,
the monarch‘s coronation ensured that ―other faiths‖ were to be viewed as
heretical if they did not strictly adhere to French Roman Catholic notions of
orthodoxy. What this meant for early Protestantism was that Catholics
generally labeled Huguenots, or Christians performing Reformed rituals,
heretical; indicating that their beliefs and practices were perilous and to be
extinguished immediately. Importantly, ―labeling‖ or ―othering‖ Calvinists as
―heretics‖ resulted in extremely violent persecution.
III. Interpreting “Rites of Violence” for French Catholics
The history of early Reformed, Calvinist and Lutheran ideas in France is
dispersed sporadically throughout the first decades of the 16th century without
overly extravagant displays of public violence. It was not until 1562 that civil
war had begun and raged in France as late as 1598. The massacre at Vassy
(1562) was the first of many mass executions in which numerous Catholic
13. Ibid, 23.
63
Strata
Rex Barnes
authorities brutally persecuted Huguenot communities.14 Social historian
Philip Benedict elucidates that in the period from 1560 to 1572 ―Such
Catholic-controlled towns as Sens and Gaillac [also] witnessed further
massacres of Protestants.‖15 One of the most infamous events worth
mentioning was the St. Bartholomew‘s Day massacre (1572). On that
occasion, the Catholic Duke of Guise reportedly instigated the murder of
Admiral Coligny (a Protestant leader) by dispatching his body from a building
and instructing his royal guard to kill all Calvinists in the city. Thereafter,
numerous Parisians mutilated Coligny‘s body, hung it from the gallows and
proceeded for days to butcher Huguenots throughout Paris and surrounding
cities. Benedict writes that ―from Paris, the violence spread to at least a dozen
provincial cities over the next days and weeks. Perhaps 10,000 victims died in
all.‖16
The methods of violence used against Huguenot populations are just
as shocking as the numbers. Catholic mobs mocked, stoned, hanged, burned,
drowned, dismembered and paraded dead Protestant bodies. In the case of
Admiral Coligny, his dead body was ―quickly mutilated. . . [by] cutting off the
admiral‘s head, hands, and genitals. The corpse was then dragged through the
streets, set afire as a heretic, and then thrown into the Seine,‖17 showing that
such physical violence was not limited to the living. Other sites of violence
include the massacre of Sens (1562). A Catholic preacher, Claude Haton,
recalls that a Protestant captain:
half dead, was dragged through the streets by the children of
Sens by a rope from one of his feet. . . raising the hue and
14. At Vassy, a group of Huguenots congregated to worship in a barn and some
thirty of which were slaughtered by Catholic authorities claiming the Calvinists had thrown
rocks at the Catholic Duke of Guise, although scholars still debate who started the quarrel. See
Potter, The French Wars of Religion, 50.
15. Philip Benedict, ―The Wars of Religion, 1562–1598‖ In Renaissance and Reformation:
1500–1648, ed. Mack P. Holt, 147–175 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002), 153.
16. Ibid, 156.
17. Holt, The French Wars of Religion, 87.
64
Strata
Rex Barnes
cry: ‗Guard your pigs, here we have the pigman‘ and at each
crossroad they burned his body with oven spits. . . The
children, having dragged the captain through the streets, went
and threw him, with his other pigs, into the river Yonne. By
this time night had fallen and imposed a silence on the fury,
and the morrow there was no man so bold as to appear in
the streets of Sens and declare himself a Huguenot.18
Comparably, an anonymous Protestant wrote of riots in Toulouse (1562)
where many Huguenots ―were stripped to the shirt, killed, dragged along and
thrown in the river. . . men, women and children were thrown out of windows
into the river. If, by chance, they got to the bank they were shot or stoned to
death.‖19
These examples illustrate a pervasive sense of physical violence on the
part of Catholics against Protestants, both living and dead.20 Moreover, we see
frequent methods of force that included Catholics, and children in many cases,
burning their victims with fire in various forms or drowning them in rivers
and other large bodies of water. In this essay, therefore, I would like to
examine precisely such issues of: why these methods (Catholic, as well as
Protestant) were employed and to what end were they performed in this way?
Were these communal Catholic attempts to harm Huguenots or communities
more specifically? In addition, I wish to consider any impetuses—in purview
of my initial discussion of Gallicanism above—that may have given rise to the
violence that destructively separated much of French society at this time.
In light of these questions, Natalie Zemon Davis‘ seminal article ―The
Rites of Violence‖ developed an original argument for interpreting a ritual
18. Potter, The French Wars of Religion, 53.
19. Ibid, 55.
20. This is not to say that Protestants did not kill Catholics. Catholics enacted
iconoclastic violence, such as the burning of Protestant books and Bibles, just as Calvinists
killed Catholics. However, the massacres and riots of the Wars of Religion exhibit predominant
Catholic physical violence and Protestant iconoclastic violence.
65
Strata
Rex Barnes
element in the violence of the French Wars of Religion. Davis, a scholar at the
University of Toronto, coins Christian violence during the 16th century as
―rites of violence‖ in which communities sought ritual purification through
violent performance. She writes: ―we may see their [both Catholic and
Protestant] violence, however cruel, not as random and limitless but as aimed
at defined targets. . . a goal akin to preaching: the defense of true doctrine and
the refutation of false doctrine through dramatic challenges and tests‖ in order
to ultimately rid ―the community of dreaded pollution.‖21 This perspective is
particularly insightful because it points out the extent to which Christian
communities viewed other Christians as ―pollution‖ within the structures of
Gallicanism. That is, they dehumanized their brethren by means of
constructing religious values that posited their opponents as objects needing
evacuation because they were ―polluting‖ the community. Furthermore, Davis
argues that Christians imitated ―the roles of priests, pastor and magistrate‖ in
their ritual attempts to purify the disparate communities.22 According to Davis
then, analysis of religious violence at this time entails comprehending a
performative aspect of Christian action that was directed towards emulation of
Christian and monarchical values as a communal whole. That is to say that this
contextual violence was generally directed towards displays of authoritative
and religious values, from magistrates and priests for example, in order to
didactically reaffirm values to the Christian body of believers. Working from
Davis‘ article, I thus wish to examine and interpret what is meant by
―pollution‖ and ―imitation‖ in the context of early modern French violence.
Firstly, it is important to notice that the ideas of ―pollution‖ were not
necessarily novel conceptions arising solely after 1562. Rather, rising
apocalyptic notions, in conjunction with the oaths and coronation of the
French king, contributed to perceptions of certain Christians as ―diabolical
contaminants.‖ With the gradual manifestation of Protestantism throughout
21. Natalie Zemon Davis, ―The Rites of Violence‖ in Society and Culture in Early
Modern France: Eight Essays, 152–188 (London: Ducksworth Limited, 1975), 154–157. The article
was first published in 1973, then republished in 1975 and another in 1986.
22. Davis, ―The Rites of Violence,‖ 164.
66
Strata
Rex Barnes
the 1540s and 1550s, French Catholic writings—concerning ideas of
Reform—stressed the imminent coming of God and the preceding
apocalypse. Certainly, eschatological themes were prevalent before the
European Reformations, but as Cunningham and Grell, of Cambridge
University and the Open University respectively, affirm: ―More than any other
period of European history the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries were
characterized by apocalyptic expectations, eschatological speculations and
millenarian dreams. . . it felt as though they were living through the Last Days.
. . it was an age of crisis.‖23 The point these authors raise demonstrates early
modern concerns for one‘s Christian salvation. In France many Catholics
related their ominous fears to Protestant behavior.
One example of an anonymous French Catholic in 1550 is revealing
of such apocalyptic anxiety: ―Since God created the world, never was seen so
strange a time in which famine, war and pestilence reigned. . . daughters
denying the holy sacrament to their mothers. . . God‘s blood flowing in the
street. . . stones cast at the cross.‖24 Similarly, another Catholic invective at this
time worries: ―Now heresy is the sign of the end of this mortal world. . . filthy
people will overthrow through their malice the pure Host and the daily
sacrifice. . . everything on earth will be consumed by fire from heaven.‖25 An
apocalyptic mood is present in these Catholic accounts and also an attitude in
which these events were the result of impious behavior. That Christians
questioned and rejected traditional sacramental rites struck Catholic
communities (in the examples above) as a sign of immoral and sinful action
on the part of reformers. Catholics targeted Calvinists as polluting agents (not
23. Andrew Cunningham and Ole Peter Grell, The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse:
religion, war, famine and death in Reformation Europe (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000),
1. The authors show that the Black Death (plague) and natural disasters in general contributed
to inflation, as well as other social problems, which were instrumental in a rising sense of crisis
and eschatological anxiety (pp. 200–295). Moreover, floods, specifically in France, killed
harvests and people in their wake, thereby adding to notions of anxiety. See Lindberg, The
European Reformations, 25.
24. Potter, The French Wars of Religion, 38.
25. Ibid, 38–39.
67
Strata
Rex Barnes
human individuals) directly causing earthly catastrophes such war, disease and
famine. More importantly, many Catholics perceived Reform acts and beliefs
as a ―disease‖ producing further infection in the body of believers.
I would distinguish that words like ―disease‖ and ―infection‖ were
tropes employed, not only by laity, but also by French kings in the mid-16th
century. In 1534, Francis I stated that French evangelicals ―were vile and had
to be dealt with like a disease‖26 after the Affair of the Placards.27 Similarly,
Henry II (Francis‘ son and successor) spoke in 1551 of the ―common malady
of this contagious pestilence [heretics or Protestants] that has infected many
noble towns.‖28 These pejorative terms (pollution, contamination, disease,
etc.) and language broach the idea of theological issues and alternate Christian
―faiths‖ endangering or infecting the socio-political body as a whole. A
Catholic fear existed that if part of the Christian community or body became
―infected‖ or ―polluted‖ with heretical beliefs and practices—whether it was
the church, the king or the laity—the whole society was in danger of utter
destruction and damnation. For this reason, many Catholics vehemently
sought to eradicate what they deemed ―heretical‖ as quickly as possible.
Following Davis, David Potter of the University of Kent contends
that ―religious violence was meant both to restore divine order and to allay
divine anger. This is why Catholics were so concerned to purify society of
heretical pollution through fire and water.‖29 The use of fire and water against
Huguenots were means of disposing of Calvinists in order to appease God by
ridding the community of the heretical contaminant. Likewise, Catholics often
used children as the epitome of innocence in ritually cleansing their
26. Hans J. Hillerbrand, The Division of Christendom: Christianity in the Sixteenth Century
(Louisville: John Knox Press, 2007), 322.
27. The Affair of the Placards (1534) was an incident in which anonymous
evangelicals posted handbills throughout various French towns denouncing Catholic doctrine
and the Mass. Significantly, one of the placards reached the king‘s habitation and thereafter ten
individuals were martyred for the outburst of Reformed public expression against Gallicanism.
See Knecht, The Rise and Fall of Renaissance France, 170.
28. Hillerbrand, The Division of Christendom, 323.
29. Potter, The French Wars of Religion, 37.
68
Strata
Rex Barnes
communities of harmful ―pollutants.‖30 Where fire and water were tools in
washing away the sins of Protestants, children were the ―most pure of
cleaners‖ utilizing earthly elements as ―cleansing instruments‖ to purify
Protestantism and restore Gallican order. It was believed that the reasons
disasters, such as war and mass hunger, occurred were due to Calvinist refusal
of Catholic oblation to God. These were perceived as heretical actions
jeopardizing Christian society; it was the duty of the monarch, authorities and
even the community to rid France of this heresy, according to many Catholics,
because Protestant impious behavior would incur the wrath of God and
destruction of the Church. These issues exhibit Catholic views of Protestants
and their dramatic performances against them, which were meant to
demonstrate ―orthodox‖ values, as French kings and authorities had
previously maintained. However, French Calvinists also applied the idea of
Christian ―pollution‖ to Catholics.
IV. French Calvinist theological perspectives and violence
Before examining Huguenot views of ―Catholic contamination‖ and
―ritualistic performance‖, it is necessary to briefly qualify French Protestant
theology and beliefs. An appropriate understanding of the French Calvinist
position displays in what ways their theology clashed not only with Catholic
doctrine, but also with Gallicanism as a whole. With this in mind, the
fundamental theological beliefs of Huguenots encompassed ideas of
corruption and lies in their Christian history, which had been instigated by the
institution of the papal Church. In opposition to Catholic ideals, reformers
often voiced their critical opinions of the mass, purgatory, the role of clergy,
sacraments and other Catholic doctrines. A description of Calvinist self-image
written in the French town of Millau in 1560 shows their cause:
30. This idea of from French historian Denis Crouzet found in William Beik, ―The
Violence of the French Crowd from Charivari to Revolution‖ Past and Present 197 (November
2007), p. 89.
69
Strata
Rex Barnes
In this present year 1560, the Gospel started to be revealed
everywhere in this kingdom; for it had been hidden almost
since the time of the Apostles until now, resulting in
tyrannies and cruelties that had been exercised throughout
Christendom by princes, kings and great lords, fed by lies,
and by false prophets against God, who had weakened the
Church. . . by idolatry, had wood, stone and the Mass god
worshipped. . . Thus he had seduced the people and did not
allow them to understand divine scripture. . . brought great
persecution on those of the Religion, who then started to be
called Huguenots. . . conveying the idea that they were
traitors (as was, once, Hugues Capet traitor to France).31
The French reformers (labeled Huguenots) sought to read and interpret
scripture, to reform the corruption of clergy and the pope in the mass and to
relinquish the idolatrous behaviour of venerating sacred objects. That is,
Calvinists in France desired reform of Church sacraments and authority, as
well as the sacrality attributed to earthly objects. For the Huguenots, like other
reformers throughout Europe, Scripture was the ultimate spiritual authority,
not the Gallican or Romanist Church. The Bible was to be made available to
all Christians to read and interpret. In accordance with their interpretation of
the Bible and the Ten Commandments, the Reformed churches affirmed strict
prohibition of graven images and denied the Catholic doctrine of
transubstantiation; meaning Christ was not corporeally present in the
sacrament of the Eucharist, as Catholics ritually celebrated it.
31. Potter, The French Wars of Religion, 40. In this quote we see the possible origins of
the derogatory label ―Huguenot.‖ Capet was the first French king in the 10th century, though I
could not find why he is considered a traitor. Another source indicates that ―Huguenot‖ is
derived from the legend of the ghost Huguet or Hugon reputed to haunt the vicinity of Tours
at night, and thus applied to Protestants because they were required to hold nighttime
gatherings to worship, as they were not a legally sanctioned ―faith‖. See Philip Benedict and
Virginia Reinburg, ―Religion and the Sacred‖ In Renaissance and Reformation: 1500–1648, ed.
Mack P. Holt, 119–146 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002), 140–141.
70
Strata
Rex Barnes
Working from the French Protestant perspective, we can endeavor to
interpret why Calvinists strove to expunge Catholic contaminants. Davis
maintains that two primary pollutants needed purification for French
Protestants: the clergy and ―defilement of the sacred by Catholic ritual life,
from the diabolic magic of the mass to the idolatrous worship of images.‖32
The clergy were viewed as detrimental agents, because they were the officials
enacting what Davis describes as the ―defilement of the sacred.‖ Likewise,
Protestants detested the idea of Catholic laity worshipping ―idolatrous images‖
for the reason that this kind of veneration perpetuated the institution of the
Roman Catholic Church and its false doctrines. For Protestants then,
Catholics were dirtying the House of the Lord through the spiritual authority
afforded to the clergy and their priestly mediation in sacred rituals, but also by
means of their veneration of icons. Remembering that Catholics viewed
Protestants as the pollutants, Calvinists generally believed priests and the
rituals of the mass, along with ―sacred‖ relics, were the contaminants, because
they were unchristian ―lies‖ dividing the true Christian community of
believers. Huguenots thus threw out, destroyed and attempted to remove all
forms of clerical influence and sacred objects from their congregations. In
more aggressive instances (for example the first quote appearing in the
introduction of a Protestant stealing the Host from the priest) this entailed
publically desecrating Catholic relics or symbols. While the majority of
Protestant hostility was overwhelmingly iconoclastic, physical violence against
Catholics, especially priests, did occur. In this way, recognizing the extent to
which Protestants engaged in dehumanizing their Catholic brethren by means
of desecrating and profaning sacred objects and symbols of the Gallican
Church can be as challenging as interpreting Catholic violence.
For Protestants, ―the purging of priestly ‗vermin‘ promised the
creation of a new kind of unity within the body social, all the tighter because
false gods and monkish sects would no longer divide it.‖33 The clergy of the
32. Davis, ―Rites of Violence,‖ 159.
33. Ibid, 160.
71
Strata
Rex Barnes
Gallican Church, whose role officiated the ―diabolic lies‖ promulgating false
religious practices and beliefs, was often the prime target of Huguenot
aggression. To cut off clerical prevarication meant easing the path for reform.
It follows that priests were often threatened, as is seen in this account of
iconoclasm and riot at Issoire, Auvergne in 1562:
Things had come to such a point that monks and priests in
the street were jeered at so they could not go out: ‗Look at
the fox, the sneak, the Papist! Furthermore, they [Calvinists]
beat on their shutters with stones, hammers and staves so
that they drowned out the noise of everything else, adding
horrible yowls. . . so that the clergy could only go into the
streets with fear.34
Some Protestants verbally assaulted their opponents and clergy with such
menace by imposing fear, just as others called them worshippers of a ―Pastry
God‖ or a ―God of dough‖, in reference to the primacy of the Eucharist in
the Catholic mass.35 This was a crucial blow to Catholic notions of orthodoxy
in which a pejorative remark to the bread of the Host denoted a false god
consisting of pastry or dough, and not the body of Christ. This is not to say
that Protestants and Catholics did not believe in the same God. Instead, I am
asserting that they staunchly disagreed over the nature of Christ‘s or any
sacred presence on earth, including a presence in the Host of the Eucharist.
These blatant rejections of Catholic ritual added resentment to an already
increasing hatred of Protestant denials of religious authenticity for Catholics.
Other drastic incidents, inclusive to those discussed above, were ―throwing
the sacred host to the dogs. . . roasting the crucifix upon a spit. . . using holy
oil to grease one‘s boots [and]. . . leaving human excrement on holy-water
34. Potter, The French Wars of Religion, 59.
35. Ibid, 42.
72
Strata
Rex Barnes
basins.‖36 These were all performances intended to persuade Catholics that
their sacred objects contained no magical power or presence. Yet, as Davis
distinguishes, such actions can be construed as symbolically violent means for
attaining religious ends. Stated differently, Protestant iconoclasm and threats
towards priests were deliberate demonstrations to convince the body social of
their (Reformed) faith and its supremacy over Catholic ignorance and
debauchery.
In assessing Christian differences in terms of violence and religious
values, it is important to underscore the considerable weight afforded to the
issue of Catholic rituals and their relationship to the French monarchy.
Catholic sacraments and doctrines of the Church were vital to Gallican
notions of eschatological existence. The Eucharist especially ―was the most
important sacrament, and the Eucharistic liturgy, or mass, was the heart of
Christian life. It was key to the economy of salvation, and the most essential
and familiar rite of the faith.‖37 Carter Lindberg, professor of Church History
at Boston University, acutely highlights the profundity of the dynamics at
work here by writing: ―an attack on the eucharist was an attack on the very
foundation of the French kingship.‖38 It should be understood that denying
Christ‘s bodily presence in the Host, as many French Calvinists did, was
interpreted as a sacrilegious abandonment of the pervasive values Catholics
attributed to their Christian life, salvation, king and God. In other words, the
differences outlined throughout this examination culminate in Christian
identities (to be understood as one body of believers) struggling to reveal or
display their own purpose and existence through the political, social and
religious institutions that had been in place since the Middle Ages. Not
unexpectedly, dismissing or contesting history, identity and religious beliefs is
dangerous business with historically violent results. The French Reformation,
like the wider European Reformations, exhibits the vital importance of
theological issues sparking tumultuous displays of conflicting religious values.
36. Davis, ―The Rites of Violence,‖ 180.
37. Benedict and Reinburg, ―Religion and the Sacred,‖ 123–124.
38. Lindberg, The European Reformations, 263.
73
Strata
Rex Barnes
The monarchy of France shared its power with the Gallican Church, as well as
Catholic rituals, to the extent that to assault one meant the other was likewise
threatened. Therefore, Protestant theology was dubiously viewed as a menace
to the livelihood of the Church, the king, the monarchy itself and the entirety
of the Catholic kingdom supporting these socio-political structures and rituals.
Conversely, Protestants were arguing for their own Christian unity through
the kingship, but their struggle was against a long historical institution rooted
in medieval Catholic ideals oppositional to their own.
V. Problematizing the performance of Rites of Violence
In the background of my analysis of Christian violence during the French
Reformation are the particular methods employed in ridding Christian
communities of their ―pollutants‖. Indeed, I have examined several accounts
of physical and symbolic violence against various Christian communities,
discussing the use of fire, water, children and iconoclasm. Of particular
interest is that, according to Natalie Zemon Davis, Protestants and Catholics
often ritualistically imitated the roles of priest and magistrate in order to purify
their Christian communities.39 This is an important distinction and I would
further argue that ―imitation‖ could likewise be interpreted as a type of
religious performance in reaffirming the ideals of one‘s religious ―faith‖. For
Davis, both Protestants and Catholics believed their theological values were
politically and religiously sanctioned and, therefore, acted violently as they
thought authorities (i.e. priests/pastors and magistrates) would have similarly
done. They were, in other words, performing the duties of authorities based
upon and demonstrated through their own religious values.
Recalling the words of Francis I and Henry II, both kings had applied
terminology such as ―vermin, disease and infection‖ towards Protestants.
Catholics thus believed their violence against Huguenots was in accordance
with the Gallican oaths and ceremonies those kings had sworn. In
39. Davis, ―The Rites of Violence,‖ 164.
74
Strata
Rex Barnes
confirmation of this idea, Barbara Diefendorf, a historian of early modern
France, provides an account of public execution of a Protestant heretic in
which a participatory element of the crowd ―became so unruly that it
threatened to take the prisoner out of the hands of the executioners and
attend to the burning itself.‖40 Diefendorf also states, in the case of the St.
Bartholomew‘s Day Massacre—quoting Claude Haton—that: ―When youths
from the crowd mutilated Coligny‘s dead body. . . parodying the forms of
royal justice. . . [they] conducted Coligny‘s trial as they dragged him along, ‗just
as if they were judges and officers of the court‘.‖41 Those Catholics zealous
enough to act against reform communities did so by means of emulating the
notions of political justice and religious anti-heresy promised by the king in his
coronation. The lay Catholic and his/her community assumed the role of the
magistrate and executioner through their own perceived notions of Gallican
justice, thereby slaughtering those deemed ―heretical.‖ Likewise, they also
took up the role of the priest whose purpose was to defend and venerate
Catholic ritual and the Christian God in the Eucharist.
For Huguenots, however, their position was not explicitly, publically,
or legally sanctioned. Until 1562, Protestantism in France had been very much
a covert ―faith‖ because the majority of laity and authorities supported
Gallican ideals, which oppressed ―heresy,‖ including Protestantism as a new
religion (labeled as heresy). Yet during the mid-16th century, ideas of Reform
gradually manifested and contested traditional religious values. Davis thus
maintains that Calvinist ―imitation‖ was especially prescriptive, in that,
―Calvinist crowds were using his sword as the king ought to have been using it
and as some princes and city councils outside of France had already used it.‖42
The crux of this argument is that both ―faiths‖ performed as they believed
authorities would or should have done—imitating magistrates and church
leaders—but that Calvinists did not initially have a governmental system
40. Barbara Diefendorf, Beneath the Cross: Catholics and Huguenots in Sixteenth-Century
Paris (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1991), 53.
41. Ibid, 103.
42. Davis, ―Rites of Violence,‖ 164.
75
Strata
Rex Barnes
officially supporting their position. However, with the rise of conflicts over
what was to be considered Christian orthodoxy, the regent monarch Catherine
of Medici sought resolution through the Edict of Toleration43 in 1562 (the
year in which the French Wars of Religion began).
Interpreting the historical significance of the edict, French historian
Denis Crouzet, contends ―Many prominent Catholics immediately flew into a
rage because of the edict while the Parlement of Paris reprimanded the king
with prophecies of the inevitable desolation of the kingdom.‖44 In the opinion
of Crouzet, the edict was a major break with the prior traditions of the French
monarchy under Gallicanism. From a modern point of view, the edict ―made
France the first Western European kingdom to grant legal recognition to two
forms of Christianity at once.‖45 However, these advances troubled Catholics
and prompted—in conjunction with their eschatological fears—their rejection
of the edict‘s legitimacy, because of their belief in the supremacy of longestablished Gallican ideals (i.e. one Catholic faith). As Crouzet puts it:
―unfortunately, the massacre at Vassy. . . can be seen as a response to this
edict.‖46 This ―response‖ further encouraged Catholic imitation of the
magistrate and priest (and executioner) in assuring religious and political order
endured, as long as it was consistent with the majority of Catholic
perspectives. Notwithstanding, for Protestants, the edict provided substantial
legal proof that their faith was becoming gradually triumphant within France.
We see then that issues of violence revolved around Christian perspectives of
what they believed authorities should have sanctioned. The monarch had
historically bolstered Catholics and their views of ―heresy.‖ Therefore, they
expected the king to act as they had in purging Huguenots. But Protestants,
43. The edict, also known as the Edict of January or St Germain, is a major factor in
the Wars of Religion because it exemplifies a legal shift allowing Huguenots the right to
worship privately without fear of persecution. See Denis Crouzet, ―A Law of Difference in the
History of Difference: The First Edict of ‗Toleration‘‖ in Religious Differences in France: Past and
Present, ed. Kathleen Perry Long, (Missouri: Truman State University Press, 2006), 1–18.
44. Crouzet, ―A Law of Difference,‖ 2.
45. Benedict, ―The Wars of Religion,‖ 147.
46. Crouzet, ―A Law of Difference,‖ 1.
76
Strata
Rex Barnes
especially after the Edict of Toleration, believed the monarch would protect
their beliefs and adherents, because they were French Christians.
Several academics have highlighted a distinction in which Davis‘
notion of ―Rites of Violence‖ must be viewed in light of what has also been
called ―Rights of Violence‖ or ―Rituals of Popular Justice‖. Stuart Carroll, for
one, indicates that many conflicts during the inception of the Wars of Religion
were about rights, in addition to rites. For Carroll, who cites Mark Greengrass,
Huguenot uprising ―was a defensive response to the imminent suppression of
their right to worship, which had been guaranteed by law.‖47 Greengrass and
Carroll do not dismiss the religious motivations of Protestants in ritually
destroying Catholic relics through iconoclastic behaviour, but they contend
that Davis‘ rites were only one part of a complex set of stimulants perpetuating
Huguenot desires for reform of the Church in their tumultuous environments.
William Monter also affirms: ―Catholics understood very well that the most
popular alternative to legal repression of Protestantism was not the policies of
compromise or toleration. . . it was illegal repression.‖48 Monter‘s argument is
that Catholics (and Protestants in many cases) increasingly operated outside of
France‘s court system imitating magistrates through their own antagonistic
methods. Catholics extralegally performed acts of physical violence (against
what they perceived as heresy) and Protestants sought legal recognition of
their faith by attacking those objects they saw as symbolic of their oppression.
According to Monter, the religious conflicts in France eclipsed the kingdom‘s
court system: ―It was caught between a growing, self-confident, fully
confessionalized Protestant ‗cause‘ and an increasingly angry and mobilized
majority loyal to the traditional faith, goaded by provocative Protestant
47. Stuart Carroll, Noble Power during the French Wars of Religion: The Guise Affinity and the
Catholic Cause in Normandy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), 5. For the early
discussion of Mark Greengrass concerning the Protestant Rights of Violence in accordance with
Rites of Violence, see ―The Anatomy of a Religious Riot in Toulouse in May 1562,‖ Journal of
Ecclesiastical History 34, No. 3 (1983), 389–391.
48. William Monter, Judging the French Reformation: Heresy Trials by Sixteenth-Century
Parlements (Cambridge Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1999), 215.
77
Strata
Rex Barnes
actions.‖49 From this interpretation, there was a vicious cycle of religious
rejection from both ―faiths‖ sustaining pugnacious religious and political
conflict.
These academic debates do not necessarily contradict one another.
Rather, Carroll, Greengrass and Monter all work from Davis‘ ―Rites of
Violence‖ to show that indeed, eschatological anxiety and religious concerns
of purification prompted religious violence. Meanwhile, after the Edict of
Toleration and the massacres at Vassy, Paris and elsewhere, Huguenots
actively criticized the monarchical legal system under the king, rather than the
Gallican Church and its theological doctrines alone. The point of contention is
that anxiety over ―pollution‖ and ritualistic performance of the magistrates‘ or
priests‘ roles (by lay crowds) could not have been the only determining factor
after 1562 and possibly before (recalling Calvin‘s epistle to Francis I). The
edict had officially reordered legal persecution in such a way that heresy and
sin were no longer viable options for Catholics or authorities to punish
Calvinists. Sedition was the only intolerable crime, which from the Protestant
point of view, is exactly what the Catholics had committed in murdering those
Christians in the massacres. It was, to state bluntly, a crime that needed
retribution, because the Edict assured Protestant protection as legal subjects
submitting to the kingship. When the monarch failed to reply to their
protests,50 Protestants generated a response of self-defense to Catholic abuses
through iconoclastic violence and prohibition of the mass, which consequently
led to harsh and long civil wars in France.
49. Ibid, 216.
50. There were various reactions to Vassy and the St. Bartholomew‘s day
massacres—some more aggressive than others—but officially the crown‘s response was to
revoke the Edict of Toleration, because the king feared if Protestants continued to worship and
respond with iconoclasm that further massacres would incur. Protestants thus felt betrayed after
having had partial legal tolerance (even if it was not adhered to in practice). See Benedict, ―The
Wars of Religion,‖ 157.
78
Strata
Rex Barnes
VI. Conclusions
The violence saturating the French Reformation, and more specifically the
French Wars of Religion after 1562, is a complex phenomenon that has
sparked the imagination of many scholars attempting to interpret why such
events transpired. My analysis here is by no means exhaustive of the issues
relating to French Catholic and Protestant turbulence during the 16th century.
Indeed, other academics have labored to explain the French Protestant
massacres in terms of economic and class struggles, which are important to
keep in perspective and are unfortunately not dealt with here. Be that as it
may, I have found the religious, theological and eschatological motivations to
be an extremely pervasive impetus for consideration. As we have seen, this
period of early modern French history is suffused with political and religious
tensions that are inextricably tied to theological issues established and
continued from the Middle Ages.
I have endeavored throughout this paper to explicate conflicting
notions of the one Gallican body of believers, including religious and political
authorities (especially the king and his relationship to Catholic rituals), with
the advent of a contesting Protestant theology and body of religious
practitioners. Understanding the form of Reformation in early modern France
entails consideration of the Gallican socio-political framework and in what
ways reformers met their unique circumstances in order to establish their new
―faith.‖ This is because the principal religious and political system of
Gallicanism was not initially accommodating to an alternative ―faith‖ when
the majority of Catholics labeled its adherents heretical. Moreover, notions of
religious ―pollution‖, in conjunction with apocalyptic anxiety and devotion to
the king (and his godly station), culminated in both Catholics and Huguenots
reacting to one another through varieties of violent action. On one hand,
Catholics generally saw evangelicals as polluting agents (in themselves) that
needed purification, even if dead, in order to eschatologically save the Catholic
community. On the other hand, French Calvinists viewed Gallican priests and
relics or icons as contaminants requiring expungement because they
79
Strata
Rex Barnes
perpetuated papal lies and false veneration thus dividing French Christians.
Both Christian communities sought to cleanse their communities through
violent performances in order to establish (in the case of the Protestants) and
maintain (for Catholics) Christian uniformity under the monarch. However,
these diverse attempts only added tensions to what was considered
―orthodox‖ or ―heretical‖ for nearly 40 years. As a result, civil war raged in
France from 1562–1598 with the destruction of many lives and Church
property.
These historical events and issues are particularly intriguing because
when analyzed through a culturally contextualized lens, we are able to glimpse
the violence as specifically oriented towards purification, rather than the
infliction of pain or agony on individuals. The massacres at Vassy and on St
Bartholomew‘s Day are historic events that will not soon be forgotten. Yet, by
investigating the stimulants behind these atrocities we might, in purview,
arrive at subtle distinctions that would otherwise have been overlooked. In
this way, 16th century French religious violence can be examined as ritualistic,
instead of dismissively pathological. This means early modern Christian
violence in France was predominantly concerned with didactic performances
in which Catholics and Protestants sought to emulate political and religious
authorities in order to maintain unity among the bodies of believers. At the
same time, Calvinist performances after Vassy often emphasized the legal
standing of their ―faith‖ instead of the theological differences that had
otherwise brought about violent persecution.
This notion of French Protestant rights is substantial because it
exemplifies the extent to which theological conceptions gave rise to social,
political and religious transformations that would affect the course of French
history. Moreover, it specifically demonstrates a dynamic distinction in social
tensions taking precedence over religious differences and definitions of
French identity. This is not to say that Calvinists did not emphasize their
Christian identity. Certainly, Huguenots were Christians arguing for their
legitimacy, even theologically after Vassy, but once Catholic mobs massacred
and took up arms in the name of the king through ritual imitation or
80
Strata
Rex Barnes
performance, French Protestants declared this an act of sedition, rather than
stressing such action as sinful. More to the point, this was a profound
moment for French Christian communities to identify themselves as subjects
under the king, instead of as theologically opposed to Catholic doctrines.
Rex Barnes en est maintenant à sa dernière année de maîtrise dans le
programme de philosophie et d‘histoire des religions à l‘Université Concordia,
où il a complété ses études de premier cycle en théorie politique. Son travail de
maîtrise examine le christianisme au cours de l‘époque médiévale et au début
des temps modernes. Plus spécifiquement, il examine les hagiographies des
mystiques Béguinage et les relations de genre entre les hagiographes masculins
et leurs homologues féminins.
Rex Barnes is in the final year of his MA in the philosophy and history of
religion programme at Concordia. He previously completed his undergraduate
studies in political theory, also at Concordia. His MA work examines medieval
and early modern Christianity, specifically the hagiographies of Beguine mystics
and the gendered relationships between the male hagiographers and their
female counterparts.
81
Military Revolutions and Revolutions in Military
Affairs: Accurate Descriptions of Change or
Intellectual Constructs?
MICHAEL J. THOMPSON
Abstract
The Revolution in Military Affairs (RMA) became a common term in military
and defence circles in the early 1990s when the Gulf War seemed to indicate a
dramatic shift in the nature of modern warfare. This idea has roots in the
concept of the Military Revolution (MR) which was used by historian Michael
Roberts in the 1950s to describe phenomena dating to the 16th C. Although
the exact nature of RMAs was debated over the course of the 1990s, the
concept itself quickly gained widespread acceptance. The questions were more
about how RMAs could be exploited and controlled rather than whether the
phenomenon itself holds weight at all. Before engaging in debates as to the
peculiarities of MRs or RMAs, one must first determine the validity of the
concepts themselves. This is especially true for those interested in policymaking where real world decisions must be made based, in part, on historical
trends and observable facts. Perhaps the most important question in assessing
the validity of such military change is whether it occurs in revolutionary
spasms or as incremental evolutions. Understanding these issues, as well as
what conditions drive certain kinds of change, is incredibly valuable for
defence policy-makers attempting to assess current and future strategic
positions. This paper does not seek to weigh in on the particular debates
surrounding these concepts but attempts to examine the literature in an effort
to understand their true value as explanatory tools in the history of military
change.
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
🍁
For many strategists the Gulf War seemed to indicate that a new era had
begun in the military sphere. The swift victory of the Coalition forces over the
Iraqi forces seemed to confirm the superiority of Western military technology
and the role that it could play in being the decisive factor in achieving military
success in modern warfare. It appeared that the key technologies of the Gulf
War—stealth, precision weapons, advanced sensors, C4I,1 and real time space
systems—represented a fundamental shift in warfare in favour of those who
could harness these new technologies. For many, the Gulf War was the first
real testament to the current revolution in military affairs (RMA).
The debates with regards to the concept of military revolutions (MR)
or revolutions in military affairs (RMA) are largely an issue of semantics.
Unable to agree if they represent cataclysmic and revolutionary events, or
merely an incremental process of change, many scholars disagree over their
cause and nature. The debates are largely confused because MRs/RMAs can
be defined in a number of ways, and thus certain aspects can be stressed or
omitted in order to fit each historian‘s definition. In the process of attempting
to bring different perspectives together, the debate can fall apart due to open
ended interpretation. Understanding the historical foundations of the concept
helps shed light on aspects of MRs/RMAs, but provides only a few concrete
lessons due to its elusive conceptual nature and controversial characteristics.
The evidence does however, suggest certain momentous changes in strategic
history (whether the result of so-called revolutionary or incremental change)
and thus has some explanatory value as a historical concept. What is more,
certain concepts that appear contradictory might in fact be reconcilable.
Despite the academic shortcomings, the concept holds significance for policymakers and thus an understanding of the various debates and interpretations
become more relevant when trying to apply concepts in the real world.
1. Command, control, communications, computers, and (military) intelligence.
83
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
Part one of this paper introduces the concept of the revolution in
military affairs, its relevance in explaining the success of Coalition forces
during the Gulf War, and a brief overview of the policy issues that emerge
from the implications of RMAs. Part two looks at the evolution of the theory
of military revolutions in the historical literature starting with its earliest
articulation by Michael Roberts in 1955. Part three provides an overview of
the different paradigms that have been used to describe the nature of military
revolutions, and highlights the major interpretations used by leading authors.
Although at first glance the various paradigms leave little room for
cooperation in their assessment of MRs/RMAs, this section attempts to show
how each paradigm might in fact be valid under certain circumstances as well
as how they share commonalities despite rhetoric that points to the contrary.
Part four provides some general lessons that can be garnered from the
literature and which are generally agreed upon despite the seemingly
contradictory viewpoints. Finally, part five provides some conclusions from a
policy perspective about how both the strengths and limitations of the history
can inform policy-making. Current and future policy-making must be aware of
the history but must also be skeptical of arguments that suggest understanding
MRs/RMAs is straightforward. Ultimately, policy must be based on analysis of
previous revolutions but will have to accept a certain degree of risk in judging
how current and future ones will proceed.
The Revolution in Military Affairs and the Gulf War Debate
An RMA can be defined as ―a major change in the nature of warfare brought
about by advances in military technology which, combined with dramatic
changes in military doctrine and organizational concepts, fundamentally alter
the character and conduct of military operations.‖2 The popular term carries
2. Elinor Sloan, "Canada and the Revolution in Military Affairs: Current Response
and Future Opportunities," Canadian Military Journal 1, 3 (2000): 7.
84
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
with it a heavy interpretive load as descriptions of the RMA—its nature,
characteristics, and relevance—are varied and plentiful.
The roots of the current RMA lay before the Gulf War and the term
itself has origins in the Soviet Union. The early influences lay in the work of
military theorists in the 1960s. Marxist-Leninist doctrine made the Red Army
receptive to the idea of revolutionary change and Soviet theorists were
pioneers in analyzing the impact of World War I on military techniques of the
interwar period.3 It was observed that the German Blitzkrieg of 1941
demonstrated the possibility for revolutionary changes in war. Moreover, in
the postwar period Soviet development of nuclear weapons and missile
systems came to rival that of the West, ushering in another seemingly
revolutionary era of military history. In the 1970s, Soviet military thinkers
writing about a ‗Military Technical Revolution‘ (MTR) argued that computers,
space surveillance, and long-range missiles ―were merging into a new level of
military technology, significantly enough to shift the correlation of forces
between East and West.‖4 By the mid 1980s, the Chief of the Soviet General
Staff, Marshal Nicolai Ogarkov, had become the leading advocate of the
concept, arguing that the Soviet position in Europe was threatened by the
United States which had pulled ahead in this technologically based revolution.
In the early 1990s, Andrew W. Marshall of the Office of New Assessment was
aware of the Soviet writings on the MTR but felt that the emphasis on the
technological aspect of the ongoing military changes was a narrow reading of
what qualified as a true revolution. As such, the term MTR was replaced with
the now broader concept of an RMA which emphasizes doctrinal aspects of
military transformation in addition to the technical/technological.
Analysts disagree on how to approach the current RMA as well as
which are the most important questions to answer in order to best inform
policy-making. Some of these questions include: What are the characteristics
3. Macgregor Knox and Williamson Murray, eds., The Dynamics of Military Revolution,
1300-2050 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001), 2.
4. James R. Blaker, ―Understanding the Revolution in Military Affairs,‖ The Officer
(May 1997), http://global.factiva.com/.
85
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
of the current RMA? How can it transform warfare? Is it possible to direct
and control an RMA? Will the new technology simply be grafted onto existing
platforms and systems? What is the role of technology in relation to the role
of strategy? But before attempting to address these issues, a more fundamental
question is whether a current RMA is in fact taking place at all — did the Gulf
War truly give evidence of a new RMA?
Neil McFarlane explains in Security, Strategy and the Global Economics of
Defence Production (1999) that understanding the RMA (or MTR/MR) and its
relationship to modern warfare is essential to ―analysis and policymaking with
regard to the restructuring of armed forces and defence industries and to the
issue of how much of what to procure.‖5 MacFarlane‘s assessment of the Gulf
War is that although it appeared to confirm a transformation in the capacity to
wage warfare based on information technology, a closer look suggests it was
not quite the case in 1991. Taking a skeptical view of the RMA, he feels that
the kinds of threats faced today—including terrorism, drugs and international
crime, proliferation of weapons of mass destruction (WMDs)—do not quite
fit with the high technology and massive applications of force envisaged by
RMA advocates, undermining its relevance.
Similarly, S. D. Biddle argues that many strategists misread the result
of the Gulf War. In a 1994 article published in International Security he argues
that the standard explanations for the outcome of the Gulf War are wrong.6
Instead of viewing the war as a one-sided contest of Coalition strength, Biddle
incorporates a more complex set of factors into his explanation of victory. He
argues that Iraqi errors and military shortcomings (poor training, morale,
leadership, and numerical inferiority) exposed their forces to higher casualties.
Without mistakes which provided the openings to Coalition success, victory
would have been different and the collation forces would not have prevailed
5. S. Neil MacFarlane, ―International Security and the RMA,‖ in Security, Strategy and
the Global Economics of Defence Production, ed. David G. Haglund and S. Neil MacFarlane
(Montreal: McGill-Queen‘s University Press, 1999), 29.
6. S. D. Biddle, ―Victory Misunderstood: What the Gulf War Tells Us About the
Future of Conflict,‖ International Security 21, 2 (Fall 1996): 139–79.
86
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
with such low losses. For him, victory was as much a result of Iraqi
ineffectiveness and Coalition skill, as a show of technological superiority. Thus,
battlefield skill imbalance will be a crucial aspect to military success in modern
war.7 Rather than a revolution through information dominance and precision
strike, the Gulf War really suggests the need to exploit mistakes. Conversely, if
opponents acquire new technologies that are traditionally associated with the
current RMA, then the threat is smaller than expected as long as quality and
skill of forces and organizations are maintained. Therefore, the benefits of
change and costs of continuity are lower than might be assumed by RMA
advocates. Biddle concludes that the war‘s failure to provide clear evidence for
an RMA has policy ramifications for modernization policy and defense budget
priorities.
Throughout the 1990s, the idea of an RMA continued to be a popular
topic of discussion. As awareness grew over the potential of the internet and
information revolution, strategists and policy analysts scrutinized the ways in
which the armed forces could be transformed in order to harness the possible
advantage. However, much of the debate seemed to assume from the outset
the validity of the concept of military revolution, disagreeing only on how to
assess the possibility of a current revolution. But do MRs in fact exist? Are MRs
an interchangeable concept with RMA? Does the evidence of history give
weight to the idea that change in the ‗way of war‘ is a radical process?
Michael Roberts and the Military Revolution: The Roots of the Debate
The current debates about the concept of the military revolution can be traced
back to Michael Roberts‘ inaugural lecture, the ―Military Revolution, 1560–
1660,‖ given at the Queen‘s University of Belfast in 1955. Roberts argued that
the way war was fought was radically transformed during this hundred-year
period. This transformation was rooted in a tactical revolution that was based
on linear formations of drilled musketeers which led to a massive increase in
7. Ibid., 157.
87
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
the size and scale of armies, and thus the size and scale of the impact that wars
had on society.8 These new armies were characteristic of Maurice of Nassau
and Gustavus Adolphus, who took advantage of the new tactical concepts and
were able to command larger armies as well as execute more complex
strategies than had previously been seen. The changes implemented by these
two men required skilled and disciplined soldiers, leading to the adoption of
drills, uniforms, and armies that were organized into smaller and more
standardized units. This laid the foundation for the ever-increasing size of
armies and had impacts beyond the military realm. There was a considerable
societal impact as larger and more permanent armies—and the resources they
required—led to an increase in the authority of the state.9 This new authority
of the state, backed by the armies, was used to impose heavier burdens of
taxation than before, and a host of new officials were needed in order to direct
resources. According to Roberts, the centrally organized, bureaucratically
governed nation-state was born from the seeds of tactical reforms of the 16th
century.
Roberts‘ thesis was well received and the concept of the military
revolution gained acceptance in historical thinking, partly as a result of Sir
George Clark‘s incorporation of the concept into his 1958 work War and
Society in the Seventeenth Century.10 The concept lay unchallenged until 1976 with
Geoffrey Parker‘s article ―The Military Revolution, 1560–1660 — a myth?‖11
Here Parker critically examined Roberts‘ thesis, finding the core of his
argument sound but disagreeing with certain points of emphasis. Parker
posited that a more appropriate starting date for the revolution is in fact half a
century earlier. He argued professional standing armies, regularly called upon
8. Clifford Rogers, ―The Military Revolutions of the Hundred Years‘ War,‖ Journal of
Military History (April 1993): 241.
9. Clifford Rogers, ―The Military Revolution in History and Historiography,‖ in The
Military Revolution Debate, Clifford J. Rogers, ed. (Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, Inc., 1995),
2.
10. Ibid., 3.
11. Geoffrey Parker, ―The ‗Military Revolution,‘ 1560-1660 – a myth?‖ Journal of
Modern History 48, 2 (June 1976): 195–214.
88
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
and organized into small units with uniform armament and (sometimes)
uniform dress, were maintained by many Italian states in the 15th century.12
Thus Parker modified Roberts‘ thesis, agreeing with the importance of
growing army size, but instead arguing that the growth started earlier than
Roberts suggests. He also argued that it was the result of more complicated
factors than just tactical reforms. Parker argued that the growth of army size
was driven by the increased manpower needed to besiege and defend the trace
italienne.13 The ability of this type of fortress to resist sieges tipped the balance
of strategy in favor of defence. As battles lost relevance, war became about
successful siege and defence, which demanded money. The growth of
European populations facilitated this, as did changes in military technology.
Moreover, the resulting increase in army size and emphasis on technology
required not only expanded government bureaucracies, but also improved
technologies of food production and transportation as well as expanding
financial institutions.14
Parker continued with his examination of the military revolution with
his 1988 book, The Military Revolution: Military Innovation and the rise of the West,
1500–1800.15 Taking inspiration from Daniel Headrick‘s work The Tools of
Empire, which examined the technological changes that paved the way for
Western imperialism in the 19th century, Parker expanded the topic of the
military revolution in order to assess the issue of the rise of the West. Acting
12. Geoffrey Parker, ―The ‗Military Revolution,‘ 1560–1660 – a myth?‖ 197.
13. A star-shaped fort with triangular bastions designed to allow better protective
cover and which is better able to withstand canon fire.
14. Alex Roland, ―Technology and War: The Historiographical Revolution of the
1980s,‖ Technology and Culture 34, 1 (January 1993): 123. Other works that examine the military
revolution and emphasize the connection between the revolution and the formation of states,
bureaucracies, and professionalism include: Colin Jones‘ ―The Military Revolution and the
Professionalization of the French Army under the Ancien Regime‖ in Clifford J. Rogers, ed.,
The Military Revolution Debate (Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, Inc., 1995) and other articles
in Michael Duffy‘s The Military Revolution and the State, 1500–1800 (Exeter: University of Exeter
Press, 1980).
15. Geoffrey Parker, The Military Revolution: Military Innovation and the rise of the West,
1500-1800 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988).
89
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
as a complement to Headrick‘s examination, Parker traced the Western
world‘s rise to imperialist domination back to the age of gunpowder. New
siege weapons led to improved fortifications which themselves required larger
garrisons and contributed to the increase in the size of armies, as originally
noted by Roberts.16 The increased impact of war on society is rooted in
increasingly destructive weapons, thus placing technology at the centre of the
story, much like Headrick‘s emphasis on technology as one of the keys to
consolidating and maintaining imperialistic power over the non-western
world.
Thus, as Parker developed his ideas, gunpowder and fortification
technology grew in importance and emphasis within the concept of MRs. This
aspect of Parker‘s analysis was criticized by Bert Hall and Kelly DeVries in
Technology and Culture (1990) for treating technology as a ―black box‖ and
consequently for advocating technological determinism.17 David Parrott‘s
―Strategy and Tactics in the Thirty Years War: The Military Revolution,‖ as
well as Simon Adams‘ ―Tactics or Politics? ―The Military Revolution and the
Hapsburg Hegemony, 1525–1648‖ (1995),18 brought into question the
predominance of tactical or technological causes of army growth. Instead, they
pointed towards changing political balances and strategic approaches. Parrott
argued that before making arguments based on tactical reforms, historians
must look at how battles were actually fought. Thus, logistics and political
influences must be assessed in determining army growth. Similarly, John
Lynn‘s ―The trace italienne and the Growth of Armies: The French Case‖
(1995), was skeptical of the technologically-based thesis, arguing instead that
16. Roland, ―Technology and War,‖ 123.
17. Bert S. Hall and Kelly R. DeVries, ―Essay Review – the ―Military Revolution‖
Revisited,‖ review of The Military Revolution: Military Innovation and the Rise of the West, 1500–1800
by Geoffrey Parker, Technology and Culture, 31, 3 (July 1990): 500–507. They quibble with some
technical aspects of his arguments and methodology. Also argue he fails in giving the full depth
of analysis to certain themes. They point out that microbes and disease play as important role as
guns in the history of Western imperial expansion and that cases like Japan are ignored in his
assertion that non-Europeans failed in adopting Western military technology effectively.
18. Both available in Clifford J. Rogers, ed., The Military Revolution Debate (Boulder,
Colorado: Westview Press, Inc., 1995).
90
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
the key behind the military revolution was the growth of populations and
wealth in Europe which were decisive in the development of massive armed
forces of the 16th and 17th century.19 Despite its criticisms, Parker‘s book was
praised for its contribution to the ―breadth and importance‖ of the subject of
Europe‘s rise to global power. It expanded the concept of military revolution
beyond the confines of early modern Europe and showed that the
consequences of military innovation ―belonged to the world as well as
European history.‖20
In 1993, Clifford Rogers published ―The Military Revolutions of the
Hundred Years‘ War‖ in which he argued that two revolutions occurred
during the Hundred Years‘ War: first in the form of an infantry revolution,
and then as an artillery revolution.21 Both, according to Rogers, represent
revolutions with consequences as significant as those that took place in the
period of Parker‘s revolutions (1500–1800). Because these two revolutions
were followed in later centuries with revolutions in fortification and
administration (as Robert‘s argued), Rogers‘ analysis points to the possibility
that there are multiple revolutions in history, as opposed to the single one
articulated by Roberts. Some have argued as many as ten revolutions, others as
few as two.22
19. Also available in ibid.
20. Ibid., 5.
21. Rogers, ―The Military Revolutions of the Hundred Years‘ War,‖ 244. The infantry
revolution was represented in the relationship between military power and political power; as
the importance of common infantry on the battlefield grew, this was reflected in the political
influence of the commons which was derived from the governments‘ need to secure financial
support of the people to sustain war efforts as well as need to secure military service. Rogers,
―The Military Revolutions of the Hundred Years‘ War,‖ 252–253. The importance of the
artillery revolution lay in the fact that artillery was expensive. Central governments of larger
states could not afford to maintain large siege trains and thus there was an imbalance between
offense and defence in siege warfare in favor of offense. Only large states and central
governments could supply the resources to maintain sizable standing armies. Rogers, ―The
Military Revolutions of the Hundred Years‘ War,‖ 272–273.
22. For example Andrew Krepinevich identifies 10; Max Boot, 4; Alvin Toffler, 3;
Williamson Murray, 4. See also, Bernard Simon, ―The Revolution in Military Affairs: Approach
91
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
Paradigms and Definitions: Evolution or Revolution?
The debate over the number of revolutions and exactly which technologies,
strategies, and phenomena constitute a revolution highlights a crucial aspect of
the military revolution debate: so much depends on the definition. Historians
and analysts are free to define what constitutes the term ―revolution‖ and are
free to interpret technologies and strategies throughout history however they
choose, adding certain ones to their list of revolutions, and leaving others off.
The number of revolutions and the nature of those revolutions across time
forms the most interesting and analytical aspect of the military revolution
debate. Just how one conceptualizes the idea of ―revolution,‖ and
distinguishes it from ―evolutionary‖ change, forms a core component of the
literature.
In ―Revolutions in Warfare: Theoretical Paradigms and Historical
Evidence: The Napoleonic and First World War Revolutions in Military
Affairs,‖ Andrew Liaropoulos notes that analysts are often in agreement that a
MR/RMA involves radical change in the history of warfare, but lack
consensus on how and when these changes take place and what causes them.23
A number of paradigms for understanding MRs have been identified, helping
to organize the debate into clear competing interpretations: ―Social Wave,‖
―Radical Transformation,‖ the ―Revolution in the Revolution‖ (MR, RMA,
MTR theory), ―Continuity and Evolution‖/‖Continuous Innovation,‖ and
―Punctuated Equilibrium‖ (action-reaction).24 What follows is a brief overview
of each model.
with caution,‖ Army Doctrine and Training Bulletin 3, 4 (Winter 2000): 60, for an overview of
various authors and what they consider to be revolutions.
23. Andrew N. Liaropoulos, ―Revolutions in Warfare: Theoretical Paradigms and
Historical Evidence: The Napoleonic and First World War Revolutions in Military Affairs,‖
Journal of Military History 70, 2 (April 2006): 366.
24. For a good overview of these paradigms, see ibid. and Gray, Strategy for Chaos:
Revolutions in Military Affairs and the Evidence of History (London: Frank Cass Publishers, 2002).
92
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
The ‗Social Wave‘ paradigm explores the broad social, political and
economic changes that affect military transformations and the way society
organizes and conducts war.25 Events such as the French Revolution, the
Industrial Revolution, and the Information Revolution are examined with
attention to how shifts between the revolutions correspond with shifts in the
nature of war. The social wave concept is usually attributed to the work of
Alvin and Heidi Toffler whose idea of social waves are expressed most clearly
in War and Anti-war (1993).26 They examine three waves of civilization—
Agrarian, Industrial, and Information—and how they correspond to war.
Their argument is that the socio-economic waves are boosted by productivity
and the resources of wealth creation and power (identified as agriculture,
industry, and knowledge), and these waves affect warfare: ―Starting with the
very invention of agriculture, every revolution in the system for creating
wealth triggered a corresponding revolution in the system for making war.‖27
Thus, military revolutions are seen as the outgrowth of changes in economic
production; the way humans make war reflects the way they make wealth. The
argument is that for the current social wave, information will become the key
source of wealth and power. This will lead to new types of war for
information, which is becoming the new strategic asset. Moreover, control of
information will not only be the source of war, but the means of war (through
C4I).
Some have been critical of the social wave theory, arguing that it
does not stand up to the evidence. Jeremy Shapiro writes that evidence of a
shift towards this third social wave is not present—where past social
revolutions have been marked by dramatic productivity improvements (food
production for Agricultural Revolution and industrial goods with the
Industrial Revolution), the productivity increase due to information is not
25. Liaropoulos, ―Revolutions in Warfare,‖ 367.
26. Alvin and Heidi Toffler, War and Anti-war: Survival at the Dawn of the 21st Century
(Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1993).
27. Liaropoulos, ―Revolutions in Warfare,‖ 368.
93
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
sufficiently evident.28 This is a conclusion supported by Biddle, who argues
that ―there is little evidence of any significant productivity acceleration
attributable to IT [information technology].‖29 However, the idea that military
change is the product of deep social, political, and economic changes indeed
fits the historical evidence.30 For example, the French Revolution and its
major effects on the way of war as a result of the levée en masse are widely
accepted. The real skepticism with the social wave theory seems not to rest in
the concept of social roots of revolutions and its impact on war, but in its
argument that a current third wave based on information is upon us.
The ‗Radical Transformation‘ paradigm emphasizes military
technology, doctrines, and organizations, and the way that these impact
warfare. The proponents of this paradigm31 view military revolutions as a
series of radical transitions where far-sighted innovators are able to see the
potential of new technologies and create new doctrines as a result. It is
innovation of great scope and speed that characterize revolutions. The most
common historical example cited is the development of Blitzkrieg by Germany
prior to World War II. Tanks, airplanes, and radios were available to all of the
great powers during the interwar period, but it was the innovation by the
Germans, born out of their loss in World War I, that spurred their
imaginations for new doctrines and new ways of organizing their armed
forces. Some disagree on this point, arguing that Blitzkrieg was not a radical
transformation, but the product of an evolutionary development of the
strategy of annihilation and encirclement that can be traced back to Moltke
28. Jeremy Shapiro, ―Information and War: Is it a revolution?‖ in The Changing Role of
Information Warfare, Zalmay M. Khalizad and John P. White, eds. (Santa Monica, CA: RAND,
1999).
29 S. D. Biddle, ―The Past as Prologue: Assessing Theories of Future Warfare,‖
Security Studies 8, 1 (Autumn 1998): 34.
30 See Liaropoulos, ―Revolutions in Warfare.‖
31 For this approach, see Krepinevich, ―Cavalry to Computer‖; Daniel Goure, ―Is
there a Military-Technical Revolution in America's Future?‖ Washington Quarterly 16 (Autumn
1993): 175–92; James R. Fitzsimonds and Jan Van Tol, ―Revolutions in Military Affairs,‖ Joint
Force Quarterly (Spring 1994): 24–31; and Eliot A. Cohen, ―A Revolution in Warfare,‖ Foreign
Affairs 75 (March–April 1996): 37–54.
94
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
the Elder.32 Thus, it can be argued that trial and error and the learning process
that is necessary for military innovations suggests an evolutionary perspective
of change.
The ‗Revolution in Revolution‘ theory argues that there are larger
revolutions, usually referred to as ‗Military Revolutions‘ (MRs) which are made
up of smaller RMAs or MTRs. Williamson Murray is the key proponent of
this perspective.33 The argument can be outlined as follows: Occasionally
history records a systematically radical change, or shock, which is considered a
true military revolution. This MR is accompanied by ―pre-shock‖ as well as
―post-shock‖ RMAs/MTRs. These shocks can result from many possible
factors, including technology (in which case it would constitute an MTR), or
strategic, doctrinal and tactical innovations (which would constitute an
RMA).34
For example, the Industrial Revolution is identified by Murray as one
of four main MRs.35 This large shock was characterized by smaller,
technologically based MTRs, which included the railroad, rifling, precision
tooling and interchangeable parts. Additionally, one could argue that a mid20th century military revolution was composed of Blitzkrieg and strategic
bombing, which would be considered RMAs because they were based on
strategic innovations applied to already existing technologies. The strength of
Murray‘s analysis lies in its ability to distinguish between MRs, RMAs, and
MTRs, accepting each as valid and avoiding the restrictions of other
interpretations. Additionally, Murray allows for a variety of influencing forces:
MRs can be the product of broader social and economic forces, while RMAs the
result of strategists‘ innovations, and MTRs can be driven by technological
32. Moltke the Elder was chief of the Prussian Army, and is regarded as on the
greatest strategists of the 19th century.
33. See Williamson Murray, ―Thinking About Revolution in Military Affairs,‖ Joint
Force Quarterly (Summer 1997) and Knox and Murray, eds., The Dynamics of Military Revolution,
1300–2050.
34. Gray, Strategy for Chaos, 40.
35. He identified four: creation of the nation state based on organized military power
in the 17th century, the French Revolution, the Industrial Revolution, and World War I.
95
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
advances. The concept of differentiating between MRs and RMAs/MTRs
holds more than academic interest. As Thierry Gongora points out:
Establishing whether we are confronted by [an MR] or [an
RMA] carries significant policy implications. If we are facing
a military revolution, the policy debate should transcend
issues of technology and operations to embrace such
fundamental aspects of defence policy as the nature of future
conflicts; the size, recruitment mode, and make-up of armed
forces; the financing of defence; and the shape of the defence
industrial base. . . if we are only confronting an RMA, then
the challenge becomes more manageable, and can be met
within the current framework of defence, so long as the
military maintain the ability to innovate.36
Similarly, Knox and Murray argue that MRs are beyond the control of
future-oriented or strategic thinkers/defence planners, a contrast to the radical
transformation paradigm that argues in favour of the notion of foresight and
control. They do argue, however, that although MRs are less controllable
because they are products of deep and varied forces, the RMAs that compose
MRs appear susceptible to human direction and institutions that can recognize
them.37
The ‗Punctuated Equilibrium Evolution‘ paradigm was articulated by
Clifford Rogers in his 1993 article ―The Military Revolutions of the Hundred
Years‘ War.‖38 He argues that that the concept of ―revolution‖ in history is
flexible. This is seen in that the term is used for events as varied as the French,
Copernican, and Industrial Revolutions; and their flexible periodizations, as
36. Thierry Gongora, ―The Shape of Things to Come: Sizing up the Revolution in
Military Affairs,‖ in Security, Strategy and the Global Economics of Defence Production (Montreal:
McGill-Queen‘s University Press, 1999): 38.
37. Knox and Murray, eds., Dynamics of Military Revolution.
38. Rogers, ―The Military Revolutions of the Hundred Years‘ War,‖ 241–78.
96
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
―revolutions‖ vary from years in some cases, to centuries in others. Rogers
identifies four revolutions over five centuries between 1300 and 1800: Infantry
Revolution, Artillery Revolution, Artillery Fortress Revolution and Military
Revolution (outlined by Michael Roberts). He acknowledges that if one so
chooses, they could continue the list with the French Revolution, Industrial
War, and Nuclear Revolution. Thus it can be argued that we are not dealing
with one revolutionary change but a series of revolutions that have all
combined throughout history to allow for Western military superiority.39 Thus,
it appears that the issue is more one of evolution than revolution in the
development of this superiority.
However, he rejects a model based on a near infinite number of tiny
changes. Instead, he advocates the ‗punctuated equilibrium‘ model that
combines both incremental and revolutionary change. Evolution is preceded
by short bursts of change, interspersed with long periods of near stasis, rather
than constant and slow alterations.40 Military change is more the result of a
long causal chain of action and reaction than sudden revolutions. Rogers
summarizes his theory by saying: ―I. . . argue that Western military dominance
derived from a series of sequential revolutions, each an attempt to reverse a
disequilibrium introduced by the previous one, rather from a single ―Military
Revolution.‖41 Rogers‘ thesis is a neat characterization of change, but has been
criticized by some, such as Murray, for imposing ―an undue orderliness upon
strategic history.‖42 Gray continues on this line of thought, noting that the
necessarily competitive context for strategic behavior ―cannot be assumed to
follow a strategically logical and tidy path of action and reaction. . . even the
most apparently self evident of action-reaction chains are not what they
appear to be.‖43
39. Ibid., 276.
40. Ibid., 277.
41. Gray, Strategy for Chaos, 47.
42. Murray, ―Thinking About Revolution in Military Affairs,‖ 70.
43. Gray, Strategy for Chaos, 48.
97
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
The ‗Continuity and Evolution‘ Paradigm takes the perspective that
―innovation and transformation [is] a continuous process intended to deal
with the chaotic nature of war.‖44 Authors like Jeremy Black and Colin Gray
take a balanced approach towards the concepts of MRs and RMAs,
recognizing the potential importance of military innovation and radical
change, but remaining skeptical towards the idea of regularly paced
innovation. Proponents of this approach agree that transformations do occur
in history, and accept the idea that pace can vary, but they view innovation as
a continual process of coping with the challenges of warfare.45
It can be argued that all current technologies and doctrines are merely
evolutionary results of thousands of years of war fighting innovation that is
never static or in stasis. The eras between each technological breakthrough are
important periods of innovative development. Each development can be
traced back through a constant evolution of innovation.
For example, one can view all current technologies and doctrines as
merely evolutionary results of thousands of years of war fighting innovation
which is never static or in stasis. Jonathan Bailey‘s work on World War I and
the emergence of artillery firepower as the dominant factor in warfare46 lends
to the perspective that current weapons technology of computerized long
range missile strike is merely an upgraded version of computer-calculated
trajectories developed after World War II. Moreover, this is the same concept
in a different form as cannons rooted in the gunpowder revolution, or siege
weapons such as trebuchets. Every innovation builds on the previous, and the
eras between each technological breakthrough are important periods of
innovative development.
Colin Gray makes the case that although innovation plays a role, the
ability of a state to cope with increasingly complex battlefields is the true
determinant of success. His book Strategy for Chaos (2002) argues that strategy
44. Liaropoulos, ―Revolutions in Warfare,‖ 370.
45. Ibid., 371.
46. See Jonathan Bailey, ―The First world War and the Birth of Modern Style of
Warfare,‖ in The Dynamics of Military Revolution, ed. Knox and Murray, 132–153.
98
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
and war are not linear, but ever changing and chaotic. Gray is skeptical of the
idea of RMA explanations of innovation, viewing RMAs more as an
intellectual construct than an accurate description of historical trends. For
Gray, evidence points more towards continuities based on a fluid and plastic
course of history than sudden changes or revolutions. This is a conclusion
reinforced by S. D. Biddle‘s article ―The Past as Prologue: Assessing Theories
of Future Warfare‖ (1998).47 His analysis of MR paradigms also concludes that
a non-revolutionary/continuity perspective is best supported by the evidence.
He posits that future war will be an incremental extension of a long pattern of
growth in skill development. For him innovation is not necessary to success,
nor does it often lead to success. Instead success is the result of the ―ability to
cope with an increasingly complex battlefield.‖48
It appears then that the idea of momentous and revolutionary change
is invalid. But, to argue that coping with complexities of war is a never-ending
process does not negate the possibility of important innovations. Gray and
Biddle seem to take a similar stance to Rogers‘ punctuated equilibrium. Both
argue that change and innovation is a reaction; one sees change as a reaction
to preceding innovations, the other as a reaction to the chaos of war. At the
core, they might be less incompatible than they appear because they are
essentially describing the same thing and attempting to contextualize the same
phenomena: the process of innovation. Indeed, where the paradigms disagree
is not in the idea of particular momentous change, but in the technical aspects
of change: Is innovation regularly or irregularly paced? How much chance and
risk is involved in assuming a revolution? How much can change be
controlled? What are the most important driving forces?
But the idea that certain strategies, technologies and ideas can have
profound and lasting effects on the way of war is indeed agreed upon. In fact
certain aspects of the debate are not mutually exclusive, but are compatible,
and combine in complex ways. After an analysis of the Napoleonic Revolution
47. Biddle, ―The Past as Prologue: Assessing Theories of Future Warfare.‖
48. Ibid., 5.
99
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
and World War I, Liaropoulos concludes that both case studies give credibility
to the social wave paradigm, as well as evolutionary paradigm. One could argue
that the social wave theory accurately explains the French Revolution and that
the revolution in revolution explains the Industrial Military Revolution.
Moreover, there is a case to be made that the modern information based RMA
will show elements of both, as well as the radical transformation paradigm. So
certain paradigms work with certain historical events, and sometimes work in
conjunction to explain the same event.49 But this raises an issue: just how one
characterizes revolutions, and indeed what even constitutes a revolution,
displays a problem of subjectivity.
However, evolutionary and revolutionary perspectives are harder to
reconcile, and it appears that the concept of incremental and revolutionary
change cannot be validated by the same MR.50 But just because particular case
studies seemingly exclude the radical transformation paradigm does not mean
we should be quick to discard the concept. An evolutionary/incremental
perspective need not necessarily be incompatible with the concept of radical
and revolutionary change. Revolutionary change might in fact be the result of
incrementalism.
Williamson Murray of the ‗Revolution in Revolution‘ paradigm agrees
that revolutionary change might in fact be the result of incrementalism. In The
Dynamics of Military Revolution (2001) he makes the case that Blitzkrieg is less a
result of revolutionary ideas than evolutionary development. He argues that
interwar German efforts and innovation were aimed at ―incremental
improvement.‖51 He maintains that Blitzkrieg was still revolutionary, but only
became so when victory was achieved. Similarly, Andrew Krepinevich argues
in ―From Cavalry to Computer: The Pattern of Military Revolutions‖ (1994),
49. For example see Jeffrey R. Cooper, ―Another View of the Revolution in Military
Affairs‖ (U.S. Army War College Strategic Studies Institute, July 1994) and David Jablonski,
―The Owl of Minerva Flies at Twilight: Doctrinal Change and Continuity and the Revolution in
Military Affairs‖ (U.S. Army War College Strategic Studies Institute, May 1994).
50. Liaropoulos, ―Revolutions in Warfare,‖ 382.
51. See Williamson Murray, ―May 1940: Contingency and Fragility of the German
RMA,‖ in The Dynamics of Military Revolution, 1300–2050.
100
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
that there is no common transition period between ―military regimes,‖ but
what is revolutionary is not the speed of transitions between regimes, but the
―the recognition, over some relatively brief period, that the character of
conflict has changed dramatically, requiring equally dramatic, if not radical,
changes in military doctrine and organizations.‖52 The idea of incremental
innovation does not necessarily remove the revolutionary importance of ideas
born out of it. Revolutions are defined by realizations of change, not pace of
change.
Thus, the outcome seems more important than the process. Although
Blitzkrieg can be viewed as an evolutionary development for Germany, it can
be considered revolutionary by the French holding the Maginot Line. Nuclear
weapons can be the result of sequential development of increasing
destructiveness of explosives, but was undoubtedly seen as radical upon its use
in Japan and the realization that a new era of warfare had begun. It is not an
either-or situation between radical or incremental process in explaining
change. Both can be accurate descriptions, and it often depends on how you
tell the story. We are faced then with the possibility that revolution is relative.
A revolution is not born out of the process of innovation, but the realization by
opponents that the way of war has been changed in some way.
Lessons from the Literature
So here some features begin to take shape. First, it would appear that the
concept of MR/RMA does fit the historical evidence. It is hard to argue that
gunpowder, levée en masse, the Industrial Revolution, strategic bombing, atomic
weapons, or a host of other developments did not fundamentally change the
nature of war. Whichever revolutions you include or exclude, the MR/RMA
seems to be a valuable analytical tool in describing military and strategic
history, especially Murray‘s analysis that accounts for both. One, however,
52. Andrew Krepinevich, ―From Cavalry to Computer: The Pattern of Military
Revolutions,‖ The National Interest (Fall 1994), http://find.galegroup.com/.
101
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
must proceed cautiously and with skepticism. Analysts must sort through the
complexity of the debate by navigating the theories and paradigms as much as
possible, and focus on the evidence that the history provides. Other than
acceptance that innovations occur, and some are more important than others,
there seems to be little else upon which to agree.53
The second salient feature is the problem of semantics. Whether one
sees Blitzkrieg as a testament to the power of technology or strategy is largely a
matter of perspective. Whether it represents the end of an incremental chain
of ideas, or a moment of genius occurring within a narrow time span is
debatable. Whether a revolution occurs when one side first conceives the
potential of a new doctrine or technology, or when victory is achieved, is a
matter of interpretation. Whether there are two, four, or ten observable
revolutions in history is a matter of opinion based on how you define military
revolution, or include sub-categories like RMAs and MTRs. The problem with
the concept is that it is largely a matter of how you define the terms used, and
what is left out or included is up to the one making the definition. This is
especially true with a term like ―revolution‖ whose historical usage is so
varied.
Colin Gray is right when he asserts that the concept of an RMA or
MR is merely an intellectual construct.54 The idea itself does not hold much
tangible weight, but has value in that it spurs research into innovations and
helps shed light on the course of military and strategic history. Whether
certain historical events or phenomena are defined as evolutionary or
53. Clearly the nature of military revolutions leaves much to interpretation. What,
then, are the general conclusions about MR and RMAs of the early modern period that find broad
consensus across the literature? According to Alex Roland, there are certain features of the
original MR debate that are generally agreed upon: sometime in the early modern period there
was a dramatic chance in Western warfare; Although this change helps explain the rise of the
West, the nature of the change is in doubt and debated; It is most likely that several, as opposed
to one revolution were taking place, but the earliest began before 1560; All the revolutions seem
tied to gunpowder; Army size increased, but not uniformly; True growth in size came with
Louis XIV and the French Revolution; Siege weapons tipped the balance towards the defence,
but only temporarily. Roland, ―Technology and War,‖ 125.
54. Gray, Strategy for Chaos, 31.
102
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
revolutionary is merely a debate of words. Clifford Rogers concludes his
analysis of the ‗Punctuated Equilibrium‘ paradigm by stating: ―It might be
argued that, so long as we all know what we are talking about when we say
"Military Revolution," my objections are mere quibbling, only a question of
semantics.‖55 Martin Dunn expresses similar apprehension when he states that
beyond the broad understanding that an RMA is a fundamental revision of
how war is conducted, the ―RMA becomes amorphous as different authors
choose to define it in different, and sometimes contradictory, ways.‖56 Because
of this problem one must either reject everything, or accept everything as
valid. But once you begin to accept the full range of periodizations and driving
forces, and accept all paradigms as valid, the historical scope in which to draw
strong conclusions becomes overwhelming.
In the end we are left with conceptual disorder—a ―multiple analytical
pile-up.‖57 Because a more universal agreement on the nature of the concept
remains elusive, it might be concluded that the phenomenon has little use
because the concept itself is a fabrication of academic minds. Yet it is possible
to pick through this disorder to identify some lessons in the literature that
hold significant importance for strategic analysts and policy experts.
The perspective that technology is an underlying factor but not a
necessary cause of revolutions runs throughout the literature. The general
consensus is that the key to success is the way in which doctrine or strategy is
applied to technology, whether it is old or new. Jeffrey Cooper, writing in the
mid-1990s, shows awareness of the serious policy implications of misjudging
the RMA, particularly in hanging too much on the role of technology.
Therefore Cooper argued against fruitless searches for a ―silver bullet‖
technology on which to build an RMA and instead argued that the crucial
issues were strategy, doctrines, and operation innovation.58 Metz and Kievit
55. Rogers, ―The Military Revolutions of the Hundred Years‘ War,‖ 278.
56. Martin Dunn, ―RMA=Revolution in Military Acronyms,‖ Research and Analysis:
Newsletter of the Directorate of Army Research and Analysis 5 (March 1996).
57. Gray, Strategy for Chaos, xiv.
58. Cooper, ―Another View of the Revolution in Military Affairs.‖
103
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
similarly conclude: ―If policymakers decide to pursue the revolution in military
affairs, strategy, rather than technological capability should guide force
development.‖59
Andrew Krepinevich concludes his article ―From Cavalry to
Computer: The Pattern of Military Revolutions‖ (1994) with a number of
lessons about the character of military revolution: First is that emerging
technologies only make revolutions possible. New strategic doctrines and
organizational structures are paramount. Second, competitive advantages of
military revolutions are increasingly short lived. Competitors can copy and
exploit new technologies and strategies. And third, although most militaries
will be quick to recognize a competitor's advantage, there are no certainties.
Not even war will guarantee that all military organizations will recognize and
exploit a military revolution or understand a revolution in all its dimensions.60
Krepinevich also argues that it is likely that other competitors may
seek to exploit the RMA. Continued technological and operational leadership
in the West (specifically in the U.S.) will not be assured. Even countries not
capable of participating in the full spectrum of RMA capabilities will become
formidable niche competitors as specialization will give advantages in certain
areas. Similarly, it cannot be assumed that competitors will follow the same
transformation paths because different security environments, strategic
perspectives, and economic situations will lead in different directions. There is
59. Steven Metz and James Kievit, ―Strategy and the Revolution in Military Affairs:
From Theory to Policy‖ (U.S. Army War College Strategic Studies Institute, June 1995). For
more on the role of technology and strategy, see: Colin S. Gray, ―Weapons for Strategic Effect:
How Important is Technology?‖ Occasional Paper 21 (Air War College Centre for Strategy and
Technology, January 2001); George Raudzens, ―War-Winning Weapons: The Measurement of
Technological Determinism in Military History,‖ Journal of Military History 54, 4 (October 1990):
403–434; S. Neil McFarlane, International Security and the RMA,‖ in Security, Strategy and the
Global Economics of Defence Production; Dunn, ―RMA=Revolution in Military Acronyms‖; Andrew
Krepinevich, ―From Cavalry to Computer: The Pattern of Military Revolutions‖; Geoffrey L.
Herrera, ―Inventing the Railroad and Rifle Revolution: Information, Military innovation and the
Rise of Germany,‖ Journal of Strategic Studies 27, 2 (June 2004): 243-271; Sean M. Maloney and
Scot Robertson, ―The Revolution in Military Affairs: Possible Implications for Canada,‖
International Journal 54, 3 (Summer 1999): 443–462.
60. Krepinevich, ―From Cavalry to Computer.‖
104
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
great danger in assuming one‘s own revolution will develop in an anticipated
direction, and equal danger in assuming the same path for others. The RMA,
even when identified, is fickle, elusive, and there is no guarantee to success if
harnessed in a certain way.
Conclusions from a Policy Perspective
The idea of an RMA/MR is a powerful one. It suggests radical changes in the
character and nature of war and requires concomitant changes in the character
of military operations.61 Advocates argue that the ways of war are
fundamentally altered by developments in technology, doctrine and
organization. RMAs thus necessitate adaptation. Adapting to changes brought
upon by an RMA, or even adapting in an attempt to create an RMA, ensures a
military‘s position in a world marked by uncertainty and chaos. Therefore, the
concept is important for policy and strategic analysts. A complete assessment
of the RMA with respect to policy assessment and implications is beyond the
scope of this paper. However, there are a few points that can be made.
First, the concept of military revolutions holds weight despite
seemingly contradictory concepts. In fact, the idea of incrementalism versus
revolution might not be so incompatible. MRs have been the product of
different forces, and thus have developed in different ways; some the result of
a slow process of social change over long periods of time, others the result of
particular technological breakthroughs or flashes of strategic brilliance. Even
incrementalists agree that transformations occur, but simply argue that they
stand out from a ―normal condition of generally steady innovation, not
periods of near stasis.‖62 To argue an incremental sequence of events does not
necessarily remove the importance of a particular event or breakthrough, if
one occurs. Even if one gets hung up on the particulars of interpretation, the
61. Maloney and Robertson, 444.
62. Gray, Strategy for Chaos, 55.
105
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
concept that certain innovations in technology, strategy, doctrine, can have
dramatic and at times revolutionary consequences is valid.
Second, the history is important. Understanding the historical
traditions of the concept is necessary if analysts are going to successfully
understand the potential nature and characteristics of any current or future
MR/RMA. Although the analysis can be messy, it has been shown that there
are several valuable and accepted conclusions that can be drawn from the vast
and varied history and literature.
Third, the debates are valuable even if they do represent a problem of
semantics. Indeed, the literature itself and its plethora of interpretations are
useful in that they suggest that the different interpretations hold different
significance for how revolutions are approached. An understanding of the
literature is useful in that there is some reason to believe that each paradigm
holds a degree of weight under different circumstances. Understanding how
the various interpretations might be valid under certain conditions, or might
interact at the same time, is an important consideration.
A fourth and related point is that the individual historical case studies
do have limits in their usefulness. To assume a particular perspective is the
valid one because it appears to dominate the historical evidence risks
misunderstanding. The interpretive nature of the concept raises doubts about
drawing universal conclusions from the past, and places emphasis on
contextual issues for understanding possible present or future revolutions. If
the concept of MR and the paradigms that describe them are dependent on a
number of political, economic, social, and technological variables, then one
needs to assess each possible revolution independently without imposing too
much upon them from the outset. If some argue that a current RMA is upon
us, analysts must be aware of the past, but must also carefully analyze the
present. Is the current situation likely to be driven by a new technology,
doctrine, or social forces? Is it likely that the process will be a rapid and
revolutionary one, or the outcome of evolutionary ideas that are identifiable?
106
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
What factors might influence this development?63 The most effective way to
approach potential RMAs is to attempt to carefully assess them individually
based on their current technological, political, economic, and social contexts.
Policy-makers need to look beyond the military and technical, assess the
external factors that shape the military and defence arena, and base their
analysis on current and relevant issues. Just because a MR of the past was the
product of certain forces, and fits a particular model, is not sufficient to
assume it will always be that way.
Finally, uncertainty should not, and cannot stop the evolution of
strategic thinking. Otherwise uncertainty of success would translate into
strategic inertia. To be sure, some have raised doubts as to the ability of
societies to predict MRs. Some have noted that Blitzkrieg was not a success
until it was proven in combat and there was no way to know during the
interwar period that the new strategy would be successful. Still, policy must
press on. Risk taking is part of the nature of planning for the future. Luckily it
can be argued that we are living in the most self aware era with respect to
RMAs. Revolutions have consistently become shorter in duration and the
result of this is that they become more salient and obvious. This increases the
ability of policy-makers and strategists to interpret the current situation and
make informed decisions based on likely trends. Preparing for the future
based on potential MRs/RMAs not only requires an understanding of the
historical tradition, but also relies heavily on assessments of current strategic
positions, sound policy-analysis, and a considerable degree of risk. Risks due
to misjudgment do exist, but they cannot stop policy.
63. If one looks at the current state of affairs, there is reason to believe that
incrementalism will characterize the current so-called RMA. There are complex and deeply
rooted bureaucratic and industrial interests involved in defence planning in the modern era
dominated by the military-industrial complex. Thus it is likely that it would be very difficult to
foster rapid investment in completely new forces and weapons systems which would require
huge sums of money at come at the expense of current forces. A more likely scenario would be
a process of upgrading existing systems to prepare the road for future developments. Theirry
Gongora sees no incentive ―to pursue the exploitation of the RMA along lines that would
undermine the relevance of its current forces and their main weapons systems.‖ Gongora, 41.
107
Strata
Michael J. Thompson
Michael J. Thompson est candidat au doctorat au département d‘histoire de
l‘Université d‘Ottawa, où il se concentre sur l‘histoire militaire canadienne. Il a
complété ses études de premier cycle en histoire à l‘Université Acadia et sa
maîtrise en politique publique à l‘Université Queen‘s. Son travail met l‘accent
plus particulièrement sur l‘histoire de la politique de défense et de sécurité au
Canada.
Michael J. Thompson is a PhD candidate in the department of history at the
University of Ottawa, focusing on Canadian military history. He completed his
BA in history at Acadia University and his MA in public policy at Queen‘s
University. His work places an emphasis on the history of defence and security
policy in Canada.
108
Not Here by Choice: Canada‘s Importation of Child
Labourers
LORI JONES
Abstract
Between the 1830s and the 1940s, more than 100,000 poor British children
were imported to Canada as indentured apprentices. While support for the socalled ―juvenile immigration movement‖ was initially strong, it did not take
long for the public and media to turn against the children. This episode in
Canadian history, wherein children became the target of hostility, is one that
until recently has been largely ignored in Canadian historiography. Although
the juvenile immigration movement is mentioned in passing in most scholarly
works about the history of British immigration to Canada, academic attention
to the practice of importing child labourers began only in the late 1970s. To
understand Canada‘s practice of importing young child labourers requires
examining Britain‘s attempts to deal with its poor, the inter-relationship
between Canada‘s labour needs and its immigration policies, and changing
public perceptions of child labour that ultimately led to the demise of child
importation.
🍁
Introduction
―Outcasts,‖ ―street waifs,‖ ―children of vicious and criminal tendencies,‖ and
Strata
Lori Jones
―the offal of the most depraved characters. . . of the Old Country.‖1 Such was
the language used in newspapers, trade union reports, and even the Canadian
Parliament toward the end of the nineteenth and into the early twentieth
centuries to describe British pauper children who had been brought to Canada
as apprentices and indentured as domestic servants and agricultural labourers.2
This episode in Canadian history, wherein children—and British children at
that, not any of the ethnic groups typically hailed as inassimilable—became
the target of hostility, is one that was largely disregarded in Canadian
historiography until Joy Parr‘s 1977 Yale University dissertation highlighted
what she called ―the dark side of evangelicalism, of turn of the century
childhood, and of Canadian rural life.‖3 Parr‘s work brought attention to the
fact that many Canadians are descended from young children removed from
their surroundings in Britain and sent to work in Canada. Since the publication
of Parr‘s dissertation, several historians have published works that explore the
juvenile immigration movement in further detail and illuminate the conditions
under which these children lived and worked.4
1. Editorial, Toronto News, 6 May 1884; The Globe, 10 September 1884; D. J.
O‘Donoghue, Trades and Labour Congress of Canada, 1895, quoted in P. T. Rooke and R. L.
Schnell, ―The King's Children in English Canada: A psychohistorical study of abandonment,
rejection, and colonial response (1869–1930),‖ Journal of Psychohistory 8, no. 4 (Spring 1981): 387;
Canada, House of Commons, ―Report of the Select Standing Committee on Agriculture and
Colonisation of the House of Commons,‖ Journals, (1888), 10.
2. Joy Parr, Labouring Children: British Immigrant Apprentices to Canada, 1869–1924,
(London: Croom Helm, 1994), 11.
3. Joy Parr, ―The Home Children: British Juvenile Immigration to Canada, 1868–
1924‖ (PhD dissertation, Yale University, 1977), iv.
4. The major works on the topic include Parr, Labouring Children; Phyllis Harrison, The
Home Children: Their Personal Stories (Winnipeg: Watson & Dwyer, 1979); Kenneth Bagnell, The
Little Immigrants: The Orphans Who Came to Canada (Toronto: Macmillan, 1980); Gail H. Corbett,
Barnardo Children in Canada (Peterborough, ON: Woodland, 1981); Rooke and Schnell, ―The
King's Children‖; Gillian Wagner, Children of the Empire (London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson,
1982); Patricia T. Rooke and R. L. Schnell, ―Imperial Philanthropy and Colonial Response:
British Juvenile Emigration to Canada, 1896–1930,‖ The Historian 46, no. 1 (November 1983):
56–77; Philip Bean and Joy Melville, Lost Children of the Empire (London: Unwin Hyman, 1989);
Marjorie Kohli, The Golden Bridge: Young Immigrants to Canada, 1833–1939 (Toronto: Natural
Heritage Books, 2003); Charlotte Neff, ―The Children's Friend Society in Upper Canada, 1833–
110
Strata
Lori Jones
To more clearly understand what motivated Canadians to import
more than 100,000 pauper children as indentured labourers—most only ten
and eleven years old—requires going beyond an isolated examination of the
juvenile immigration movement and exploring the history of British poor
relief as well as the relationship between Canadian labour needs and
immigration policies in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
Understanding the cessation of the practice likewise requires looking beyond
the reported public hostility to, and poor treatment of, the children and
investigating the evolution and acceptance of the concept of ―childhood‖ and
its impact on the development of British and Canadian child labour laws.
While relying on the major scholarly works that have explored Canada‘s
importation of child labourers in detail, this paper also draws from a variety of
sources that address British and Canadian social and immigration histories in
an effort to situate the juvenile immigration movement within its broader
historical context. Numerous primary sources available through Library and
Archives Canada, particularly personal and government letters, orders-incouncil, police reports, government reports, and lists related to the juvenile
immigration movement, were gleaned from RG17 Agriculture, RG18 Royal
Canadian Mounted Police, RG25 External Affairs, and RG76 Immigration
and used in the writing of this paper. Historical newspaper articles, House of
Commons reports, and a publication by Thomas Barnardo, one of the leading
philanthropists involved in the movement, were also consulted to cast light on
contemporary public and political opinion of the children and their presence
in Canada. Phyllis Harrison and Gail H. Corbett have, in their respective
works,5 provided significant collections of memories from former child
immigrants. Recognising the inherent challenges involved in basing historical
works on long-term memories without sufficient corroboration, however, this
paper does not use those sources to any great extent. It does, however, include
a single case study that is drawn primarily from the unpublished records of
1837,‖ Journal of Family History 32, no. 3 (July 2007): 234–255; and Roy Parker, Uprooted: The
Shipment of Poor Children to Canada, 1867–1917 (Vancouver: UBC Press, 2008).
5. Harrison, The Home Children and Corbett, Barnardo Children in Canada.
111
Strata
Lori Jones
one philanthropic organisation, with minor details added from the
unpublished memoires of the former child immigrant herself.
I. Solving the “Problem” of Pauper Children
Charitable efforts to provide relief to Britain‘s poor have had a long history.
The growth of religious-based philanthropy in the mid-nineteenth century was
little more than a product of, and reaction to, the evolution of poor laws over
the previous centuries. In another sense, though, the juvenile emigration
movement was unique in that it represented the organised separation of
children from their families and their emigration from Britain.6
Early English Charity
The nature and foundation of medieval English charity—based upon the
almshouse—were largely destroyed by the dissolution of the monasteries in
1536–40 and of religious guilds, fraternities, almshouses, and hospitals during
the following decade. The evolution of the country‘s poor laws was primarily a
parliamentary attempt to fill the gap. The 1597 and 1601 Acts for the Relief of the
Poor created a national poor law system that was largely parish-based, locally
enforced, and voluntary. The system permitted almshouses to care for those
too disabled to work and established workhouses for the able-bodied. Child
pauper apprenticeship was also introduced through the Act as a means to
arrest and forcibly apprentice vagrant children between the ages of five and
fourteen.7 Seventeenth century records show that pauper apprenticeship was
used extensively to reduce poor rate expenditures. As such, the ―parish did
not focus on doing good for the child but on relieving itself of a burden and
6. Parker, Uprooted, xiii.
7. Charlotte Neff, ―Pauper Apprenticeship in Early Nineteenth Century Ontario,‖
Journal of Family History 21, No. 2 (April 1996): 146. Pauper apprenticeship differed significantly
from trade apprenticeship, as the ―children were [simply] to be kept busy, off the streets, fed,
clothed, and housed‖ (144).
112
Strata
Lori Jones
blight.‖8
In 1662, An Act for the Better Relief of the Poor of this Kingdom allowed city
officials to return newcomers to their previous place of settlement if they were
deemed likely to become a public charge.9 By 1834, the Poor Law Amendment
Act created a more rigorously implemented, centrally enforced, and mandatory
system centred on the workhouse and managed by administrative units called
Poor Law Unions.10 It also included a financial provision for the emigration of
the poor. Two subsequent amendments led to a significant increase in the
emigration of the poor: the 1848 Poor Law Amendment Act created a common
fund to finance emigration, while the 1850 Poor Law Amendment Act provided
that a Poor Law Union could assist the emigration of poor orphan or deserted
children under the age of sixteen.11
Assisted Emigration of Pauper Children
As soon as they began settling the Virginia colony in the early 1600s, the
British sought to ensure that there was a sufficient labour supply to keep the
colony functioning. It achieved this through the use of indentured servitude,
whereby in exchange for their transportation to the colony labourers agreed to
work for a pre-determined number of years for little or no wages. In the early
American colonial period, the size of the indentured population was almost
triple that of the non-indentured. Indentured labourers included men and
women as well as children, and by the later seventeenth century, forty-five
percent of the indentured servants arriving in Lancaster County, Virginia were
under the age of 16.12 At the same time, assisted emigration—the partial or
total absorption of emigrants‘ transportation and settlement expenses without
8. Ibid, 147.
9. Paul Slack, From Reformation to Improvement: Public Welfare in Early Modern England,
(Oxford: Clarendon, 1999), 138.
10. Ibid., 60.
11. John Eekelaar, ―‗The Chief Glory': The Export of Children from the United
Kingdom,‖ Journal of Law and Society 21, No. 4 (December 1994): 489.
12. Richards, Britannia‘s Children, 55.
113
Strata
Lori Jones
a work-as-payment requirement—was also promoted in Britain as a viable way
to both ease the social problem of poverty and purge the criminal class.13
From the late eighteenth through the nineteenth centuries, displaced
agricultural workers and unemployed wage workers from throughout the
British Isles and Ireland were assisted to emigrate in large numbers. 14
Although they later became the most likely to be emigrated, workhouse
inmates or those receiving parish relief were at first explicitly excluded.
In its earliest days, the emigration of pauper children was undertaken
primarily to remove those who had committed crimes or ―become public
nuisances through destitution.‖15 Sending such children initially to the
American colonies and after 1783 to Australia, South Africa, and Canada was
seen as an appropriate and expedient response to the problem of child
pauperism that also helped to meet the colonies‘ labour needs. The first
recorded emigration of poor children dates to 1619, when the London
Common Council sent one hundred vagrant children to Jamestown,
Virginia.16 From the seventeenth through early nineteenth century, thousands
of children may have been sent overseas.17
By the mid-nineteenth century, child pauperism had increased
significantly as a result of a mass migration of the rural poor to cities. Many
poor families, unable to find work, were forced to survive with insufficient
food, water, and clothing in dirty and crowded hovels. Young children were
often compelled to work in very low paying and tedious jobs to supplement
13. Harper and Constantine, Migration and Empire, 247.
14. Encyclopedia of Canada's Peoples, ed. Paul R. Magocsi (Toronto: University of
Toronto Press, 1999), 1119. While the majority of Scottish agricultural immigrants paid their
own way, a significant minority were assisted to emigrate. Helen Cowan, British Emigration to
British North America: The First Hundred Years (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1961), 43;
Harper and Constantine, Migration and Empire, 16–17, 52; Kirby A. Miller, Review of Sending Out
Ireland‘s Poor: Assisted Emigration to North America in the Nineteenth Century, by Gerard Moran,
Journal of Social History 38, no. 3 (Spring 2005): 784. Cowan, British Emigration, 68–70.
15. Wagner, Children of the Empire, xiii.
16. Ibid, 251; Eric Richards, Britannia‘s Children: Emigration from England, Scotland, Wales
and Ireland since 1600 (London: Hambledon and London, 2004), 54.
17. Bean and Melville, Lost Children of the Empire, 37–38.
114
Strata
Lori Jones
their families‘ incomes. Child pauper apprenticeships also shifted from their
original focus on agricultural and domestic work to factory work. Many poor
children died before reaching adulthood; those who survived faced a life of
grinding poverty, crime, and disease.18
Recognition of the at-times deplorable conditions under which poor
children worked contributed—in part—to the growth of philanthropy and
social reform in early nineteenth century Britain. The seventh Earl of
Shaftesbury was particularly noteworthy in bringing attention to the working
conditions of child colliers, factory workers, and chimneysweeps and was
instrumental in the development and passage of acts abolishing child
apprenticeship and setting restrictions on child labour. He also helped to
establish some of the earliest ―ragged schools,‖ which acted as industry
training centres for youth. During the same period, the concept of childhood
began to evolve and children began to be seen as more than just little adults.
By the latter decades of the century, reformers were successfully arguing that
children should not work until the age of fourteen, that government-funded
schooling should be mandatory, and that child abuse should be criminalised.19
However, while the concept of childhood was recognised among the
middle and upper classes, it was seen quite differently between rural and urban
areas and between classes. Evangelical philanthropists, who were heralded
among the wealthy for their family-modelled institutions, used emigration to
separate children from parents deemed unworthy.20 By the mid- to late
nineteenth century, social reformers targeting poor children used the bleak
economic and social prospects facing pauper children to justify their
emigration.21 The reformers argued that the colonies‘ labour needs could be
18. Parr, Labouring Children, 15-18.
19. Rooke and Schnell. ―Imperial Philanthropy,‖69; Parr, Labouring Children, 12.
20. Parr, Labouring Children, 12.
21. ―Child saving frequently entailed the separation of children from family, friends,
and community by means of institutionalization and placing out in order to ensure effective
guardianship,‖ R. L. Schnell, ―The Right Class of Boy: Youth Training Schemes and Assisted
Emigration to Canada Under the Empire Settlement Act, 1922–39,‖ History of Education 24, no.
1 (March 1995): 73. See also Elaine Hadley, ―Natives in a Strange Land: The Philanthropic
115
Strata
Lori Jones
best met by the ―surplus of destitute, homeless and unemployable children in
Victorian Britain‘s urban centres.‖22
As the century progressed, economic justification was supplemented
by an evangelical conviction that removing pauper children from cities and
sending them to colonial farms would benefit them not only economically, but
also morally and spiritually. By the end of the century, a further ―imperialist‖
argument was used: the need to settle uninhabited lands throughout the
Empire with British emigrants. By this reasoning, pauper children were not
just being rescued but were acting as the building blocks of the Empire.23
Advocacy for formally organizing the emigration of destitute children
from Britain began before 1830. In 1826, Robert Chambers, a London police
magistrate, appeared before a British Parliament Select Committee convened
to address the broader issue of emigration. As a key witness, Chambers
declared that London had become overrun with beggar children and that the
best solution was to send them to Canada. He stated that ―children who [are]
down and out, those twelve years of age and upward, should be sent to
Canada, where they [are] badly needed, to be apprenticed to persons who. . .
would be glad to receive them as workers on the land.‖24 Chambers‘ testimony
was supported by others who also believed in the great public benefit of
emigrating homeless boys.25
By the 1830s, several private agencies, notably the Society for the
Suppression of Juvenile Vagrancy (renamed the Children‘s Friend Society in
1834), were already providing training to children and sending them as
apprentices to Canadian farms.26 The mission of the Society was to rescue
Discourse of Juvenile Emigration in Mid-Nineteenth Century England,‖ Victorian Studies 33, no.
3 (Spring 1990): 418-419.
22. Wagner, Children of the Empire, xiii.
23. As Schnell notes, ―the movement of children. . . was conducted in the context of
imperial relations and of Canadian national aspirations,‖ ―Right Class of Boy,‖ 73. See also
Wagner, Children of the Empire, xv.
24. Bagnell, The Little Immigrants, 23.
25. Ibid, 24.
26. Corbett, Barnardo Children in Canada, 23.
116
Strata
Lori Jones
poor children from their negative urban environments and provide them with
―useful, healthy, and profitable employment.‖27 Although the British Colonial
Office opposed efforts to organise child emigration on an official basis, the
Society sent 141 child apprentices to Upper and Lower Canada between 1833
and 1836. As debates about child emigration persisted in the British
Parliament over the next decade, private agencies continued to train and equip
poor children for the colonies.28
Despite the advocacy, the early child emigration initiatives started by
Lord Shaftesbury, the Children‘s Friend Society, and the Reformatory and
Industrial Schools did not receive sufficient public support and were shortlived.29 However, their underlying philosophy motivated the large scale
juvenile emigration movement of the 1860s. By this time, a growing number
of organizations and private individuals managing children‘s homes began to
more seriously organise the emigration of children to the colonies, particularly
to Canada. Eventually, more than fifty organisations were engaged in this
work.30 The most prominent included Maria Rye, Annie Macpherson, Dr.
Thomas Barnardo, the Quarriers, the Methodist Children‘s Home, Dr.
Thomas Bowman Stephenson, James William Condell Fegan, and Ellen
Smyly. Most of the organisations ran on a strong evangelical Protestant base
and worked in the belief that removing pauper children from their
environments would provide them with socio-economic and spiritual
opportunities. Several Catholic organisations, working on the same general
premise, also emigrated pauper children.31 Barnardo started small and initially
worked through Macpherson and Stephenson. However, his organisation
grew quickly and by the turn of the twentieth century he was sending more
than 1,000 children to Canada each year, making his the largest of the
27. Neff, ―The Children's Friend Society,‖ 235.
28. Ibid, 234; Neff, ―Pauper Apprenticeships,‖ 153.
29. Wagner, Children of the Empire, xiii.
30. Harper and Constantine, Migration and Empire, 253.
31. Several works provide detailed accounts of the various organisations, their
missions, and their work. See in particular Kohli, The Golden Bridge and Parker, Uprooted.
117
Strata
Lori Jones
organisations.
Less than one-third of the children sent to Canada were actually
orphans or completely destitute. Many arrived without their families‘
knowledge. Some children had sought philanthropic help themselves, while
others were referred by third parties such as city missionaries, church
ministers, or other charities.32 The majority were surrendered by parents who
could not afford to look after them and, seeking to avoid the workhouse,
hoped that philanthropic organisations might provide a temporary refuge.
However, most of the organisations believed that child poverty was related to
poor parenting and used this as a justification to permanently separate the
children from their families.33
In almost all cases, the child and his or her parent had little choice
about emigration. Parents were pressured to sign the Canada Clause which
allowed philanthropic organisations to send children to Canada. Barnardo,
however, was not concerned about such a policy and openly used emigration
to separate children from parents whom he deemed unfit.34 Barnardo‘s
records show that six percent of surrendered boys and eight percent of
surrendered girls were emigrated without parental consent or knowledge.35
Believing it immoral to leave children in pauperised conditions, in 1885
Barnardo wrote an article in which he not only questioned whether judicial
law should override moral law, but declared that he had abducted forty-seven
children and sent them to Canada. ―I have myself frequent bought little
children. . . I have also smuggled children quietly away, or I have abducted
them almost by force in the face of angry opposition.‖36 Another
32. Wagner, Children of the Empire, 137
33. Rooke and Schnell, ―The King‘s Children,‖ 391.
34. Lydia Murdoch, Imagined Orphans: Poor Families, Child Welfare, and Contested
Citizenship in London (Piscataway NJ: Rutgers University Press, 2006), 23.
35. Wagner, Children of the Empire, 138–140.
36. Thomas Barnardo, ―Is Philanthropic Abduction Ever Justifiable?‖ Night and Day,
(London: November 1885), 149–50. Parr estimates from Barnardo‘s records that nine percent
of boys and fifteen percent of girls emigrated to Canada were abducted by Barnardo (Labouring
Children, 67).
118
Strata
Lori Jones
philanthropist, Arthur Thomas, justified child emigration thus: ―We are merely
transferring them from one part of the Empire to another – from our own
England where they have no prospects, to our own Canada, where their
prospects are as bright as the flame that glows on the maple leaf in the fall.‖37
II. Canada’s Need for Cheap Labour
The push to remove pauper children from Britain could only have succeeded
if there was a reciprocal desire for such children at the receiving end. Canadian
support for the juvenile emigration movement was multi-faceted and multilayered, based on a combination of labour needs, population needs,
endorsement of evangelical philanthropy, and a belief that importing child
labourers mirrored existing child apprenticeship practices.
Population Gaps and Labour Shortages
While Britain faced crowded cities full of destitute families, British North
America—and later the Dominion of Canada—had a small population. Even
as the population grew, however, outside of a few towns and cities it remained
primarily scattered and rural. There was also a shortage of agricultural labour,
particularly in the provinces of Ontario and Quebec.38
Canadian policy and practice encouraged the immigration of
agriculturalists. However, the land grants system by which immigrants
acquired farmland resulted in a proliferation of relatively small farms. Families
were typically granted less than 200 acres.39 Work on small farms was
undertaken primarily by unpaid family members. In many cases, though,
farming families could neither do all of the work themselves nor afford to hire
37. Rooke and Schnell, ―The King‘s Children,‖ 393.
38. Although the Province of Ontario came into existence only in 1867, the term
Ontario is used here for clarity. The same reasoning is used for Quebec.
39. Parker, Uprooted, 129. Until 1911 the majority of Canadian farms outside the
prairies were smaller than 100 acres.
119
Strata
Lori Jones
permanent labour. This created a growing demand for a supply of cheap
casual labour that could be hired only as needed.40 Although the 1871 Census
showed that eighty percent of the Canadian population lived in rural areas,
this percentage decreased by 6 percent per census year as young adults moved
away to seek education and non-farm employment or to acquire cheap land in
the west.41 This in turn reduced the availability of family labour and further
increased the demand for cheap wage labour. It was this labour gap that
imported boy labourers would fill. As Parker notes, ―They were replacement
labourers, but replacement labourers who were more akin to unpaid family
workers than to hired workers, even though many had indentures of
apprenticeship.‖42 Imported girls filled similar gaps as domestic workers,
particularly in farm and rural homes.43
Child Apprenticeship
The concept of apprenticing young pauper children was not new. By the late
eighteenth century the primary formal and legal mechanism to support
orphaned and abandoned children in Ontario was apprenticeship. This
mechanism was recognized in the 1799 Act to Provide for the Education and
Support of Orphan Children and in an 1846 Toronto municipal statute (An Act to
Authorize the Apprenticeship of Minors in Certain Cases and to Regulate the Duties of
Masters and Apprentices).44 Pauper apprenticeship provided boys and girls with
homes and training that they would otherwise have received from their
parents or other relatives. Apprenticeships were governed by written
40. Ibid.
41. Ibid, 131–133.
42. Ibid, 134. Parker notes that between 1901 and 1911, imported children replaced
farmers‘ sons at a rate of about twenty-seven percent; if regarded as wage labourers, the 1911
Census shows that they ―constituted 80 per cent of the growth in male wage labourers on
Ontario farms during the same time.‖
43. Parker also notes that rural areas were ―considered to present less temptation and
threaten less moral danger‖ than would cities (Uprooted, 137).
44. Neff, ―Pauper Apprenticeship,‖144.
120
Strata
Lori Jones
indenture documents signed by town wardens or the child‘s mother, and
countersigned by two justices of the peace. The apprenticeship was to last
until the child was an adult.45 In 1827, a further provincial act extended
apprenticing rights to guardians, including children‘s homes, while subsequent
acts redefined various aspects of the apprenticeship mechanism. In 1893, the
foster care system was established through the Children‘s Protection Act, and the
Adoption Act of 1921 legalised adoption.46
Ontario‘s rapidly expanding labour-intensive agrarian economy meant
that pauper apprentices were a source of cheap and readily available labour. As
a result, the organisations involved in apprenticing children found that they
regularly had more applications than available children. These organisations
worked alongside the homes that were later established as distribution centres
for immigrant children.
Support for the Importation of Child Labourers
A number of high level government and industrial officials advocated for and
provided both direct and indirect support to the philanthropic organisations
engaged in supplying pauper children. In 1825, Peter Robinson, a member of
the Legislative Assembly of Upper Canada who oversaw adult emigration
schemes, advocated that destitute British children be sent to Canada as
labourers.47 With Robinson‘s support and involvement, the Children‘s Friend
Society established branch societies in Canada. Through a letter printed in
newspapers and sent directly to private individuals, the Society encouraged the
establishment of committees to manage the Canadian end of the immigration
and placement process.48 By March 1835, such a committee was formed in
Toronto and included a number of prominent citizens and politicians,
including Robinson. The Lieutenant Governor and the mayor and council of
45. Ibid, 148.
46. Ibid, 144–45.
47. Corbett, Barnardo Children in Canada, 23.
48. Neff, ―Children's Friend Society,‖ 236.
121
Strata
Lori Jones
the City of Toronto were committee patrons.49 Similar organisations were
subsequently formed in Huntington, Cobourg, and Kingston, as were auxiliary
―Ladies Committees‖ which oversaw girl emigrants. Children sent by the
Society between 1833 and 1836 were placed in Upper and Lower Canada and
New Brunswick as domestic and farm workers with a range of hosts,
including friends of the board members.50 Boys were apprenticed until the age
of twenty-one and girls to the age of eighteen.51
Small numbers of child labourers were sent through various
organisations until the late 1860s, most often at the request of Canadian
emigration agents or provincial governments in Upper and Lower Canada and
the Maritimes. By the late 1860s, the juvenile immigration movement had
increased significantly. The level of support in Canada for the movement also
increased. Prominent officials and citizens from many towns assisted and
encouraged the philanthropic organisations by providing homes for
distribution centres. For example, the mayor and a justice of the peace in
Niagara-on-the-Lake supported Rye‘s purchase of an old court house and
jail.52 Belleville‘s Mayor and city council donated a home to Macpherson,53
while the citizens of Galt gave her a farm and land and the family of Mr
Justice Dunkin (Minister of Agriculture, 1869–1871) raised half the funds to
purchase a home in Knowlton, Quebec.54 Similarly, Sir George Cox, president
of Midland Railway Company and later a Liberal Senator, donated the home
―Hazel Brae‖ rent-free to Barnardo in Peterborough, Dr. Morley Punshon, a
Methodist minister, bought a home in Hamilton for Stephenson, and William
49. Ibid.
50. Parr, ―Home Children,‖ 2.
51. By the indenture terms, the master fed and clothed the child and paid three
dollars per year to the Society and seven dollars per year to the local committee to hold for the
child until he/she became of age. Neff, ―The Children's Friend Society,‖ 241.
52. Kohli, Golden Bridge, 72.
53. When the home burned down in 1872, City Council offered another house rent
and tax free for 3 years; local citizens furnished the home and took in the children. Wagner,
Children of the Empire, 66–67.
54. Ibid, 68–69. The Province of Quebec granted the remaining funds for the
Knowlton purchase.
122
Strata
Lori Jones
Gooderham, a wealthy Toronto citizen, gave Fegan a distributing home.55 Sir
Charles Tupper, then the Canadian High Commissioner in London, worked
with the Minister of Agriculture and the Canadian Pacific Railway to help
Barnardo acquire a 2,800 hectare industrial farm in Manitoba in 1887.56
Canadian Immigration Policy
Despite the active involvement of government officials as individuals in the
juvenile immigration movement, there were no official government policies
related specifically to the importation of child labourers. Prior to
Confederation, immigration to Canada was largely unrestricted, unregulated,
and fragmented between both the public and private sectors and federal and
provincial levels of government.57 The Constitution Act, 1867 specifically
recognised agriculture and immigration as the responsibility of both the
Dominion and provincial governments, while the first Immigration Act of 1869
deemed immigration to be a federal responsibility and placed it under the
Department of Agriculture, where it remained until 1892. While the Act said
nothing about the admissible classes of immigrants, a subsequent amendment
in 1872 prohibited the entry of ―criminals and other ‗vicious classes.‖58 An
1879 order-in-council further excluded paupers and the destitute. However,
since immigration was largely associated with agriculture, the importation of
pauper child agricultural labourers was not discouraged. In fact, in 1875, Lord
55. Ibid, 104.
56. Dr. Barnardo wrote to Tupper asking the Canadian government to grant him
good land near Winnipeg for a farm training school as well as railway transportation from all
ports of entry to Winnipeg. LAC, RG17, Agriculture, Volume 411, Docket 44833, 26 June
1884. Tupper replied with a letter of introduction to the Minister of Agriculture and suggested
that Barnardo contact the president of the CPR. Ibid, 11 July 1884. The land granted by the
government was supplemented by a land grant from the Manitoba and Northwest Railway. Ibid,
RG17, Agriculture, Volume 487, Docket 53503, 3 June 1886.
57. Reg Whitaker, Canadian Immigration Policy since Confederation (Ottawa: Canadian
Historical Association, 1991), 3.
58. Valerie Knowles, Strangers at Our Gates: Canadian Immigration and Immigration Policy
1540–2006 (Toronto: Dundurn, 2007), 49.
123
Strata
Lori Jones
Dufferin, the Governor General, agreed on behalf of the Canadian
government to Dr. Stephenson‘s request to financially support the children‘s
pre-departure training. Thereafter the government provided a grant of $2 per
child brought into Canada.59 This decision to financially support the juvenile
immigration movement clearly expressed the government‘s approval, even if
implicit, of the importation of child labourers.
The linking of immigration to agriculture continued, and was
strengthened after Clifford Sifton was appointed Minister of the Interior in
1896.60 To Sifton, significant agricultural immigration was the key to Canada‘s
success.61 In 1901, he sent a memorandum to the Prime Minister stating ―[our]
desire is to promote the immigration of farmers and farm labourers. We have
not been disposed to exclude foreigners of any nationality who seemed likely
to become successful agriculturists. . .‖62 While Sifton is perhaps best
remembered for his desire to attract ―stalwart peasants in sheepskin coats,‖63
his focus on agriculturalists also implicitly included child agricultural labourers.
In spite of such implicit support, however, the government had no
intention of being responsible for the children and left this duty to those who
brought them to Canada, none of whom were bound by any rules or
regulations. This lack of an explicit policy meant that the juvenile immigration
movement developed and grew in an uncoordinated and haphazard way. The
initiative for finding children, selecting new homes, and supervising them (or
not) remained entirely in the hands of philanthropic organisations, each of
59. Stephenson‘s request for financial support was addressed to the Minister of
Agriculture, and passed through the Prime Minister to the Governor General for response,
(Kohli, Golden Bridge, 139–140). In addition to the $2 per head support, the government also
subsidised the transportation costs of many children. See for example, LAC, RG17, Agriculture,
vol. 50, file 4708; ibid, vol. 110, file 10751; ibid, vol. 346, file 36829; ibid, vol. 347, file 36927;
ibid, vol. 729, file 83960; ibid, RG25, Immigration, ser. B-1-b, vol. 198, file I 6/90.
60. The Ministry of the Interior assumed responsibility for immigration in 1892.
61. Knowles, Strangers at Our Gates, 61.
62. Mabel F. Timlin, ―Canada's Immigration Policy, 1896–1910,‖ Canadian Journal of
Economics and Political Science / Revue canadienne d'Economique et de Science politique 26, No. 4
(November 1960): 518.
63. Knowles, Strangers at Our Gates, 91.
124
Strata
Lori Jones
which set its own practices and guidelines.64
In 1874, Andrew Doyle, Britain‘s Senior Local Government Board
Inspector, prepared a report in which he strongly condemned the juvenile
emigration movement, saying of it ―to send them as emigrants can be
regarded not as a way of improving their position, but simply of getting rid of
them at a cheap rate.‖65 He also criticised Canada‘s lax management of the
children once they arrived. His report was rejected by the Canadian
government, which subsequently set up a Commons Select Committee on
Immigration and produced its own report to demonstrate that child labour
importation was both successful and beneficial.66 In 1884, the government
issued an order-in-council giving provincial governments responsibility for
supervising immigrant children.67 The Ontario government followed this in
1897 with the Act to Regulate the Immigration into Ontario of Certain Classes of
Children, by which the work of each agency was to be inspected quarterly and
the children supervised until the age of 18. The Act also stipulated that all
child emigration agencies were to maintain proper homes for the children and
made it an offense to bring any child who was intellectually or physically
defective or had been convicted of a crime. Similar acts followed in Manitoba,
Quebec, and Nova Scotia. The Ontario government also appointed J.J. Kelso
as Secretary of Neglected and Dependent Children. Kelso later produced a
Special Report on the Immigration of British Children which was largely meant to
calm fears about the supervisory system.68 In 1899, the federal government
created a new position to deal specifically with British immigrant children.
George Bogue Smart was appointed the Inspector of British Immigrant
64. Ibid, 79.
65. Quoted in Parr, Labouring Children, 32.
66. Wagner, Children of the Empire, 87-88. Even so, the Local Government Boards
(LGB) still urged the Canadian government to undertake annual inspections of the children.
LAC, RG17, vol. 346, file 36882. In 1875, the LGB suspended the emigration of children based
and after ―a great deal of lobbying‖ by the Canadian government and assurances of annual
government inspections, did it reinstate emigration in 1883. Rooke and Schnell, ―Imperial
Philanthropy,‖ 62.
67. LAC, RG17, vol. 421, file 45958.
68. Wagner, Children of the Empire, 154–155.
125
Strata
Lori Jones
Children and Receiving Homes in 1900 and remained in this position until
1933. He standardized the inspection process and published annual reports on
his findings, which largely focused on improvements in the way child
labourers were being treated.69
In spite of these actions, the Canadian government continued to see
child emigration as the cheapest way to increase the number of new
immigrants and subsequent reports made by immigration officials did nothing
to disturb the notion that child labourers were an asset to the country. They
also did relatively little to improve the children‘s living and working
conditions. In the mid 1920s, more than sixty British Boards of Guardians
sent identical resolutions to the Canadian High Commissioner demanding that
the Canadian Government make it compulsory that government officials
examine and pre-approve all homes receiving children and frequently monitor
the homes. In 1924, the government passed an order-in-council that
effectively made it illegal for unaccompanied children under the age of
fourteen to enter the country. In 1925, it placed a three-year moratorium on
the immigration of school-age children. The moratorium was made permanent
in 1928. Although small numbers of underage immigrants continued in the
1930s, these policies largely brought an end to the importation of young child
labourers.70 The practice continued in various guises, though, until almost
mid-century for those over the age of fourteen.71
69. See for example LAC, RG76, Immigration, ser. I-A-1, vol. 200, reel C-7354, file
83981 parts 1 and 2 for Bogue Smart‘s inspection reports for the years 1900–1933.
70. Rooke and Schnell, ―Imperial Philanthropy,‖ 59.
71. Children were sent by the National Children‘s Home and Orphanage until at least
1934, while inspections of the children continued until at least 1937. LAC, RG76, ser. I-A-1 vol.
45, reel C-4708 and vol. 46, reel C-4709; ibid, ser. I-A-1, vol. 66, reel C-4734; ibid, volume 67,
Reel C-4735; vol. 68, reel C-4736; vol. 69, reel C-4736, file 3115. Schnell provides a detailed
look at the policy and practice of juvenile emigration under the Empire Settlement Act between
1922 and 1939. ―Right Class of Boy.‖ Harper provides a detailed look at juvenile emigrants in
1920s New Brunswick. Marjory Harper, ―Cossar‘s Colonists: Juvenile Migration to New
Brunswick in the 1920s,‖ Acadiensis 28, No. 1 (Autumn 1998): 47–65.
126
Strata
Lori Jones
III. Changing Public Perceptions
The reception given to the juvenile emigrants was mixed and changed
dramatically over time. Canadians‘ need for cheap labour was such that they
initially gave no thought to the origin or background of the children.
Economic recessions, an increase in (adult) pauper immigration, and the
creation of child protection acts caused the later Canadian response to range
from ―callous indifference to contempt and virulence to ambivalence.‖72
A Positive Welcome. . .
Initial Canadian perceptions about the importation of child labourers were
generally positive, as seen by the provision of distribution homes mentioned
above and the ease with which the children were placed into homes that
required their labour. The evangelical approaches used by the philanthropic
organisations resonated with Canadians, and local newspapers bought into the
rhetoric that saving destitute British children and giving them a new working
life in Canada was a positive thing to do. For example, reporting on one of
Maria Rye‘s first shipment of girls to Niagara-on-the-Lake in 1869, the local
Niagara Mail reported that ―[the] scheme of relieving destitute children is a
most judicious movement. It enables children to be trained here and begin life
under better auspices.‖73 Likewise, in October 1875, The Globe reported that
―There can be no just motive, then, for retaining [the children] in their pauper
condition, or [not] letting them have the chance which pauper apprenticeship
affords. Almost any change would be for the better. . .‖74 The Peterborough
Examiner quoted the local MP stating that although there were some
objections to the pauper children, ―[the] feeling was not general, for there was
room in the broad Dominion for every soul likely to become a good and
72 Rooke and Schnell, ―The King‘s Children,‖ 388.
73 Niagara Mail, 17 November 1869.
74. ―Juvenile Immigration,‖ Daily Globe, 2 October 1875, 4.
127
Strata
Lori Jones
industrious citizen.‖75 Similar stories appeared in other newspapers and almost
all generally reflected the attitude that such children ought to be grateful to be
in Canada.
. . . Followed by Criticism
In the 1830s, initial criticism focused on the fact that almost all of the children
sent by the Society had ―been parcelled like so many serfs among our upstart
nobility, to learn to wait at table, to clean boots and shoes, knives and forks,
and perform all the menial offices of scullions.‖76 There was also
consternation that the children had been placed almost exclusively in the
service of the members of the Toronto Committee.77
By the late nineteenth century, there was an increasingly negative tone
to news stories written about the child labourers. In spite of a general rejection
of Doyle‘s 1874 report, the report nevertheless fostered a major negative shift
in perceptions about the juvenile emigration movement. At the same time, an
increase in poor immigrants led Canadians to resent the idea that their country
was used as a dumping ground for what they considered to be Britain‘s
underclass.78 However, it was only after a series of scandals and tragedies
involving the children—including criminal charges, suicides, and the apparent
murder of one boy—that opposition to the movement became widespread.79
There was a growing belief—largely instigated and fostered by the media—
that the unregulated importation of children of suspect upbringing was not in
75. ―An Hour with Dr. Barnardo,‖ The Peterborough Examiner, 21 August 1884.
76. Correspondent and Advocate, 25 June 1835.
77. Letter to the Editor, Correspondent and Advocate, 2 July 1835. Neff notes that some
of this consternation may have been due to a misinterpretation of the Society‘s objectives and
to objections about the people with whom the children were placed. Neff, ―Children‘s Friend
Society,‖ 243.
78 Ibid, 75; Wagner, Children of the Empire, 118.
79 Thompson notes that at least one child was sold at an auction. Allan Thompson,
―Time to Accept Canada‘s Role with Home Children,‖ Toronto Star, 28 August 2010, L7. See
also LAC, RG18, RCMP, ser. B-1, vols. 1284, 1400, and 1427, which address various criminal
activities attributed to ―Barnardo Boys.‖
128
Strata
Lori Jones
Canada‘s best interests. There was also suspicion that philanthropists profited
from the movement. The Toronto News commented
We have enough orphan and abandoned children in our own
streets to look after. The impudence of a large class of
pseudo-philanthropists who make a trade of shipping outcast
children from England to Canada. . . was well exemplified in
the remarks of one. . . who had the cheek to contend that
more immigration was desirable.80
Six months later, The Globe echoed the sentiments, stating that ―waifs and
inmates of reformatories, refuges, and lodging houses. . . are not the classes
with which to build up a strong nationality.‖81
As the movement grew, so too did the number of reports
commenting on crimes committed by some of the children. In August 1890,
The Globe reported on a special session convened by the Prison Commission
to investigate the work of Dr. Barnardo.82 While the paper provided a detailed
summary of Barnardo‘s explanation of the purpose and benefits of his work, it
ended the article by echoing the comments of a commissioner, who suggested
that the unskilled labour undertaken by the child workers ―put skilled labor
out of work, and condemned the whole system, on the ground that there were
boys enough in Ontario without importing them from England.‖83 The Star
reported that ―the children sent to Canada from England are street waifs and
workhouse paupers, and. . . the professional philanthropists engaged in the
work are largely prompted by mercenary and not charitable motives.‖84 In his
popular analysis of Canadian society, Strangers within our Gates, James S
Woodsworth commented that although British immigrants were desirable, the
80. Toronto News, 6 May 1884.
81. The Globe, 10 September 1884.
82. ―The Prison Commission,‖ The Globe, 5 August 1890, 5.
83. Ibid.
84. ―Child Emigration to Canada,‖ The Star, 18 April 1891.
129
Strata
Lori Jones
imported children ―from such surroundings with inherited tendencies to evil
are a very doubtful acquisition to Canada. . . . we would not refuse to help the
needy. But we must express the fear that any large immigration of this class
must lead to the degeneration of our Canadian people.‖85
The prejudices promulgated by the media were further vocalised by
trade unions. The Globe reported on the 1885 annual meeting of the Trades
and Labour Council, which declared its
most earnest protest against the allowance of the movement.
The very large numbers of strong, healthy children. . . in
[Canada‘s] orphan asylums, children‘s homes, etc., are living
evidence. . . that if ‗good homes‘ are to be found for orphan
children in this country, there are unfortunately many more
of them. . . than can be provided for by the demand. . . [we
predict] the Reformatory as the most likely ‗home‘ for a large
number of these [imported] children.86
The Council then denounced the government‘s encouragement of poor
immigrants, both adults and children, who would compete against Canadians
for jobs.87 The Trades and Labour Congress of Canada later stated that
Canada had become ―a dumping ground for the refuse of the highways,
byways and vice haunts of the great cities – waifs, strays, and the children of
vicious and criminal tendencies, antecedents, and environments.‖88 The
85. James S. Woodsworth, Strangers Within Our Gates: Or, Coming Canadians (Toronto:
F. C. Stephenson, 1909), 61.
86. ―Vigorous Protest against Importation of Pauper Children,‖ The Globe, 19 January,
1885, 3.
87. ―Trades and Labour Council: Report of the Legislative Committee,‖ The Globe, 23
June, 1885, 2.
88. D. J. O‘Donoghue, Trades and Labour Congress of Canada, 1895, quoted in
Rooke and Schnell, ―The King's Children,‖ 387. Similar reports were published by other labour
papers and the Ontario Department of Agriculture. Even the Social Service Council of Canada
questioned ―the eugenic effects of bringing in thousands of boys and girls, a considerable
portion of which have sprung from stock, which, whatever else may be said of it, was no able to
130
Strata
Lori Jones
groups‘ objections were based largely on a mistaken belief that child labour
would drive down wages and that after their farm indentures, the children
would move to cities and compete for urban jobs. However, farm families
taking in child labourers generally could not afford adult labour and the
unskilled children posed little threat to skilled labourers.89
Although some newspapers attempted to provide a balanced view of
the juvenile immigration movement, the children faced ongoing ostracism and
criticism.90 Government ministers received letters complaining about them.91
By the 1920s, the Canadian Council on Child Welfare, under the leadership of
Charlotte Whitton, was collecting and publicising sensationalistic statistics
from asylums, jails, health clinics, and reformatories to demonstrate that the
child emigrants
failed the test of desirable immigrants on every score. As the
dregs of British society, their fares underwritten by charity
and government subsidy, their placement in rural Canada a
payment for their poverty and dependence, and without a
commitment to the land, these children and youths had no
redeeming qualities.92
That the Canadian Council on Child Welfare played such a leading role in
criticizing the juvenile immigration movement seems at first glance to be
based on an increasing acceptance of the concept and importance of
childhood. The decades prior to the 1920s had seen the emergence of child
protection laws and child welfare practices in Canada, and certainly these laws
and practices were instrumental in finally bringing an end to the movement.
hold its own in the stern competition of the motherland.‖ Rooke and Schnell provide a detailed
account of these articles in ―The King‘s Children.‖
89. Wagner, Children of the Empire, 135
90. See, for example, ―The Barnardo Boys: Interesting Conversation with the
Canadian Agent,‖ The Globe, 27 October 1894, 4.
91. For example, see LAC, RG76, Immigration, ser. I-A-1, vol. 311, reel C-7861.
92. Harper, ―Cossar‘s Colonists,‖ 49.
131
Strata
Lori Jones
However, this is insufficient to explain the derogatory attacks, as they were
targeted not at the juvenile immigration movement itself, but at the poor
immigrant children directly.93 Instead of embracing the emigrated children
within the broader confines of childhood, the campaign instead embraced
eugenics to claim that the children were morally, socially, and physically
defective. Criticism of the juvenile immigration movement in fact ―united. . .
disparate groups as trade unions, women‘s organizations, sheriffs, country
doctors, and exponents of Canadian child-saving.‖94 In the end, the criticism
was so ubiquitous that many imported children chose not to mention their
history as adults.
IV. Life Experiences
It is estimated that approximately one-third of the children brought into
Canada as labourers were well-received and humanely treated and some were
adopted. The majority, however, ―were exploited, neglected, defrauded, or
mistreated.‖95 For example, the suicides of three juvenile emigrants in the
1920s were highly publicised in the newspapers, not only as examples of the
inadequate placement and supervisory policies but as examples of child
immigrants being unprepared for life in Canada.96 The death of one child in
1895—and his mistress subsequent acquittal on manslaughter charges—was
used by the press to highlight the deficiencies of the children being
imported.97
In The Home Children, Phyllis Harrison published stories from more
93. Rooke and Schnell, ―Imperial Philanthropy,‖ 69.
94. Ibid, 58.
95. Rooke and Schnell, ―The King‘s Children,‖ 388-89.
96. Ibid, 407.
97. For example, The Globe reported ―It is expected that the defence will take the
ground that young Green was diseased and unhealthy, and evidence will also be offered
showing the previous good character of Miss Findlay.‖ ―The Barnardo Boy Green,‖ The Globe,
18 November 1895, 3.
132
Strata
Lori Jones
than one hundred children imported between 1871 and 1930.98 To those
memoires can be added many more, including the following that has been
extracted from the official and personal papers of one imported child
labourer:
Winifred was not yet 6 years old when she was admitted to
the Barnardo home in Essex in 1903 with her 3 year old
brother Frank. Her two half-brothers had been admitted
seven months earlier. Her father had died from pneumonia
the previous year. Her mother, who worked as a charwoman,
was unable to support her five children. She had tried to get
outdoor relief, but because her youngest children were
illegitimate, had been refused. The children arrived at
Barnardo‘s by horse-drawn wagon, carrying all of their
belongings in a single small bag. Winifred‘s intake report
noted that ―the children have been much neglected and practically lived
in the streets. During the past six months, the mother has had the
greatest difficulty procuring food. . . and the mother and her children
appeared insufficiently clothed and fed. . . Their furniture has been sold
by degrees. . . ‖ Although the Barnardo home offered to take
Winifred and her brother in temporarily, she was immediately
placed in a Girls Village Home, and then transferred to foster
parents where she remained for three years. In July 1907 she
was sent to Canada. Within a week of her arrival, she was
placed on a farm in Port Perry, Ontario. Over the next eight
years she was moved to seven different homes, most often at
the request of the homeowners because she was considered
to be rude, naughty, too young, too old, not tidy enough, or
not smart enough. In one home she was sexually assaulted, in
another she was worked like a slave, in yet another she was
98. Harrison, The Home Children (Winnipeg: Watson & Dwyer, 1979).
133
Strata
Lori Jones
deemed not worthy of the amount that the homeowners paid
to keep her, so they sent her away. She was allowed to go to
school only until the third grade. Regular monitoring reports
commented on her clothing, cleanliness, appearance, and
attitude, but little about the conditions under which she lived
or worked. The homeowners‘ thoughts about her suitability
and habits are noted, but nothing is said about Winifred‘s
feelings or how she was being treated. Although she was able
to reconnect with her three brothers – one in Canada, one in
South Africa, and a third in Australia – she never again saw
her mother or the baby who had stayed behind in England.
By the time she turned nineteen, Winifred had been working
for wages in low-paying jobs for two years, was attending
business college, and was planning to be married – sight
unseen – to another former Barnardo child. Doing so was
something that she rued for the rest of her life.99
Conclusion
Between the 1830s and 1940s, more than 100,000 children were imported into
Canada through the juvenile immigration movement and apprenticed or
indentured shortly after their arrival. They were valued more for their labour
than for their existence as children.100 Had they stayed in Britain, most were
too young to leave school under that country‘s compulsory schooling laws.101
Even for those children who were placed in good and loving homes,
the general prejudice that prevailed against the ―Home Children‖—an epithet
that had pejorative connotations—did little to make them feel welcome or
part of Canadian society. As adults, the majority of these children remained
99. David W. Anderson, ―Winifred Frost‘s Story,‖ (Painted Post, NY: unpublished
manuscript); Barnardo, file ACS/KF/RECNO (London: unpublished records).
100. Rooke and Schnell, ―The King‘s Children,‖ 397.
101. Parr, Labouring Children, 11.
134
Strata
Lori Jones
and became settled in Canada. However, the work that philanthropic
organisations and individuals did, removing British slum children and sending
them to rural Canada for their own good, was controversial at the time and
remained so until it ended.102
It is estimated that twelve percent of people living in Canada today
are descendants of these imported child labourers. On November 16, 2009,
Canadian Immigration Minister Jason Kenney issued a statement that Canada
would not apologize to child migrants, stating
[there‘s] no need for Canada to apologize for abuse and
exploitation suffered by thousands of poor children shipped
here from Britain starting in the 19th century . . . the issue
has not been on the radar screen here. . . we are taking
measures to recognize that sad period, but there is, I think,
limited public interest in official government apologies for
everything that‘s ever been unfortunate or [a] tragic event in
our history.103
Less than one month after Kenney‘s statement, Member of Parliament Phil
McColeman (Brant, Ontario) introduced a private member's bill in the House
of Commons encouraging the proclamation of 2010 as year of the British
Home Child. The bill was passed and in September 2010, Canada Post issued
a stamp to commemorate the significance of the declaration. That this
previously ignored chapter in Canada‘s immigration history has now been
recognised is perhaps little consolation to those who have not survived to see
it. For their descendents, however, understanding the contributions made by
these children, in mind, body, and spirit to the growth of Canada—both
willingly and unwillingly—is important for defining who we are as individuals
and as a country.
102. Knowles, Strangers at Our Gates, 72.
103. ―Canadians Not Interested in ‗Home Children‘ Apology: Minister,‖ The Star, 16
November 2009, 3.
135
Strata
Lori Jones
Lori Jones est une étudiante de l‘Université d‘Ottawa à la maîtrise en histoire
avec une spécialisation en études médiévales et de la Renaissance. Elle a
complété son baccalauréat en histoire et en politique à l‘Université Trent et sa
maîtrise en affaires internationales à la Norman Paterson School of
International Affairs de l‘Université Carleton. Ses recherches portent de
manière générale sur les maladies infectieuses au cours de l‘époque médiévale
et au début des temps modernes en Grande-Bretagne et plus spécifiquement,
sur les concepts et les réactions sociales à la « contagion ».
Lori Jones is an MA student in history at the University of Ottawa, with a
specialization in medieval and Renaissance studies. She has an honours BA in
history and politics from Trent University and an MA in international affairs
from the Norman Paterson School of International Affairs at Carleton
University. Her current research focuses on infectious diseases in medieval and
early modern Britain generally, and specifically concepts of and social reactions
to ―contagion.‖
136
Comptes rendu
Book Reviews
————————————————
Lynn Abrams, Oral History Theory (Oxon: Routledge, 2010). 214 pp.
ISBN 0-415-42755-X (pbk), $42.00.
In her new book, Oral History Theory, Lynn Abrams has successfully created a
user-friendly guide to the practical application of theory. Abrams, an
experienced University of Glasgow oral historian, defines oral history as a
method of research which is distinct from other historical endeavors. What
sets it apart is its collaborative approach; the researcher instigates and leads
interviews and from these interactions historical documents are created. The
historian‘s involvement in the production of historical data creates possibilities
for new lines of historical inquiry, such as studying individuals or groups
whose experiences have not previously been documented, but the oral
historian‘s method also brings with it unique difficulties. Unlike other sources
an historian might use, each interview is the result of a dialogue between the
interviewer and interviewee. Moreover, the social structure of the interview
and the culture of each participant dramatically affect the content and
performance of the interviewee‘s narrative. Abrams synthesizes the theories
that explain the complex interplay of these factors using practical examples to
illustrate theory and demonstrating ways in which theory improves
methodology and the analysis of oral history data.
The book was developed as a result of Abrams‘ need for a textbook
that united oral history theory and practice when she taught a course on that
subject. The course was offered to undergraduate students at Glasgow
University, and the book‘s informal style is suited to the intended student
audience. Abrams writes with clarity, demystifying theoretical terms within the
text and providing a glossary for quick reference. She draws on the work of
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
the field‘s leading experts, such as Allessandro Portelli, Paul Thompson,
Michael Frisch, Julie Cruickshank and Valerie Yow, to present models of how
oral history theory has been used in different contexts. She explores the
development of work in the field by using examples of recent projects by
other historians working in Britain, Europe, Africa and Canada, describing
how theory has changed in response to practical considerations,
interdisciplinary influences and cultural discourses. As such, her book helps
students grasp the utility of oral history theory by not simply presenting it as
theory, but by also demonstrating its practical uses.
The book begins with an introduction to the history of oral history
methodology. It describes the four common steps in the process: the original
interview, recording of the interview, transcription and interpretation of the
interview material. Abrams points out the many layers of interaction that
occur within the interview: between the interviewee himself/herself, between
the interviewer and interviewee, and between participants and their culture(s).
She explains the need for accurate transcriptions of interviews and explores
both sides of the argument for maintaining a narrator‘s linguistic
idiosyncrasies. One side of this argument states that precise transcription is
necessary in order to retain the speaker‘s rhythms of speech, dialects and
silences, while the other side claims that the most important need is to convey
the speaker‘s meaning. Abrams argues that it is possible to strike a balance
between meaning and detailed transcription, and she illustrates this balance
with examples from her own interviews with Shetland Islanders, whose
vocabulary and accent can be almost incomprehensible to outsiders. Abrams
demonstrates that without some editing on the historian‘s part a speaker‘s
meaning can be lost to the general readership. She concludes that while speech
patterns are important, the ultimate aim of the historian should be to present
the speaker‘s meaning; she does however acknowledge that the search for the
narrator‘s meaning is not a simple task. Abrams explains that oral history
theory helps historians decode data, enabling an understanding of the links
between individual and general narratives, between personal and public
experience, and between the past and the present.
138
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
Abrams goes on to explain how oral history differs from conventional
historical methodologies, which rely on written sources for data. She discusses
orality, narrative, subjectivity, memory, mutability, collaboration and personal
testimony, referring to these aspects as the peculiarities of oral history,
describes how each influences the interview process, and offers some practical
advice: historians, Abrams states, must approach their interviews with an
openness that permits the interviewees to influence the direction of the
project. This openness must carry through to the publishing stage where
Abrams advises oral historians to include a description of themselves and their
goals for the project as well as to include the questions they put to the
interviewees. Narratives should not be neatly edited to further the historian‘s
argument. Rather, Abrams applauds a study published by Allesandro Portelli
in which the author consistently privileges the names and narratives of the
interviewees over the historian by, for example, listing the names of those
interviewed at the beginning of the book, and beginning each chapter with a
long story told by one of the interviewees. In these ways, Abrams argues,
historical works can create more satisfactory representations of their oral
sources.
The remainder of the book explores theoretical topics relevant to oral
history in depth: theories of self, subjectivity and inter-subjectivity, memory,
narrative, performance, and power and empowerment. In each case, Abrams
defines the theoretical term under examination, explains its relationship to oral
history practice, and describes the turning points in oral history method when
this theory was applied. She then explains the theory in detail, after which she
provides useful examples of oral history projects that have used each theory.
Most importantly, she describes how each theory has been successful or has
introduced challenges within the projects, and outlines her recommendations
on how best to apply the theory in question. This section is particularly
instructive for neophytes in the field and Abrams demonstrates her mastery of
the material by the way she clarifies each lesson. She acknowledges the
evolving nature of oral history theory while providing the reader with practical
guidance on how to approach their own work.
139
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
Criticisms of Oral History Theory are minor and relate mainly to the
book‘s format, though the book would be improved by the inclusion of charts
and models that outline the theories being discussed. Models would reinforce
the ideas being presented and aid students who are visual learners.
This book is an excellent reference tool for oral history students. It
provides useful insight at all stages of an oral history project. Abrams‘ clear
explanations of terminology and theories allow novices to better understand
when to apply particular theories. She illuminates theory with dozens of recent
examples, demonstrating how particular theories have been employed in oral
history projects around the world. Abrams combines her masterful grasp of
theory with practical advice to guide others. Anyone who is interested in
understanding the complexities of the oral history theory would benefit from
reading this book.
KIM MADSEN
MA Student, University of Victoria
🍁🍁🍁
Donica Belisle, Retail Nation: Department Stores and the Making of
Modern Canada (Vancouver: UBC Press, 2011). 308 pp. ISBN
9780774819473 (hc), $85.00.
Donica Belisle, an Assistant Professor of Gender and Women‘s Studies at
Athabasca University, is perhaps best known for her previous Marxistfeminist works, in article form, addressing Canadian consumerism in the earlyto mid-twentieth century. Her recent book Retail Nation: Department Stores and
the Making of Modern Canada does not veer from this path and serves as an
assemblage of these previous arguments, taking into consideration a wide
variety of companies, including Eaton‘s, the Hudson‘s Bay Company,
Spencer‘s, Sears, Morgan‘s, Simpson‘s, Woodward‘s and Dupuis Frères for her
present analysis. In keeping with her previous works, Belisle emphasizes the
140
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
various paternalistic and exploitative relationships found within the realm of
early-twentieth century Canadian department stores, while emphasizing those
cases in which these relationships were compromised.
With this work Belisle hopes to push beyond the ‗consumer-asduped‘ versus the ‗consumer-as-active‘ paradigm that has dominated the
landscape of Canadian consumer historiography; instead, she aims to present a
portrait of early twentieth century Canadian consumerism as a complex web
of business, state, and consumer interests, claiming that this approach ―avoids
simplistic depictions of consumers as either passive or liberated‖ (6). This type
of approach has already been introduced in the work of both Joy Parr and
Cynthia Wright, who also advocate a multi-faceted approach to studying
Canadian consumerism in the twentieth century. Belisle‘s study points
specifically to major retail stores—here, Eaton‘s and the Hudson‘s Bay
Company get the most attention—as epicentres of Canadian modernity during
the late nineteenth- and early-twentieth centuries; in this she draws inspiration
from American historian Susan Porter Benson who focuses on American
department stores during this same period and their important role as sites
where issues such as modernity and gender were negotiated.1 Making
Canadian department stores even more striking as examples was, as Belisle
emphasizes, their activity in all three aspects of the marketplace: production,
distribution, and consumption. Retail Nation builds on the work of Parr and
Wright who focus on post-Second World War consumerism as well as race
and gender issues within Canadian consumption, respectively, but differs in
that it points to the importance and centrality of mass retail during an earlier
era and its influence on the development of Canadian society in later years,
especially when concerning notions of gender and nationhood. As such,
although Belisle‘s work is somewhat repetitive in the international context,
drawing heavily from American consumer historiography, it serves as a valid
1. Susan Porter Benson, Counter Cultures: Saleswomen, Managers, and Customers in
American Department Stores, 1890–1940 (Urbana and Chicago, IL: University of Illinois Press,
1986).
141
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
contribution to the Canadian discussion on historical consumerism, touching
on issues that have not yet been addressed in the Canadian context.
Divided into seven chapters, Retail Nation covers much ground, with
paternalism emerging as the pervading theme throughout most of the work.
Belisle begins her book by arguing for the importance of department stores in
Canadian consumer development; this is contrasted with the British and
American examples wherein department stores held a far less prominent
position. In an effort to explain the uniqueness of the Canadian experience,
Belisle traces the post-1896 geographic and demographic evolution of
Canadian settlement during and after the Sifton era, drawing parallels between
the changes in consumer demand that occurred during this period and the
simultaneous growth and expansion of Canadian department stores. Most
interesting are the correlations Belisle reveals between stores, their
commodities, and their consumers on one hand, and a burgeoning national
identity on the other. As such, Belisle argues that department stores were
largely responsible for creating an ideal Canadian identity and for defining
―modern Canadian life as consumerist, middle class, and white‖ (7).
Chapters three through six focus heavily on the themes of
paternalism and emotional labour, drawing heavily on both Belisle‘s previous
work and that of American Historian Arlie Hochschild on flight attendants in
the post-war decades, and the gradual commercialization of private feelings.2
Drawing attention to the inherent paternalism in relationships between male
managers and both female salespersons and female customers, again drawing
from the work of Benson, Belisle highlights the gender hierarchies that
permeated department stores during this period. Contemporary assumptions
of female intellectual inferiority and the belief that women belonged within
2. See Donica Belisle, ―A Labour Force For the Consumer Century:
Commodification in Canada‘s Largest Department Stores, 1890-1940,‖ Labour / Le Travail, 58,
2 (Fall 2006): 107–44; Donica Belisle, ―Negotiating Paternalism: Women and Canada‘s Largest
Department Store, 1890–1940,‖ Journal Of Women‘s History, 19, 1 (Spring 2007): 58–81; and Arlie
Hoschild, The Managed Heart: The Commercialization of Human Feeling (Berkeley and Los Angeles:
University of California Press, 1985).
142
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
the domestic sphere translated into a system where women rarely achieved
management roles. Of course, these pro-male environments were further
buttressed by racial and class hierarchies that were reinforced in a similar
manner. Belisle accuses early department stores of using promotional
materials to portray ―First Nations people as pre-modern, Africans and Asians
as labourers, and whites as consumers. . . [thus] department stores suggested
how mass merchandising helped to establish modern European civilization.
This political economy drew upon imperialist legacies in its construction of
race hierarchies‖ (69). It is in these discussions that Belisle is at her strongest,
relying on her extensive research on the issue of paternalism, and revealing the
more oppressive aspects of early twentieth century Canadian retail.
Belisle‘s final chapter analyzes the response of those who were critical
of department stores and the rise of mass retail. For many Canadians, the
hedonistic consumerism associated with the monumental shrines of shopping
was viewed as a danger to the purity and wholesomeness of white women.
Other social reformers and labour leaders viewed the mass retailers as a threat
to the development and sustainability of small, local businesses. Belisle argues
that while these critiques were prominent and widespread, they were never
able to significantly hold back the development and growth of big stores. This
was largely due to the critics‘ failure to address and find a competitive solution
to the convenience and selection offered by retailers like Eaton‘s or the HBC,
and their failure to gain government support in their struggle against Big
Business.
Retail Nation offers readers an extensive look at the rise and
development of mass retail culture in early twentieth-century Canada. While
self-admittedly the author focuses mostly on Anglophone examples, insight
into the Francophone experience is still offered with examples from DupuisFrères, the major French-Canadian department store of this era. Belisle‘s
analysis is also heavily weighted towards the feminist perspective and the
exploitation of women as both labourers and consumers within the sphere of
department stores; as such, issues of masculinity and mass retail culture tend
to fall to the wayside. There is much work to be done in this area in the future,
143
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
including further investigation into the links between mass retail and earlytwentieth century constructions of masculinity. In terms of analysis, Retail
Nation draws heavily from American historiography on consumer culture, and
from Belisle‘s own previously published articles, making it somewhat
redundant both in terms of a contribution to the international historiography
of consumerism during this period and those contributions already made by
Belisle to the Canadian historiography on this subject. However, to those
readers unfamiliar with her work, Belisle has presented a useful contribution
to the Canadian discussion, while offering a thorough explanation of existing
historiography, both within and outside the Canadian context. To those
readers who are familiar with Belisle‘s previous work, Retail Nation offers
similar arguments but with much greater detail and more in depth analysis.
Additionally, Belisle has successfully engaged with pre-existing works
throughout her book, making Retail Nation an excellent introductory work for
any student or scholar interested in consumer history both within a Canadian
or an international context.
MADELEINE KLOSKE
PhD Candidate, University of Ottawa
🍁🍁🍁
Nancy Christie et Michael Gauvreau, Christian Churches and Their
Peoples, 1840–1965: A Social History of Religion in Canada (Toronto,
University of Toronto Press, 2010). 232 pp.
ISBN
9780802089496
(cloth), 65,00$; 9780802086327 (pbk), 27,95$.
Cet ouvrage a été rédigé par deux auteurs : Michael Gauvreau, professeur en
histoire de l‘Université McMaster et Nancy Christie, détentrice de la bourse
Eakin en études canadiennes de l‘Université McGill pour l‘année 2010–2011.
Gauvreau et Christie sont tous deux des spécialistes de l‘histoire de la religion
au Canada anglais. Partageant plusieurs publications communes, ils se sont
144
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
réunis de nouveau afin de présenter l‘histoire religieuse du Canada à un public
non spécialiste dans le cadre de la collection Themes in Canadian History.
Publié en 2010 aux presses de l‘Université de Toronto, Christian
Churches and Their Peoples, 1840–1965 : A Social History of Religion in Canada a
pour objectif de faire la synthèse des transformations historiques des mœurs
religieuses au sein des confessions chrétiennes dominantes au Canada. En
entamant un survol historique de 125 années, les auteurs tentent de démontrer
les convergences et les divergences entre les branches du christianisme à
travers la longue durée. La période étudiée recense l‘histoire canadienne de
l‘Acte d‘union jusqu‘à la Révolution tranquille, présentant une histoire
institutionnelle qui suit largement le développement de l‘État. L‘ouvrage
enrichit l‘historiographie en tentant de présenter une interprétation accessible
de l‘histoire du christianisme au Canada à un public qui possède une
connaissance générale de la matière.
La thèse présentée par les auteurs est que, contrairement aux
interprétations historiques qui conçoivent les églises comme étant contraires à
l‘avancement de la modernité, les églises chrétiennes au Canada ont été au
cœur du processus de modernisation de l‘État. Selon Gauvreau et Christie, les
églises chrétiennes sont les acteurs qui diffusent le plus les valeurs dites «
libérales » de la modernité au sein de la société et des institutions politiques qui
la dominent. La sous-thèse des auteurs, peut-être plus importante que la thèse
dominante de l‘ouvrage, est qu‘il n‘y a pas de long déclin de la vie religieuse ni
de laïcisation progressive qui peut être perçu au cours de l'histoire canadienne.
Le culte religieux chez les Canadiens est plutôt marqué par la transformation
des relations entre les institutions religieuses et les croyants.
Afin d‘appuyer les deux arguments présentés ci-dessus, les auteurs
entament une analyse chronologique de l‘histoire des églises chrétiennes au
pays, débutant par la période coloniale et se terminant vers le milieu des
années 1960. Gauvreau et Christie parsèment leur argumentation d‘éléments
d‘analyse conformes aux méthodes de l‘histoire sociale, c‘est-à-dire des
portraits d‘individus croyants, qui servent d‘idéal type de la pratique religieuse
au Canada. En abordant le sujet du christianisme, les auteurs tentent de rendre
145
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
les ressemblances entre les pratiques laïques du protestantisme et du
catholicisme romain plus explicites. Pour ce faire, les auteurs résument
l‘histoire de l‘épanouissement de diverses Églises protestantes (anglicanes,
méthodistes, presbytériennes) ainsi que de l‘Église catholique. Néanmoins, la
synthèse historique manque de rigueur méthodologique, par l‘absence de
division précise entre les chapitres.
Soutenant la thèse qui présente l‘Église en tant qu‘agent diffuseur des
valeurs de la modernité, les auteurs débutent en soulignant le grand pluralisme
religieux au Canada durant les années 1800. Selon eux, ce pluralisme permet
aux gens de jouir d‘un haut niveau de liberté puisqu'ils sont en mesure
d‘adhérer à la secte religieuse de leur choix. Cependant, la liberté de pratique
du culte se limite souvent à cette décision. La fin des années 1800, sous un
État canadien uni, témoigne d‘une ouverture des églises vers la société
canadienne dans un contexte d‘interdépendance. Les citoyens ont besoin des
églises pour régir leurs vies sociales, et les églises ont besoin de paroissiens
pour assurer leur survie économique.
La majorité de l‘ouvrage aborde le 19e siècle à travers des concepts
tels que la citoyenneté chrétienne au Canada ainsi que l‘influence de cette
idéologie au sein des missions religieuses se retrouvant sur des terres éloignées
des centres urbains. Toujours dans l‘esprit d‘un travail de recherche
appartenant aux branches de l‘histoire sociale, les auteurs tentent de mettre en
valeur l‘idée que la diffusion du christianisme n‘aurait pas pu avoir lieu sans
l‘appui direct et continu de chefs autochtones. Cet exemple se plie moins bien
aux deux thèses avancées si l‘on considère la relation de pouvoir défavorable
aux Autochtones. Quoique la conversion au catholicisme ne pouvait être
coercitive dans le sens de l‘emploi de la violence, l‘emploi de connaissances
scientifiques, dont l‘habileté de prévoir des éclipses lunaires ou solaires afin de
paraître plus près de Dieu était une méthode employée afin d‘inciter la
conversion. Cette réalité est certes loin des valeurs de liberté et
d‘autodétermination de la modernité.
L‘argumentation des auteurs est difficile à suivre, car la synthèse
historique est rédigée sans ligne temporelle ou thématique précise. De plus, en
146
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
conceptualisant le Canada français comme une entité politique et sociale
restreinte aux frontières de ce que devint la province du Québec, les auteurs
négligent un aspect clé de la pluralité religieuse du Canada en y excluant la
diaspora francophone. Non seulement ne parle-t-on pas des francophones
hors Québec, on ne les prend aucunement en compte malgré leur lourde
influence sur l‘histoire de l‘Église et de l‘État, notamment dans le cadre du
conflit du Règlement 17. De plus, les auteurs n‘ont aucunement considéré
l‘analyse religieuse intimement liée au discours de l‘ethnogenèse de la nation
canadienne-française, ni de sa mission providentielle. Ces deux éléments sont
pourtant essentiels à la compréhension historique de l‘identité religieuse au
Canada auprès des laïcs.
La qualité d‘analyse en histoire sociale se perd dans le texte, car
l‘argumentation s‘oriente surtout vers l‘analyse institutionnelle. Les quelques
exemples concrets de dissension entre la réalité des laïcs et la volonté des
églises ne suffisent pas pour distinguer le livre de Gauvreau et Christie des
autres synthèses d‘histoire religieuse au Canada. Les éléments de preuve
soutenant les thèses avancées ci-dessus sont pauvres pour la première et un
peu plus riches pour la seconde, quoique l‘on ne retrouve pas ici de grandes
nouveautés historiographiques. En effet, le déclin de la participation religieuse
active au Canada est un phénomène qui s‘est produit rapidement, quoiqu'il ne
soit pas linéaire. L‘originalité de l‘ouvrage analysé aujourd‘hui est plutôt dans
sa comparaison des mœurs catholiques et protestantes dans un sens large, qui
se rejoignent jusqu‘au déclin de la participation religieuse durant les années
1960.
ÉMILIE PIGEON
Étudiante au doctorat, Université York
🍁🍁🍁
147
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
Jonathon Glassman, War of Words, War of Stones: Racial Thought and
Violence in Colonial Zanzibar (Bloomington: Indiana University Press,
2011). 414 pp. ISBN 978-0-253-35585-0 (cloth), $80.00; 978-0-253-22280-0
(pbk), $27.95.
Jonathon Glassman‘s War of Words, War of Stones makes some important
revisions to many long-held assumptions in the discipline of African history.
Most notably, he is sceptical that we can trace the origins of racial thought to a
single source: colonialism. He rightly points out that it is difficult to prove the
claim that racial thought has one unique (Western) source, especially since, as
evidenced in the Zanzibar case, racial thought was pervasive enough that racebaiting was present and politically effective in the 1960s—the focal point of
his study—even among sections of the population that had had little direct
contact with British institutions and intellectual traditions.
Glassman calls for a rethinking of the origins of race. He demands we
question our unsubstantiated conviction that racism originates in the West,
urging us to engage more fully with the intellectual histories of other peoples
and to challenge our assumptions regarding the dominance of Western ideas
in Africa in the colonial and post-colonial eras. Importantly, he distinguishes
between racism and racial thought, arguing that an exclusive focus on ‗racism,‘
i.e. the modern Western form of race thinking, masks the more globally
widespread tendency for people to think racially; that is, to categorize
humanity into different groups to which we attribute certain characteristics
and ―rankings.‖
The move towards global historical studies of race is very exciting—
and overdue. While Glassman is careful to underscore the fact that it is not his
intention to apologize for the horrors of white supremacy, he convincingly
demonstrates that racial categories existed in Zanzibari thought prior to
British colonialism through a close reading of local textual sources. He does
not believe that entirely foreign ideas, with no parallels or analogues in local
ideational repertories, could move local Zanzibaris to the point of murdering
their neighbours, as they did in the pogroms of 1964. I am inclined to agree.
148
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
My own experiences in Tibetan and Malian communities has brought to my
attention that racial thought is widespread, even among peoples never
subjected to European colonialism (as in the case of Tibet).
While this evidence is purely anecdotal and based on personal social
interactions and observations, unfavourable representations of Africans
appear widespread in Tibetan communities, and ‗being black‘ seems often
linked to notions of danger, evil, and repugnance. Meanwhile in Mali,
racialized discursive constructions of southern ‗blacks‘ and northern ‗whites‘
have been used to accomplish various kinds of social and political ‗work‘ in
the Sahel for centuries, as Bruce Hall has detailed in his recent book, A History
of Race in Muslim West Africa, 1600–1960 (2011), and these continue to hold
sway. Having been in Mali during the Arab Spring, I was indeed struck by the
way people in Bamako constructed a sense of racialized difference between
themselves and the North African Arabs flooding their television screens. If
we are to further our understanding of the ways different societies construct
their ‗others‘ and how they conceive of their relationships across communities,
examining the diverse historical roots of racial thinking is essential.
Glassman also endorses recent trends in intellectual history which
qualify the power of colonial ideas to shape the minds of subjects, and which
highlight the dynamic agency of African thinkers who engage critically with
new ideas, rather than passively sponging them up. Citing Philip Zachernuk‘s
Colonial Subjects (2000) and Kwame Anthony Appiah‘s In My Father‘s House
(1993) as examples of this approach, he calls for a new intellectual history
which abandons the notion of indigenous and colonial thought ‗mixing,‘ as
though they were two separate, well defined spheres. He argues African
intellectuals—colonially educated or otherwise—talked to each other more
than they engaged with colonists. Furthermore, their race thinking was more
influential for the general public than any kind of pure, Western, imported
ideas. He strongly challenges the assumption that racial thinking was
borrowed from the West, and as such he is one of the first in the field to take
the insights of this new perspective in intellectual history and apply them to
questions of race.
149
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
Glassman also makes a strong argument against those who posit
―ethnic tension‖ as the cause of ethnic or communal violence, suggesting
there is nothing inevitable about tension being resolved in bloodshed. To
illustrate his point, he notes that such tensions are long-lasting and pervasive,
whereas violence is sporadic and short; why it arises in certain contexts and
not others cannot be explained by simply citing ―tensions.‖ He further argues
that such ethnic violence as the 1964 pogroms in Zanzibar was not
―instrumental,‖ i.e. strictly aimed at redistributing access to resources, because
it was ―ritualistic and theatrical‖ (19), involving such atrocities as the
mutilation of corpses. He suggests instead that we must understand it within
the context of an intellectual history of discourses about violence and
victimhood. When we do this, we have to look beyond the role of the elite to
understand how and why their rhetoric appealed to common people. How did
they use ideas that were consonant with ordinary people—ideas already in use
or modified from some pre-existing discourse—to draw people in and
motivate them to kill? In this respect, the book reflects works such as Carolyn
Hamilton‘s Terrific Majesty: The Powers of Shaka Zulu and the Limits of Historical
Invention (1998) and Thomas Spear‘s article ―Neo-Traditionalism and the
Limits of Invention in British Colonial Africa‖ (2003), which argue that
compelling discourses must draw primarily from the repertory of ideas current
in the society at hand, if they are to do the social ‗work‘ their creators intend
for them.
This is an important book. It is a welcome addition to the latest wave
of intellectual history, challenging the conventional wisdom that tells us how
European ideas overran the minds of Africans. It is certainly one of the first
efforts in this field to apply these insights to race thinking, and to put racial
thought in a comparative global context. A truly admirable piece of
scholarship, it seems that Glassman takes little on the authority of others;
whether thinking about the origins of the idea of race, the nature of Swahili
identity, the causes of ethnic violence, or the effects of colonialism, he
challenges received ideas and presents well-measured arguments devoid of
oversimplifications or polemics. Beyond its value as a contribution to studies
150
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
of race and ethnic violence, this book is an excellent example of history that
asks probing questions and offers thoughtful answers.
ROBERT NATHAN
PhD Student, Dalhousie University
🍁🍁🍁
Andrew Rossos, Macedonia and the Macedonians: A History (Stanford:
Hoover Institution Press, 2008). 366 pp. ISBN 978-0-8179-4881-8 (cloth),
$40.00; 978-0-8179-4882-5 (pbk), $25.00.
With the debate over the official appellation of Macedonia having reached two
decades of impasse and with national questions reemerging in the Balkans,
Andrew Rossos‘ Macedonia and the Macedonians: A History is a timely arrival. The
‗Macedonia‘ this book addresses is that of ‗Geographic Macedonia,‘ which
encompasses the territory of contemporary northern Greece, southwestern
Bulgaria, and all of the current Republic of Macedonia.3 Geographically,
Macedonia is the crossroads of the southern Balkans, a location that has made
it home to a myriad of peoples over the centuries. Rossos focuses on the
history of the Slav-speaking Macedonians who, the author argues, developed
as a distinct nationality in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
This nationality was the historical precursor to the ‗Macedonianism‘
championed by Socialist Yugoslavia in 1944, and it is the national identity of
the majority of the population in the Republic of Macedonia today. In telling
the history of the Slav-speaking Macedonians, Rossos‘ book is an affirmation
of their presence in a history and a historical process which remains
3. The state is constitutionally known as the Republic of Macedonia. Due to
objections by Greece, it was admitted to the United Nations temporarily as the Former
Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia in April of 1993. While several states have chosen to use the
constitutional name in bilateral relations, others use the temporary designation, which is also
used in multilateral settings. As of July 2011, the dispute over the name remains unresolved.
151
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
controversial and very much contested. In accordance with terminology in the
book being discussed, this review will refer to the Slav-speaking Macedonians
as ‗Macedonians‘ to avoid taking a stand on the sensitive name debate.
Andrew Rossos, a professor of history at the University of Toronto,
has published extensively on the Balkans, including the book Russia and the
Balkans: Inter-Balkans Rivalries and Russian Foreign Policy 1908-1914.
Internationally educated with a doctorate from Stanford, he has more recently
written a number of articles and chapters on Macedonian nationalism and
identity as well as on the breakup of Yugoslavia. For Professor Rossos, there
is a personal stake in this history, as he was born in what is now Northern
Greece, a region thousands of Macedonians fled during the Greek Civil War.
It remains a region affected by its painful past and the politics of
dispossession.
While the book surveys some 2,500 years of history, it focuses
primarily on the past two hundred years. Parts of the book build on Rossos‘
previous articles on the existence of the Macedonian nationality, and on the
secondary literature, in which scholars such as Victor Freidman and Victor
Roudometof have discussed the presence of Macedonianism in the nineteenth
and early twentieth centuries. Rossos argues that there was historical
continuity between the documented accounts of Macedonianism. After the
events of 1878 left Macedonia to be contested in a propaganda war between
its neighbours, the voices of mid-nineteenth intellectuals coalesced into a
nationalistic feeling. This collective sentiment was further galvanized with the
emergence of the Internal Macedonian Revolutionary Organization (IMRO) in
the 1890s. IMRO‘s failed Ilinden Uprising of 1903 was the watershed event
that solidified the Macedonian national movement, which—the author
contends—continued to struggle against foreign rule until 1944. Rossos argues
that the Macedonian national movement developed through the same phases
of inquiry, agitation, and popular movement as the other Balkan national
movements. The difference was that Macedonians lacked the support of state
institutions and had to struggle against multiple foes, chiefly their neighbours
Bulgaria, Serbia, and Greece. Tito‘s championing of Macedonianism in 1944
152
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
was mutually beneficial. It added the Macedonians to the ranks of the
Yugoslav partisans while realizing a Macedonian state within federal
Yugoslavia.
While it is perfectly legitimate to acknowledge the existence of
Macedonianism, arguing that there was a continuum between the documented
cases is somewhat problematic. Several observers in the late Ottoman period
wrote of the chameleonic nature of the Christians in Ottoman Macedonia,
who changed their nationality to suit their needs and to survive. Furthermore,
some of those who professed Macedonian nationality later adopted another
identity. Such was the case with Krste Misirkov, who, after professing
unambiguous Macedonianism in his 1903 publication On the Macedonian
Matters, later professed to be a Bulgarian. Regarding this and other such
incidences, Rossos writes that people like Misirkov were hiding their true
Macedonian identity when they claimed to be Bulgarian, Greek, or Serbian.
This is a hard point to disprove, but it is also a difficult matter to categorically
substantiate, given the lack of any ongoing record of documentation which
consistently affirms the presence of a distinctly Macedonian identity prior to
1944. While Rossos is quick to problematize claims that the Slav-speaking
Macedonians were Greeks, Bulgarians, or Serbians, he is less inclined to
subject Macedonianism to the same critical scrutiny. The prevailing
uncertainty and instability of the last Ottoman decades and the first half of the
twentieth century made national identity highly subject to politics and
circumstance. Keith Brown has shown this in his work on the 1903 Ilinden
Uprising, The Past in Question: Modern Macedonia and the Uncertainties of Nation,
which discusses the difficulties of drawing definitive conclusions about
national identity and the details of historical events. Identities could overlap or
be interpreted in different ways by different observers.
Rossos‘ book could benefit from more discussion of the complexities
and nuances of identity and from greater use of the recent historiography by
scholars who have accessed the Ottoman and Bulgarian archives, such as M.
Şükrü Hanioğlu, Ipek K. Yosmaoğlu, and James Frusetta. What is more,
speaking of the ―territorial integrity‖ of Macedonia in reference to all of
153
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
Geographic Macedonia is bound to alarm Greeks and Bulgarians. Indeed, this
is precisely the sort of language that has stoked Greek fears of irredentism by
its northern neighbour—an enduring stumbling block in the negotiations
between Athens and Skopje.
Nevertheless, while Rossos asserts Macedonianism, his book is not a
polemic. He provides historical advocacy for the Macedonians; however, he
does not go so far as to make grandiose claims of exclusive blood connections
between them and the people of Alexander‘s Ancient Macedon. This will not
please the neo-nationalists in Skopje, who are casting their lineage back far
beyond nineteenth-century awakenings. Nor will the hard-line nationalists
likely enjoy reading Rossos‘ call for more trust and respect to be shown
towards the country‘s Albanian minority.
Macedonia and the Macedonians: A History is a well-written and accessible
survey which will be helpful for those seeking to understand one of Europe‘s
least known nations and a useful reference for this historically complex region.
As Professor Rossos rightly points out, failure to recognize and respect the
Macedonians will only foster regional instability in the future. Despite its
shortcomings, this book is a welcome addition to the historiography of the
region.
JULIAN BROOKS
PhD Student, Simon Fraser University
🍁🍁🍁
Andrew Smith, British Businessmen and Canadian Confederation:
Constitution Making in an Era of Anglo-Globalization (Montreal and
Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2008). 240 pp. ISBN
9780773534056 (cloth). $95.00.
Reflecting on Canada‘s past and the antecedents to Confederation give rise to
the examination of the factors that coalesced to give birth to this great nation
154
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
144 years ago on Prince Edward Island. Canadian Confederation has been
extensively examined by historians, many of whom focus on the passing of
the British North America Act as an inevitable step in the natural progression
of Canada. Some argue that the spectre of the American Civil War galvanized
colonial officials into action, while others attributed the momentous occasion
as a convenient solution to political deadlock in the colonies. However,
beginning in 1995, scholars such as Ged Martin began revising the
interpretation of Canadian Confederation, arguing that the British were not
merely onlookers but rather played a prominent role in Confederation.
Adding to the revisionist approach initiated by Martin, Andrew
Smith‘s well researched and judiciously argued monograph, British Businessmen
and Confederation: Constitution Making in an Era of Anglo-Globalization, seeks to
revise traditional interpretations while also striving to correct Martin‘s
omission of the crucial role that British business played in driving the
Confederation agenda. Smith deviates significantly from the traditional
historiography by placing financial motivations at the forefront of the debate.
Smith significantly enhances our interpretation and understanding of Canada‘s
political genesis by examining the previously underdeveloped facet of finance.
By 1867, Confederation was not a novel concept. Smith argues that
the idea of federation had been suggested in the past but only really began to
pick up steam after British businessmen began rallying behind it for the sake
of their enterprises. As British North American investments began failing in
the 1860s, British investors responded to the crisis by favouring the idea of
politically united colonies. A federated British North America coupled with
close ties to the Empire would ensure the continued inflow of capital to
Canada, which would be imperative to keep investments afloat. Even within
British North America, Smith reveals how ―many of the Fathers of
Confederation were personally involved in projects that were dependent on
the continued inflow of British capital‖ (18). Indeed, he argues that the
Fathers of Confederation and their business associates in the British
investment community were self-interested and rational economic actors. For
example, George-Etienne Cartier was the chief solicitor for the Grand Trunk
155
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
Railroad, John A. Macdonald was gainfully employed by the British-controlled
Trust and Loan Company of Upper Canada, and Charles Tupper had a vested
interest in the development of the Halifax-Québec Railway. Therefore, in
addition to their political motivations, the Fathers of Confederation also had
financial incentives, much like their British counterparts—they needed the
union to ensure a continued transatlantic flow of capital in order to guarantee
the survival and long-term viability of their investments.
In this respect, Smith takes a more materialist approach to the subject
matter. While materialist perspectives are not novel and more often prosaic
than laudatory accounts, in many instances they are subverted in favour of a
more celebratory narrative. Smith‘s approach helps us situate Canadian
Confederation in a more accessible paradigm for understanding why it
occurred and why it happened when it did.
In addition to contributing to the revisionist writing on Confederation,
Smith‘s study is also important because it brings something to the table for
imperial economic historians. Specifically, he develops a Canadian perspective
to Peter J. Cain and Anthony G. Hopkins‘ much heralded idea of the
‗gentlemanly capitalist‘ theory of imperial development. Their thesis posits
that the financiers at the centre of London, the City, used their clout to run
the British Empire for their own purposes at the expense of other interests,
namely London‘s industrialists.
Elaborating on Cain and Hopkins, Smith divides the British
businessmen and investors into two groups—the Liverpool school, comprised
mainly of industrialists, and the London School, comprised mainly of
investors. Championed by Richard Cobden and John Bright, the Liverpool
group consisted of classic liberals, and opposed state intervention in the
economy as well as costly imperialist expansion. Conversely, the London
faction favoured state intervention in the colonies. Smith refines the Cain and
Hopkins thesis by noting that pro-Imperial financiers in the City were not
entirely antithetical to members of the manufacturing sector. Through his
inclusion of Manchester manufacturer Edward Watkins, Smith demonstrates
how investors from the City and industrialists could have similar aims.
156
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
Consequently, this reveals that the ‗gentlemanly capitalist‘ model is not as
black and white as Cain and Hopkins purport. Smith illustrates this through
his discussion of how investors from the City and manufacturers to the north
of London combined their resources and formed the British North American
Association in January 1862 to hasten the idea of political union across the
Atlantic for financial purposes. While it is important for us not to lose sight of
the political achievements that the Fathers of Confederation had made, Smith
wants his readers to remember that British and Canadian capitalists were
equally important to the founding of Canada.
Nevertheless, Smith‘s account is lacking attention towards the issue of
globalization. While the word is emblazoned in the book‘s subtitle, the issue is
dealt with only minimally in the concluding chapters and leaves the reader
with some unresolved issues.
In the end, it is hard to disagree with Smith‘s opening sentence and
ultimately his treatise—―British businessmen played a crucial role in the
achievement of Canadian Confederation‖ (3). Given the outcome of the
discussions on 1 July 1867 as well as Smith‘s brilliant study of the key players
involved, British Businessmen is a successful account of Canadian Confederation
that is sure to turn heads for quite some time. As historical studies shift
further away from inward-looking accounts, Smith provides his Canadian
peers with a gem on how to carry out an excellent transnational study. This
book is a recommended read for economic historians in general and Canadian
scholars in particular. Future discussions of Canadian Confederation would
not be convincing without an inclusion of Smith‘s groundbreaking work.
Prior to embarking on his journey to pen British Businessmen, Smith
completed his PhD at the University of Western Ontario. He has since served
as an assistant professor of history at Laurentian University. In 2010, he took
157
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
his talents to England where he is currently a senior lecturer in history in the
Department of International Studies and Social Science at Coventry
University.
MICHAEL COMMITO
PhD Candidate, McMaster University
158
Strata
Comptes rendu / Book Reviews
S
trata
Revue d‘histoire des étudiants diplômés de l‘Université d‘Ottawa
University of Ottawa Graduate Student History Review
160