debt management consumer credit

Transcription

debt management consumer credit
Annual Report
Association des Banques et Banquiers, Luxembourg
The Luxembourg Bankers’ Association
Luxemburger Bankenvereinigung
www.abbl.lu
Table of contents
46

50

Retail banking study

The Retail and Commercial Banking Group
55
Social rented housing
Message from the Chairman

3
European instutions 2013/2014: From the
end of a cycle to new beginnings

10
Financial Market Regulation
Transparency and comparability of banking
fees, bank account switching and access to a
basic bank account
Mortgages

Financial education
14
Credit register
Financial market regulations
Mortgage brokerage
Post-trade regulation
Consumer credit
Fund matters
Lobbying via the European Banking Federation
Global regulations
Other matters
Banking Union

Banking Supervision
21
Banking Technologies and Payments
SEPA / Payments
CRR / CRD IV
LEI - Legal Entity Identifier
Structural reform of the EU banking sector
New ICT technologies – new opportunities
FATCA

Legal and Tax
27
Innovation and finance
XBRL
EU and national financial transaction taxes
Social Affairs & Employers’ Representation
Evolutions in the field of international exchange
of information in tax matters
Draft bill of law 6545 on the reform of social
dialogue and the elections of staff delegations in
November 2013
Consumer protection: New CSSF rules on
alternative dispute resolution
Draft bill of law 6555 on the reform of the procedure of reintegration of workers
New European legislation on mortgage lending
Liaison Committee for Social Affairs
Modernisation of Luxembourg bankruptcy law
Diversity
AGDL

The Private Banking Group, Luxembourg
1
42
Sectorial agreement on moral harassment at
work
Private Banking Group, Luxembourg: A
combination of strategic factors
Renegotiation of the collective bargaining
agreement
The Private Banking Group, Luxembourg in
2013
Survey on the social situation in the banking
sector for the year 2012
Events

65
IFBL

66
Luxembourg for Finance

68
Appendices

73
Chairman’s message
Ernst Wilhelm Contzen
Chairman of the ABBL
The past year has been a very eventful year for this country, its financial sector and
for us at the ABBL. In many respects, 2013 must be regarded as a watershed year
for the Luxembourg financial centre, and particularly the banking industry. A number
of decisions taken in Luxembourg and in Brussels in 2013 will lastingly change the
way we do business and, by extension, the shape of our financial centre.
At European level, the crisis has triggered a whole avalanche of new regulations.
Indeed, no other sector has ever faced such an in-depth regulatory upheaval in such
a short time in modern history.
Probably the biggest outcome of the EU’s regulatory zeal is the banking union, which
was given concrete shape last year with the decision to create a Single Supervisory
Mechanism (SSM). I don’t think it is an exaggeration to call it a game changer.
Roughly half of the banks present in Luxembourg will fall under ECB supervision,
most of them as subsidiaries of larger European groups. The ECB will take over
supervisory responsibility in November 2014. In practical terms, this means that we
will no longer have national sovereignty as far as our supervision is concerned. This
is, of course, quite a change for a financial sector that was used to directly deal
with a strict but also pro-active regulator that very much understood the day-to-day
business realities of the sector. But the ECB is the next best choice for us, since
the institution has the clear advantage of being independent and thus being free of
the political power play that so marred the previous home/host system within the
European Banking Authority.
Like our colleagues at the European Banking Federation, we fully support the idea
of a banking union. Importantly, we call for a full banking union which, besides the
SSM, encompasses a single deposit guarantee and a single resolution mechanism.
It is only with a real banking union in place that we can increase financial stability as
well as confidence in Europe’s banks by breaking the doom loop tying weak banks
to weak member states. The deposit guarantee scheme still has quite a way to go,
as there is no political consensus at this point. But the single resolution mecha-
3
nism (SRM) is starting to take shape, especially now that a compromise between
the EU Parliament and Council positions has been found, which takes into account
certain terms by the Parliament, including an earlier mutualisation of the resolution
fund and less influence by Member States in decisions to close banks. In any case,
the SRM will carry a price tag. It will be financed ex-ante with a target level for the
Single Resolution Fund set to 1% covered deposits held at the banks of participating Member States, to be reached over 8 years. This represents a total of 55 billion
Euros for SSM-participating banks. As far as the use of the SRM is concerned, the
ABBL believes that, as a general rule, the Single Resolution Fund should not absorb
losses in the place of shareholders and creditors, who must first contribute through
the bail-in mechanism.
44
Another important dossier for Luxembourg remains CRD IV, in particularly its liquidity provisions. Luxembourg’s traditionally highly liquid banks, specialising in wealth
management and fund administration, have always been important liquidity providers
for their groups. While Basel III is calibrated to deal with big cross-border groups and
thus an application at the consolidated level only, prudential rules in the EU apply
both at consolidated level and at solo level. This is why the liquidity waiver, which
provides an exemption from fulfilling the Liquidity Coverage Ratio at solo level, is so
important for Luxembourg banks. Yet we should not take the waivers for granted!
They come with strings attached: The group must establish contracts of liquidity
support to the subsidiary that can be triggered without
material practical or legal impediment, and superviIt is only with a real banking
sors must reach a joint agreement on the organisation
union in place that we can
of liquidity risk across the group as well as distribution
increase financial stability
of Liquid Assets across the group’s entities. For SSMas well as confidence in
participating banks the ECB will take this decision alone,
Europe’s banks by breaking
and the ABBL calls for a consistent and flexible apthe doom loop tying weak
proach by the ECB.
banks to weak member
states.
Beyond the regulatory upheaval, the financial crisis also accelerated the trend towards tax transparency. The automatic exchange of information (AEOI) has gained
a particular momentum in 2013 and is now on the verge of becoming the single
global standard. An intermediary step towards a global standard was taken on 20
March 2014 with the agreement in the European Council to extend the scope of
the European Savings Directive. While I welcome the efforts to have a single global
standard, I nevertheless insist on the fact that the EU Commission must move forward swiftly in order to ensure that concerned non-EU countries continue to apply
measures equivalent to those in the in the EU. I am therefore particularly pleased that
our Prime Minister was given guarantees by his European colleagues that negotiations would be concluded by the end of the year.
Furthermore, the ABBL, like the European Banking Federation, calls for a single,
consistent and coherent framework for the automatic exchange of information to be
put in place. EU and OECD approaches must be aligned in order to avoid a costly
and burdensome proliferation of different AEOI standards and deadlines of entry into
force. This global standard must be manageable for the financial industry from a dayto-day operational point of view.
With the imminent adoption of the automatic exchange of information as an international standard by all major financial centres, the AEOI has simply become a
business reality for Luxembourg private banks and is no longer a political issue or a
question of competiveness.
Nevertheless, the switch will not be a painless exercise. While some banks will be
affected more than others, overall the private banking landscape in Luxembourg
will fundamentally change. We will see considerable restructuring over the next few
years and, I fear, potential job losses. The staff profile required to deal with the new
client base we seek to attract is not necessarily the same as the client advisers and
relationship managers that were used to servicing our traditional clientele. This is why
5
further training and constant skill updates will be a crucial element of the successful
adaptation process of any bank.
The silver lining in all of this is that the sector has been changing for quite some time.
We have indeed successfully managed to attract a larger share of entrepreneurial
and high-net-worth clients. From a sword of Damocles hanging over our private
banking industry, the automatic exchange of information has become an opportunity
to pursue and attract new business. In this new era of transparency, our banks will
need to step up their efforts and take a more pro-active approach both in terms of
client acquisition and the services on offer.
66
The ABBL will continue to play its role in accompanying its members in the current
transition process.
Yet the transition process on the financial centre does not only concern the private
banking sector, even if this sector gets a lot of the headlines. Our financial centre
is changing at every level. In a globalised world marked by increased regulatory
harmonisation, there is little room left for carving out sovereign niches. Our future
clearly lies in providing an added value proposition for clients through our unique
competencies and expertise. If I had to sum up Luxembourg’s unique selling proposition in one word it would be “cross-border”. We have become the first port of call
for any company or client seeking to do business
or invest in and out of Europe or the Euro Area.
Whether we are talking about private banking,
In this new era of
investment funds, reinsurance or the listing of intransparency, our banks will
ternational bonds, Luxembourg is the undisputed
need to step up their efforts
cross-border financial centre of the Euro Area.
and take a more pro-active
The increased interest of non-European groups
approach both in terms of
in setting up their European headquarters or
client acquisition and the
business hubs in Luxembourg is testimony to this
services on offer.
fact. In 2013, for the first time in over a decade,
we saw strong growth in the number of banks established in Luxembourg: between
December 2012 and December 2013 there was thus a net increase of 6 banks (from
141 to 147), including the establishment of a third Chinese bank and the first Latvian
bank on the financial centre. This trend is likely to continue in the coming years, as
more and more financial institutions seek to gain a foothold in Europe and in the Euro
Area to expand their business.
I am particularly pleased about the success we have had in recent times – in no
small part thanks to the promotion efforts of Luxembourg for Finance – in attracting
the international Renminbi business to Luxembourg. In terms of offshore Renminbi
business we are truly playing in the big league now: we have Europe’s largest pool
of RMB deposits, RMB loan portfolio and trade finance volume, we are the leading
RMB fund centre in Europe and we are the N°2 Euro country for RMB payments
value. This success is proof of the forward-looking attitude of this financial centre, its
ability to monitor international developments and take change in its stride.
If anything, 2013 has reminded us that change is indeed the only constant. The
Greek philosopher Heraclitus famously wrote that “no man ever steps in the same
river twice, for it’s not the same river and he’s not the same man.” It is a lesson our
financial centre has learned a long time ago. As the world around us changes, we
must remain aware of the fact that what worked yesterday may not necessarily work
tomorrow. We therefore need to continue to adapt to new regulatory realities and not
be afraid to change, to challenge and question ourselves and to innovate wherever
we can.
Luxembourg has what it takes to continue to play a leading role as a global financial
centre.
Luxembourg, 21 March 2014
7
ABBL Management Board
Jean-Jacques Rommes
Serge de Cillia
Marc Hemmerling
Member of the
Management Board
Member of the
Management Board
Catherine Bourin
Member of the
Management Board
Chief Executive Officer
Head of the
Management Board
9
1.
10
E
uropean institutions 2013 / 2014:
from the end of a cycle to new beginnings
Like the year’s seasons, politics is a matter of
cycles. This holds true for the European Union as
well. The current mandate started with the 2009
European elections that voted in the European
Parliament followed by the appointment of the
European Commission and will come to an end
with this year’s European elections. To continue
the metaphor, 2013 and the beginning of 2014
are the European Winter while Spring and the
new seasonal year will start on 25 May with the
elections for the future European Parliament.
The European seasonal Winter is a time of closing dossiers that have not yet been finalised,
among which most prominently the vast project
of the banking union. The first leg of the latter,
two legislative proposals creating the Single
Supervision Mechanism (SSM), has been successfully adopted in 2013. The second leg, the
Single Resolution Mechanism (SRM), has made
major progress in 2013 and will most likely be
adopted in the first quarter of 2014. A pre-condition for the adoption of the SRM has been an
agreement on the Bank Recovery and Resolution
Directive (BRRD) and the Deposit Guarantee
Schemes Directive (DGSD), both found in
December 2013. The last major legislative
proposal in the supervision area is the reform of
the bank structure where the Commission has
adopted its legislative proposal in January 2014
and the Council and the European Parliament
are to start work this year in order to adopt the
regulation most likely in 2015.
In financial markets, an agreement on MiFID/R
has been found in January 2014 and the legislation is ready for adoption later in the year. On the
Packaged Retail Investment Products (PRIPs)
proposal and on UCITS V separate agreements
have been found in the European Parliament
respectively in the Council, with the inter-institutional negotiations left as a last round before the
end of the parliamentary term. The proposal for
a regulation on Money Market Funds (MMF) is
currently going through the European Parliament
with a first reading expected before the elections,
but the Council will start its work only later in the
first half of 2014.
In the tax field, 2013 has been a crucial year
and 2014 will be even more so. Regarding the
Savings Tax Directive, Luxembourg decided to
adopt the automatic exchange of information by
2015 and agreed to a negotiation mandate with
third countries. With these major changes and
the issue being discussed at the most senior
levels of the European Council, 2014 could well
be the year that the new directive is adopted.
The issue is scheduled for the February ECOFIN
meeting. A similar hot potato, the revision of the
directive on administrative cooperation in tax
matters, could see major progress and possibly an adoption in 2014. This holds also true
for the financial transaction tax that is currently
discussed by 11 Member States in the restricted
circle of the enhanced cooperation procedure.
Luxembourg does not take part, but will be
strongly impacted. With a new found determination in Germany with its new government in
place, a rumoured Franco-German joint initiative,
a Commissioner whose term is coming to an
end later this year and Greece – a member of the
eleven – holding the Council presidency for the
first 6 months of the year, major developments
can be expected.
In the world of payments, a first reading position
of the European Parliament on the revision of the
Payment Services Directive and the Regulation
on multilateral interchange fees is likely to be
agreed in February 2014.
On the retail banking side, the mortgage credit
directive has been adopted by the Council in
January 2014 concluding the legislative process.
Also, on the proposal on bank accounts, the institutions are gearing for trialogues to be finalised
before the European elections.
The 4th anti-money laundering directive is still
being negotiated separately, respectively in
the European Parliament and in the Council.
Although an agreement in a single reading via
successful trialogue meetings between the
institutions is far from being certain, at least a
vote on the European Parliament position in one
of its last plenary sessions is rather likely. On the
European Account Preservation Order, the institutions are aiming at an agreement in trialogue
to be voted at the last plenary session of the
European Parliament in April 2014 and a subsequent Council meeting.
As the end of the political cycle nears, a renewal
of the key institutions is in the air and omnipresent in the minds of decision makers, interest representatives and consultants. For Luxembourg,
such a renewal has come early with a change in
11
government and new representatives in major
Council formations and the European Council.
2
11
2
The key dates for the renewal of the European
Parliament are 22-25 May 2014, the days of
European elections in the 28 Member States.
The composition of the European Parliament is
currently expected to undergo profound changes
with fringe parties expected to make a strong
breakthrough while more traditional parties, in
particular the liberals, expected to loose ground.
Such a scenario is bound to have an impact on
majorities in the European Parliament and the
voting behaviour of MEPs in particular on financial services.
One of the first tasks of the European Parliament
will be to confirm a candidate nominated by the
Council for the position of Commission president
followed by hearings of the other Commissioner
candidates and a confirmation of the whole
college. This process is scheduled to take up all
summer and part of autumn.
As a conclusion, 2014 will turn around the
renewal of the European Parliament and the
European Commission. With a new government
in December 2013, Luxembourg will see its
political representatives at EU level completely renewed in less than a year and a potential shift in
the orientation of the European Parliament. The
ABBL will adapt to the new realities and continue
representing its members’ interests in this new
environment.
Brussels, 29 January 2014
EU Representative Office
Louise Marcellin
Aurélie Cassou
Research Assistant
European Affairs
Antoine Kremer
Adviser to the
Management Board
Head of European Affairs
2.
Financial Market Regulation
Financial Market Regulations
4
11
4
Since the end of the 10 first years of the new millennium, everybody has been talking about the
regulatory tsunami or avalanche. Yet contrary to
the speed of an avalanche in the Alps, the speed
at which the regulatory avalanche develops is
bound by the political process of preparing and
agreeing to regulations at the European level. It
seems that now the avalanche of financial market
regulation is about to hit the financial village.
Indeed, 2013 was a year of finalisation or quasifinalisation of regulations.
The Market Abuse Regulation is now nearly approved. The text, split into two parts consisting of
a regulation (approved in September 2013) and a
directive (regarding sanctions, not yet approved),
has already seen a consultation from ESMA on
the technical measures. Major features will include the confirmation of a broader scope, both
in terms of products and platforms subject to the
regulation, and notably the commodities markets
and OTC derivatives will now fall under the market abuse rules. They will also cover new areas,
regulatory wise, which include specific limitations
to high frequency trading and “manipulation” of
benchmarks. Interestingly, many details are to
be addressed in the level 2 rules and all will be
pending until the finalisation of MiFID II.
Speaking of MiFID II, the Lithuanian Presidency
of the EU Council for the second half of 2013
did an incredible job by nearly finalising the text
before the end of its mandate. Were it not for one
or two areas (notably the definition of the scope
of inclusion of commodities and third country
relationships) they may actually have succeeded
in finalising the text. Concretely, what is now key is
agenda management: As expected the text was
politically finalised in mid January, while technical
work and cleansing of the text lasted until midFebruary, this then led to a plenary vote in the
European Parliament about one month later in
March and, given the requirement to translate the
text into every official language before publication
in the Official Journal of the EU, an additional delay
of 4 to 5 months must be added, which brings us
somewhere between July and September 2014.
Added to this, there will be an additional 20 days
and a delay of implementation of about 24 months
(maybe even up to 30 months, something not yet
decided at the time of writing). MiFID II will then
be live and operational for financial intermediaries
after the summer of 2016 at the earliest. There are
several areas of attention. Besides the discussions on inducements and the classification of
products, there is the MiFIR part with the organisation of markets and the extended role of the SI
or Systematic Internaliser. The latter activity will be
extended to all products (not only shares) and will
trigger a requirement to disclose pre- and posttrade information on all products that an institution trades, including bonds, derivatives… In this
respect, the role of ESMA will be key both for the
precise definition of what an SI is and the definition
of the threshold above which these obligations are
triggered. A a new area of attention will also be the
composition and qualification of board members
and the limitation of their mandates outside of the
group. One may expect that, after lengthy discussions at level one, level two, i.e. the technical part,
will also be extremely intense.
On the market side, we also find what is probably one of the worst examples of a regulation:
EMIR. EMIR has been applicable since 16 August
2012, but it was only this year that implementing
rules were partially issued and it was only on 7
November 2013 that ESMA confirmed the licence
for 6 Trade Repositories on which all institutions (financial or not) will have to report, from 12
February 2014 onwards, all their trades (besides
some FX derivatives whose status is even less
clear), backload the trades that remained open
after the launch of EMIR in 2012 and, after a turf
war between ESMA and the EU Commission,
also report exchange traded derivatives, instead
of benefiting from an exemption to report for one
year. At the time of writing, December 2013, no
one knows yet which will be the licenced clearing
houses, nor which products may be subject to the
clearing obligation, but in the meantime reporting of all derivatives is mandatory. What shall be
done with non-clearable products, i.e. pure OTC
derivatives, is another major concern. IOSCO
and BIS issued standards regarding non-centrally
cleared derivatives but they are not legally binding.
It is thus not clear what institutions have to do with
them, nor with the EMIR requirement to post collateral margins in bilateral trades.
A last concern regarding EMIR is the requirement (from an ESMA Q&A) to use the LEI or the
Legal Entity Identifier (the number imposed by the
G20 to identify legal entities’ counterparties all
over the globe). Luxembourg had the possibility
to be equipped with a numbering agent by early
Autumn 2013, but for no apparent reason the
authority in charge has failed to deliver the licence
in time. This is a frustrating story for one of the
world’s largest financial centres, whose entities
now have to apply through other jurisdictions
(USA or Germany). This situation should be normalised in 2014, but only after reporting becomes
compulsory. Having said all this, and to conclude,
we can consider that if EMIR will probably not be
fully in force until well into 2014 (once both products and clearing houses will be licenced), one of
the most amazing things is that EMIR will supposedly have to be revised in 2015 already.
15
What happens to regulations that are not finalised before
the EU elections?
16
2014 will be a special year. At the end of May there will be EU elections, the
European Parliament will be disbanded, the EU Commission will be dismissed
and both institutions will be reappointed, in July for the Parliament and beginning of November for the Commission. Without entering into crystal ball predictions on who will be Commissioner in charge of what or which EU party will
lead the new Parliament, it may be interesting to discuss what would happen
to regulations not finalised in time for the elections. There are a variety of cases.
The most straight-forward case is that of regulations for which there is manifestly no time for a vote. The consequence will be that the entire dossier will be
handed over to the new institutions with a new rapporteur in Parliament and
(most likely) a new Commissioner. This raises several questions: will the dossier
still be a priority and will the rapporteur follow the same lines as the previous
one if he/she is not re-elected? The most problematic dossiers will probably
be the ones that are a bit late, but not too late. Let’s assume, for instance, that
there is an agreement in Trilogue on PRIPs (the Packaged Retail Investment
Products Regulation) but that it is only reached in mid-March. Given that the last
week for a vote will be at the end of April and that at least one month is required
between the political approval in Trilogue and a plenary vote in Parliament (for
technical/legal reasons) and that there will be many dossiers to vote on at the
same time, it may turn out that the text will be voted without these technical
checks in order to save time, so that in the new set up with the new Parliament
a “confirmation” vote will have to take place to introduce the potential changes
that the EU Commission’s legal services will have identified, raising the same
questions as before: what happens if Parliament has largely changed?
Post-trade regulation
There are two noticeable elements for 2013.
The first is the continuous progress made in the
deployment of the ECB’s T2S project (Target 2
Securities). The waves of implementation have
been determined and the project is becoming
increasingly more concrete. On the ground, what
is visible is that many markets have decided to
move to T+2 for settlement ahead of the regulation and ahead of T2S (most will by October
2014) and that, even if T2S has led markets
to improve harmonisation of procedures (a
great benefit of the work done by the ECB), the
number of trades has been decreasing since the
start of the project (contrary to the original rosy
assumptions) to such a degree that the viability
of the project in its current form is questionable.
Now that T2S becomes increasingly a reality, new points of view emerge on the matter,
which were already identified in 2 white papers
published by the ABBL. They mostly concern
collateral: first, there is the possibility to mobilise
collateral across borders on a single platform and
secondly there is the fact that collateralisation
will be on flow instead of stocks, which will most
likely free up some space as each transaction
may in the end be the collateral, or part of it, for
ensuing transactions.
The other important dossier in the post-trade
universe at EU level is the CSD-R (Central
Securities Depository Regulation) which after
much stop and go has finally been approved at
the last ECOFIN of 2013, thanks to the good
work done by the Lithuanian Presidency. The key
features are the recognition of CSDs with a banking licence (subject to some specific constraints
and additional rules), the unfortunate introduction
of settlement discipline rules and the mandatory
convergence to the T+2 standard for settlement.
ESMA has some work ahead of it in 2014 to
develop technical standards in time before the
live date of the regulation and the start of the first
migration wave under T2S.
Fund matters
In the area of funds 2013 saw three milestones.
The first was the live date for the AIFMD in July:
a lot of debates, a lot of expectation and still a lot
of work to be done in terms of industry guidelines
and practices. On that front, the Luxembourg
financial centre is well placed with the ABBL-ALFI
Depositary Bank Forum, where experts are able
17
to exchange their points of view and practices,
notably through guidelines, such as those on
oversight duties published in July 2013 and more
to come in 2014.
18
A second milestone is the near finalisation of
the UCITS V rules. The EU Parliament has a
text since July 2013, the EU Council since
November, so that the Trilogue can start and is
likely to progress smoothly given the few differences between the different versions of the texts
among the 3 EU Institutions. There are 3 parts:
one on remuneration, one on sanctions for failing
to comply and one on depositary institutions.
On this latter subject, the idea was convergence
plus with the AIFMD standards, and ahead of
the Trilogue one may consider that as achieved.
One may also question the rationale behind the
standards and the few differences of treatment
and responsibilities over assets or, most problematically, the rules regarding the (non-) reuse of
assets.
Although there were other dossiers in the area of
funds, the last milestone worth mentioning here
is the EU Commission’s draft proposal on Money
Market Funds or MMFs, in line with both an
agenda on shadow banking and the communica-
tion on the Fund Regulation of 2012. This project
will regulate MMFs relying on both the UCITS and
AIFMD regulations. A fund may choose its status
and impose additional rules on top of these regulations that are specific to MMFs like maturity
of eligible instruments, scope of instruments or
the requirement to internally rate investments
but bans on MMF rating. The most controversial
part of the regulation is on the differences made
between Variable NAV (net asset value) and
Constant NAV funds. In the case of the latter a
“protection” buffer of 3% is imposed so that in
the rare case of runs the fund is protected by
a coffin of 3% (do not ask where this number
came from). The ABBL sees several issues here:
one may argue that what is bad for MMFs will
mean more deposits at banks, but this is probably a little bit short-sighted since clients benefit
from diversification with MMFs and, in any case,
there are alternatives to MMFs (mostly for large
corporates). One may also legitimately ask why
a fixed 3% for CNAV? In the current environment
of low rates the 3% are tantamount to a death
penalty for CNAV, and it is totally ridiculous once
rates return to more standard levels (which will
inevitably happen): will these 3% really protect
investors? The ABBL proposal would have been
to simplify rules: choose one of either underlying status, AIFMD or UCITS, authorise UCITS
status only for VNAV funds and let AIFs be CNAV
(or choose either option), remove the buffer in
case of problems then force them to convert
to UCITS. The rational being that AIF clients
are, according to AIFMD rules, supposed to be
professional investors and thus the best informed
or most able to seek advise and understand the
products. Our proposal would also have had the
advantage of being simpler and clearer for clients: UCITS MMFs are VNAV and AIF MMFs are
CNAV, not the current mixture of statuses. As this
dossier is only a draft at the EU Commission and
currently only in discussion mode (amendment
phase at the end of 2013) in the Parliament, it
is rather unlikely that it is finalised in time before
the recess in May 2014, something which ECON
discussions in January seem to have confirmed
in the meantime.
Global regulations
2013 has confirmed the increasing importance of
global regulators like IOSCO, FSB or BIS/CPSS,
who felt that with the backing of the G20 they
have more free space to express themselves. In
2013, they were trendsetters in shadow banking,
where they tried to impose haircuts on the reuse
of assets and traceability across the holding
chain, and they issued draft requirements for
the disclosure at the point of sales (for managed financial instruments). As mentioned above
they were also active in producing rules regarding non-centrally cleared OTC derivatives. The
ABBL has been actively following these trends
and was able to participate at the IOSCO annual
conference held in Luxembourg. The ABBL also
proudly hosted the IBFED financial market working group, a global banking association gathering
many of the world’s banking associations (among
others from the USA, Australia, Japan, Canada
and Europe, South Africa). Since October 2013,
the ABBL is member of this group.
19
Banking and Finance
Serge de Cillia
Fabio Mandorino
Economics,
Commercial & Private
Banking
Member of the
Management Board
Gilles Pierre
Adviser to the
Management Board
Head of Banking
Regulation
Benoit Sauvage
Financial Market
Regulation
3.
Banking Supervision
Banking Union

The
magnitude of the exercise within the set
deadline (i.e. October 2014)
Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM)
The SSM now enters into a concrete phase,
where the ECB will take over the supervisory
responsibility of banks located in the Euro area
in November 2014. Prior to this, the ECB will
conduct a comprehensive assessment of the
banking sector, covering the 130 significant banks
identified according to the criteria of the SSM
Regulation (consolidated balance sheet bigger
than EUR 30 billion, etc.): the supervisory risk assessment, the Asset Quality Review (AQR) and the
stress tests.
The Asset Quality Review phase of the
Comprehensive Assessment is expected to start
in late February or early March 2014 with focus
on the selected portfolios, which will represent a
significant part of the risk weighted assets (RWA)
of every banking group (probably exceeding 50%
of total RWA). The Asset Quality Review will mainly
assess the adequate provisioning of credit exposures, the appropriate valuation of collateral and
the valuation of complex and illiquid instruments.
The main concerns of the banking industry as to
the Comprehensive Assessment refer to:
The
potential conflicts between audited figures
and AQR outcomes;
The
consideration of the diversification benefits
of cross-border banking groups;
The
criteria for national discretions and options;
The
communication of results (AQR & stress
tests).

ank Recovery and Resolution Directive
B
(BRRD)
In December 2013, a political agreement was
reached between the European Council and
Parliament on the Bank Recovery and Resolution
Directive (BRRD). This long awaited legislation
bridges the gap between the prudential and financial stability framework.
The Directive establishes a clear mechanism and
common toolkit for banks to plan for and act in
stress situations with emphasis on early intervention and recovery while also putting a framework
in place that would anticipate the worst case scenario of a systemically important bank failure. As a
result, it should help restore confidence in banking
21
supervision to minimise the fall-out from bank failures while providing the foundation for the Single
Resolution Mechanism (SRM) – the counterpart to
the new Single Supervisory Mechanism for euro
area banks and other EU countries, which wish to
opt in. The BRRD is expected to apply to all banks
in all 28 Member States by 2015, while the bail-in,
a regime to hold shareholders and bondholders
accountable for the cost of resolution, will enter
into force in all jurisdictions by January 2016.
22

Single Resolution Mechanism (SRM)
In late December 2013, the Council and the
European Parliament respectively reached an
agreement on their general approach and Report
to negotiate the proposed Single Resolution
Mechanism (SRM). It includes the creation by 1
January 2015 of a Single Resolution Board (SRB)
and of a Single Resolution Fund (SRF).
After the Single Supervisory Mechanism, the
SRM is the logical next step in the Banking Union
process to centralise crisis management for ECB
supervised banks. It will further ensure a consistent application of the recently agreed Bank
Recovery and Resolution framework for banks
within the SSM.
There are many discrepancies between
the Council and EU Parliament’s positions.
According to the latter, a compromise is very
unlikely to be agreed on in the foreseeable future. The Parliament indeed strongly rejects the
Intergovernmental Agreement approach on the
SRM in the Council, on the basis that it undermines the Community Method and the Ordinary
Legislative Procedure.
If the negotiations do not move forward in a constructive manner, the EU Parliament will reserve
its right to put forward for adoption in plenary its
first-reading position on the basis of the ECON
Committee report.

Deposit Guarantee Scheme Directive (DGSD)
On 17 December 2013, a political agreement
was reached by the EU Commission, the EU
Parliament and the EU Council on the recast of
the Deposit Guarantee Scheme Directive (DGSD)
after more than three years of negotiations. For
the first time since the introduction of DGS in
1994, there are financing requirements for DGS in
the Directive. The target level for ex-ante funds of
DGS is 0.8% of covered deposits to be collected
from banks over a 10-year period (which can
be extended by 4 years if there is a substantial
disbursement of DGS funds during the phasing-in
period).
Mandatory
With regard to the initial Commission proposals and the strong negotiating position of the
EU Parliament the final outcome of the recast of
DGSD is seen rather favourable by the ABBL. The
following should be highlighted as positive:
The
Ex-ante
financing has been lowered to 0.8% of
covered deposits over 10 years from the initial
proposal of 1.5% of all eligible deposits;
30%
of contributions are allowed to be made
under the form of payment commitments;
While
a reduction of fast pay-out to 7 days
could not be avoided, a more feasible phasing
in period until 2024 was introduced;
borrowing between DGS schemes
was made only voluntary;
contribution of the DGS to the financing of
resolution has been limited.
Five years after the entry into force of this
Directive, the Commission shall submit a report,
and, if appropriate, a legislative proposal to the
EU Parliament and the EU Council setting out
how DGS operating in the Union may cooperate through a European Scheme to prevent risks
arising from cross-border activities and protect
deposits from such risks.
In the short term, Luxembourg authorities will have
to decide, in collaboration with the AGDL, on the
legal and operational shape of the national DGS.
23
CRR / CRD IV
4
22
4
The CRR / CRD 4 package, implementing the
Basel III agreement, was formally endorsed by
the EU authorities in June 2013, and it has been
applicable since 1 January 2014. The package is
composed of an EU Regulation, encompassing
technical provisions directly applicable to banks
(the Capital Requirement Regulation, the CRR),
and of a Directive defining the organisation of the
supervision (the Capital Requirement Directive,
the CRD).
Unlike the Regulation, the Directive needs to be
enacted into Luxembourg regulation. The CSSF
will thus issue a new CSSF Regulation containing
the Pillar 2 requirements as well as the provisions
regarding the Supervisory Review Process. Other
provisions will be reflected in the law of 5 April
1993 on the financial sector.
In terms of implementation, the main issues at
stake for Luxembourg banks are the impacts
of the SSM on the decision-making process for
granting waivers for the Liquidity Coverage Ratio
and intra-group exemptions for large exposures,
the internal management and coordination of the
CRR / CRD IV project and the consequences
of the new rules on profitability and on banks’
strategy.
As in the past, the ABBL, in collaboration with
the IFBL and Deloitte Luxembourg, has set up
training sessions in order to assist members in
implementing the CRR / CRD IV. Each session
consisted of four modules that could be attended individually: Module 1 on capital requirements
(Pillar 1 solvency ratio, leverage ratio, capital
buffers, etc.), Module 2 on Pillar 2 and internal
governance, Module 3 on counterparty credit
risk, CVA risk and EMIR requirements, Module
4 on the new liquidity rules. The initiative proved
to be quite successful: 6 sessions have been
completed, representing 18 training days in total,
where more than 200 bankers were present.
In October 2013, the ABBL, in collaboration with
the CSSF and ALRiM, also organized a conference on the new CRR/CRD IV rules. A large
audience, consisting of around 200 risk managers, compliance officers, treasurers and other
concerned financial professionals, amply demonstrated that this issue is followed with great
interest by the Luxembourg financial community.
Structural Reform of the EU Banking
Sector
that customer-related transactions should not be
assimilated to trading activities.
Following the conclusions of the High-Level
Expert Group (HLEG) chaired by Erkki Liikanen,
the EU Commission released in 2013 a consultation document on the structural reform of the EU
banking sector. The most significant issue of the
EU Commission consultation touches the mandatory separation of proprietary trading activities
and other significant trading activities, including
the market-making activity, exceeding a certain
threshold. Such activities would be segregated in
a specific legal entity, i.e. the “trading entity”. All
other banking activities are allowed to remain in
the deposit-taking entity, i.e. the “deposit bank”.
On 29 January 2014, the EU Commission tabled
an official proposal articulated around two main
principles :
The structural reform would impact Luxembourg
banks if the definition of trading activities is broad
and if the thresholds for exemption were not adequately calibrated. Potentially, some transactions
performed with our customers (private customers, investment funds, corporate, etc.) could be
eligible for a mandatory separation. The ABBL
has met the EU Commission and has advocated
It is unlikely, however, that the European
Parliament will be able to reach a position on the
proposal during this term due to their substantial
outstanding workload before the elections.

he ban of riskiest activities, i.e. proprietary
T
trading, which is used for speculative purpose and has no link with depositors and real
economy.

he potential separation of risky market activiT
ties other than proprietary trading, where more
responsibility is given to the supervisor. If it is
justified, the supervisor will impose a subsidiarisation of these activities.
25
Legal and Tax
Catherine Bourin
Patrick Gouden
Legal & Compliance
Rüdiger Jung
General Counselor
Member of the
Management Board
Simone Kayser
Consumer Protection
Camille Seillès
Legal & Tax
4.
Legal and Tax
FATCA
2013 has been another busy year when it comes
to FATCA. Major developments included the
release, at the beginning of the year, by the US
Department of the Treasury (US Treasury) and
the US Internal Revenue Service (IRS), of the final
regulations under FATCA (the Final Regulations),
followed in July by a further postponement, by
an additional 6-month period, of several key implementation deadlines. The announcement, by
Minister Frieden, that Luxembourg has chosen
the Model I Intergovernmental Agreement (the
Luxembourg IGA) was another main point of
attention, as was the subsequent negotiation of
the same with the US Treasury.

The final framework materializes
On 17 January 2013, the US Treasury and
the IRS issued final regulations under FATCA,
a document exceeding 500 pages. The Final
Regulations generally follow the guidelines set
forth in proposed regulations issued in February
2012 (the Proposed Regulations), but in the
meantime include many changes that reflect
comments on the Proposed Regulations submitted by industry group participants, bring the final
rules in line with intergovernmental agreements
(IGAs) signed to date, and incorporate some of
the timeline changes announced by the IRS in
Announcement 2012-42 released on 24 October
2012, which provided for a first 6-month postponement of FATCA.
On 12 July 2013, the IRS released Notice
2013-43 providing for a further revision of the
applicable timeline for implementation of the
FATCA requirements, which was postponed, for
the second time within less than a year, by an
additional 6-month period. All in all, as a result of
this timeline revision, FATCA is now to become
effective as of 1 July 2014. Another notable
consequence is that US account reporting will no
longer be required with respect to calendar year
2013, meaning that the first US account reporting under FATCA will be eventually due in 2015
with respect to calendar year 2014.
On 19 August 2013, the IRS finally unveiled its
FATCA Registration Portal, an internet-based
application that Financial Institutions (FIs) may
use, where applicable, to register for FATCA
purposes. FIs were provided with the opportunity
to use the remainder of 2013 to become familiar
with the FATCA Registration Portal.
27
Luxembourg
goes for a Model I IGA
In the context of the then ongoing negotiations
with the US Treasury, Minister Frieden announced, on 21 May 2013, that Luxembourg
has chosen the Model I Intergovernmental
Agreement on FATCA, on par with the other
Member States of the European Union that have
announced to have either signed or initialed an
IGA with the United States to date.
8
22
8
The Luxembourg IGA will provide essentially for
automatic exchange of information between the
Luxembourg and US tax authorities on financial
accounts (i.e. bank accounts, certain insurance
contracts and units in investment funds) held
in Luxembourg by citizens and residents of the
United States. According to our Government,
the aim of this decision is to put Luxembourg’s
relations with the United States in line with a declaration of 10 April 2013 by which Luxembourg
announced that it will introduce, on 1 January
2015 and within the current scope of the EU
Savings Directive (Council Directive 2003/48/
EC), the automatic exchange of information
within the European Union. In the meantime,
the Luxembourg Government made it clear that
Luxembourg wishes to see the same conditions
apply to all competing financial centres1.
Action
points for 2014
Once signed, it is anticipated that the
Luxembourg IGA will be ratified by the
Luxembourg Parliament and that a legislative
implementation package will be adopted in parallel so as to resolve possible conflicts between the
terms of the IGA and current statutory provisions,
notably in the fields of data protection, banking
confidentiality and taxation.
The ABBL has already compiled, and is still in the
process of compiling, guidance notes on FATCA
for use by members. This document can, however, not entirely substitute formal administrative guidance. The ABBL indeed takes the view
that the ratification of the Luxembourg IGA shall
necessarily be accompanied by the release, on
the part of the Luxembourg tax administration,
of additional guidance on the implementation of
FATCA in Luxembourg, an initiative that would
put Luxembourg on par with most, if not all, peer
EU jurisdictions that have signed a Model I IGA
with the United States.
1 http://www.mf.public.lu/actualites/2013/05/facta_210513/index.html
EU and national financial
transaction taxes
The “fair-share taxation” objective is high on the
agenda of policy-makers and appears to be
crystalized in the European Union by the debate
on a Financial Transaction Tax (FTT).
In the absence of a consensus among the then
27 EU Member States on an FTT scheme,
the European Commission put forward, on 14
February 2013, a proposal for a Council Directive
to implement an FTT via the enhanced cooperation procedure (ECP) in which 11 Member
States, namely Austria, Belgium, Estonia,
France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Portugal,
Slovakia, Slovenia and Spain, are participating. Luxembourg announced that it would not
participate to the scheme under ECP, given the
absence of a level-playing field at the global level,
a concern shared by our association.
The Commission’s proposal focuses on financial
institutions (FIs), which it defines broadly. The tax
chargeable event is the execution of a financial
transaction involving a FI connected to the FTT
zone. This connection is based on a number of
factors including an establishment criterion and
an issuance principle. The former is intended to
subject to the tax any transaction involving an FI
established within the FTT zone, while the latter,
in the same way as the French and Italian FTT,
is intended to subject to the tax any transaction
pertaining to a security issued within the FTT
zone. Each FI shall have primary responsibility for
the payment of the FTT to its local tax authorities,
even if there is, in principle, a joint liability of each
party to the transaction. So far, it is unclear how
the FTT will be collected in practice.
The magnitude and scope of the Commission’s
proposal are far-reaching:

he FTT will apply to a broad population of
T
FIs and to a very large range of products and
transactions. No significant exemption is provided by nature of actors (e.g. market makers
are in scope), nor by nature of products (the
purchase of government bonds and the conclusion of derivatives are taxable), nor by nature of transactions (repos are in scope). Few
carve-outs are provided: ring-fencing SMEs
and private households, primary markets, issuing of government bonds, as well as monetary
policy instruments and post-trading activities.
29
The
0
33
0
effective rate of the FTT will be much
higher than the headline rate of 0.1% - perhaps ten times higher. The reason is the chain
of trading and clearing that lies behind most
securities transactions. A purchase of securities on a stock exchange ordinarily involves
the sale and purchase by a number of parties,
including market makers, brokers, clearing
members and the central counterparty to the
clearing system. Each sale will be subject to
the FTT, with only the central counterparty being exempt.
Although
Luxembourg is not participating to
the scheme, FIs established in Luxembourg will
be subject to the tax in many occurrences due
to far-reaching extraterritorial elements set out
in the proposal. Luxembourg FIs would indeed
be required to pay the FTT each time they
are engaged (i) in a financial transaction with
another FI established within the FTT zone, (ii)
in a financial transaction with the Luxembourg
branch of an FI established within the zone, or
(iii) a financial transaction pertaining to a security issued within the FTT zone, in the latter
case regardless of the country where the counterparty to such a transaction is established.
The aforementioned extraterritorial elements
have been at the centre of much controversy.
On 18 April 2013, the United Kingdom brought
to the European Court of Justice an action for
annulment against the Council’s decision dated
22 January 2013 to authorize enhanced cooperation in the field of FTT on the ground that
this decision “is contrary to EU law because it
authorizes the adoption of a financial transaction
tax (…) with extraterritorial effects which will fail
to respect the competences, rights and obligations of the Non-Participating States” and “the
implementation of which will inevitably cause
costs to be incurred by the Non-Participating
States”, while, in the meantime, the decision
under review is “unlawful because it authorizes
the adoption of an FTT with extraterritorial effects
for which there is no justification in customary international law”. Similar conclusions with respect
to the Commission’s proposal were drawn by the
Council’s own legal service in an internal opinion dated 6 September 2013. While the Court’s
decision is still pending at the time of writing, our
Government has expressed its (informal) support
to the position of the United Kingdom.
Despite these setbacks and the reportedly
slow pace of the negotiations at the level of the
Council, the political idea of an EU FTT is still
here and we anticipate that political pressure will
push the 11 Participating Member States and
the Commission to find ways in 2014 to achieve
tangible progress, albeit on a watered-down FTT,
the scope of which remains to be ascertained at
the time of writing.
Whatever its final scope may be, assuming
such a tax is ever to come into force, an EU FTT
would remain problematic from a Luxembourg
perspective as long as (i) it would provide for a
direct obligation on the part of FIs established in
Luxembourg to collect and pay the tax to foreign
tax authorities and (ii) it would lead to an increase
of the total tax burden for the same FIs to the
exclusive benefit of the 11 Participating Member
States. Similar considerations apply to the
French taxe sur les transactions financières and
the Italian imposta sulle transazioni finanziarie,
which, contrary to the EU FTT, already constitute
operational realities.
In Luxembourg, like in many, if not all, EU
Member States, a tax can only be enforced on
the basis of a bill adopted by the Parliament and
published in the Official Gazette. In the absence
of such prerequisites, FIs in Luxembourg cannot
be expected to act as tax collectors on behalf
of foreign jurisdictions and one may wonder in
the first instance whether foreign countries are
entitled to tap into our businesses to replenish
their public finances.
Evolutions in the field of
international exchange of
information in tax matters
At the G8 summit of Lough Erne, Enniskillen, of
June 2013, the Prime Ministers of the G8 countries decided to enter into a new era of automatic
exchange of information (AEOI).
This decision triggered a real flood of international and European initiatives on AEOI, including a draft OECD Model Competent Authority
Agreement (CAA) and its appendix, the draft
OECD Common Reporting Standard (CRS),
and, as a result of competition between the
international legislative bodies of the OECD and
the EU, two different and subsequent amending
proposals to the EU Directive on Administrative
Cooperation (DAC). These legal instruments
come in addition to the Savings Directive as well
31
as an older amending proposal to the Savings
Directive, on the one hand, and FATCA, on the
other.
2
33
2
Besides this evolution on automatic exchange
of information, Luxembourg further signed, in
2013, the OECD/Council of Europe Multilateral
Convention on mutual administrative assistance
in tax matters and continues to sign and ratify
amending protocols to its double taxation treaties in the field of exchange of information on
demand.
These initiatives will put an end to the ambiguous
strategy of States to obtain as much information
as possible on their own (resident) taxpayers (in
order to ensure a correct and proportional burden sharing amongst them), while at the same
time attracting and maintaining foreign capital
investments in their country (leading to more
economic welfare and financial resources) by refusing to transfer information on non-residents to
other countries. The objective of more horizontal
tax transparency between countries of the world
is thus to be fully supported.
There are, however, two elements, which lead to
clearly mixed feelings about these initiatives:
The
first one is the non-coordinated approach
to the problem by different international bodies:
compliance with the multiple new legal instruments (with different scopes of application and
dates of entry into force) create a considerable,
partially useless and clearly disproportionate
additional workload for those who have to
deliver the information needed, i.e. the actors
of the financial sector.
The
second one is neglect of the vertical
aspect of automatic exchange of information:
when elaborating and adopting the new
instruments in an inter-governmental
organisation like the OECD, governments are
– in complete compliance with international
public law, which only addresses States totally ignoring the rights of the taxpayers
(companies and individuals). Within the EU,
with its largely more developed body of law,
governments as well as financial institutions
(who are intermediaries between citizens /
companies and governments) are, however,
legally bound to respect the interest of third
parties. Will financial intermediaries really
be authorised by law to send all available
information on their customers to all 28 EU
member states without asking for the consent
of the customer, which is required by the Data
Protection Directive and the EU Charter of
Fundamental Rights?
In a letter sent to the G20, to the G8, to the
OECD and to the EU instances, the European
Banking Federation (EBF) consequently established a wish list, containing notably the following
points:
1. Coordination and consistency of the international approaches (definition of the financial institutions charged with the reporting; definition
of the object of reporting (per account vs per
person); definition of income; harmonisation of
reporting standards; etc.);
2. Clarification of the legal feasibility (under data
protection rules) of a FATCA type AEOI, applied to non-residents only, within the EU;
3. “Big bang” approach (as the OECD approach
is a bilateral one, there is a risk that every
year one or more countries will join “the club
of AEOI”, after ratification of a new bilateral
agreement, which will lead to a constantly
changing scope of application and to a complex and long lasting implementation process
for the financial institutions concerned);
4. Sufficient lead time and a “phased in approach” for AEOI, because of operational
challenges (i.e. a “three steps – approach”: (a)
reporting identification information on account
holders and balances, (b) income (c) sales
proceeds);
5. Consolidated guidance and technical issues
(high risk of reporting to multiple countries due
to the “indicia” approach, etc).
Given the situation described above, the only
solution that could meet at the same time
the OECD (G8/G20) approach as well as the
complex legal situation within the EU, is to use
the future OECD common reporting standard
(CRS) as a frame (only) for the EU legislation.
This will allow financial institutions to use one
single standardized reporting tool as a basis for
all countries where they are established. As it
seems legally impossible to implement the fully
fletched CRS within the EU, the volume of information exchanged certainly needs to be reduced
considerably. But as the CRS is only used as a
33
frame, this is not a problem. A certain number of
“fields” of the reporting tool will then simply not
be filled in for EU residents having invested in
another EU country.
Consumer protection:
New CSSF rules on alternative
dispute resolution
4
33
4
On 15 October 2013, the CSSF adopted a new
regulation on alternative dispute resolution (ADR).
Regulation No 13-02 shall replace Circular No
IML 95/118 on the handling of client complaints.
Section 1 of this regulation (procedure before
the CSSF) shall apply from 1 January 2014, and
Section 2 of the regulation (provisions applicable
to professionals) shall apply from 1 July 2014.
The CSSF is responsible for receiving client
complaints from institutions under its supervision
and acting as an intermediary in order to reach
an amicable agreement on these complaints,
particularly under Article 58 of the Law of 5 April
1993 on the financial sector.
A condition for opening the ADR procedure with
the CSSF is that the client has already attempted
to amicably resolve the dispute with the institu-
tion concerned. The regulation requires that
complaints must have first been submitted in
writing to the management body of the professional named in the complaint.
CSSF Regulation No 13-02 introduces new
requirements for professionals. Moreover, the
regulation lays down a specific procedure for
resolving disputes before the CSSF once a complaint has been lodged.

New requirements for professionals
One of the main obligations laid down in the new
CSSF regulation is that the professional must set
up a client complaint management policy. This
policy must be defined, approved and implemented by the management of the institution. A
member of the management team shall be responsible for implementing an internal procedure
for handling client complaints.
If the client relations manager was initially contacted by the client and the dispute remains
unresolved, the client must be able to contact
the management of the institution. The client
must be provided with the name and particulars
of the person responsible for his case and have
clear and concise information regarding the
procedure for dealing with complaints (information to be provided, details of proceedings, etc.).
This information must be provided either at the
client’s request or by acknowledging receipt of
a complaint. An acknowledgement of receipt
must, in any event, be sent to the client within 10
working days from the date of complaint receipt.
As a minimum, a response on the merits of the
dispute must be provided within this period.
When a complaint has been filed, the professional is required to compile and analyse all
relevant proof and information. He must respond
(in a manner that is clear and easy to understand) without undue delay and within one month
from the date of complaint receipt. If the deadline
cannot be met, the professional shall inform the
client of the reasons why and give the date when
a response is likely to be received.
If the professional’s response is unsatisfactory,
the professional must provide the client with all
explanations regarding his position and inform
him, in writing, of a pending ADR procedure
before the CSSF, as well as furnish the CSSF’s
contact details.
Finally, professionals must carry out a complaints
analysis addressed to them in order to identify
and deal with recurrent or systematic problems,
as well as potential legal and operational risks.

lternative dispute resolution procedure
A
before the CSSF
This procedure is not a mediation procedure
within the meaning of the Law of 24 February
2012. Furthermore, the CSSF acts as neither an
arbitrator nor judge and the decisions made by
the CSSF when the dispute has been brought to
an end are not binding on the parties.
The CSSF regulation respects the rules laid down
in Directive 2013/11/EU on alternative dispute
resolution for consumer disputes. In particular,
the CSSF’s involvement is subject to the principles of impartiality, independence, transparency, competency, efficiency and equality. The
procedure shall be conducted in writing only. The
parties involved may invite a third party to assist,
or be represented thereby, during all stages of
the procedure.
The first stage involves the CSSF assessing the
admissibility of the request. In the event that said
35
request is deemed inadmissible, the CSSF must,
within three weeks, inform the applicant and
the profesional involved of the reasons why the
CSSF will not handle the dispute.
The CSSF shall send written confirmation to
the applicant once his case has been deemed
admissible and complete. If there are missing
documents, the CSSF shall request the applicant
to submit the required documentation within a
certain period a time.
6
33
6
The CSSF shall send the request to the professional who must clarify his position within one
month. Once the CSSF is aware of the professional’s position, it shall analyse the case and
may, within this context, request additional
information, documents or clarifications from the
professional, who shall be required to respond.
The CSSF shall make a reasoned decision within
90 days; this period may be extended if the case
is complex.
Once the assessment is complete, and if the
CSSF considers that the positions are irreconcilable or cannot be verified, the CSSF shall send
the parties a letter containing its findings and
invite them to contact each other to resolve the
dispute. The parties shall be informed that they
are free to accept or reject the CSSF’s findings.
The parties shall inform the CSSF of the outcome. Should they be unable to reach an agreement, the CSSF shall inform them that they have
the option of taking legal action. However, it must
be noted that this procedure does not suspend
the limitation periods for legal proceedings. This
is not in accordance with Directive 2013/11/EU
which states that Member States must ensure
that ‘limitation or prescription periods do not expire during an ADR procedure’. An amendment
to the legislation was therefore necessary in this
regard in order to avoid infringing upon fundamental principles, particularly the right to an effective appeal and the right to a fair trial. An ADR
procedure shall not deprive a person (consumer
or professional) of their right to appeal.
In short, the main amendments at procedural
level relate mainly to the deadlines now laid down
during the procedure. Moreover, since the CSSF
requires that institutions implement internal procedures, this part of the regulation shall enter into
force on 1 July 2014. Circular IML 95/118 shall
therefore remain in force up to this date.
New European legislation on
mortgage lending
At the beginning of 2014, the European legislator
adopted the Mortgage Credit Directive in order to
strengthen consumer protection within this field.
The aim of the European Commission is to create a European market that is ‘more competitive,
more efficient and more responsible’.
The text covers loans granted to private individuals to purchase property for residential use
and lays down certain provisions with which
the borrower must comply prior to entering into
the contract. The Directive thus provides for, in
particular:

ertain obligations that must be respected
C
concerning advertising for mortgage lending,

ules for the authorisation and registration of
R
credit intermediaries,

he permanent availability to the consumer
T
(either on paper, another durable medium or in
electronic form) of general, clear and understandable information about mortgage products on offer,

he provision of customised information to the
T
consumer based on a European Standardised
Information Sheet, which will enable consumers to compare offers from various providers,

The assessment of the consumer’s creditworthiness prior to entering into a contract, based
on his income and expenses, as well as other
economic and financial criteria. The lender shall
provide the consumer with the loan only if said
assessment shows that the obligations under
the contract will, in all likelihood, be met in accordance with the terms laid out therein.

lear clarification as to whether the consumer
C
will be provided with advisory services when
conducting a given transaction,

onsumer information (either on paper or
C
another durable medium) regarding any
amendment to the borrowing rate, prior to said
amendment becoming applicable,

period of at least seven days in order to
A
compare offers, assess the implications thereof
and make an informed decision. The aforementioned is either a cooling-off period prior to entering into the contract, a period during which
the right of withdrawal after contract signature
may be exercised, or a combination of the two.
37

A
harmonised annual percentage rate (APR),
making it easier for the consumer to compare
all advertising material, as well as pre-contractual information,

8
33
8
he opportunity for the consumer to pay back
T
the loan in advance, either in whole or in part.
Member States may provide for fair and objective compensation for the borrower, but may
not impose a penalty on the consumer.
The text also urges Member States to promote
measures to foster consumer awareness about
responsible borrowing and debt management,
particularly in terms of mortgage lending.
Member States have until 21 March 2016 to
implement the directive into national law.
Modernisation of Luxembourg
bankruptcy law
On 1 February 2013, the Minister of Justice introduced a draft law pertaining to “the protection of
enterprises and the modernisation of bankruptcy
law”1.
1 Projet de loi (n°6539) relative à la préservation des
entreprises et portant modernisation du droit de la faillite
(…).
The aim of this initiative is to reform the current
legal framework by providing conservatory measures and legal instruments to prevent financially
distressed businesses from being declared bankrupt should their financial problems be detected
at an early stage. The draft law, which draws
on a similar reform carried out in Belgium from
2009 onwards, intends to modernise the current
statutory framework by favouring turnaround
options, by way of conciliation proceedings with
creditors, rather than the liquidation of distressed
businesses.
The ABBL generally welcomes this initiative, which
we feel was long overdue at a time where the
number of business bankruptcies is steadily increasing and considering the fact that the current
legal framework appears to provide for inadequate
responses in many occurrences. The ABBL nevertheless conveyed two major reservations as to the
current stand of the draft law. The first reservation relates to the suggested measures providing
for an early detection of the financial problems
faced by businesses, which, as it currently stands,
would only benefit public creditors. The ABBL
advocates for an extension of the benefit of the
aforementioned measures to private creditors, in
the first instance banks,
considering the fact that public creditors benefit in
the first instance of special legal privileges for the
recovery of their debts in case of bankruptcy. The
second reservation relates to the new conciliation
proceedings to be established by the draft law
under review. While the said proceedings would
undoubtedly enhance the applicable statutory
framework, the ABBL is of the view that the benefit of the said proceedings should be subjected
to more stringent conditions as those currently set
out in the draft law under review, considering the
significant number of misuses or frauds recorded
in Belgium since the inception of a comparable
framework.
The ABBL and AGDL have always constituted
two separate and autonomous organisations, but
since the creation of the AGDL, in 1989, both
associations were always closely linked,
particularly - but not only, through a service
level agreement entrusting the day-to-day
administrative work of the AGDL to the secretariat
and staff of the ABBL.
Since its constitution, the AGDL had to intervene
4 times in its function as Deposit Guarantee
Scheme:

In 1991 with the failure of
 B
ank
of Credit and Commerce
International S.A. (BCCI)
AGDL
The “Association pour la Garantie des Dépôts
Luxembourg” (AGDL) is the Luxembourg Deposit
Guarantee Scheme as well as the Luxembourg
Investor Compensation Scheme. Its purpose is
to set up, in accordance with the law and the
European directives, a mutual guarantee scheme
covering cash deposits of the customers of credit
institutions and claims arising out of investment
transactions in favour of investors with credit institutions and investment firms.

In 2008 with the failure of

Glitnir Bank Luxembourg S.A.,

Landsbanki Luxembourg S.A.,

Kaupthing Bank Luxembourg S.A.
In all four cases the process of compensation
of the clients was successfully managed by the
AGDL on the basis of a long-standing outsourcing
contract with a consultant firm and thanks to the
fully efficient computerised system, developed in
39
cooperation with this consultant, and the substantial efforts made by its staff.
The Glitnir case was already closed in 2009 with
a restructuring plan and the AGDL recovered its
debt.
0
44
0
In July 2009, Kaupthing was split in two parts: 1)
Pillar Securitisation S.à.r.l., taking over the debts of
Kaupthing and 2) creation of a new Bank “Banque
Havilland S.A.” which took over the customers of
Kaupthing with their deposits, while the customers of the Belgian branch were taken over by
Keytrade Bank. The recovering process began in
August 2009 and the AGDL receives a reimbursement 4 times a year. This will continue in 2014.
The Landsbanki case was closed in 2011. The
AGDL recovered entirely its debt.
The BCCI case was definitively closed in 2013
with the AGDL recovering entirely its debt.
Since 9 October 2008 no failure of a member of
the AGDL has been registered.
The most significant issue for the AGDL in 2013
was the successful implementation, by its credit
institution members, of the CSSF circular 13/555
introducing the “Single Customer View” in the
context of the deposit guarantee. The purpose
of this regulation is to set up a process by which
a credit institution in failure is able to produce a
single view of the assets of its clients within 72
hours after the declaration of insolvability. During
the whole year 2013, the secretariat of the AGDL
was at the disposal of its members to provide assistance in applying the circular.
At the European level, the AGDL closely followed
the evolution of the various European projects
affecting the reform of the deposit guarantee
system:

he draft Bank Recovery and Resolution
T
Directive,

The proposals for a Banking Union,

he draft Directives for Deposit Guarantee
T
Schemes and Investor Compensation Schemes
issued in 2010.
As the discussions around the project of the
Deposit Guarantee Scheme Directive have almost
come to a conclusion in 2013 and as the Directive
is expected to be published during the first halfyear of 2014, the main task for the AGDL and all
stakeholders in 2014, on the national level, will be
to relaunch the project of a “new” AGDL, which
has been on ice since 2010.
AGDL
Gilles Pierre
Patrick Gouden
AGDL General Secretary
AGDL
5.
The Private Banking Group, Luxembourg
Private Banking Group, Luxembourg:
A Combination of Strategic Factors
The ABBL’s Private Banking Group, Luxembourg
(PBGL), created in 2007, currently comprises 48
private banks employing around 7,000 people.
2
44
2
The PBGL’s primary mission is to represent,
within the ABBL, the specific interests of this
category of members and defining, as part of
the general policy pursued by the association,
the initiatives and actions to be taken in the
interest, and for the defence and promotion, of
the specific activities of operators in the areas
concerned.
In addition, the PBGL plays a crucial role in
promoting the private banking industry’s positions on key banking developments and issues
both in Luxembourg and at the international
level, as well as in preparing the future of private
banking in a fast-changing market and regulatory
environment.
Indeed, the international private banking Industry
is undergoing unprecedented changes that
have a direct impact on the global competitive
landscape: if we could observe the globe from
outside, we would notice a world perfectly cut in
two in which ‘mature’ economies and ‘developing’ economies are moving at different speeds.
Furthermore, on the regulatory side, there is
the sustained activity by Western governments,
especially in the US, to eliminate opportunities for
their citizens to hold undisclosed wealth offshore.
Thus, if achieving profitable growth is the clear
goal for private banks in general, applying diverse
strategies seems to be the right overall strategy
to implement in order to deal with the different
sets of problems in the two parts of the world.
So, eyes have to be focused on both sides!
In this context, Luxembourg’s competitive position will be determined by a combination of
factors: political vision, by regulators and supervisors, and corporate actions to be undertaken by
wealth managers.
Luxembourg has always been traditionally open
to the outside world with the clear objective of
increasing the geographical diversification of the
financial centre, both in terms of the companies
present here and their clients.
In 2013, as never before, the international aspect
of its business model has been incorporated ‘by
law’ in the DNA of the Luxembourg financial centre. This can be summed up in two moments:
In
April, with the Prime Minister’s declaration
that from 1 January 2015 Luxembourg will introduce provisions for the automatic exchange
of information within the European Union
(within the scope of the 2003 EU Savings
Directive, limited to interest income);
In
May, with the Minister of Finance’s announcement that Luxembourg will ratify the
Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA) Model I to
allow for an automatic exchange of information
between Luxembourg and U.S. tax authorities on bank accounts held in Luxembourg by
citizens and residents of the U.S.A.
These decisions show the capacity of the legislator to react rapidly in an ever-changing international environment; this characteristic has often
given Luxembourg a competitive advantage.
At the same time, national commitments and
international trends have, by default, a direct
impact on the private banking business in
Luxembourg: in general, measures such as the
automatic exchange of information, in order to
be effective, should be well managed at all levels
to avoid encouraging the flight of assets out of
Europe. As a result, since the world of finance is
strongly interconnected, ensuring full level playing field conditions through a global standard is
crucial for Luxembourg.
Locally, the issue lies in the short term: the sector’s transition, from a business model based on
confidentiality to a new one fostering international
diversification, is triggering significant challenges
putting the industry under pressure.
In order to accompany the on-going private
banking restructuring process, a multi-dimensional approach should be useful in better understanding and addressing the local challenges:
43
Private banking challenges in 2014
Clients
44
Focus lies on the UHNWI and HNWI segments, which will be the primary sources of new wealth, as well as keeping old Clients
Markets
New geographical markets are being explored (e.g. Russia, Latin
America, Gulf region)
Margins
Under the current macro-economic scenario, we are experiencing a
deterioration of profit and revenue margins in an environment of lowrates and increasing regulatory pressure
Regulatory
In this uncertain and shifting landscape, financial institutions need to
closely monitor the activity of their Regulatory Supervisors and reach a
shared understanding of what is required to meet the higher standards
People
For individual banks, but also for the financial centre as a whole, training competent managers in Front / Middle / Back office is essential
New
Technology
Clients today expect more interaction and more collaboration than
ever before. Private banking clients are getting wealthier and more
globally diversified; they are also constantly on the move.
Promotion
Expand the product offering for Luxembourg at international level
(Fondation Patrimoniale, Renminbi Products, Islamic Finance...)
Support the Activity of LFF
The PBGL in 2013
In June 2013, a new governance was set up: Yves
Maas, CEO of Credit Suisse (Luxembourg) SA,
was elected Chairman of the Executive Board of
PBGL and Head of the Private Banking Group,
Luxembourg, replacing Luc Rodesch, Banque de
Luxembourg, who had occupied this position for
two consecutive terms of two years.
One of the first actions that the PBGL EXBO has
delivered is to recompose and entrust new mandates to its Working Groups, taking into consideration these new developments:
Working Group ‘Promotion’: Define a strategy for
how private banking “made in Luxembourg” can
be put on the map of our target customers and
markets. Analyse the appropriate communication
channels for these private banking target audiences (road shows, conferences, brochures, social
media). Support Luxembourg for Finance’s activity
in promoting Luxembourg worldwide. Expand the
product offering for Luxembourg at international
level (Private wealth foundations, Renminbi products, Islamic Finance…);

Working Group ‘Training’: Re-examine the training offer for qualified professionals who have to
adapt to the fast changing business environment
in the financial services industry and who wish
to partake in further education. Explore ways to

facilitate, “improve” and coordinate the offering
across the various partners (e.g. IFBL, University of
Luxembourg);
Working Group ‘Statistics & Business
Intelligence’: Production of various statistics and
market research that could be used by private
banks to better understand their market positioning, competition analysis, client breakdown analysis, anticipating future trends (markets and clients),
better understanding the international competition.

Working Group ‘Wealth Planning’: After three
years of gestation, the draft law on private wealth
foundations, largely developed within our wealth
planning working group has finally been submitted
to the Luxembourg Parliament. The working group
will continue to work as a think tank for developing new ideas for the private banking industry in
Luxembourg.

The Private Banking Cluster also actively collaborates with the Luxembourg Stock Exchange,
ICMA, the Luxembourg Freeport, the University
of Luxembourg and the Luxembourg School of
Finance, Luxembourg for Finance, etc.
Finally, the PBGL closely monitors the combination
of strategic factors for designing innovative products and services, attract client assets so as continue to create a significant share of Luxembourg
national income.
45
6.
The Retail and Commercial Banking Group
Retail Banking Study
The “Retail Banking” study, initiated in 2011, was
repeated in 2013 with the participation of BGL
BNP Paribas, Banque BCP, Banque Raiffeisen,
BIL, ING Luxembourg, BCEE and POST Finance.
Social rented housing
6
44
6
A delegation from the working group on social
rented housing met with representatives of the association of real-estate professionals (CIGDL), who
presented their draft legislation on an affordable
housing report. The proposal made by CIGDL
is specifically intended to increase the supply of
affordable rental properties by involving private
developers in the construction of rental properties
aimed at people on modest incomes. The draft
legislation drawn up by CIGDL and a detailed plan
were sent to the members of RCGB: Retail.
Transparency and comparability of
banking fees, bank account switching and access to a basic bank
account
The European Commission has published its
draft directive on the transparency of bank
account fees, basic banking services and bank
account switching. Specifically, the text covers
the option of switching bank accounts across
borders, sets out a list of 20 services related
to bank accounts for which consumers should
be given information on fees, and includes a
glossary of standardised European terms for
these services.
The ABBL set up a working group to analyse the
draft directive in detail and make observations,
which were subsequently sent to the European
Banking Federation (EBF). Amendments to the
EC text and to the draft report of the ECON rapporteur were sent to the Ministry of Finance and
some members of the European Parliament.
Mortgages
At the beginning of 2014, the European legislator
adopted the Mortgage Credit Directive in order
to strengthen consumer protection within this
field. The text covers loans granted to private
individuals to purchase property for residential
use and lays down certain provisions with which
the borrower must comply prior to entering into
the contract.
Please see page 37 for more details on the new
European legislation on mortgage landing.
Financial education
In the field of financial education, the Financial
Consumer Protection Committee of the CSSF,
of which the ABBL is a member, has set up an
ad hoc working group to consider a programme
of financial education in schools. At the request
of the Minister for National Education, the group
has drawn up proposals for the content to be
incorporated into the relevant school syllabuses.
The European Banking Federation (EBF) has also
set up a working group — of which the ABBL is
a member — dedicated to promoting financial
education across Europe.
Credit register
A “Credit register” working group has been set
up to analyse in detail the practicalities of setting
up a credit register in Luxembourg. The working group expressed its preference for a negative credit register, incorporating data on private
individuals, in the form of an economic interest
grouping administered by a support professional
of the financial sector (PSF).
As part of this process, a delegation from the
working group visited the Central Credit Register
run by the National Bank of Belgium (BNB) and
held a discussion with the BCL.
Mortgage brokerage
The ABBL has met with representatives of
two leading real-estate mortgage brokers in
Luxembourg. In light of the lack of regulation in
this sector, brokers are hoping to work together
with banks to draw up a set of basic principles
in the form of statutes, with a view to protecting,
defending and developing the brokerage sector
in Luxembourg. The ultimate aim is to exclude
brokers who do not have the skills and knowledge required to operate in this field.
Consumer credit
The EC has carried out a detailed analysis for
each EU Member State on the legal implementation of the consumer credit directive and
its related practical repercussions. The ABBL
Secretariat and a number of banks participated
in this study.
47
Lobbying via the European Banking
Federation
The Secretariat of RCBG: Retail attended
the meetings of the EBF Consumer Affairs
Committee and contributed to the different positions taken by the EBF on the EC initiatives in the
field of real-estate mortgages, bank accounts
and over-indebtedness. It also answered a number of EC queries concerning unfair commercial
practices and consumer credit.
48
Other matters
Members have been kept up-to-date and
involved in the discussions on the following
subjects: SEPA, MiFID II, taxation of savings and
mobile payments.
Controlled management and bankruptcy
proceedings
RCBG: Commercial has set up a working group
charged with analysing the draft law on company
preservation and modernizing the bankruptcy
law. The working group submitted its conclusions
to the Chamber of Commerce, which is about to
issue its opinion.
Banking Technologies and Payments,
Retail Banking and IT Support
49
Carlo Fonseca
Jean-Pierre Borsa
Simone Kayser
Olivier Pemmers
Information
Technologies
Payments, Finance
IT, Standards
Retail Banking
Head of Information
Technologies
Marc Hemmerling
Member of the
Management Board
7.
Banking Technologies and Payments
Payments
During 2103 the Payments, ICT and Standardisation
Committee (PISC) of the ABBL and the different
related working groups focused their activities on
the migration of the legacy payment systems to
the SEPA compliant systems as requested by the
so-called SEPA end date regulation. The ABBL
continued to work on the many issues raised by the
new legal frameworks that have been proposed by
the European Union in the payments domain.
0
55
0

SEPA
As in the previous year, the achievement of the
Single Euro Payments Area - SEPA - remained at
the heart of PISC’s work in 2013. In order to help
companies to become SDD (SEPA Direct Debit)
compliant, the ABBL, together with its member
banks taking part in the SDD scheme, stepped
up its efforts and organized multiple information
sessions throughout the year helping companies
to smoothly migrate to the new SEPA systems.
SEPA Migration Having been successfully
launched on 28 January 2008, the SEPA project
is about to celebrate its sixth anniversary. The
main challenge in 2013 was the migration to
the SEPA direct debit schemes as a result of
Regulation (EU) N° 260/2012 establishing technical and business requirements for credit transfers and direct debits in euro, which effectively
mandates the migration in the euro area by 1
February 2014.
Thus, during 2013, banks have helped their
customers to use the migration scenario, which
was developed in order to simplify the migration
process as much as possible for companies.
Nevertheless, the migration process will require
time and substantial changes to the existing systems that should not be underestimated.
NASO activities The role of the ABBL as NASO
(National Adherence Support Organisation) is
to give advice and coordinate the adherence to
the EPC schemes, SEPA Credit Transfer (SCT)
and SEPA Direct Debit (SDD) of the remaining
institutions, i.e. to provide support to banks and
financial service providers in order to correctly
complete the SDD and SCT adherence forms.
At the end of 2013, 77 financial institutions had
adhered to SCT, 22 to SDD Core and 15 to SDD
B2B; in terms of SEPA reachability via their parent
companies, the figures are as follows: 87 for SCT,
26 for SDD Core and 16 for SDD B2B.
In its role as NASO, the ABBL has also set up a
process in order to generate and manage SEPA
Creditor Identifiers, which are mandatory for creditors in order to allow them to collect payments via
SDD. This solution has been available since July
2010.
In 2013, this activity exploded with over 1’120
Creditor IDs generated (an average gross increase
of 2000% compared to 2012 and 2011).
SEPA Standards At the same time, the Standards
working group of the ABBL Payments, ICT &
Standardisation Committee has developed XML
implementation guidelines for payment status reports issued by banks for companies, and started
work on XML messages for statements.

ecurity of payment systems and
S
instruments
The ABBL working group dealing with the security
of payment systems and instruments continued to
monitor the various threats and attacks detected.
In the first half of 2013 and until the holiday season, numerous phishing attempts were observed
in Luxembourg as well as in other European
countries.
Being in contact at the European level with different working groups (EPC-ISSG, EBF IT-Fraud),
we have observed that various techniques are
now used by criminals to make it more difficult for
administrators to deactivate phishing websites.
Apart from those sophisticated phishing attacks,
scammers are also up-to-date with the SEPA payments regulation. In countries where IBAN conversion is needed, a growing number of phishing
websites, mailing or vishing (phishing via phone)
have appeared in order to try to collect customer
data.
In that context, the ABBL has decided to set up
new or reactivate existing awareness campaigns.
Together with the Luxembourg Police (Service
Communication et Presse), the ABBL working
group produced an awareness-raising document,
which was published on the Police website, social
networks and relayed to online newspapers.
In the meantime, and using the technical means
of the Police’s communication service, the ABBL
was involved in the production of a 2 minute video
sequence warning and informing clients on phishing techniques.
This video sequence is available at:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=anmZqVeftbs
51

Changing legal framework
In 2013, the ABBL began following the legislative
process of the proposals for a reviewed Payment
Service Directive (PSD2) and a Bank Account
Directive, as well as a proposal for a regulation
capping multilateral interchange fees in card payments, which were tabled in 2013. This follow-up
of legislative proposals was undertaken in close
cooperation with relevant European Banking
Federation working committees.
2
55
2

e-Invoicing
LEI – Legal Entity Identifier
During 2013, the ABBL monitored the project of
the implementation of a LOU (Local Operating
Unit) in Luxembourg, issuing LEI and managing the related data. The ABBL supported its
members by convincing public authorities to set
up such an infrastructure in the interest of the
Luxembourg financial centre.
New ICT technologies – new
opportunities
In 2013, the ABBL continued to chair the eifL
(electronic invoice forum Luxembourg) – the national multi stakeholder forum on e-invoicing and
to represent Luxembourg in the European multi
stakeholder Forum on e-invoicing co-chaired by
the EC DG-Internal Market and DG-Enterprise.
The EC extended the mandate for a further period of 3 years.
During 2013, the ABBL, as representative association of Luxembourg’s largest ICT technology and services users, contributed to building
the future national body defending the interests
of ICT technology users and suppliers. This body
is to be become the voice of the private sector
in discussions with the government on future
strategies that are to be defined and undertaken
in the ICT domain.
The major evolution has been the European
Commission’s proposal for a directive imposing
the future acceptance by public entities of electronic invoices in public procurement.
Innovation and Finance
In 2013, the ABBL organised a workshop for its
members on the future of payments, which are
about to change due to newly available technologies but also to new customer behaviour.
The ABBL continued its participation in the epayment/e-invoicing working group of the ICT
Luxembourg cluster managed by Luxinnovation.
Several workshops around mobile payments and
virtual currencies took place.
The ABBL also took part in a working group set
up by the High Committee of the Financial Centre
(HCPF) regarding the emerging crowdfunding
business.
XBRL
As a founding member of XBRL Luxembourg,
the ABBL continued, as in previous years, to
monitor the use of the XBRL standard in regulatory reporting by Luxembourg banks to the
CSSF and the Luxembourg Central Bank, as well
as the evolution of the reporting requirements.
The ABBL closely followed the various changes
announced by regulators.
53
Social Affairs and Employers’ Representation
Jean-Jacques Rommes
Chief Executive Officer
Head of the
Management Board
Fabienne Lang
Employers’ Affairs
Danielle Haustgen
Employers’ Affairs
8.
Social Affairs & Employers’ Representation
Draft bill of law 6545 on the reform
of social dialogue and the elections
of staff delegations in November
2013
The draft bill of law 6545 on the reform of the
social dialogue was submitted to Parliament at
the end of February 2013.
The reform notably foresees the abolition of the
joint labour council. This would grant more power
to the staff delegation, as well as render decision
taking on former labour council subjects a lot
more difficult.
The draft bill of law also proposes to lower the
present threshold for permanent delegates from
501 to 250 employees and to provide training for
alternate members of the delegation.
One of the biggest changes, however, is the
possibility for staff delegations to invite external
consultants, including union members, at the
company’s expense.
The Industrial Relations and Social Affairs committee of the ABBL created an ad hoc working
group to analyse the text. The ABBL is of the
opinion that the new law increases company
costs, complicates social dialogue, and limits the
decision-making powers of employers while giving unions more influence at company level.
The ABBL position was largely taken into account in the Chamber of Commerce’s position
paper on the draft bill of law.
In May, the UEL organised a press conference
to show its official opposition to the reform. It
pointed out the importance of social dialogue,
but added that the new law could lead to a
deterioration of relations between employers and
staff delegates and ultimately have a negative
impact on the very dialogue the reform is trying
to enhance.
At the beginning of July 2013 the Council of
State issued a very mitigated opinion on the draft
bill of law. This forced the Minister of Labour
and Employment to renounce pushing through
a reform of the social dialogue, which according
to employer’s representatives lacked maturity in
many aspects.
The opinion of the Council of State also had the
merit of clarifying the situation for the elections
of staff delegation in November 2013: in the absence of a new text, Articles 411-1 and following
of the Labour Code would remain the legal basis
for social elections in 2013.
55
From that moment on, employers’ representatives and the ITM (Inspection du Travail et des
Mines) worked on updating their website dedicated to the social elections, www.electionssociales.lu, where all relevant bills, documents and
explanations can be found in French, German
and English.
6
55
6
In September, the ABBL, together with the
Fedil, invited employers to several well-attended
conferences with Pierre Lorang of the ITM who
provided detailed explanations of the procedure
of the social elections.
Draft bill of law 6555 on the reform
of the procedure of reintegration of
workers
In March 2013 the draft bill of law 6555 on the
reform of the procedure of reintegration was submitted to Parliament. The Industrial Relations and
Social Affairs Committee of the ABBL invited M.
Faber of the Ministry of Labour and Employment
to present the draft law. If the ABBL can agree
with some of the changes proposed, such as the
increased speed of the procedure, the medical
review of the person benefiting from reintegration
and a limited access to the procedure, it cannot,
however, agree with the proposal of the daft law
to increase the scope of companies forced to
comply with an internal reintegration by abolishing the quotas of disabled or assimilated members of staff.
The ABBL has actively participated in the drafting
of the Chamber of Commerce’s opinion on the
draft law.
Liaison Committee for Social Affairs
On 21 and 22 June 2013, the social affairs department of the ABBL had the honour of hosting
a meeting of the Liaison Committee for Social
Affairs in Luxembourg. This body, composed
of European employers’ representatives of the
banking sector, meets once a year, each time in
a different Member State, and exchanges views
on matters relating to social affairs that are of
interest to the financial sector.
The representatives from Germany, France,
Belgium, Italy, Danemark, Switzerland and
Cyprus thus came to Luxembourg to meet up at
the ABBL
On Friday, 21 June the participants attended a
work session to exchange views on the political,
social and economic situation of their Member
State, as well as on the collective bargaining agreement in their banking sector. The day
ended with a gala dinner at the Château de
Schengen.
On Saturday, 21 June the participants visited the
Luxembourg satellite company SES in Betzdorf.
Diversity
In matters of diversity, the ABBL continues
promoting its Charta in favour of diversity and
equal opportunities in the financial sector, and
invited interested members to its regular forum of
exchange on diversity.
In July 2013, the ABBL and the Fedil hosted a
workshop, “Equality pays off”, an initiative set
up by the European Commission’s Directorate
General for Justice. The aim of the workshop
was to exchange knowledge and experience
on how to attract and retain female top talent
within a context of changing demographics and
increasing demand for skilled labour.
Sectorial agreement on moral harassment at work
In April 2007 the social partners, at the European
level, concluded a framework agreement on
moral harassment and violence at work. In
Luxembourg, this framework agreement was
implemented in 2009 by a cross-sectorial agreement signed by the UEL and the trade unions
and has been declared of general obligation.
In July 2013, the social partners of the banking sector reached an agreement to adapt the
national agreement to the banking sector.
This sectorial agreement provides bank employees with the possibility to seek the help in case
of moral harassment, freely and anonymously, of
the sector’s occupational health service ASTF.
The ASTF has a specific service to professionally
accompany bank employees in case of moral
harassment.
The agreement will be integrated into the next
collective bargaining agreement.
57
8
55
8
Renegotiation of the Collective
bargaining agreement
Survey on the social situation in the
banking sector for the year 2012
Since the collective bargaining agreement for
bank employees came to an end in December
2013, renegotiations were on the agenda in
autumn 2013. However, due to legislative and
social elections in October and November 2013,
the ABBL and the trade unions decided to postpone the start of the negotiations to December
2013. Due to this delay, the negotiations for a
new collective bargaining agreement had only
barely begun at the end of the year.
Like every year, the ABBL collected data
amongst its member banks on the social situation in the banking sector. This data gives the
ABBL detailed information for the negotiations of
the collective bargaining agreement, which have
started at the end of 2013.
Concerning
the representativeness of the
survey, the participation rate, even lower
than in 2011, still covers 86.5% of the employees of the member banks, i.e. 20’625
people. According to the CSSF’s statistics,
employment for the entire banking sector
in Luxembourg reached 26’537 persons in
December 2012.

Distribution by nationality
More than 60% of the workforce in Luxembourg
consists of foreign nationals. Most foreign employees are commuters, coming from the crossborder regions. Among all employees, the number of Germans, Belgians and Luxembourgers
is slightly decreasing while the French working
population is increasing.
Distribution by Nationality - 2012
16,91%
Luxembourgish
Belgian
French
German
Italian
British
Portuguese
Dutch
Spanish
Danish
Swedish
Other EU countries
Norwegian
Swiss
Japanese
American
Other non-EU countries
17,82%
8,31% 9,37%
11,52% 10,27%
Men
Women
5,81%
7,12%
0,74% 0,09% 0,21% 0,01% 0,01% 1,01% 0,10% 0,14% 0,32% 0,20% 1,55% 0,30% 1,48%
0,74% 0,13% 0,09% 0,06% 0,01% 0,94% 0,18% 0,34% 0,25% 0,29% 1,09% 0,73% 1,87%
59
Average years of service (in years) - 2012
12,0
10,0
8,0
10.2
6,0
9,2
4,0
2,0
Men
Women
0
66
0
0,0
Average age (in years) - 2012
50,0
40,0
30,0
42,2
20,0
10,0
0,0
40,0
Men
Women

Seniority and Age


he average seniority as well as the average
T
age of all employees has increased.
he distribution of men/women is as follows:
T
53.5% men (i.e. 11025 men) and 46.5%
women (i.e. 9600 women).
Evolution of part-time employees 2006-2012
20
18
Men
Women
16
61
14
12
10
8
6
11.67%
4
15,41%
15.57%
16,76%
1.53%
1.74%
1.71%
1.89%
2008
2009
2010
2011
17,16%
11.48%
2
0.93%
0.76%
0
2006
2007

12.75%
2.40%
Part-time work

The percentage of people working part-time continues to increase slowly but steadily.
2012
Distribution of employees by duty groups - 2012
3.05%
2
66
2
0.27%
14.10%
35.14%

Group I

Group II

Group III

Group IV
22.65%

Group V
24.80%

Group VI

Distribution of employees by duty groups

ooking at the distribution of employees
L
within the duty groups of the collective
bargaining agreement, it is worth mentioning
that there is an increasing number of employees in groups IV to VI, whereas the population in groups I to III is diminishing.

Distribution by level of studies

It is worth mentioning that the category of
Bac + 4, i.e. Masters degree level, is the largest and is increasing every year. This clearly
indicates that higher qualifications have
become a necessity for the sector.
63
Distribution by level of studies - 2012
13.81%
32.81%

Studies < BAC

BAC

Bachelor (BAC + 2/3)
24.33%

Master (> / = BAC + 4)
29.05%
Support Service, Communication and Corporate Secretariat
Daniel Lehmeier
Chantal Petesch
Administration
General
Counselor
Jean Schmitz
Piero Ruscitti
Facility
Management
Facility
Management
Philipp von Restorff
Betty Pauly
Membership
Management
Tom Théobald
Communication
and Press Relations
Stéphanie Haan
Corporate Design
and Publications
Adviser to the
Management Board
Head of
Communications
Jessica Thyrion
Communication
Missing:
Brigitte Etgen
Corporate Secretariat
9.
Events 2013
21/03/2013
EMIR Conference

10/04/2013
ABBL member meeting with Minister Frieden
26/04/2013
ABBL General Meeting
26/04/2013
ABBL Press Conference

05/06/2013
The LEI – Legal Entity Identifier and its role in
the EMIR reporting
19/06/2013
Private Banking Group Members’ Meeting
65

17/09/2013
Information Session on Social Elections
03/10/2013
PBGL welcome reception for LSF Master in
Wealth Management Students
23/10/2013
The new CRR / CRD IV rules

06/11/2013
Trade Repository access and services
14/11/2013
ABBL Chairman’s Dinner
Throughout the year
SEPA Direct Debit Migration Sessions

10.
66
IFBL
The structural changes to the financial sector, which have been ongoing for several years,
continued in 2013. While the financial centre
has been enriched with a number of institutions
from areas that are more distant geographically,
changes are also envisaged with regard to the
type of customers that we are seeking, both in
terms of the volume of wealth and more international origin. On the other hand, the growing
requirements relating to the supervision and regulation of the financial markets also have a great
impact on the internal organisation of financial
institutions, which must adapt to meet the new
demands.
All these changes are of course felt as far as training requirements are concerned, and the IFBL
has therefore amended its provision of services
by establishing new partnerships, creating new
certification programmes and discontinuing some
training courses that no longer meet the centre’s
requirements. In terms of man-days (one manday corresponds to one person following 8 hours
of training), the institute has recorded a slight
decline of 5.20% in comparison with a particularly
good year in 2012. However, at 12,389, the number of man-days remains very high and significantly exceeds the volume of the last five years.
Fewer registrations for ‘à la
carte’ courses, strong growth in
certification programmes
The decline in registrations for ‘à la carte’ courses
is largely offset by the increase in registrations for
certification programmes and cycles (+20.05%
compared with 2012). These professional qualifications, organised in conjunction with representative professional associations on the financial
centre, set common standards for most business
lines in the financial sector with regard to the
knowledge and expertise required to satisfy current demands. The figures for 2013 clearly show
that employers are increasingly adopting these
certification programmes in order to be optimally
placed to address the challenges they face.
At certification programme level, the Compliance
training, organised with ALCO, and the Risk
Management training curricular, set up with the
Luxembourg Association for Risk Management
(ALRiM), remain in high demand, with increases
of 23.33% and 51.26% respectively. Overall, all
training courses linked directly or indirectly to the
regulatory and supervisory environment of the
financial centre recorded gains in 2013, a trend
that should continue in 2014 in view of the regulatory measures that banks are obliged to implement progressively.
With regard to training in financial markets, the
programmes organised in conjunction with
ICMA Luxembourg (namely Capital Markets and
Financial Instruments Certificate and Capital
Markets Crisis Management Initiatives) were, as
usual, very successful. Training courses in collective investment schemes, created in collaboration
with ALFI, have been extended to include the
AIFMD (Alternative Investment Fund Management
Directive) and have seen an increase of 7.24%. In
the field of Retail and Corporate Banking, some
25 participants underwent the final assessment to
achieve the title of Certified Retail Client Advisor
and Certified Corporate Client Advisor. With
regard to Private Banking, the Certified Private
Banker training was organised once again, after
being suspended in 2012 for one year, with a
group of 16 participants.
New in 2013
In 2013, the IFBL rekindled its collaboration with
ACI (Financial Markets Association) to provide
preparatory courses for three internationally
recognised exams: the ACI Dealing Certificate,
the ACI Operations Certificate and, lastly, the ACI
Diploma. In the Back Office area, a new, twolevel training course called “Capital Markets Back
Office Certificate” (CAMBOC) was created. With
36 participants, this course has been very well
received from the outset.
The topic of “career and personal
development”
Since 2010, the Institute has broadened the
range of its services by providing, in addition to
the training it offers, measures and actions in the
area of “career and personal development”. This
approach is primarily aimed at companies looking
for solutions regarding the orientation, support
and coaching of their employees. On the other
hand, the IFBL also supports initiatives launched
by the Ministry of Labour and the Employment
Administration in connection with the national
strategy to combat unemployment. Thus,
the Institute ran 7 cycles of the “Fit4Financial
Markets” programme between 2010 and 2013,
accommodating 453 candidates in total, of which
104 attended in 2013 alone.
67
11.
Luxembourg for Finance
The year 2013 was a year of change for
Luxembourg for Finance (LFF). Five years after its
establishment, the Ministry of Finance decided
to increase its commitment by placing a diplomat at the head of LFF, Nicolas Mackel. Fernand
Grulms, who has helped set up LFF and had
been its CEO until July 2013, left to meet new
professional challenges. LFF is grateful for his
efforts to make Luxembourg’s financial centre a
recognised brand.
8
66
8
The new CEO, Nicolas Mackel, served as Consul
General in Shanghai from 2011 to 2013, where
he was in charge of promoting Luxembourg’s
economic interests throughout China as the
executive director of the Luxembourg Trade and
Investment Office. A lawyer by profession, he
has also served as Luxembourg’s Permanent
Representative to the EU and as deputy chief of
mission at Luxembourg’s embassy in Washington
DC.
The appointment of a career diplomat goes in line
with a redirection of LFF from a focus on events
towards a more communicative approach. The
internal reorganisation included the hiring of new
staff. Thus LFF’s activities in 2013, particularly
in the second half of the year, primarily focused
on the revision of key messages on the qualities
of the Luxembourg financial centre. Following
this, the main support material was updated and
redesigned, like LFF’s PowerPoint presentation
for use abroad. In this context, all communication
tools have been revised, of which some projects
are still ongoing.
The range of communication tools has been
enriched by videos that are produced in-house.
Providing a different way to spread key messages, the videos also widen the scope of LFF’s
target audience. Last but not least, LFF staff, who
are in regular contact with the international press
have facilitated media training with renowned
international experts.
The launch of a website dedicated to renminbi
business in Luxembourg (www.rmb-business.com)
and communication activities associated therewith,
helped put Luxembourg on the map for Chinese
officials and European customers interested in
the further circulation of the renminbi. Since then,
Luxembourg has experienced continuous media
coverage as the third largest renminbi hub in the
world.
2013 also saw the creation of a fully functioning
market intelligence department. Though the
idea for such a team was born in 2012, it
was completed with two additional staff and
activity was kicked off with meetings with the
Ambassadors to Turkey, India, Russia and
Indonesia, during which business opportunities in
the respective countries were discussed. These
meetings will serve as a future model to identify
and tailor LFF’s target countries and the sectors
to promote during financial missions.
The task of the market intelligence team is to
monitor competing financial centres’ activities and
market trends, as well as to explore new business
opportunities for the Luxembourg financial centre.
Prior to financial missions, the team also prepares
country reports and briefings on special topics
when required.
LFF’s financial missions led experts from the
industry to the following destinations: Asia
(Beijing and Shanghai), the Middle East (Riyadh
and Dubai), Scandinavia (Sweden and Norway)
and Turkey. Apart from these missions which
were, with the exception of Turkey, led by former
Minister of Finance, Luc Frieden, LFF represented
the financial centre at several other events, in
particular at MIPIM in France, the City Week in
London, the CIFA and the GAIM in Monaco,
the Private Wealth Forum in Brazil, Expo Real
in Munich, the Asian Financial Forum in Kuala
Lumpur, the World Islamic Banking Conference
in Bahrain, the Euromoney Qatar Conference and
the Asian Banker Renminbi Conference in Beijing.
LFF staff also participated in economic missions to South Africa and South America (Peru
and Colombia). On the occasion of each of the
above-mentioned events, LFF grasped the opportunity to promote the value proposition of the
Luxembourg financial centre abroad.
A major event taking place in Luxembourg
and partnered by LFF as a sponsor was the
38th Annual Conference of the International
Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO),
gathering professionals from the regulation sector
worldwide.
The reorganisation of Luxembourg for Finance
has helped take the agency to the next level. In
an ever competitive financial world, quality is key
in order to keep up with the big players.
69
Reception Desk and Secretariat
Chantal Hoffman
Reception Desk
Colette Kremer
Sabine Nickels
Reception Desk
Reception Desk
Marc Hemmerling
Diane Meunier
Member of the
Management Board
Executive Secretary,
Organisation
Nadja Pfleger
Natacha Brunelle
Antonella Bocci
Sophie Poekes
Secretariat
Secretariat
Secretariat
Secretariat
71
Accounting and Human Resources
Alain Hondequin
Doris Cavallaro
Secretary General
Head of Accounting
Elisângela Furtado
Accounting
Catherine Bourin
Carole Bertemes
Human Resources
Member of the
Management Board
Myriam Sibenaler
Head of Human
Resources
Missing: Nathalie Bertemes
Accounting
12.
M
embership of the Board of Directors
(as at 31 December 2013)
Chairman
Ernst Wilhelm CONTZEN
Vice-Chairman
Deutsche Bank Luxembourg
Carlo THILL
BGL BNP Paribas
Elected members
Co-opted members
Jean-François ABADIE Crédit Agricole Luxembourg
Rima ADAS PricewaterhouseCoopers
Massimo AMATO UBI Banca International
On behalf of the ABBL/ALFI Depositary Bank Forum
Martin F. DOBBINS State Street Bank
Luxembourg
(as of 22 January 2013)
Gerard-Jan BAIS Erste Europäische Pfandbrief- und
Kommunalkreditbank
Michel BIREL Banque et Caisse d'Epargne de l'Etat
Sébastien DANLOY RBC Investor Services Bank
Véronique de La BACHELERIE Société Générale Bank & Trust
(as of 23 May 2013)
Chris EDGE J.P. Morgan Bank Luxembourg
Jean-Marc FANDEL CETREL (until 12 June 2013)
Falk FISCHER Commerzbank International
Frédéric GENET Société Générale Bank & Trust
On behalf of the ABBL Private Banking Group
Luc RODESCH Banque de Luxembourg
(until 9 July 2013)
Yves MAAS Credit Suisse (Luxembourg)
(as of 11 July 2013)
On behalf of Clearstream Banking
Jeffrey TESSLER
On behalf of the ABBL Retail and Commercial
Banking Group
Paul WARINGO Banque et Caisse
d’Epargne de l’Etat
(as of 22 January 2013)
(until 30 April 2013)
Roland LUDWIG
André MARC
Eric MARTIN
Jhon MORTENSEN
René MOTTAS
François PAULY
Jacques PETERS
Fouad E. RATHLE
Robert SCHARFE
Thierry SCHUMAN
Hajime USUKI
Rik VANDENBERGHE
Luc VERBEKEN
CETREL (as of 23 September 2013)
Allen & Overy
BGL BNP Paribas (until 30 April 2013)
Nordea Bank
UBS (Luxembourg)
Banque Internationale à Luxembourg
KBL European Private Bankers
Garanti Bank
Bourse de Luxembourg
BGL BNP Paribas (as of 23 May 2013)
Nomura Bank (Luxembourg)
ING Luxembourg (until 21 March 2013)
ING Luxembourg (as of 26 April 2013)
IFBL representative
Fouad E. RATHLE Garanti Bank
73
Editor ABBL
Layout & Graphics Interligne / ABBL
House of Finance 12, rue Erasme L-1468 Luxembourg
P.O. Box 13 L-2010 Luxembourg | Tel.: (+352) 46 36 60-1 | Fax: (+352) 46 09 21 | [email protected] | www.abbl.lu