Interventions de Monsieur Abdellatif Chaouite et Philippe Hanus

Interventions de Monsieur Abdellatif Chaouite et Philippe Hanus

! "
#
$
%
(
#(
&
&
"
(
#
&
#
1
4
#
1
#"
)
2 # 0 #
## "
#
9 :;#
!9
#
$
"
/
##
'
&
#
8
(
7
%
(
?
#
3
7
0
1
(
0
%
# "
% ## "
#
#(
&
&
2
&
"
#
#
45
6
"
2
"
#
"
2
&
: 1
5
(
+
#"
<
*
&
#
*1
1
"
0
)
+
(
(
7
#
#"
#
# "
%
%
"
'
# "
'(
8
7
/
&&
#
%
1#
#
#
+,#
%
#
5
" #
% ## "
+.
"
7
#
1
&
1
#
(
# (
3
& # &
% (
7
+ 2
"
(
'
0
)8 " +
2 7
!
# "
# "
%
&
%
"
#
/
'
#
)
#"
(
&
* #
(
# )
& #
#"
#
#
'
# # (
#
"
" #
(
&
'
)*
/
%
#
#
&
(
1
7 "0
(
#"
## 7 #
#
( % &
% ## "
#
=/
"
; >
#
# #
#
8
& "
! 6
(
7
0
"
&
#
(
&
&
(
(
# "
(
#
%
8
4 &
& A
#
B &
&
&
@ 8 &
&
A
%
%
%
3
%
CDCB
8
'
##
&
(
%
'
&
7 4
#
"
3
7
&
7(
&
# #
##
&
(
"(
##
#<#
#
(
$% E % &0 #
( %
&
"
#
$
8'
7 #
#"
-0
"
(
&
(
3 %
%
#
7
"
0 #
# (
" '
) #
" ## % 7
#<#
*
#
! 6
( "
8
'
%
%
" A
"
"
#
#
B 4
(
B
## "
&
'
( A
7
#
$
"
*%
"
$!
#
%
%
B2
#
7
&
'
&
#
## "
% 7 #
%
"
7 ## "
#
(
7#
$
"
& #
#"
( %
##
(
&&
( %
F
#
7
&
##
%
&
B
8
&
&
%
' 1G &
'
( &
' %
(
%#
#
(
( (
'
( %
A* ?
&
#
(
#
(
(
#
#
%#
$ /
&
'
$
&
&
'
+
# #
'
/ 8
! "
7 B
&
7 %
#"
&
%
%
5
2 %
'F
&
(
# " #
(
'
# #
##
*%
##
/
C
'
A
%
'
#
&
0
%
"
A
# 0
! *-4
'
#
&
#
&
"
'
3
8
& @
8 "
# "
(
&
&
#
E
##
B
7 #
(
&
#
& #
#
8
"
%
8
"
CC
%
%#
##
#
8
#
% ## "
@
7A
7 #
#
#
%
3 %
'
"
%
&
%
"
&
%
' %
% #
/
#
&
"
&
0
'
&
A
#0
% &
H&
$%
(
##
' %
%
# 0
4 I @ / J @ # A(
#<# ' % "
#
B
% ## "
#
5
(
' *5 -%
%
#<# # #
( F
" #
(
%
(
"
#
&
B
(
#
#
3 ##
&
&
!
#<#
8
5
7
K
##
;
'
#
7
8
8'
&
(
% "
%
%
( %
% "
' # #
8
(
%
<
" 5 "
"
#
##
8
%
# "
+ #
7 & ## B #
&
%
%
&
##
7
L
CD;
#
M
M
#
%
&
B *
0 6
@
7 #
( %J&
0
%
%
B
&
A
K
'
%
A%
%
(
CDD
(
+
A
(
( %
' %
( %
#
8
)"
&
#(
5
%
(
* (
#
+
' %
(
#
#
%
' %#
"
' %
%
(
8
'
L
'
%
&
%
"
##
&
&
#
(
#
7 #
(
#"
0
#
%<
#
# #
B
#"
"
"
%
"
8
#
3
#
)
#
'
##
3(
M
=$
# #
##
(
&
A
(
(
%
N
#
7
,B
#
" ##
## "
A ( %
' A
B
% "
'
&
&
(
( %
)
'
'
#
"
#
7
#
'
&
E
(
&
"
7A
B
6 A
&
"
#
3
" "
#
# #
(
(
#
&
#
( %
% 7
"
"
B
#
#
)#
A
%
8
%
'
(
(
"
%
)
(
%
"
8
"
"
&
#
"
( %
#
#
% 7
B
0
%
&
"
&
#
"
) &
%
B % 8
%
3
" ##
(
'
%
(
" ##
'
"
&
'
( %
#
)
+
( %
%
&
"#
6 #
&
8
'
(
#
"
+
%
#
5
&
#
3
#<#
&
%
3#
'
#
%
# "
A
A
#
%
5
%
%
&
5
"
'
"
G
##
&
&
(
'&&
#
B
#
#
(
'
(
(
'
#
7
%
A(
+
#"
##
B
#
##
7 #"
(
"
% 8
#"
(
O
8
#
(
#
%
B %
8'
&&
%
&
(
"
/
&
B
A'
A
%
+# #
' (
#
'
%
7 &
A
&
%
% #
'
8
%
&
5
3
#
7
%
(
'
&
! "
'
' %
P
%
&
#
(
0
7
# 7
%
(
#
(
(
8
&
%
/ 8 &
/
#
&
"
'
0
"
(
& "
%
&
"
/
"0
E
#
(
"
& "
%
! 6
#
#
#
"
$
"
'
#
7
@
A
#
#
" A4 &
8 ( 1
D
4
"
4
! 6
4 &
#
$ 6#
0
A! 6
B
*
-0 B
#
?
#
7
B9
"
(
4 &
5 #
#
N
1-
#"
!" #
*
N
8 #
#
#
9 #
#
"
*1
#
A
7
F 50
$ 6#
#0
/
# "
5
B
"
'
*
#
#(
( 1
!
(
"
#0
&
*
#
"
'*
4
# (
#
R-R
# "
'
0
%
$
%
?
/
#
##
% E
( %'
B3
%
'
"
S #0
@
&
%
. L
( %'
&
" 0
A
"
#
"
"
#
:
#
#
?
4
(
#
%
B
.
%&%
0
(
R-R
0
A &0 #
" + %
##
' <
( 2 &
<
"
" 8 "
"
( (
&
B
A
&
#
(
(
* #
( &
1
"
1# "
#
7
*
&
#
#
$
)
1#
7
8
#
9 %
1
"
"4
7
&
&
#
"
$
A?
(
'K
#
&
! "# Q
#
&
# & #
0
R-R
#
(
#
(
M
#"
1
1
1
" "
0
B
3
##
R-R
0
M
6 '
)
"
3
#
*
(
# M
+ ' *5
*
0
A
#
'
##
#
R-R
1-
&
0
C TB
$
%%
*
#"
#
! 6
$
6
0
A
&
"
'
18 "
B
*
&
DD
8 (
' F
&
C
*
% ## "
% ## "
"
#
$
% "" #
5
U 4
H
#
B V
#
## "
0
#"
1
&
# 0
RR
" 0
"
A "
&
( %
&
7 L
#
0
#
7
<
% & "
#
7 &
#
#<#
#
0
#0
#
RR
0
"
#
A
# "0
"
B
"
$0 1
##
7"
F
A
B
! 6
0
##
## "
9S 5 9
#
%G &
#
"
C;T
0
"
W #
?
1
7 #"
1 "
#
1
! 6
(
1
#
'
0
&
7 ## "
(
"0
1
7"
(
&
(
1
&
1
1
##
'
#0
$
'
#
4
F
#
"
#
?
#
B3
O #
8
# "
(
*1
## "
1/ "
"
#
%L
K
1-## "
CP:B / CT;
#
"
#"
#
##
& 7
"
A
U
#
)
9
% ## "
A# "
9
+
)
" #
#
#
F
"
1
"
"
-
J "
"
/
A
(
1G & ## "
"0
+ (
S ( &
<
' * "
0 A 0
4 & B
7
%
?
' 1
&
&
"
&
1G &
#
1G &
#
18
7
B
*
#
X
#
&
#
#
$
11 "
1/
M
1
E
# 5 '
A$ 6# B ! 5
A- 0 B
( )*+,
$ "#
$
7
7
0
/
B
##
/ A #
4
CT
&
A
*5
#(
"
"
CTP A 7
CT
'
5 #(
" *
*
# (
# 5
4 &
CC
B
'
0
& 5 "
#
M
A
7
;:
&
&
1 "
"
' 1
L
&
#
1- 0
'
(
1G &
F
7
C
!
A- 0 B $
# #
" #
&
"
*1 ## "
#
"#
4
%
T
/
0
RR
A!
?
7
"
1
(
%
(
"
#
##
#
G &
5 "
L
##
"
7
##
#
1
:B
&
4
"
'
&
(
6
0
8
#"
1
.
! 6
#"
(
1 7
#
)
0
+ (
' 1
#
1 #
&
"
! 6 A
*5 $
B
A4
#
F
B &
45
C $
#0 F
#
##
F ##
'
5 A- 0 B
#
#
&
#
'
1
#
#
&
&
C
(
&
&(
( (
&
' 1
1Q"
A4 & B 2 1
1
' X " %L
#
#
8 &
%/
5
&
" 0
#
C;
! 6
"
W
"
&
"
& "
@
% 7
X
A4 & B ' $
A$ 6# B
*
A- 0 B % E & <
"
& " &
4
"
%
CP
5
& #
&
A
" B
F
1/ " (
1
C;
CP:
##
!
A &
P:
&
C;CB 3
#
%
7
! 6
"
0
$ 7 0# F
#
#(
(
(
/
&
#<# 1 ## "
1 0
CT
?
1
& #
3 7
(
#
A
"
B
7
! 6
1- S A
"
F
#
##
&
.
"
M
## "
#(
&
! 6
4 &
&
&
#
A4 &
1
#
#B
CD
"
1 &
# (
&
&
B
*
-
CD
*5 B
$
7
#
)
*5
B
5
"
1
CC
F
A
5B
# + A#
'
F
# " 1
5
B (
&
5
(
"
S
&
A CCCB
/
CD
&
' 1 ## "
1
'
0
&
7
' 1 &0 #
6# "
#
* )
8
' 1 ( )
7 0# "
+
)
+ 1
&
' 1
#
(
#
) 1
1/ 5
+
8
'
7
1
#
CD;
' &
' #
0
)
&
+ 9 7
9
(
"
'
7 &
"
A &
"
1 "
&
B
A
1
"
"
#
&(
#
B
'
! 6
& ##
"
'
&
(
2
7
+
## "
0
#
7
# '
##
"
#
M
(
8
#
.0
7
"
*1 &
"
(
?
!
#
3
4
/ 4 &
W ( 1' #
# & #
&
X "(
"
1 ## "
7 #
#
"
&
&
&
DT
1
#"
#
RR
#
1 <
"
W ( 1 7
*5
1 12
(
4
"
A&
0
"
#
#0
"
1-
(
"
&
"
#
&
K
"
#
1
&
"
&
&
&
X
?
7B
&
?
&
&
CD
RR
0
1 ## "
'
#
#
&
! 6
#
'
#
#
1G &
1 (
"
4
(
.
!
$
7
&
"
"
#
&
"
#
#
#
(
D
B
L &
4
" #
1
(
3
&
V (
" 9
&
9
&
" B '
#"
A 5
4LK
&
8
3
YQ
"
(
&
5
3
'
* $ 0
" #
@
#
&
7#
L ! B U %
)Y
'
7B
K &
' *5
*
# #
1
## "
#
A#
1
*
"
&
0&
#
<
" #
5
C
+ A(
' 5
A
!
7*
'
7
#
F
7 # # (
% ## "
' *5
0 3
"
0
'
( 1N
A
#
##
F
B
#
##
## "
% &
#"
&
1/
7"
W
1/
1/ F
#
"
"
(
4
##
1/ $%
%
'
##
(
(
.
4
(
#
CC *
& A
#"
1
&
(
%
#
7
Z
' 1 7
(
"" #
(
1
! 5 # Q
5
&
A
#<#
#
#
' %
&
*
'
(
1
7
3
##
#
#
W $
&
(
6
(
#
#
#
7
"
B *
#
7
(
B
##
=
%
7
(
&
(
&
%
#
(
%
#
%
8
1
&
#
"
#
1 7
(
"
&&
"
1 ## "
5
#
(
#
K
C
'
&
#
&
&
#
(
&
& '&
(
/
&
&
1
%
#
7
0
'
#
#
%
'
%
%
#<#
1/
*5
(
A
"
-
! #
#
&
#
'<
8
#<#
%
1
*%
0
2
(
7
V
(
R-R
415
37
$
%
#
0
0
6
&
*5
%G & ## "
#
& 7
#0
#"
5 "
&
X S
(
& B
*5
##
%
1 7
1 7
#
! #
/
1L
"
#
#
&
1L
#
1 "
"
&
3
M
1
5
(
1/ "
8
1
(
*
#
"
*5
"
!
!
X
&
&
E