Revisiting the Boeing B-47 and AVRO Vulcan Configuration

AIAA 2009-6998
9th AIAA Aviation Technology, Integration, and Operations Conference (ATIO) <br>and<br>Air
21 - 23 September 2009, Hilton Head, South Carolina
!"#$
!"
## !"
$
! !"
%
! & %
$
$!
%
%&
"
'
%(
%
)*
)&
)&
'
+'
,')
.*
! ""
#"$
""
!
"
%"
"
&
"
"' "
"'(")$
' "
"'(
*
+,'()$
(" "
"
Copyright © 2009 by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Inc. All rights reserved.
'! '
#" --.--/ "
'"
$
0"$1
1.0/ "
2'$ '
$
!"'
%$!
"
'
"
$ -- 0 "
' "
$'1!%
--134
5#65"
0 $
7389
7:89'
"
"
'"
$$#
'#!
'
"
;
< % 0 "
'2'
$ -- 0 % --"
% 0
"
$
" --9
)&
0( --
0 %$
'9'%
'
$ "
%$!
"%&
'
"
"'" "
--134
5"
'
'
)
%"0
!16 .)60/
'%$!-134
5"
%"' 4
4''
%&' '
*
"'
$
$%&
'2'
)& -134$
>
"'
@
"?))
" -1349)&'
"
',- $
"
$
'A"
"
%$! 0 !!
#!
"'"A"
%
1
A"'-134
5"
$
$
"$
0
"
-134
5"
"'
"$
'$
"
0
"
' "
9
+$
'
!"
--0'
( -134 5"
' " "
"
+
'
B
!'
A" '
'$"
- "'
$ " ! "
(
# :
C $"-134 "0--134
0
:0 734'
-134
"7D7(
"'"
'"$$$'
" 11
0 '
-134""
"
" 0
$
-134A""
8'888 '$"
"1
A"
E E
!1 .?06/
*"
1 -134
0 $ , -134'
E"
0-134"%&
,?341:"$E'
":D48$ "
E'
$ 488$
"0
)* 84$F$F
$1
@
))
'?';
+G
'
*""1,
"'<,
"'0-
'B88D
(" "
"
"0
D '
84 '
C 0
%
388 '"
7D
%
C7'888$'
%" "
$"8'888$'
%"
:888$'
)06 C:888$
"%
!'-134
1 '888$$
"
" "
%)06 '
%" "
$
%
"
!'
$$$
!
0-134,"
C'888 %"" 3C8!')
8C30
%""
%
888'
""%(1%1
%
:8!
0
$
$" -134,%
$
"
"+!
(!
!"#
1$&2#
$
&()!*+,!"#
-#.,!%/!"#
0$, !"#
%&'
* +!"
("
#$
!,!
! "
!)
*5#65"
-'# 7 8 " "05#6
5"
--
'$
%
:8
0 "'
-'
7:0
'!-134'
1
"'"$'"$$
"
2'"$A"
" "
"" 11
5"
A"
7888 "
*"
1 5#65"
-
0
E"'-'
-
$" %-)-A" "
-6")!8)!8'
" 4888$8888$0)*
%
8C$F$F $0
'
777 '
3 0
"
7D3 '"
% 0
5"
%"" %
:88!'
:38!
D888 0 %
:D'888 '$
$"
8'888$'
8'888$'
%" "
73'888$')06 5"
-
8'888$B
-134'
" "
"
"%
"
!
"
%5"
9)06*
'
"
$"888
""
%)
E
5"
-
0
$
(" "
"
")!
!)!
!"#
1$&2#
$
&()!*+,!"#
-#.,!%/!"#
0$, !"#
'
'
%&'
* )!"
!)#$
!+0!
! -./
3
0
"'
$
0(5:
"
'"
01
"
"
?
9 /0 '
* "
"
0(
I
*
5"
' +0+/)!+H D
0 0( " " ' "
!
5(+JJ9
$$
;
1"
'
$""
" ""' H5 "
065J <K
"
0E" "
0&)"G
' "$"
'
" ' "
'
' '""
0 '$
0(+'$""A"!'"
'
%"
"
'%'
0"G"
%A"
'"
0"
" "
%"
0
"G" '""
'"
'
0""G
"
$'"
"$E'"$ '
' 6 " $
' "$E'"$ '
"
"
'+''"
'
0
E"G
E'"
"
"$'"'' '
I
5(+JJL5(+'
$H#JGFF
FMF5(+MF'N
:887O
K
5(+JJH9&"'#8DF8DF88:'H#JG
GFF
FMF5(+MFMM3M"9M"FN: '887O
3
(" "
"
P
'
$""
"
5(+JJ9
$ 0
$
"'
$
"'
'
'
E0 !
'E"
6
2
$! .62/'
1 $
' ;1
<$-134
5"
*
'"
")
"$
% A"
"
$
''! -
(!)
0 "$ E E'$
$
0('$"
"
"A"
! -
(
!)"',
0
0(5: $
01
0("!0
!$'
E"
$"
'
$
$0&
+!$"
+
*"
3
1!%
-134'
5"
* 1! . 1& (
*!1&
$
!
!)
$
!
0
"
9 $
"$E $
"
$
! '"*'"
"
0
"
"
-1349
"
""'' " !
%
"'$
"
" *
'
$
" ! $ -134 5"
' $ %
$
1'
"
0
" +0(
"'
0"A"
!0"
$"
"
"
$
*":
D
+ -134
5#6
5"
P
')'H(H +
-
'58'H#JGGFF
"""F1
F
FM
$
'NC 887O
:
(" "
"
G:4 GC8743 JG83 *,!"
1&
(!
GC G73D: JG77D *2!"
1&
!)!
D
(" "
"
0)& -134"C874 '":4: B
0(
'
"%
!J
" "
)& -134
88 "
%
!'
%& 0%&$
D:
'
05"
)& 73D '
" 4: J
" "
5"
78 ')&$7D88 '
%& $'
"
%& 2
0(5:'% !$"
! "
/-
0 %
-134'
"
%
-134
!
";1<
0
-1349"
%
0(*"4
-134
" B G
" "
'
"
"
; < "
$ ''
%
"
!
0 "%
"
! G%
"
!
-134"%
2'
""'
"
! " "
"
)'
! "
$ $
"
%
0 ' %" %
"
! "
E" *
' %
0(
9 $' $ 0$
"$E * !
&
,?C:+"
"/
!
-134' F
E " !1 ' " ?06 "0 "
"488$'
"
%
8888$ ""
!1 -
"
F
E
'
?06' ?34
" 0 -134
1 " :D48$'
)* 84$F$F0)*
%
Q
"
0" -134 " %
-134G
C'888$
) -134
8'888$0
G
0-13462C$$
888$
%"
'""
"%
"
!
$$$
'
%"
" -134'%"
"%
$$$
!'
%
4C'888$
%
C7'888$'
C'888$ )06
0
"
0-134"BD3.:/
' "
"
$ 0 'BD38' +9
P
$
$
"08 R*
%
)
"$0
"
" %
" 2' " A"
$ "
$> "
% ' R* 2' " $ '
R*"
0
E" '$"
"A"
0-134
P
')'H(H +
-
'58'H#JGGFF
"""F1
F
FM
$
'NC 887O
4
(" "
"
'
"
' 62
0
"9 %
"
$
0
" G
3
0
!1 $7'888 $$
"
)
84D'
""
'$
" "
+
"
J
B
"!
"
-
' ; < $' " E" ' ' '
''"
62 *"C
"
!
!
'
!!"
'
'
'
'
'
'
''
*3!"
!
B
"
*"C
'
"
'
D4'83C$ "
$"
! 0
$ "
"
"$ 62
"
0S*')06'
"
"0 " "
0"873'
%
Q
"
62 %
888"" "
' " " $ "
0 " " "$ "
)* $Q
"
"
1
'"
" ?34""
62 "$
%
4D88$ "
47C$'3Q0$"4"'
62 8"0
"
$
D'
D
0"$
!1 -134
)06
%
'888 "
E "
?06'8'3: 0"
*#
!1 '"
:8 $
'"
0
'
'
3'4 %"
"
0
:'888$'
"
8: #B-1349
3'888$
62 %
D888 $
!1"
0 "
062$
)
"$ 8C'
%"
3:!0"; <' "0 '
$
!" 12'
)
"$ 8C'
38'888 " %
DC'":8$ "'
A"E"C" 2' "' 38'
A":4$ "0
"$
:8 F" C
(" "
"
A"
$'
!'
"" ":8
$
1"
3:888 "
-134'$
" 62(
'$62
"14
/
.5!
)'*
)*
*
%+*
*-*
'
()**-*
'
'
*+**-*
'
H $' "
0
$30
0 '"
"
"'
DQ "
0" -134
0 ! '
")
"$'
"
"
0"
%"
" " *
'
'
$
"
$$$
' "%")
"$ %""
)
"$$
' $$
)
"$
"
)
"$
0 "
$5"
-134
" ' )06 0 " "' '
"4"
#$
'
%&#%'
%()*
)'*
'
'
''
'
'
'
#$
'
'
'
%&#%'
%+,
!)*(
'
'
%()*
)'*
0
" 5"
9 (((
! "
/-
!)
0 $ 5"
-
%
0
A"
$ " -134'5"
$"' 0(+
A"*"7
5#65"
" 7
(" "
"
0 " " ' " 0
'$"
$
"
-134'
"
%
$
""
; <$
"
*
'
0( 2' ' ' F "
" 5"
0(
( ' $ &
, ?C: $
-1
6")!8"$E 5"
-* 64
?C:'6")!8
"
1/!
' " "
""$E"
"''
"
?C: 6"')* 8C4
"%
6")!8
$'
'6")!8
8'888$
"'
"$
)* 8C$F$F 9)* 6")!8
%
DQ
)!8 0" 5"
"
-134905"
"
8'888$'
"
"
$)06-134'5"
%
)06 " " " ' $" )06 "%
!
-
""
)06'"
5"
"%
"
)06'
"
0
" 5"
-134
R*
H!-134'5"
"
'$"
0 "! " A"
%
0
A"%
0
:DQ '$
'
%
B88'$
B888C :Q0BD38C
%
' 7Q ,
9% 9
'
0(0
$
'
$
-134'
"
"R*
%
" -134' $
"R*
" (
E"'5"
9
'
"
'A"
7
-1340%
5"
T
"
$
'
" G
3
0
!1 $3':88 $$
"
)
8C'
""
$
" "
+
"
J
'
;< 5"
$'"
E"
' ' ''"
62 0 "5"
;
<
"(
E" 62*"8
"
'
'
E"'0
$:
"
"62
8
(" "
"
'
!
!
!!"
'
'
'
'
'
'
''
'
''
'
'
'
'
*+0!"
!
0
!1 62
%
D888 Q
!1 DC "$A"4844$ "'62 %
4888$>
Q0$
$$ $ 62$
%
88
3 $3':88 '
"
C7
: $0
Q
'
8Q0"'9$
$
"
0" 5"
9
"'
0"
'
-134'
D'
88
5"
T 62'
Q
0 ' "":83'
4
'
" 0 "" 88"
)06 %
43'888$'
0"5"
$!
"
)
"$"
$'
$"
$
0 "
62"
$0
62
"
'$" ""062 )
8C4
% 8! '
3 :D
"'
"
9 37">
620
"
"'$"" " "!
"
5"
'"
$
62(
' "
",4
/
.5!
'
'
!
34
'
'
H
$'
"
0
$D0
0 '"
"
"'
DQ "
0" 5"
0 '! -134'!
'
")
"$'
"
" 0"
%"
" " B
"A"
*
'
'
$
"
$$$
' "%")
"$ %"")
"$$
'
$$
)
"$
")
"$
0 "
$ 5"
-134 "'
)060"
"'
'
(" "
"
"24"
!
#$
'
%&#%'
%()*
)'*
'
'
'
'
#$
'
'
'
'
'
''
%&#%'
%+,
!)*(
'
'
%()*
)'*
'''! -/
0 -1349 5"
9
"
!1
'$'
"
-
!1 '5"
! DC '
-134A"83: >
5"
38Q"
-13405"
" -134
!1 G
?34-134
+' %
87""
" E?06'
5"
$
+' 8'38Q
'5"
9
%
48Q
-13490"
)06
') :$F C$F 5"
-134
0$ 5"
" -134$
*"
"'
""
)06"$
!1 )06 $
0" *"
$ 0
$
5"
% :888 F'
-134
%
888 F
0
*"
$
' ""
0
$
"
"'5"
"
" " )*
(" "
"
*++!
!
%
*"'
$
!1 $
'
"
+' -134 5"
" "
!1 '
$
2'5"
!
-134"
$
"
"
:8Q -1349')
0 0
$ 3 D -134 5"
' ' 1
*"
*+)!
!
0
%
(+1 '$!
$"0
%"
A"
'7:Q-134'
74Q5"
0
-134
5"
%
:88
$2'
(" "
"
'-134
Q
'C$!
"4CB
"
Q
$
0 '
1
"$A"
*"" "0
$3
D(
$!"
" ""
" "
$
")
"$
* +1! "
$ $ !
0-134 " $
0
$3
D'
"2'
$
"6"
"5"
" ""
-134
B
-134
"")* "
0 "((" $!
$!
*"3
$!
" $! $
'*":
$! " $!
0-134
$
D8
3:!05"
43
33!"
$
$
A"
'-1349$!DQ0$!
$"-1349" %"
05"
T$
$-134$
" $
"
'
5"
T " F "A" "
( -134
A" "*
5"
'*"3"!
$
$
-134
"' " $ $ $! 0 -134 "
""
'"$
$
B
$" """-1349
"
$!
'$! " " -134"!$
$ ")*
"
*
'$
-134'
5"
*"
3
-134
"")
"$'
5"
! 0-13462 $
$
( %"
"$)
84
)
84D'
CC!
3:!
*"32'
-1349
A"
$0 "
"$" )
8CD
62
(
$$ -134 ""
3
(" "
"
*+!"
$
$
!
*+,!"
$ $
!
*"D"
"
$ $
0
$$
62
0-134
"
CD"
$! :C!0
")
"$ 8D:0
)
"$" )
"$ "
)
"$ 8D:'"
-1344D!
38888 '
7:!062
88
!
:888 '
%
:8!"
062$"
8!
$
)06
"
05"
" 44"
$! 3!0
")
"$ 8C'
" 3:C!
:8888 0
"7!05"
9
627:!
$"
:
(" "
"
*+2!"
$
!
0"
-134
"
5"
9'' -134$
$" ""E" '$)*"
5"
-134" -134"
""
$$!
"
")
"$'*"40
*"4" '
)
"$
'A"
"
*+!$ !
0 "$-134
5"
*"405"
Q
"
-134
A"
0 "
"'
5"
9
2'"-134
A"
"
5"
'"$
$""
'
$!
'
B
$
! '
$
-134
5"
D
(" "
"
'! &
*
! "
/-
0 $-134
5"
%
388 '
$":Q'
48Q
5"
-1342
-134 "A"'88 '%&D:'
05"
9%&
+%$!
$A" ' 5"
-134
405"
9
$
'
%
:':Q
-134
' 47C0 %& 5"
%
8Q
-13490 ' ' %& "
"'$"
' 0 $
$:Q
$ ' :Q "
0"
((("
$-134
5"
'
((-A"
$
"
$62 $
'
5"
9 !- % )*
"$
2'$
"
"$""0
" ' ! .'
&
*'
" $
G
-134
" '
5"
"
">A"!$
"
"
-134'
!
"+'"$0"
-134" $
' )* )' +' " -1349$!'
"'
A"
!1 0
%
$ &
,?341:"$E
-16")!80
'
E
""
'?34$
E"E
0 " $! " $ -134 ! ' 5"
0
-134
$
; < 5"
05"
"" -134"
!1 05"
T
$F)
+'
"
$
"
--" "
")06
0 ' +' A" *"" --
0""A"
'
+F )*
$-134
5"
" 0 "G
""
5"
-134
%
)06 '
'
"
-- 0
"
$0-134
"0'
5"
" > $
% $
$
" $
$ '
"
("
'
"'
! 0 A"
A" $
' " $" E ( 1' '
A"
"
$
'
$1
4
(" "
"
! $
0
--134
5#65"
"
0(5: $
"
'
$ " %$!2'
$ 1
1
,"
%&'
F
0+
$
"
0$
$
$
"
'
'
'$'
!1 '
"$"
$!
0
""
$-134
5"
'
$11$ "$1 "
-
' ! "$1
'"'
!1 '
! $ 2' $11$
"
$
$ ('
'"
$"E!$ "$1 "
'
!1 A"
B
$
$11$ "
' "
"$!'%"
$
0 "
!5(+JJ "0
"
!+
#$ 5"
!0" 5#65"
;0--'<BJ
#
'*1774184131J
#'2
'5'?"774
#
'+' #30 4440 /'3'(,"
'#'5'
#!
'?';
+HA" "
'<)504 + /00#0 5-400'CC:','
''67CC
3
0(5:'+ !
'5:'+
"'
2'
:
-
'J./'67/07 '7:417:C')&
12-!
'BU!'BU
D
5(+3'
'53'5(+JJ'-
!$"'5
4
'-J'8+"+ /00#5
009#4 '8814'('+
'62'?"88
C
;*2
$!'H*-134-V-134,
06-134,1<'7::'H
'J"')6
7
<5"
-)!)
"
8-1781:<''748
8
;5"
- '<#
*12'H#JGFF
"!FMF '
N?
7887O
?'#0./'67/07 '7DC17D7')&
12-!
'BU!'BU
,
'#';6
-134'<*#/'5:'?
"
7:4':1D
C
(" "
"