Mise en garde contre les innovations
Transcription
Mise en garde contre les innovations
! ! ! " ! ! " # ! $ ' % ( % & % & ! & !! " ) $ # " $ + ! ! ! ( * , & $ , ! # " ! ! ! * , .. !! % / & ) ) ! " % # $ # $& ' $ ! ( & $& " , & ! $ " /# #"$ .. ! & ! ( 0 % & && % ) & & ! & ' + , "* ) #- .% !! ! " '1 2 & && ! / ) % ) & ! & && ! )3 "- 45 " 689:" / 7 )3 "0 ) 89 '; <" - && ! * 6 55" " " ) !) 3 " - ' & ' % ) ! !1 =& ; ! & ) # $! 11 ' && ) 2 ! .. ! & 0 + , *" & ' % ! . ! . % !% & 0 & !& ! 3 ) #4 & + .% & 43 &% &+ & !& 1 5 6!, & ! !" & ! ! &,' &$ & &+ !& ! , ! & &7 & . &2 !& & & 0 & & ! + , / 3 ! & 0& 9 *" ! & !"8 ) #: 5 !' ) 2) & & )& & & ! !1 ' 23 + , ! *" !(! ! ( $ ) ' *" $ " 0 ) 6 '> " 0 ) -- " 0 ) 9 '= 7 " 0 ) 8 '*@ ' 5- " ?@ " ::" -" 6 ," !! ! * $ !! # $ ! A " % $ $ $ $ ! $ ! ! ". $ $ ! ! ! $ * # ! ," * ! $ ! ! ! ! # !! # * " & @ $ B! ) ) * + - * & , *% . / " . / " . ! ! " * 4! % & ! !! ! " /& !) 3 " 6 6865" 8 & ! ! !! * # !(! $ + ! ! !! $ ' ! " * " . !" * $. ! $ $ $ C * ! !! "D !(! % & $ $ , $ !! ! ) ( + * ! 0 * * ! * ! ," B !(! ! + $ ! " % '! ! & $ !! # , !, * + ! " # ! ! ! $ $ ! " " * !) 3 " 448" 5 ! & E# # 0 , " # #; ) & & ! & 9 < && / && && / . &% !! ! " $! & & & % % & ' ( / && '& & ! 2 = ! "> & & + , ! & ! 1 ! *" ) ! =& ) #? & & ! &' 5 + , *" ! ! / > $ $ ! $. * $. $ !! 0 * $ $ $ . $ " 0 ) 6 '> @ " 0 ) 6 '0 * 89" @ < :" " " , * ! $ # # # ! ! # + ! $ " $ ! ! C ( $ + ! "0 ! ! ! ! # # ! " 0 $ $ ( $ C * " B ( ! ! E ! F ! + + #$ = & & & ! !&' ) &/ & 3 0 ! '% = !) ! @ & & 1 & 5 1& / & 0 &" = & @ & + , & &A & % &" * '% #? " !! ) ) 5 .% & ! & + & ! ) "* ! '1 " 4 , ' / $ # # !! # ! ' , ! ' !, # !! ! !! $ ! "% ! ! + * !! ! ! $ + $ * 1 !! # , + # $ # $ ! $ E # % & $ ' !! " / * $ ) 2 $ . " ' .. + " ) 3 + 0 " " # , + 4 0 5 ) . ? * 5 ' * + )3 " #@! 5" -: 9" 9 ! ! ) . 1A2 @ # * 0 #. A G ! & 0 + ! * $ # $ ! $ , ! , ! !! , & !! & " . #! & ! ! "0 A ! H "> $ @ $( ! # ! ," $ ! / !(! ! * $ , " & # " 0 ! * + $ ! !! J ! I # C J ! + @! $ " * I & ! !! " '* $! '1 2 )3 "6 586" : ) #$ &' 0& ' & % & !' & " $!& && & && ' 2 + , &" * ) 4 7 6 4 ' + 0 ! !(! % ! J ! ! & ! ! $ I "0 ! ! " ! $ 0 $ + " 0# ! # $ " % ! * ! H " " 0 ) * !) 3 " 6 '* #! A 8588" ! = % 8' 5" ) # ? & ! & 9@ & % & ! & @ 0 7B + , && + , "* && & &% !& ) # % " 0 & $ * % & ! ! ! & " !(! & " ! ! ! % $ $ & & + !! " 3 ' .8 * +' * 3 .8 . * ' " % 2 " + " " 0 * 9 " * ) -'> K@E) 3 " , ' ?@ *% 0 * 85" 8" #" $ % $ & ' ( &) , * ! ! " # ! #8 - 0. * 0# # # # !! * # # ! ' " # & +2 " , ! ' ) /> &% & ' % ? & ! ' 1 / &% !& ! 3 ! - ? ! ( %& ' 1! 1 !'> . % ! & ! ! ! , + & &7 & % "* + , % , & L # &! # #. & " # ! % ! & & ! " 0 !! ! "0 & ! ! + # #. ," " L #8 - 0. - ! ! ! " 0 #! + # !! % ! ! " % ! & " !(! ! , ! ! #! # 0 ! " 0 ) ( "0 # < '. @ & # " 6 % + ! # " ! !! * # # ! ! !! + ! " # % ". ! ! & + ! # " ! ! % # ! # ! ". & ! ! ! ! ! " A " #. % " & ! + ! + ! " % # # ! + ! #. !" / . ! @! & ' !@ # ) 8 # , ! " #: 5 !' ) ' 2) & & )& & & !1 ' 23 + , !" * ! ' 0 A@) #< ! ! ( & & && & +/ ,% ! . & & & &% 3 !3 5 & & &C< '& 3 A & 1 !3 ! ! ' 11 " & + , & !5 & & ! ! & 0 ! !" * * # ! ! # 0 & &' ! " !! # " % ! M N # & '1 2 # !! !N # * O M & % & ) * .& " " " 0 0 -! * ) ) '1 2 6 55" 8 '*@ 6 '0 )3 " - 5 -" @ " 45 " * !) 3 " - / ) # . ' 6! D * # & % & ! # & I@ ) ( 6 + * & 'G. @ , ! 0 * * * 8! . @ ! # )M H # Q0 % & , ," > E! ) P * , # "/ " . ) M4 . . ' / . : % E ( . * . ' " ; # $ # $& ' " " * * $ !) 3 " !) 3 " & ! ( % $& 6 5<" 448" < 5! !(! # ! ! ! ! * ! # " 0 , + ! + ! ," ! $ ! ! $ # + + # ! " ! ! ! ! # "/ ! ! ! # #: 5 ) ' 2) ! *" 0 * # + , , ) & ! " " : " 0 / 7 )3 " 689:" 6-" . * + )3 " ) 8 '*@ -" 4 = ! 6 " )3 " I# & '! # + #8 - 0. # ! # # # #. !" / !(! # & ! ! ! #. ! +# ! & ! ! ! & !! 3 ' * ! # # " . * .' " . * ' .& . 0 < . ' 6 #. ! 0 , *% 0 * # 9 6 " * " +," ) ! " R % & # * !! % & , * ! " ) #: 5 !' ) ' 2) & & )& & & ! !1 ' 23 + , !" * . ) #< ! ( & & && ! . & & !3 5 & & &C< '& 3 A ! ! ' 11 & !5 & & ! ! & 0 " " 0 0 !' ) ) 8 6 '*@ '0 : & +/ ,% & &% 3 & 1 !3 " & DE ! !" * -" @ " & &' . * # !! M & !N & % M '1 2 @ N ) # & O * .& -:! * / ) # . ' - ! * % ! & ! * * # & +@ ! + ) ( 6 + 6 0 * * * * - ! ! , & ! " " " " ! !! " / !(! % & ! % & '1 2 )3 " 6 55" * !) 3 " * !) 3 " # ! # # & ! # ! !! , # 45 " 6 5<" 448" * !) 3 " - # !! !! & ( ! + "0 !(! " ! ! ! % , # !! & " 0# , # . S @ '= & #. ! + ! ! ! A E + A 0 @! !! # " % ! # ? ! + A " . " % #* . - + # ! # ! & ' # ! ! " # ! !! ! " > ' ". D % ! */ 0 @ @ ! & % # # ' " ! # ? #* . ! ' ! " % ! # , ! ';@ 6 - , . # $0 .- J + ". ! # # " 8&! # #* . - ! + 0 " & # @ # , = ! ! . "I ! + #! ! # A ' ? " # ! ! + # % & " 0# + ! , ! , , ( ( # + " = ! 0 ( " 0 !! ) - #; ) ! & & ! & 9 < && / && && / . &% !! ! " $! & & & % % & ' ( / && '& & ! 2 = ! "> & & + , ! & ! 1 ! *" . ) #? & & ! &' 5 + , "* . ! .8 #=& ? & & ! & - ) '& + , ! / ( !! & ! ' & &" * . ) # & ! ! 9 :@ !? ! 9 &! ! & && ! &% 3 &! 3 5 & & &' % 3 & !3 ! ! && % & &% 3 & & & ! 0 + , & ! ! ," * " " " " 0 0 0 0 ) ) ) ) 6 6 6 '> @ '0 '.! @ '> @ 6 89" @ :" - " 58" & ! & ! ! ! ' % ! +/ !(! . ! 0 + ! ! ," # "0 ! # , ! , !! ! ! ! ' ;@ # J + ! & =@ # % * 2 8&! , # ! $0 .- 6 'D !@ ! & ' ' " */ G ! # #* . # !(! ! "D + + )M & T @ ! * # @ ! " # + , # F & + ". # , # , ! # /# ; +@? + ! ,' 1 " + ! , G @ * 2 J !@ U * F # ! ! *@ 2 " 8 # ! # # & % 'D */ K ) !& T @ # # !! ! ! !@ * # ! "% ! # ! & 2 C J@ 7 # ". @ # , , + ' ! # "0 !@ ) M 0 'T ! -. * ; , &! ! # ! & ! 0 % ! # # ' 7?@#E #.!@! + */ " 0 # 'D V # !@! ! ! * . - " % # !@! ! # # , ( " / # 0 ! + # & "= 5 & E ? &! , F " " !! ! 'J !@ W ?E " ! #* . # !! & # =- . % ? &! # % !(! # ! */ " N =- . ' 7 + ! 'D . ;@ J + # ! + #* . + # # # ' " ! % ? &! ! ". , ! & ! " R # ' 7?@#E ! L ! ';@ ! J + " #! # !! ! !(! & ! 0 % & + " ! #( ! # # ! ! # ! ! ) ' # * !) 3 " - . -<! 6 5<" < " #.!@! A 1 2 '= A E # ! ; 7@ 7 1 # N) . S @ ! ) M> # + #* . * 2 A 8&! ! "N # > ! O #* . )M @ + # ! . ! )M A* 2 8 ! N + ! N ! ! "N U # M ' X 7@ )M P Q0 8&! )M & #* . X@ ! , # ! # !! " , &! ' ' '.2 @ , "" " N 0 ! ' " '0 72@ E ! * +! # U &! + # # M ' U &! ! " E ! , '0 72@ E 4 # M '* 2 N) M &! 8 #* . ; @ # & #* . 8&! + A ? + N & !E & . "N M ' #@ E# N) M 0 ? #* . '.2 @ , ! """ ! " . / + ," G )M ? # "N . ? ' .2 @ ! & " ) M & & ? = ! !! # M #. @# N ! , , & " & #* . 8&! + !! # ! & "0 # = ! E # & % #* . - & ! O & 8&! L ! > ! " 0 & O 9 9 . # " / !(! G + # ! & "N. + !! # ' ;@ & & # 8&! % & > 7@7E & & & 'G. @ E #* . # ! M ' * +! # N) M ! M $ *-< ? & * & ! ! ? &! ! & F & % ( & R A N M . @ B A!' '/E ! ! " / !(! & ! ( + " & " ** . , "N ! M RA ' ' ! !! ' N , !@! !! " & ! " 2 .! O L ! J !@ , # !@! '* & # E A * ! !! & ! & " ! -: ! + "% , '( ! 8&! + " #* . - + A ? ! + # C " ! #. ! & ! # !! # #. #: 5 ) 2) !' ! !1 & &' 23 + , !"* & & )& % !(! # & ) + "* ) * .& -9! * !(! 0 # & " / ) % ; ** & ) " " 0 ) '1 2 6 55" 8 '*@ )3 " - - -" 45 " * !) 3 " - 3 ? / ? ? # " 6:! * ! #! + ! # % 0 !! + L !! & " % & ! ! "/ #! # " / # # J ! ! / F % '!(! 9 1*- & " % * M **0 & ) !) 3 " 865" - M & !! ** $ # 7 . * * * * 6 ! * # #* . 7 8&! ! !& ! 0. - #8 - % !! '!(! " ! # , ! # # , # 3 , ! & & " ? ! ! ! 8&! 7 # % ! # + ! ! , & # #* . - & "D #. , !" / !(! !! <&! 7 #8 . # "/ !! 0. + " '1 2 & ( ( ( " # )3 " -5" -- !(! # Q # " % 0. - # # # # ! #8 . <7 " & # ) ! - 3 ) ' 0 * . .8 * . ' ' ' " 2 " * 0 " 0 0 * , # -6 *% !! ', ) # % ' & ) # " ) #8 0. - '= % ? &! ! # ) # ! ) -" . # # #* . - ) -8 :" !