F13-1011 - Association for Computational Linguistics

Transcription

TALN-RÉCITAL 2013, 17-21 Juin, Les Sables d’Olonne
!"#$%&'(")*+"*!,-*".*#/01()*1/(0*23#&4&."0*4")*
2/05(43.&/%)*"%*3%643&)*)#&"%.&2&'("*7#0&.
!"#$%&'"()%*+",-(%./*0"(#"*1"#23%))/*4,5$))%*6")"$.%7
8/9*:;$<=*>#%;?@)%*4)A%.B*:+6*C*0DED0F!B*6&GHIJI*>#%;?@)%
8G9*:;$<=*>#%;?@)%*4)A%.B*:'!6*C*0D>&>FK40'B*6&GHIJI*>#%;?@)%
!"#$%&'(#)*&+,#-.)&/0*#)$#+1#$23&**45),6'7$&89:*&+6$0;
#-1%**&+6#*#%/&5%"#7+6$
LMN:!MOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
P?(. * A#Q.%;2?;. * )R"S"A2"2$?; * S% * )" * @".% * SRQ,#$2. * .,$%;2$T$-(%. * %; * )$U;%*
N,$%;2%V2*A?(#*(;*W*;?(<%"(*X*A(@)$,*Y*,5%#,5%(#.*%2*"(2#%.*"(2%(#.*T#";Z"$.*
SRQ,#$2.*.,$%;2$T$-(%.B*"[";2*@%.?$;*S%*#QS$U%#*%;*";U)"$.=*\%22%*"S"A2"2$?;*"*
,?;.$.2Q * ] * "^?(2%# * S";. * )" * @".% * S%. * #%-(_2%. * A#Q,?SQ%. * -($ * A%#`%22%;2*
SR"TT$,5%# * )%. * ,?;2%V2%. * S";. * )%.-(%). * )%.* "(2%(#. * SR"#2$,)%. * .,$%;2$T$-(%. * %;*
";U)"$. * %VA#$`%;2 * )%(# * ?@^%,2$T * S% * #%,5%#,5% * %2 * ] * %;#$,5$# * )R$;2%#T",%*
N,$%;a(%.2 * S% * ;?(<%))%. * T?;,2$?;;")$2Q. * A?(# * `Q`?#$.%# * %2 * #Q"TT$,5%# * )%.*
,?;2%V2%.*A%#2$;%;2.B*A?(#*T",$)$2%#*)"*,?;.()2"2$?;*A"#*(;*A(@)$,*A)(.*)"#U%=*0%.*
;?`@#%(.%. * S%.,#$A2$?;. * )$;U($.2$-(%. * S% * )" * #5Q2?#$-(% * S%. * "#2$,)%.*
.,$%;2$T$-(%.*$;.$.2%;2*.(#*)R$À?#2";,%*S%*)"*,#Q"2$?;*%2*S%*)R?,,(A"2$?;*SR(;%*
W*;$,5%*X * S% * #%,5%#,5%= * \5%#,5%(#. * %2 * S?,2?#";2. * ?;2 * $,$ * (; * `?[%; * SR%;*
<$.(")$.%# * S%. * %V%À)%. * .";. * ,?;;"b2#% * ." * T?#`()"2$?; *! " #$%&$%B * <$" * ;?.*
#%-(_2%.= * P?2#% * Q<")("2$?; * .(# * )% * ,?#A(. * S% * 2%.2 * %; * S?;;% * (;% * A#Q,$.$?;*
U)?@")%*S%*HcBd*e=
4fNKL4\KOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
8-9 * 3%+ * #/01() * ."#$%&'(") * 2/0 * 2&%+&%6 * 2/05(43.&/%) * .$3. * 23#&4&.3."*
)#&"%.&2&#*:0&.&%6*&%*;%64&)$
K5$. * A"A%# * A#%.%;2. * "S"A2"2$?;. * ?T * 25% * -(%#[ * ?A2$?;. * $;2%U#"2%S * $;2? * 25%*
?;)$;% * ,?#A(. * N,$%;2%V2 * .? * ". * 2? * @%22%# * .%#<% * " * ;%3 * "(S$%;,%Y * 6#%;,5*
.,$%;2$.2. * 3#$2$;U * $; * F;U)$.5= * g% * "SS%S * A#%&,?S%S * -(%#$%. * 25"2 * S$.A)"[ * 25%*
,?;2%V2.*$;*35$,5*"(25?#.*?T*.,$%;2$T$,*"#2$,)%.*$;*F;U)$.5*.2"2%*25%$#*#%.%"#,5*
?@^%,2$<%=*6(#25%#`?#%B*;%3*T(;,2$?;")*?A2$?;.*%;#$,5*25%*N,$%;a(%.2*$;2%#T",%*
"))?3$;U*#%.()2.*2?*@%*T$)2%#%S*T?#*;?$.%*";S*25%;*."<%S*T?#*,?;.()2"2$?;*@[*"*
)"#U%#*A(@)$,=
'#%<$?(.*.2(S$%.*?;*25%*.,$%;2$T$,*S$.,?(#.%*";S*#5%2?#$,*?T*.,$%;2$T$,*"#2$,)%.*
5"<% * 5$U5)$U52%S * 25% * $À?#2";,% * ?T * %.2"@)$.5$;U * ";S * ?,,(A[$;U * " * #%.%"#,5*
;$,5%= * 1%#%B * T#";,?A5?;% * #%.%"#,5%#. * ";S * S?,2?#") * .2(S%;2. * 3$25?(2 * A#$?#*
S$.,(#.$<%*h;?3)%SU%B*,";*",,%..*"(25%;2$,*";S*`()2$A)%*3"[.*?T*T?#`()"2$;U*
" * #%.%"#,5 * ?@^%,2$<%= * i(# * %<")("2$?; * ?T * " * 2%.2 * ,?#A(. * .5?3%S * "; * ?<%#"))*
",,(#",[*?T*Hc=d*e=*
!iKN&\0MN*Y*";U)"$.B*A"2#?;.*)%V$,?&.[;2"V$-(%.B*N,$%;a(%.2B*N,$%;2%V2=
jFkgiLEN*Y*FN'B*)%V$,?&.[;2",2$,*A"22%#;.B*N,$%;a(%.2B*N,$%;2%V2=
146
c ATALA
�
!
"#$%&'()$*&#
!"# $ %&"'%&"('# $ ") $ *"(+"# $ %&"'%&"('#, $ -(".." $ -(" $ #/0) $ ."(' $ 10#%02.0+", $ #/+)$
34"+5#$6$2'/1(0'"$1"#$5%'0)#$#%0"+)070-("#$"+$3+8.30#,$+"$#"'30)9%"$-("$2/('$."$
'5#(45$1"$."('#$3')0%."#:$;0$13+#$%"')30+"#$10#%02.0+"#,$+/)344"+)$."#$#%0"+%"#$
10)"#$<$1('"#$=,$.3$-(3.0)5$1"$.3$.3+8("$+>"#)$23#$."$2'"40"'$3))"+1(,$0.$'"#)"$
+5%"##30'"$1"$43?)'0#"'$."#$7/'4(.3)0/+#$23'$."#-(".."#$#"$43+07"#)"$.>322/')$
#0+8(.0"'$1"$.>3')0%.",$%3'$".."#$"+$%/+#)0)("+)$#/(@"+)$.3$<$@0)'0+"$=$-(0$301"$."#$
."%)"('#$2/)"+)0".#$6$15%01"'$#0$.>3')0%."$@3()$."$)"42#$1>(+"$."%)('":
A"2"+13+),$."#$%/425)"+%"#$1"#$3()"('#$#%0"+)070-("#$#/+)$#('$%"$2/0+)$)'B#$
@3'03C."#$")$."#$%&"'%&"('#$-(0$+"$#/+)$23#$23'$30.."('#$#25%03.0#)"#$1"$.3+8(" $
")$1"$.0))5'3)('"$+>/+)$23#$+5%"##30'"4"+)$.3$10#2/+0C0.0)5$1"$#"$%/+#3%'"'$6$(+$
322'"+)0##38" $ 7/'4"., $ )/() $ "+ $ 3D3+) $ C"#/0+ $ 1" $ 15)"'40+"' $ .3 $ 7/'4(.3)0/+$
322'/2'05": $ E3' $ "F"42.", $ ."# $ -("#)0/+# $ -(0 $ 2"(@"+) $ #" $ 2/#"' $ ./'# $ 1" $ .3$
'513%)0/+$%/+%"'+"+)$."#$"F2'"##0/+#$&3C0)(".."#$1"$.>/C*"%)07$1"$.3$'"%&"'%&",$
1"# $ &D2/)&B#"# $ 1"# $ %&"'%&"('#, $ 1"# $ '575'"+%"# $ 3(F $ )'3@3(F $ 3+)5'0"('#, $ 1"$
.>322/')$#25%070-("$1"$.3$'"%&"'%&"$13+#$."$%&342$10#%02.0+30'",$")%:
G/(#$15%'0@/+#$0%0$.>3132)3)0/+$6$%"$)D2"$1"$C"#/0+$1>(+"$'"##/('%"$"+$.08+",$
.3$C3#"$1>5%'0)#$#%0"+)070-("#$;%0"+)"F)$HI()0+$!"#$%,$JKKL$M#N3.30#"#!"#$%&,$JKOO3,$
I()0+$!"#$%&'#6$23'3?)'"(:$G/(#$3@/+#$()0.0#5$."#$/()0.#$")$)"%&+0-("#$1($IP!$")$1"$
.3 $ .0+8(0#)0-(" $ 1" $ %/'2(# $ 2/(' $ "+'0%&0' $ .3 $ C3#" $ 1" $ '"-(Q)"# $ 3@3+%5"#, $ 2'59
%/15"#$")$40#"#$6$10#2/#0)0/+ $ 2/('$.3$#5."%)0/+$1" $%/+)"F)"#$#('$ 1"#$C3#"#$
)*+",)-.,9/+0$1"-23!/:$!3$1/(C."$23')0%(.3'0)5$1"$%"#$'"-(Q)"#$"#)$-("$1>(+"$
23') $ ".."# $ #/+) $ 7/+15"# $ #(' $ ."# $ 10775'"+)# $ )'3@3(F $ '".3)07# $ 6 $ .>/'83+0#3)0/+$
'&5)/'0-("$1($)"F)"$#%0"+)070-("$2/('$2'/2/#"'$(+"$"+)'5"$<$23'$.3$7/+%)0/+$=$
") $ +/+ $ <$23' $ .3 $ 7/'4"$=, $ 1>3()'" $ 23') $ ".."# $ )0'"+) $ 23')0 $ 1" $ .3 $ 2(0##3+%"$
1>"F2'"##0/+$3()/'0#5"$23'$.>3++/)3)0/+$1"#$)"F)"#$"+$'".3)0/+#$#D+)3F0-("#,$%"$
-(0$2"'4")$1"$#>377'3+%&0'$1"$@3'03)0/+#$.05"#$6$.3$.0+53'0)5$")$1>"F2'04"'$1"#$
152"+13+%"#$"+)'"$."#$10775'"+)#$5.54"+)#$%/+#)0)(3+)$.3$%0C."$@0#5":
!>0+)5'Q) $ 1>(+" $ '"%&"'%&" $4-$$ .3 $ 7/+%)0/+ $ '&5)/'0%/9#543+)0-(" $ "#) $ 1"$
2"'4"))'" $ 3( $ %&"'%&"(' $ 1>08+/'"' $$ # 5)-,)-$ ." $ @/%3C(.30'" $ 6 $ "42./D"' $ ") $ 1"$
15%/(@'0' $ ."# $ %/+#)'(%)0/+# $ 2/##0C."# $ 6 $ )'3@"'# $ ."# $ "F"42."# $ 3()&"+)0-("#$
3(F-(".# $ (+" $ '"-(Q)" $ .(0 $ 2"'4") $ 1>3%%51"': $ E3' $ "F"42.", $ .>/C*"%)07 $ 1"$
'"%&"'%&" $ #>5+/+%" $ 3(##0 $ C0"+ $ #/(# $ .3 $ 7/'4" $67!)!' # 8! # -14!/"-9$"! # "*! #
!4,%3"-,1 # ,: # ,1! # ,: # "*! # 0,/" # /")-;-19 # !<$05%!/ # ,: # /!<3$% # .,1:%-." # -1 #
*!)0$5*),=-"!/&&&> #-("$R?*!#$-0#,:#"*-/#/"3=@#8$/#",#!<$0-1!#"*!#!::!."#,: #
,.!$1 # .%-0$"! # ,1# :,)$9-19 # /3..!// # -1# "*-/ # =!!5A=-4-19 # 0$)-1! # 0$00$% # &&&>:$
G/(#$+/(#$7/%3.0#/+#$0%0$2.(#$23')0%(.0B'"4"+)$#('$.3$7/'4(.3)0/+$1"$.>/C*"%)07$
1"$'"%&"'%&",$6$#/08+"'$6$.3$7/0#$23'%"$-(>".."$"#)$85+5'3."4"+)$1/(C."4"+)$
2'5#"+)",$13+#$."#$'5#(45#$")$13+#$.>0+)'/1(%)0/+$1"$.>3')0%.",$")$23'%"$-(>".."$
#08+3."$.3$#25%070%0)5$1"$.3$'"%&"'%&"$-(0$730)$.>/C*")$1"$.>3')0%."$13+#$."$%&342$
10#%02.0+30'":
G/)'"$3')0%."$#"$#)'(%)('"$30+#0$S$13+#$(+$2'"40"'$)"42#,$+/(#$"F2/#/+#$."#$
)'3@3(F$#('$.3$'&5)/'0-("$1"$.>3')0%."$#%0"+)070-("$")$.3$73T/+$1/+)$0.#$/+)$15*6$
5)5$"F2./0)5#$13+#$."$%31'"$1($IP!:$E(0#$+/(#$"F2.0%0)/+#$."#$C"#/0+#$3(F-(".#$
147
c ATALA
�
!"#$% & $%''"($)% & %! & *+,!% & -%(# & $./"!0$%1 & 2!3+! & !"(' & 0.)$+-"!' & %# & .-4*("!'&
!"#$%&#$4-4+*&05%!$+)6+''%7%!#&0%&8)+%!#%9#1
!
"#$%&'()*+,('*-&'.'/0*+*&+,*,+.1-(&'1-,+%23&1%'/0*,
:%/(+' & *;.#(0% & %7/+$+<(% & 0% & 8+!)*4+$= & >"!%' & %# & :4*%? & 04!' & *%' & 4!!.%'& @ABC&
DECCFG=&/(+'&*%'&#$4-4(9&0%&8H4*%'&D@AACIECCFG=&*%'&)4$4)#.$+'#+<(%'&0(&,%!$%&
!"#$%&' ( )%$'*#$+$,-'& "!# & .#. & %9/*"$.%' & '%*"! & 0%' & 49%' & 0+-%$'&J & -4$+4#+"!'&
*%9+)4*%' & %!#$% & 4$#+)*%' & 0% & $%)6%$)6% & %# & 4(#$%' & #?/%' & 05.)$+#' & ')+%!#+3+<(%'&
DK"(04# & %# & L"**%##%= & EC@EG= & '/.)+3+)+#.' & *%9+)4*%' & 0% & )%$#4+!%' & '%)#+"!' & M & /4$&
%9%7/*% & *5%7/*"+ & 0% & )%$#4+!' & -%$N%' & 04!' & *%' & $.'(7.' & DO4$#H%**= & EC@P=&
O4$#H%**&%#&>4)<(%'&EC@EG&"(&*4&'4+**4!)%&0;+#%7'&*%9+)4(9&DQ*%06+**=&ECCCG&M= &
.-"*(#+"! & 0%' & R&/4##%$!'&S & *%9+)"T,$4774#+)4(9 & '%*"! & *%' & '%)#+"!' & 04!' & 0%'&
4$#+)*%' & 0% & N+"7.0%)+!% & D84N%$= & EC@EG= & "( & %!)"$% & /"'+#+"!!%7%!# & %# & 4(#"T
$%/$.'%!#4#+"! & DO?*4!0= & ECCF&U & O?*4!0= & EC@EG= & R&-"+9&S & 0% & *54(#%($ & '%*"! & *4&
0+')+/*+!%&DL*V##(7=&W+!!&%#&:46*=&ECCXG111&Y"+!&054-"+$&+!-%!#"$+.&*4&#"#4*+#.&0%'&
#$4-4(9 & )"!'4)$.' & Z & *5.)$+# & ')+%!#+3+<(%= & /4$#+)(*+[$%7%!# & %! & R&4!,*4+' & 0%&
'/.)+4*+#.&S= & *%' & $.3.$%!)%' & <(+ & /$.)[0%!# & !% & 0"!!%!# & <(5(! & 4/%$\( & 0% & *%($&
3"+'"!!%7%!#1 & ]%*(+T)+ &#+%!#& '4!'& 0"(#% & 4(& 34+#& <(%=& /"($ &(! &')+%!#+3+<(%= & *4&
74+#$+'% & 0( &.$)%/-")& %# & 0%' &0'*"') (4''")+.' & D^4'#+%$= & ECC@G & /4$#+)+/% & 0% & *4&
)"7/.#%!)%&0%&)6%$)6%($1&2!&"(#$%=&'+&*5"!&%!&)$"+#&K"!#+**%&DECCBG=&04!'&*%'&
')+%!)%' & %9/.$+7%!#4*%'= & *4 & !"$74*+'4#+"! & 0% & *4 & '#$()#($% & 0% & *;4$#+)*% & 0%&
$%)6%$)6% & 4 & 4))"7/4,!. & *4 & 3+94#+"! & 0% & *4 & 0.74$)6% & ')+%!#+3+<(% & Z & *4 & 3"+'&
)"77%&/$"0()#+"!&0%&)"!!4+''4!)%'&%#&)"77%&/$4#+<(%&'")+4*%1
Y54$#+)*% & ')+%!#+3+<(% & $.4*+'% & 0"!) & *%' & )"!-%!#+"!' & Z & *4 & 3"+' & 0+')($'+-%' & %#&
/$4#+<(%'&*+.%'&4(&34+#&7_7%&0%&34+$%&0%&*4&')+%!)%=&)%&<(+&%'#&Z&*4&3"+'&(!% &
)"!#$4+!#% & %# & (! & )40$% & '#$()#($4!#1 & 2! & %33%#= & )%# & 4'/%)# & )"!-%!#+"!!%* & '%&
#$40(+#&/4$&0%'&3"!)#+"!'&$6.#"$+<(%'&$.,(*+[$%'&0"!#&"!&'(//"'%&<(5%**%'&'%&
3"$7(*%!# & /4$ & 0%' & %9/$%''+"!' & *+!,(+'#+<(%' & $.)($$%!#%'1 & ]%##% & 6?/"#6['%&
'"('T#%!0 & !"#477%!# & *%' & #$4-4(9 & 0% & `%(3%* & '($ & )% & <(5%**% & 4//%**%&
1"0-2'*#!#$3' ( 4/*$*0= & Z & /4$#+$ & 0%'<(%*' & "!# & !"#477%!# & .#. & .*4N"$.' & 0%'&
'?'#[7%' & 0% & $.'(7. & 4(#"74#+<(% & D`%(3%*= & @AAa&U & `%(3%* &'# ( !&5= & @AAAG & %#&
054##$+N(#+"!&4(#"74#+<(%&0%&)+#4#+"!'&D8+0064$#64!&'#(!&5=&ECCB&U&`%(3%*&'#(!&5=&
ECCXG1&]%'&$%)6%$)6%'&'54//(+%!#&'($&*4&'?'#.74#+)+#.=&%#&7_7%&/*('=&'($&*4&
!.)%''+#. & 0%' & 7"(-%7%!#' & 4$,(7%!#4#+3' & .#(0+.'1 & b* & '%$4+# & %! & %33%#&
+!%!-+'4,%4N*%&0%&34+$%&0%&*4&$%)6%$)6%&'4!'&)+#%$&054(#$%'&4(#%($'&%#I"(&'%&
/"'+#+"!!%$&/4$&$4//"$#&4(9&#$4-4(9&4!#.$+%($'1
c!%&4(#$%&"/.$4#+"!&!.)%''4+$%&0%&*54$#+)*%&0%&$%)6%$)6%&%'#&*4&)$.4#+"!&05(!&
%'/4)% &0% & $%)6%$)6% &D%"'!#$*0 ( !( "')'!"%6 ()7!%'G= &<(+ & +7/*+<(% & #$"+'& .#4/%'&
D2/3')G&J&@1&.#4N*+$&(!&#%$$+#"+$%&0%&$%)6%$)6%&U&E1&.#4N*+$&(!% &*$%6'& 04!'&)%&
#%$$+#"+$%&U&P1&"))(/%$&)%##%&!+)6%&D8H4*%'&%#&L%4d=&ECCFG1&K"($&)%##%&0%$!+[$%=&
*4& 7%!#+"! & 0% & *;"Ne%)#+3 & "( & 0%' & 4'/%)#' & 74e%($' & 0% & *;.#(0% & %'# & "N*+,4#"+$%&J&
8(/-#&$*$*0(7-"7/)')(/"()#!#$*0(#6'(*!#-"'(/+(#6'(7"')'*#("')'!"%6(9& D/1&EFFG1&
]5%'# & /4$ & )%##% & 7%!#+"! & <(% & *;4(#%($ & "))(/% & )%# & %'/4)% & 0% & $%)6%$)6%1 & 84&
3"$7(*4#+"! & $%/$.'%!#% & 0% & )% & 34+# & (!% & )"7/.#%!)% & !.)%''4+$% & /"($ & *%'&
)6%$)6%($'1
148
c ATALA
�
!
"#$%&'$()#$(*+#,*+#-,$(#.(,#$$%-,*#$(#'(/&0'#
!" # $%&"'()* # +, # -.,/0"$, # +, # %,$1,%$1, # /.)02%, # 3"4)%('"(%,3,*' # +"*/#
-.(*'%)+5$'()* #+,# -."%'($-,#,'#363,#+2/#-,#%&/53& #+,# -."%'($-,7 #8%9#363, #-,/#
%,:5,/#;%"*$)01)*,/#+,3"*+,*'9 #0)5%#-"#0-50"%'9 #5*#%&/53&#,*#"*<-"(/9#$,#
=5(#(30-(=5,#=5,9#0)',*'(,--,3,*'9#')5'#$1,%$1,5%#;%"*>"(/#,/'#$)*;%)*'&#?#-"#
;)%35-"'()*#,*#"*<-"(/#+,#0)(*'/#"5//(#$%5$("5@#=5,#-"#/(*<5-"%('&#,'#-."00)%'#
+,#/"#%,$1,%$1,7
A"%',%BC1)3"/ #!" # $%&# D? # 0"%"('%,E # )*' # 3(/ # ,* # &:(+,*$, # =5, # -,/ # *5"*$,/9#
/5F'(-('&/ # ,' # /0&$(;($('&/ # +.,@0%,//()* # ,* # "*<-"(/ # /)*' # 3"-"(/&,/ # ? # 3"('%(/,%#
0)5%#-,/#$1,%$1,5%/#;%"*>"(/9#363,#$1,:%)**&/9#363,#1"F('5&/#?#%&+(<,%#,*#
"*<-"(/7#!,/#"00%)@(3"'()*/#-"*<"<(2%,/#0,5:,*'#6'%,#0&*"-(/"*',/9#G#$)30%(/#
+"*/ # -,/ # +(/$(0-(*,/ # 0)5% # -,/=5,--,/ # -" # $)%%,$'()* # -(*<5(/'(=5, # *.,/' # 0"/ # 5*#
,*4,5 # 3"4,5% # D-,/ # /$(,*$,/ # +(',/ # H#+5%,/#I9 # *)'"33,*'E7 # J"(/ # -.,30-)( # +5#
',30/#+,/#$1,%$1,5%/#,'#,*$)%,#0-5/ #+,/# "00%,*'(/B$1,%$1,5%/#D+)$')%"*'/E#
*,#-,5%#-"(//,#0"/#-,#-)(/(%#+,#/,#$)*/"$%,%#?#5*#"00%,*'(//"<,#0)5//&#+,#-"#
-"*<5,7#K-#,@(/',#+(:,%/#)5:%"<,/#+,#$)*/,(-/#0)5%#-"#%&+"$'()*#D0"%#,@,30-,#
J"''1,L/#,'#J"''1,L/9#MNNO#P#QL"-,/#,'#R,"S9#MNNTE9#$,0,*+"*'9#"5//(#F(,*#
;"('/ # =5.(-/ # /)(,*'9 # (-/ # /)*' # %"%,3,*' # )0&%"')(%,/ # ,' # *, # 0,%3,'',*'#
<&*&%"-,3,*' # 0"/ # +, # %&0)*+%, # %"0(+,3,*' # ,' # H#,* # +(%,$'#I # ? # -" # =5,/'()*#
H#$,'',#;)%35-"'()*#,/'B,--,#"00%)0%(&,#U#I#)5#H#$)33,*'#,@0%(3,B'B)*777#U#I7
!,/#,@,30-,/#"5'1,*'(=5,/#+."%'($-,/#+,#%,$1,%$1,#05F-(&/#/,%"(,*'#?#363,#
+,#;)5%*(%#5*,#"(+,#)0&%"')(%,#,*#$,#=5.(-/#0,%3,'',*'#+,#:)(%#$)*$%2',3,*'#
H#$,#=5(#/,#+('#I#+"*/#',--,#)5#',--,#+(/$(0-(*,7#V"*/#-,#$1"30#+,#-."*<-"(/#+,#
/0&$("-('&9#-,/#3&%(',/#+,#-."$$2/#"5@#$)%05/#+.&$%('/#"5'1,*'(=5,/#/)*'#+,#0-5/#
,*#0-5/#%,$)**5/#DW)5-')*#!"#$%&9#MNNXE7#!"#3"(/)*#+.&+('()*#Q0%(*<,%9#?#'%":,%/#
/)* # /(', # Q0%(*<,% # Y@,30-"% Z# );;%, # 5* # ',- # "$$2/ # ,* # 0,%3,''"*' # +,/#
$)*$)%+"*$,/#/5%#+,/#3(--(,%/#+."%'($-,/#05F-(&/7#J"(/#)*#*,#0,5'#/&-,$'()**,%#
-,/#$)*',@',/#=5,#0"%#5*,#%,=56',#/5%#5*#3)'#)5#5*,#,@0%,//()*9#$,#=5(#,/'#
'%2/#5'(-,#/(#-.)*#:,5'#:&%(;(,%#-.,30-)(#+,#',-#:,%F,9#',-#*)3#)5#',-#"+4,$'(;9#3"(/#
*, # 0,%3,' # 0"/ # "5 # /$%(0',5% # 1&/('"*' # +, # +&',%3(*,% # ":,$ # =5,--, # ;)%3, # )5#
,@0%,//()*#'%"+5(%,#-,#3)5:,3,*'#%1&')%(=5,#%,=5(/7
A.,/' # 0)5%=5)( # *)5/ # 0%)0)/)*/ # +, # %&5'(-(/,% # -" # F"/, # ,* # -(<*, # +.&$%('/#
/$(,*'(;(=5,/#Q$(,*',@'M9#)%(<(*,--,3,*'#$)*>5,#0)5%#-"#%,$1,%$1,#-(*<5(/'(=5,9#
,*#-."+"0'"*'#,'#-.,*%($1(//"*'#0)5%#);;%(%9#?#$['&#+,/#$)*$)%+"*$,/#$-"//(=5,/#
/5%#-"#;)%3,9#-,#-,33,9#-"#$"'&<)%(,9#5*#"$$2/#0"%#-"#/(<*(;($"'()*7#K-#/."<('#F(,* #
+,#0,%3,''%,#5*#"$$2/#+(%,$'#?#+,/#$)*',@',/#+)*'#*)5/#":)*/#:&%(;(&#=5.(-/#
%,30-(//,*'#',--,#)5#',--,#;)*$'()*#%1&')%(=5,#D($(#-.,@0%,//()*#+,#-.)F4,$'(;#+,#
%,$1,%$1,E7 # V, # ',--,/ # %,=56',/ # ,@(/',*' # +&4? # 0)5% # -, # ;%"*>"(/9 # 3"(/ # ,--,/#
$)*$,%*,*' # -.&'5+, # +5 # 0)/('()**,3,*' # +, # -."5',5% # ,' # *.)*' # 0"/ # &'&#
$)30-2',3,*' # %,0%)+5(',/ # 0)5% # -."*<-"(/7 # !.);;%, # +, # %,=56',/ # 0%&$)+&,/ # ,*#
"*<-"(/#,/'#45/=5.($(#-(3('&,#"5@#$('"'()*/7
Z
M
1''0\]]LLL7/0%(*<,%,@,30-"%7$)3]#A)*/5-'&#-,#ZM]NT]MNZ^7
V(/0)*(F-,#?#-."+%,//,#\#1''0\]]/$(,*',@'73/1B"-0,/7;%#A)*/5-'&#-,#ZM]NT]MNZ^7
149
c ATALA
�
!
"#$%&$&'()*#+*,-'+)&+.&
!" # $"%& # '()&*+&,+ # " # -+- # (.--& # / # 0&%+)*"+)1* # 0&% # 2)*34)%+&%5 # 614. # 6&.7&++.&#
28-+40&#0&%#+.")+%#04#0)%(14.%#%()&*+)9):4&;#!8-(.)+#%()&*+)9):4&#&%+#.&6.-%&*+-#/#
+."<&.%#0&4,#(1.64%#=
> # &* # 9."*?")%5 # 0&% # +@A%&%5 # ".+)(2&% # 0& # (1*9-.&*(&% # &+ # ".+)(2&% # 0& # .&<4&%#
&%%&*+)&22&7&*+#0"*%#0&%#0)%()62)*&%#0&#'B'#CD5E#7)22)1*%#0&#71+%F#G
>#&*#"*32")%5#0&%#".+)(2&%#%()&*+)9):4&%#0&#$)1213)&#&+#7-0&()*&#CHD5E#7)22)1*%#
0&#71+%F;
!&%#+&,+&%#7)%#/#0)%61%)+)1*#0"*%#2"#$"%&#1*+#(&()#0&#.&7".:4"$2&#6".#."661.+ #
/ # 08"4+.&% # $"%&% # +&,+4&22&% # :48)2% # 1*+ # -+- # "*"2I%-% # %I*+",):4&7&*+; # !"#
%-2&(+)1* # 084* # (1.64% # &+ # %1* # )*+&..13"+)1* # %& # 91*+ # / # +."<&.% # 28)*+&.9"(&#
'()&*J4&%+5#7)%&#"4#61)*+#6".#K;#L"2")%&#CL"2")%&#!"#$%&5#MNHH$#G#MNHMF;#O&22&>()#
"P14+&#"4,#91*(+)1**"2)+-%#(2"%%):4&%#0&#(1*(1.0"*(&%#%4.#91.7&%5#2&77&%#&+#
("+-31.)&%#2"#61%%)$)2)+-#0&#%6-()9)&.#0&%#(1*+.")*+&%#0&#.&2"+)1*%#%I*+",):4&%#
&*+.&#2&%#-2-7&*+%#0&#2"#.&:4Q+&;
R1% # .&:4Q+&% # 1*+ # -+- # (1*%+.4)+&% # %4. # 4* # (1.64% # 08-+40& # 624% # .&%+.&)*+ # &+#
+&%+-&%#%4.#2&#.&%+&#0&#2"#$"%&5#%&21*#2"#0-7".(@&#&,61%-&#0"*%#(&++&#%&(+)1*;
!/0 1+-2+'3*#+4*#())5+4*6*-(7%24*+&*85&9(#+
'4)<"*+#4*&#0-7".(@&#(14."*+&#&*#2)*34)%+):4&#0&#(1.64%#&+#SK!5#*14%#"<1*%#
0"*%#4*#6.&7)&.#+&76%#(1*%+)+4-#4*&#2)%+&#0&%#6@."%&%#)*0):4"*+#2T1$P&(+)9#0&#
2" # .&(@&.(@&5 # "9)* # 08&* # 1$%&.<&. # 2&% # 0)99-.&*+&% # 91.742"+)1*% # &+ # 08"<1). # 4*&#
2)%+&#0&#.-9-.&*(&#614.#28-<"24"+)1*#)*)+)"2&;#O&++&#2)%+&#"#-+-#0.&%%-&#/#6".+). #
084*#%14%>&*%&7$2&#0&#UNN#".+)(2&%#(@1)%)%#%&21*#0&4,#(.)+A.&%5#2"#<".)-+-#0&%#
.&<4&% # 0& # 64$2)("+)1* # &+ # 281.)3)*& # "*3216@1*& # 0& # 28".+)(2&5 # "66.-@&*0-& # 6".#
28"0.&%%&#0&#28"4+&4.#=#*14%#"<1*%#.&+&*4#0&%#".+)(2&%#6.1<&*"*+#084*)<&.%)+-%#
08K*32&+&..&5#04#O"*"0"#&+#0&%#V+"+%>W*)%#08K7-.):4&;#O&++&#.&%+.)(+)1*#*8&%+#
6"% # 4*& # 3"."*+)& # "$%124& # :4& # 28"4+&4. # %1)+ # 4* # "*3216@1*& # *"+)95 # 7")% # &22&#
2)7)+&#+14+#0&#7Q7&#2"#:4"*+)+-#0&#*1*>*"+)9%;#O&++&#%-2&(+)1*#0&#UNN#".+)(2&%#
"#-+-#16-.-&#0&#9"?1*#"4+17"+):4&5#6".#4*#%(.)6+#&,+-.)&4.#/#'()&*J4&%+;
X14. # 2" # (1*%+)+4+)1* # 0& # 2" # 2)%+& # 0& # 6@."%&%5 # *14% # *14% # %177&% # 2)7)+-% # "4,#
.-%47-%; # !& # .&(4&)2 # " # -+- # &99&(+4- # &* # 6".+)& # 7"*4&22&7&*+5 # 01*( # %&#
(1*(&*+.&.#%4.#2&%#.-%47-%#"#"((-2-.-#2"#+Y(@&;#Z&#624%5#0"*%#2"#%+.4(+4."+)1*#
084*#".+)(2&5#(&++&#-+"6&#0&#0-9)*)+)1*#&+#1((46"+)1*#084*&#*)(@&#&%+#6.-"2"$2&#
&+#)*+&.<)&*+#0"*%#2&#.-%47-#&+[14#0"*%#28)*+.104(+)1*;
W*& # (&*+")*& # 0&% # UNN # .-%47-% # *8)*0):4")+ # 6"% # 0& # 9"?1* # (2").& # &+# 0-2)7)+-&#
281$P&(+)9#0&#.&(@&.(@&5#(&24)>()#-+")+#&*#:4&2:4&#%1.+&#0)24-#0"*%#28&,61%-#0&#
(& # :4& # 2" # .&(@&.(@& # (14<.")+; # \2 # -+")+ # "((&%%)$2& # 6". # )*9-.&*(&5 # 7")% # 2")%%-#
)762)()+&;#O&*+#"4+.&%#.-%47-%#*81*+#6"%#(1*+.)$4-#/#2"#710-2)%"+)1*#6".(&#:4&#
2&% # 91.742"+)1*% # &7621I-&% # %1)+ # -<1:4")&*+ # 4* # +."<")2 # %4. # 28@I61+@A%& # 0&#
.&(@&.(@& # C'( # "!)" # "*! # *+,("*!)-)&&&F5 #%1)+ # &7621I")&*+ # 4*& # 2"*34& # %) # 6&4#
]#%+"*0".0#^#:4&#2&#014+&#-+")+#61%%)$2&#%4.#2"#2"*34&#*"+)<&#0&#28"4+&4.5#%1)+#
150
c ATALA
�
!"#$%&'"!()*"!(#$)'#+)#%&,-+)%*(&#'-..*')!("#$/-%#-!"#0/1&+*')(*/!2#34"'(5651*%"#
7-4*+#"-(#.)++-#$%"'7-"#-!"#%"7-8("#1*..&%"!("#$)%#$9%)'": #;)#0/1&+*')(*/!#"(#
+4&+)</%)(*/!#1"#%"7-8("'#'"#'/!(#1/!3#)$$-=&"'#'-%#>??#&!/!3&':
!"# $%&'()*+,-(.+/0,+**)%1-&+*-%23+45)6*-&+-,+47+,47+
;) # 0/1&+*')(*/! # 1"' # "@$%"''*/!' # "( # '(%-3(-%"' # "0$+/=&"' # $)% # 3"' # &!/!3&'#
$/-% # '(*$-+"% # +4/<A"3(*. # 1" # +) # %"39"%39" # '4)$$)%"!(" # 6 # +) # 3/!'(%-3(*/! # 1"#
$)(%/!'#+"@*3/5'=!()@*7-"'#BC/!1)0*!"'#!"#$%&2#D??E#F#G)37-"'#!"#$%&2#D??EH:#I+#
'4),*(#1"#%"$&%"%#6#+)#./*'#+"'#%&,-+)%*(&'#'/-'5A)3"!("'#"(#+"'#3)%)3(&%*'(*7-"'#
1*'3%*0*!)!("'#1"'#&!/!3&'53*<+"':#I+#.)-(#"!#&()<+*%#-!"#,%)00)*%"#7-*#3"%!"#
+"' # (%)*(' # $)% # +"'7-"+' # /<("!*% # +) # '&+"3(*/! # 1"' # &!/!3&'53*<+"' # "( # '"-+"0"!(#
3"-@5+6: # ;) # 0/1&+*')(*/! # "( # +) # 3/!'(%-3(*/! # 1"' # %"7-8("' # $/-% # J3*"!K-"'(#
$%/3L1"!(#1/!3#$)%#M:#(=$*.*3)(*/!#1"'#/33-%%"!3"'2#D:#%"$&%),"#"(#&+*0*!)(*/!#
1"' # (%)*(' # !/! # 1*'3%*0*!)!(': # C" # 1"%!*"% # ("0$' # %&'*1" # 1)!' # +4)1)$()(*/!#
'-33"''*N"#1"'#$)(%/!'2#("++"#7-"#0/!(%&"#1)!'#BO"<"=%/++"#!"#$%:2#D??MH:
C4"'(#6#3"(("#&()$"#7-"#+4)!!/()(*/!#'=!()@*7-"#"(#+"#'-$$+&0"!(#$/("!(*"+#1"#
3/!(%)*!("' # 7-4"++" # 3/0$/%(" # 0/!(%" # (/-(" # ') # $-*'')!3": # P)% # "@"0$+"2 # -!"#
%"7-8("#B.*,-%"#D2#$+-'#+/*!H#7-* #0/1&+*'"# +"#$)(%/!#1&()*++&#1)!'#+)#.*,-%"#M#
$"-(#Q#3)$("%#R#)-''*#<*"!#+4"@"0$+"#MD#1"#+)#'"3(*/!#S:M#7-"#T
'() #* # +!,-./0"/1!! "#$%&❶# 23#
$+4%" # -5,"/- # 3/6.2,/, # 0$"/!7", #
8&&&9 # :$, #'()%$'#*%❷# #(❸
*+,-$,#*❹# ";! # 0.!1$%!7-! # 23 #
2,"!202.2,/,
'<) #.(❸# %*#*/01)*❹# ";!#
3.!=4!7-5> # ./,? # 3$-"2. # $7+ #
@2."$%/"5 # 23 # 72,2-2@/$% #
07!4@27/$ # $ # 0.2,0!-"/1! #
"#$%&❶#:$,#'()%$'#*%❷#
U*,-%"#M#V#W!#"@"0$+"#1"#$)(%/!:
C/00"#/!#+"#N/*(#)N"3#BMH2#+"#%"3/-%'#)-@#%"+)(*/!'#'=!()@*7-"'#$"%0"(#1"#!"#
$)'#'"#'/-3*"%#'$&3*.*7-"0"!(#1"'#3)'#14*!'"%(*/!#1"#3/!'(*(-)!('#B)1A"3(*.'2#
3/0$+&0"!('#1"#!/0'2 #)1N"%<"':::H2#)+/%'#7-"#1)!'#+"#3)'#1"#$)(%/!'#<X(*'#
-!*7-"0"!(#'-%#1"#+4&(*7-"(),"#0/%$9/'=!()@*7-"2#*+#"'(#!&3"'')*%"#1"#$%&N/*%#
6#+4)N)!3"#-!"#1*'()!3"#$/''*<+"#"!(%"#+"'#&+&0"!(':
Y"#080"2#BDH#0/!(%"#7-"#+4/!#!4)#$)'#6#'$&3*.*"%#+4/%1%"#1"'#3/!'(*(-)!('#T#'*#
1)!'#+"#$)(%/!#"'(#*!'3%*("#-!"#%"+)(*/!#"!(%"#-!#N"%<"#"(#-!#3/0$+&0"!(#/-#
"!(%"#-!#N"%<"#"(#-!#'-A"(2#3"-@53*#$"-N"!(#)-''* #<*"!#'"#(%/-N"%#)N)!(#/-#
)$%L'2#"!#1&<-(#/-#"!#.*!#1"#$9%)'"2#6#$%/@*0*(&#/-#6#1*'()!3":
Z*%)!( # $)%(* # 1" # 3"((" # $-*'')!3"2 # -!" # 1/-[)*!" # 1" # $)(%/!' # 1*..&%"!(' # ) # &(&#
&+)</%&"#$/-%#$%"!1%"#"!#3/0$("#+)#N)%*&(&#1"'#"@$%"''*/!':
151
c ATALA
�
!
"#$%&''()*+,&+-.)/0&12(3+,&+%&14&%14&+&*+5*6-5('
!78 9*5-:'&+-(*6;('2(<;&
!"#$%&#'$ ( %)*%+&$ ( $,)- ( *%$+'%.%)/)-$ ( 0,#' ( #)& ( %*&)-%1%+/-%,) ( /#-,./-%2#& ( *&(
"3&40'&$$%,)(*&("3,56&+-%1(*&('&+7&'+7&8(9)(0'&.%&'("%&#:(,)(0&#-('&./'2#&'(2#&(
+3&$-("3,++/$%,)(*&(;,%'(/00/'/<-'&("&(+7&'+7&#'("#%=.>.&:($,#$("/(1,'.&(*3#)(
0',),.(0&'$,))&"(-&"(2#&(!(,#("#8(?,#-&1,%$:(+&-(%)*%+&()&(+,)$-%-#&(0/$(@("#%(
$&#" ( #) ( ./'2#&#' ( 0',5/)-: ( ),#$ ( "3/;,)$ ( *,)+ ( /$$,+%A ( @ ( *3/#-'&$ ( A"A.&)-$(
"%)B#%$-%2#&$(C ( +&'-/%)$ ( ;&'5&$ ( 0'A+%$: ( /%)$% ( 2#& ( "& ( *A%+-%2#& ($#%#: ( 2#%:(
0,$%-%,))A ( &) ( *A5#- ( *& ( 07'/$&: ( '&$-'&%)- ( "/ ( 0,'-A& ( *& ( "/ ( 0',0,$%-%,) ( /#(
+,)-&4-&(%..A*%/-:(+3&$-=@=*%'&("3/'-%+"&8
9)($&+,)*("%&#:("&$(-&'.&$(.>.&$($%B)%1%/)- (&'(#)*+,:(@($/;,%' (-.%-&/#012&340 1
3+501&'(#)*+6#:(+,.5%)A$(/#(;&'5&('#(&-(#)(+,.0"A.&)-(%)-',*#%-(0/'(*&:(0,#'(
$%B)%1%&'(#)(5#-:($,)-(*&(5,)$(./'2#&#'$(*&$(+,)-&4-&$('&+7&'+7A$8
D)(-&"(+,.0"A.&)-(%)-',*#%-(0/'(*&1,#(+71&%8#%1*&1/00/'/<-('AB#"%E'&.&)-(*/)$(
"&$(+,)-&4-&$('&+#&%""%$:(./%$(/#$$%(*/)$(*3/#-'&$(+,)-&4-&$:(+,..&("/(+%-/-%,)(
*3/#-'&$(-'/;/#48(!,#'("%.%-&'($,)(/.5%B#F-A:(),#$(/;,)$(+,)-'/%)-($/(0,$%-%,)(
@ ( "/ ( ->-& ( *& ( 07'/$& ( ,# ( ),#$ ( "3/;,)$ ( /$$,+%A ( @ ( *3/#-'&$ ( +,)-'/%)-&$ ( "&4%+,=
$G)-/4%2#&$8
H/(*A%4%$:(2#/)*(&""&(0&'.&-(*&(*A$%B)&'("3/'-%+"&("#%=.>.&(,#("3A-#*&(2#%(G(&$-(
&40,$A&:( 1,#')%- ( #)( 5,)( %)*%+& (@( -'/;&'$(*&$( +,)$-'#+-%,)$ ( +,..& (9+7:( *$+/1
/*.8;:(9+7:1*$#1-%#/#7*1/*.8;8
9)1%): ( +&'-/%)$ ( ;&'5&$ ( -&"$ ( 2#& (-%#/#7*0 1 8#*#%5+7#0 1 3//#//0 1 8#/)%+'#0( &) ( +&(
2#3%"$($,)-('&"/-%;&.&)-($0A+%/"%$A$(*/)$("3&40'&$$%,)(*&("/('&+7&'+7&:($,)-(*&$(
./'2#&#'$($/-%$1/%$/)-$:(@(+,)*%-%,)(*&("%.%-&'("&#'(,++#''&)+&(/#4(+,)-&4-&$(
*/)$("&$2#&"$("&#'($#6&-(&$-("&(0',),. ("#( ,# (!:(*A$%B)/)-("&(,#("&$(/#-&#'$(
&#4=.>.&$8
I/%$ ( +&--& ( '&$-'%+-%,) ( 0&#- ( $3/;A'&' ( %)$#11%$/)-&8 ( J& ( ./)%E'& ( BA)A'/"&: ( #)&(
*%11%+#"-A ( 'A+#''&)-& ( -%&)- ( @ ( "3/.5%B#F-A ( &)-'& ( "3&40'&$$%,) ( *& ( "3,56&+-%1 ( &-(
"3&40'&$$%,) ( *& ( "/ ( .A-7,*&8 ( D) ( ;&'5& ( -&" ( 2#& ()&5-3%# 1&$- ( @ ( +&- ( AB/'*(
&4&.0"/%'&8 ( J/)$ (<1=# 1 )&5-3%# 1 >&7*# 1 ?3%4&1 >3%@&6 1)$3+7 1 3734;/+/ 1&, 1 *"& 1
6#%; 1 8+,,#%#7* 1 5#3/.%#/ 1 &, 1 $;-#%*#7/+&7 1 +7 1 *$# 1 /+5.43*#8 1 A#7#*+) 1 B734;/+/ 1
=&%@/$&-1CD183*31*&1#E35+7#1$&"1)$&+)#1&,15#3/.%#13,,#)*/1*$#1%#/.4*/F1G01
"&$(+7&'+7&#'$(%)*%2#&)-(+&(@(2#,%(%"$(;&#"&)-(/5,#-%'(./%$ ()&5-3%# 10&'.&-(
*3&40"%2#&' ( +& ( 2#& ( "&$ ( +7&'+7&#'$ ( 1,)- ( &- ( ),) (/*%+)*& 1 /#7/.( "/ ( K()%+7&(L(
,++#0A&8 ( H/ ( .,%-%A ( *& ( $&$ ( ,++#''&)+&$ ( )& ( +,''&$0,)* ( 0/$ ( /#4 ( +,)-&4-&$(
'&+7&'+7A$:(),#$("3/;,)$(*,)+(1%)/"&.&)-(A"%.%)A(*&$(*%;&'$&$("%$-&$(*&(;&'5&$(
&)-'/)-(*/)$("&$('&2#>-&$8
M&('&0A'/B&(*3%)*%+&$(/(/5,#-%(@("3A"/5,'/-%,)(*&(*,#N&(0/-',)$:(0,#'("&$2#&"$(
;,%+%(*&$(&4&.0"&$(*&(+,)-&4-&$(;%$A$(O&)(+/'/+-E'&(B'/$("&$(A"A.&)-$('&-&)#$(
0,#'("/(+,)$-'#+-%,)(*&$('&2#>-&$P(C
CF !"#"01$"%#"&'#(1*$#1%#/.4*/1&,131/.%6#;1*&13//#//1*$#1-%#634#7)#1&,18%21+7 1
152
c ATALA
�
!"#$%&!$$'"()*()+),-!-./)"*!,)$"%0"1.+)!+)2!++%3.!-)1"4),.,#%3%33.5
65 !"#"7"!"+-!-.+-.3!$"$"%$"-%"1)-)3-"#),)"3%,/)(+.%,"89:"&%'(#"%")$"*5
;5 +)',#*"#'$,'*"$"#-&)""<=.3="0%%1+"4.#=-"&)"()$!-)1"-%"1.+)!+)"!3-./.-'"., "
>?"!",)<"4)-=%1"%0"1.)-!('"!,!$'+.+"<!+"1)/)$%*)1"!,1"!**$.)15
@5 .,'/)*"#%$0)*" -=)"*='+.%$%#.3!$ "*(%3)++)+"()+*%,+.&$) "0%(")$)/!-)1"?1 "
!33A4A$!-.%,".,"+=%%-+"8555:7"?1"A*-!B)"!,1"-(!,+$%3!-.%,"<)()"+-A1.)1"89:
C5 +)'$1&%" ()-(%+*)3-./) "#"2&"37"<)")D!4.,) "<=)-=)(" *(%#()++.%, "-%"EFGH "
3!,"&)"*()1.3-)1"!,1"<=)-=)("-()!-4),-"8555:
I5 +) ' $1" ' 4/##")$ ' %$/*5" <) " ()*%(- " -=) " .+%$!-.%, " !,1 " *()$.4.,!(' "
3=!(!3-)(.J!-.%,"%0"=%4%$%#%A+"*(%-).,+"0(%4"#%!-"+)4.,!$"*$!+4!5
K5 .1&% ' 0#$&46" ' ,/$6&)"%" -=) " )/%$A-.%, " %0 " ! " 3%44A,.-' " *=!(4!3'2&!+)1 "
+A*)(/.+)1"3%,+A4*-.%,"%0"4)-=!1%,)"*(%#(!4".,"L(!-)("L$!+#%<5
M5 .1" ' (#"%")$ ' %$/*5 ' 0**#"%%"%" -=) " ()$!-.%,+=.* " %0 " *(%-)., " 0%$1.,# "
*(%*),+.-.)+"-%"-=)")/%$A-.%,!('"()$!-.%,+=.*"&)-<)),"()+.1A)+5
N5 7/# ' 0&- ' 30% ' $, ' *"$"#-&)" '-=) " )00)3-+" %0" -!B.,# " !" ()1" 3$%/)(21)(./)1 "
.+%0$!/%,)"+A**$)4),-"1!.$'"0%("O"')!("%,"4!44%#(!*=.3"&()!+-"1),+.-'5
OP5 8" ' (#"%")$ 'Q%4%$%#' " R,1A3-.%, " SQRT7 " ! " ,)< " !**(%!3= " -% " .,0)((.,# "
=%4%$%#'5
OO5 8"'0&-"*'$,'0%%"%%"<!(0!(.,"-()!-4),-".,"*(.4!('"=)!$-="3!()"
O65 .1&% ' %$/*5" <!+ "/)*"#$09")" $, ' 410#04$"#&:"" -=) " )D*()++.%, " %0 "
3=)4%B.,)"()3)*-%(+
!"#$%&'($)#%*(+%$(,#-.(+%*&/+%012(/3#(+.45%6"212%1(77(%,#2%1"$$(+'"/*%8%9:;<%=
UU " >, " /)(&) " 1VW"X-A1)"Y " !'!,- " *%A( " +AZ)- " A, " ,%4 " 1X+.#,!,- " $! " ()3=)(3=) " )- " *%A( "
3%4*$X4),-"A,"F["0%(4X"1)"-%")-"A,"/)(&)"\A)$3%,\A)
>$(+(&$1?@+(&$1?5$(+(&$1?5+.#*A5'$"B(1.
UU"$&%$"'),-%'*"'#"41"#41"
>6($CD@1&$$A51"/*#1.5#/*($.&E(5'($F"$G5*(+2H/%
UU"6&%$"'2"#;"%'*<=$/*"
I&2/ % @ % JF"$G@>$(+(&$1?5K;L % MM % J7(GG&@>6($CD5K:L % MM % J7(GG&@."5KDL % MM%
J1&.@NON5KPL % == % 990QR5K:5K;< % ST % 90QRUSI!5K;5K:<< % VWX % 9!TY!5K:5KD< % VWX%
9WSI!TY!5KD5KP<%Z
UU"#>?6"'(#&)4&(06"'SF>]7"F>]?^_[7"[GE[7"`^_[GE["1X+.#,),- "
$)+"()$!-.%,+"+',-!D.\A)+"),-()"$)+"A,.-X+"$)D.3!$)+"%A"#(!44!-.3!$)+T
[\]QTY%;%^%Q/%(_(G'7(%*(%$(,#-.(%*&/+%012(/3#(+.`
!"# $%&'(&)*+,
U"GG(%+"#6(/.%7"$+,#a27%+a&H2.%*(%*bF2/2$%7(+%c%G&$,#(#$+%d%72/H#2+.2,#(+%*a#/%
1($.&2/ % 1"/.(/# % +bG&/.2,#(5 % 7& % '$"B(1.2"/ % +#$ % 7(+ % 1"$'#+ % *(+ % $(,#-.(+%
b7&C"$b(+%c%$&Ge/(%d%&#++2 %C2(/%7(+%1"/.(_.(+% 62+b+%,#( %*a&#.$(+%1"/.(_.(+%
,#2 % /a"/. % '&+ % 7& % +2H/2F21&.2"/ % +"#?&2.b( % ^ % /".&GG(/. % (/ % $&2+"/ % *( % 7& % F"$.(%
4
fa(/+(GC7(%*(+%$(,#-.(+%(+.%$(/*#%*2+'"/2C7(%+#$%7(%+2.(%*(%012(/.(_.`
153
c ATALA
�
!"#$%&'()*+,(-+*.#/+0($1*2+*-+03+-03+*+(*")(3.2+4*5.&6$%,)+*76&5*3!&(8
9.&5*!:.,5*2.,0*):!6&)*03!0&,+*2+*,.5*-+;&<(+5*=*2!,5*&,*7-+"$+-*(+"75*
5&-*6+*0.-7&5*2>)(&2+*2+*?@@*!-($06+54*2!,5*&,*2+&A$B"+*(+"75*5&-*6+*-+5(+*2&*
0.-7&5*!,%6!$5*2!,5*C0$+,(+A(4*5.$(*+,:$-.,*D@@@*!-($06+58*9.&5*!:.,5*6$"$()*6!*
"+5&-+ * 5&- * 0+ * 2+-,$+- * E * F@@ * 0.,(+A(+5 * "!$5 * 0+-(!$,+5 * -+;&<(+5 * ,>+,*
1.&-,$55+,(*7!5*!&(!,(8
G+ * (!#6+!& * H * -)0!7$(&6+ * 6+5 * 2$11)-+,(+5 * -+;&<(+54 * 6+ * ,."#-+ * 2+ * 0.,(+A(+5*
-+,:.I)*7!-*03!0&,*+(*6!*7-)0$5$.,*7.&-*03!;&+*0.-7&58
J!(-.,5
H*LM+-+4*N+888O
P*LM+-+4*!*9*$5888O
R*LV,*.-2+-*(.888O
S*LW.*X888O
F*LV,*(3$5*5(&2IO
?*LV,*(3+*7-+5+,(*
5(&2IO
T*LW3$5*7!7+-*XO
D*LW3+*7-+5+,(*
7!7+-*XO
U*LY&-*!$"*$5*(.O
H@*LZ+*7-+5+,(O
HH*LN+*X*(.O
HP*L(3$5*5(&2I*X*(.O
K.-7&5*2>)(&2+
K.-7&5*2+*(+5(
9."#-+*2>.008
J-)0$5$.,
9."#-+*2>.008
J-)0$5$.,
P?
DD4F*Q
RSP
DT4H*Q
R
H@@*Q
PP
FU4H*Q
HP
??4T*Q
H@S
D?4F*Q
SU
RS4T*Q
RUR
TT4H*Q
RS
DD4P*Q
SPH
DD4?*Q
S
D@*Q
HPD
DU4H*Q
US
DH4U*Q
SUD
D@4F*Q
HP
TF*Q
HF?
DT4D*Q
?R
U@4F*Q
SU?
UD4D*Q
HFS
TT4U*Q
F@@
DT*Q
PHR
?R4D*Q
PFU
DP4?*Q
HR
DS4?*Q
HUP
DT4F*Q
W[\G]*H*^*_+5&-+5*2+*7-)0$5$.,*2+5*-+;&<(+5*7.&-*6>+A7-+55$.,*2+*6>.#/+0($1*2+*
-+03+-03+*+,*!-($06+*50$+,($1$;&+*+,*!,%6!$5
9.&5 * ,>!:.,5 * 7-$5 * +, * 0."7(+ * ;&+ * 6! * 7-)0$5$., * 0!- * 6! * (`03+ * 2)1$,$+ * $0$*
,>$"76$;&+*7!5*2+*(-!;&+-*(.&5*6+5*-)5&6(!(5*7.55$#6+5*7.&-*&,+*-+;&<(+8*K+*;&$*
+5(*$"7.-(!,(4*0>+5(*;&+*6+5*-+;&<(+5*5.$+,(*1.-"&6)+5*2+*(+66+*5.-(+*;&>+66+5*
154
c ATALA
�
!"#$%&''(%)*+#*,-($,-(#$.',$&/)(#$*#%(*&01(*'+)&'!+&'+%)(*0(*2+*!+3"%*0"%)*4*3+*
/(#)*'51,$&$(*67*,5(').8.0&$(*9#5(22('*,"#:$(%)*2('*0&:($'('*:+$&+%)('*05#%*;<;(*
)=/(*0(*!"$;#2+)&"%>*?+$*(@(;/2(7*2('*AB*/$(;&($'*$1'#2)+)'*0('*$(9#<)('*C*()*
D*,&.0(''#'*;"%)$(%)*EA*,";F&%+&'"%'*0(*:($F('*()*'#G()'*0&!!1$(%)('7*,(*9#&*
'(;F2(*'#!!&'+;;(%)*&%!"$;+)&!*/"#$*#%*)(;/'*0(*,"%'#2)+)&"%*$(')$(&%)>
?+$*+&22(#$'7*2('*$1'#2)+)'*'#$/$(%+%)'*0(*2+*2&H%(*A*$1,2+;(%)*(@/2&,+)&"%>*I+%'*
%")$(*,"$/#'*051)#0(7*2('*$1'#2)+)'*"%)*(%*!+&)*1)1*4*/"22#1'*6*/+$*0('*:($F('*
&%0&9#+%) * 2+ * ;1)-"0( * /2#' * 9#( * 25"FG(,)&! * J/+$ * (@> *!" # "$%&'"(% # )*+, #
-+(+).)+"/>>>K7*)"#)(!"&'*,('*:($F('*1)+&(%)*/$"/"$)&"%%(22(;(%)*;"&%'*/$1'(%)'*
0+%'*2(*,"$/#'*0(*)(')*L*M)"#"$%&'"(%N*/+$*(@>*+//+$+O)*P*!"&'*'#$*AQ*0+%'*2(*
,"$/#'*051)#0(*()*A*!"&'*'#$*EQE*0+%'*2(*,"$/#'*0(*)(')>
R5(%'(;F2(*0('*$(9#<)('*'#$*2(* ,"$/#'*0(*)(')*0"%%( *#%(* /$1,&'&"%*H2"F+2(*
;"=(%%( * 0( * DS7T*U*L * ETVP * ,"%)(@)(' * :1$&!&1' * J/+$ * #%( * 2",#)$&,( * %+)&:(*
05+%H2+&'K7*ACT*%"%*:+2&01'>*W($)+&%('*",,#$$(%,('*,"$$('/"%0(%)*8*/2#'&(#$'*
$(9#<)('7*'#$*2(*,"$/#'*051)#0(7*2(*$(,"#:$(;(%)*1)+&)*05(%:&$"%*Q*U>
X:"&$*0('*/+)$"%'*9#&*0"%%(%)*0('*$1'#2)+)'*2('*;"&%'*F$#&)1'*/"''&F2(*%(*'#!!&)*
/+'*'&*"%*%(*'5+0$(''(*%&*8*0('*2&%H#&')('*%&*8*0('*1)#0&+%)'*0(*2+%H#(*;+&'*8*
#% * /#F2&, * 9#& * %5+ * /+' * !"$,1;(%) * 2+ * ,";/1)(%,( * /"#$ * !+&$( * 2#&.;<;( * 2+*
0&')&%,)&"% * (%)$( * 1%"%,1' * /($)&%(%)' * () * F$#&)> * R+ * 0($%&Y$( * +0+/)+)&"% * /"#$*
+))(&%0$(*%")$(*"FG(,)&!*,"%,($%(*25&%)($!+,(*0(*Z,&(%[#(')*(22(.;<;(>
!
"#$%&'()&*+)(*,%-.)/.)(*0)&.'-)-.(
X*25"$&H&%(7*Z,&(%)(@)*()*'"%*&%)($!+,(*Z,&(%[#(')*"%)*1)1*/$1:#'*/"#$*"!!$&$*8*
25#)&2&'+)(#$*E*%&:(+#@*0(*$(9#<)('*L*#%*%&:(+#*0(*,"%,"$0+%,&($*0+%'*2(9#(2*
25#)&2&'+)(#$*(')*H#&01*/"#$*!+F$&9#($*0('*$(9#<)('*/"#:+%)*,";F&%($*!"$;('7*
2(;;('7*,+)1H"$&('*;"$/-".'=%)+@&9#('*()*$(2+)&"%'*'=%)+@&9#('*\*#%*%&:(+#*
0( * $(9#<)(' * '1;+%)&9#(' * 0+%' * 2(9#(2 * 25#)&2&'+)(#$ * '12(,)&"%%( * #%( * $(9#<)(*
'1;+%)&9#(*/$1.,"01(*()*(%!&%*#%*%&:(+#*+:+%,1*0+%'*2(9#(2*25#)&2&'+)(#$*,"0(*
2#&.;<;(*'+*$(9#<)(*+:(,*2(*2+%H+H( *05&%)($$"H+)&"%*'"#'.G+,(%)*J]+2+&'( *%)#
.-07*PBVVFK>*^+&'7*9#(2*9#(*'"&)*2(*;"0(*05&%)($$"H+)&"%*,-"&'&7*"%*"F)&(%)*0('*
$1'#2)+)'*F$#)'*()*/+$*,"%'19#(%)*F$#&)1'>
R+*;"0&!&,+)&"%*+,)#(22(*,"%'&')(*0"%,*8*/"#:"&$*;1;"$&'($*J8*)($;(7*'#$*2(*
'($:(#$K*()*$(,-+$H($*+#)+%)*9#(*0(*F('"&%*#%(*'1$&(*0(*,"%)(@)('*:+2&01'>*R+*
01!&%&)&"%*&,&*(@/"'1(*0(*$(9#<)('*'1;+%)&9#('*/"#$*+))(&%0$(*0+%'*2('*)(@)('*
2+*!"$;#2+)&"%*0('*"FG(,)&!'*0(*$(,-($,-(*%(*'(*2&;&)($+*0"%,*/+'*8*2+*;&'(*8*
0&'/"'&)&"%*0('*$(9#<)('*12+F"$1('*;+&'*+#''&*0('*,"%)(@)('*01F+$$+''1'*0(*
2(#$'*$1/"%'('*%"%*/($)&%(%)('>
R+*!&H#$(*E*;"%)$(*#%(*/+$)&(*0(*,())(*%"#:(22(*!"%,)&"%%+2&)1*L*8*2+*!&%*05#%(*
2&')(*0(*,"%)(@)('*_*0"%) *,($)+&%'*&%:+2&01'*J01.'12(,)&"%K*_7*#%( *,";;+%0(*
/"#$*'+#:(H+$0($*'"&)*2('*$1'#2)+)'*'(#2'*8*(@/2"&)($*0+%'*#%*+#)$(*2"H&,&(27*'"&)*
2+*'12(,)&"%*8*$(,-+$H($*#2)1$&(#$(;(%)*0+%'*Z,&(%[#(')>
155
c ATALA
�
!"#$%&'(')'*+,-.+/-01'.23'4536,/+/3'2/'3+6728+4.2'.+13'9:-21;623/<
!"#$%&'=')'>?+482@21/'.A612'42B6C/2'2/'323'4536,/+/3'.+13'9:-21;623/<
156
c ATALA
�
!"#$ % &'()* % +(,#* % $*$$-"). % +( % /-*( % &* % 0+-#* % ()* % )"(1*//* % #*23*#23*. % -/ % $*#+%
4"$$-5/*%&*%#*23+#6*#%/+%#*7(8,*%*,%/*$%#9$(/,+,$%19#-0-9$%:;-6(#*%<=>
? % ,*#@*. % /'(,-/-$+,*(# % &-$4"$*#+ % &-#*2,*@*), % $(# % /* % $-,* % &* % A2-*),*B, % )")%
$*(/*@*),%&*$%#*7(8,*$.%C%(,-/-$*#%*)%5/"2%"(%()*%4+#%()*.%@+-$%+($$-%&'()%
2*#,+-)%)"@5#*%&*%2"),*B,*$%1+/-&9$.%2*%7(-%2")$,-,(*%()*%0")2,-"))+/-,9%(,-/*%
+($$-%4"(#%/'*)$*-6)*@*),D+44#*),-$$+6*%&*$%/+)6(*$>
!
"#$%&'()#$
!'+&+4,+,-") % &* % /+ % 5+$* % A2-*),*B, % *) % 1(* % &E"00#-# % () % +22F$ % -@@9&-+, % C % &*$%
2"),*B,*$%4*#,-)*),$%4"(#%/'*B4#*$$-")%&*%/'"5G*2,-0%&*%#*23*#23*%*)%+)6/+-$%+%
-@4/-7(9%,#"-$%9,+4*$%H
I>%/*%#*2(*-/%*)%2"#4($%&'()%923+),-//")%&'"22(##*)2*$%&*$%9)")29$%1-$9$%J
K>%/+%@"&9/-$+,-")%&*%2*$%9)")29$%$"($%/+%0"#@*%&*%4+,#")$%/*B-2"D$L),+B-7(*$%
,#+&(-,$%*)%#*7(8,*$%&+)$%A2-*)M(*$,%J
N>%&+)$%/'-),*#0+2*%A2-*)M(*$,.%/+%1+/-&+,-")%*,%/+%@9@"#-$+,-")%&*$%9)")29$%
4*#,-)*),$%4"(#%/-@-,*#%/*$%+00-23+6*$%(/,9#-*(#$%C%2*$%$*(/$%9)")29$>
O* % ,#+1+-/ % 1-$* % C % 2"@5/*# % () % @+)7(* % /-9 % +( % 0+-, % 7(* % /+ % 4/(4+#, % &*$ % "(,-/$%
&'-),*##"6+,-") % &* % 6#"$ % 2"#4($ % "00#* % &*$ % 4"$$-5-/-,9$ % &* % 2")2"#&+)2*$ % "(%
&'*B,#+2,-")$%C%4+#,-#%&*$%/*@@*$.%0"#@*$%"(%2+,96"#-*$%@"#43"$L),+B-7(*$%
:4"(# % 2*#,+-)$= % @+-$ % 4+$ % C % 4+#,-# % &*$ % $-6)-0-2+,-")$ % *//*$D@8@*$> % P#. % ()*%
&-00-2(/,9 % 0#97(*),* % 4"(# % () % /"2(,*(# % )")D)+,-0 % 7(- % &"-, % #9&-6*# % &+)$ % ()*%
/+)6(*%$*2")&*%#9$-&*%&+)$%$+%@92"))+-$$+)2*%&*$%0"#@*$%@"5-/-$9*$%4"(#%
()%2*#,+-)%$*)$>%!*$%2"#4($%7(-%0"#@*),%/+%5+$*%A2-*),*B,%4*(1*),%+-)$-%8,#*%
(,-/-$9$%4"(#%1-$(+/-$*#%/+%&-1*#$-,9%&*$%0"#@(/+,-")$%4"(#%()*%@8@*%-),*),-")%
2"@@()-2+,-1*>%Q"$%#*7(8,*$%$'+G"(,*),%C%2*//*$%7(-%*B-$,*),%&9GC%*)%+)6/+-$%
*, % *) % 0#+)R+-$ % 4"(# % /+ % 0"#@(/+,-") % &*$ % 2-,+,-")$ % &'+(,#*$ % ,#+1+(B. % &*$%
3L4",3F$*$%&*%#*23*#23*.%&(%4"$-,-"))*@*),%&*%/'+(,*(#.%9/+5"#9*$%$*/")%()*%
&9@+#23*%$-@-/+-#*%C%2*//*%7(*%)"($%4#9$*),")$>
!'+&+4,+,-")%&*%/'-),*#0+2*%2")2*#)*%/'*)$*@5/*%&*%/+%5+$*%H2"#4($%+)6/+-$%*,%
0#+)R+-$> %S"(#%@*$(#*#%/'(,-/-,9% &*$%)"(1*//*$%0")2,-"))+/-,9$. %-/%*$,%4#91(%&*%
,*$,*#%2*,,*%+44#"23*%$(#%/*%2"#4($%0#+)R+-$%&+)$%/*%2+&#*%&*%/'*)$*-6)*@*),%
+$$-$,9%4+#%"#&-)+,*(#.%+1*2%()%4(5/-2%&*%)")D0#+)2"43")*$ <!
T) % +(,#* % -),9#8, % )") % )96/-6*+5/* % &( % ,#+1+-/ % 4#9$*),9 % -2- % *$, % /+ % #9(,-/-$+,-")%
&'()* % #*$$"(#2* % 4(5/-7(* % *, % "(1*#,* % C % ,"($> % O* % ,L4* % &* % #*$$"(#2* % 9,+),%
#*/+,-1*@*), % 2"U,*(B % C % 2")$,-,(*#. % 4"(# % #*),+5-/-$*# % /*$ % *00"#,$ % *, % /'+#6*),%
-)1*$,-$%*,%49#*))-$*#%/+%#*$$"(#2*.%-/%)"($%$*@5/*%)92*$$+-#*%&*%&-1*#$-0-*#%$*$%
(,-/-$+,-")$ % *, % &* % /+ % #*)&#* % &-$4")-5/* % 4"(# % &* % )"(1*+(B % 4(5/-2$ % *, % &*%
)"(1*+(B%5*$"-)$>%O*/+%4+$$*.%2"@@*%)"($%/'+1")$%@"),#9.%4+#%()*%91"/(,-")%
&*$ % 0")2,-"))+/-,9$ % *, % 4+# % ()* % +(6@*),+,-") % 2"),-)(* % &*$ % #*$$"(#2*$%
2"))*B*$%,*//*$%7(*%/*$%#*7(8,*$%4#92"&9*$>%!+%2"//+5"#+,-")%&(%V?!%*,%&*%/+%
/-)6(-$,-7(*%&*%2"#4($%*$,%+-)$-%"4,-@+/*>
<
%W+)$%()%4#"G*,%-@4/-7(+),%?>%;+/+-$*.%X>%V#+)%*,%?>%V(,-).%&(%/+5"#+,"-#*%!YWY!Z[>
157
c ATALA
�
!
"#$%#$&#'(#)
!"#$%"&'()*(+,(-.$/0$1'(2*(345567*(/89+8:,(;<=>?@A,B+C(@B<?DE(B8F+(,B+(9<EC*(
%<<D@(D+8=:+=@(B8F+(,B+(=GHB,(,<(?@+*(!"#$%IJAK5'(>8H+@(LKKALM5*
;)N%0NA%/"1)2'(2*(O(N"-$0PAQ"$.R0%'(0*(3S(>8=8G,=+*7(N8>><=,+=(D8(F<GT(E+(DU8?,=+(
E8:@ ( D+@ ( 8=,GVD+@ ( E+ ( =+VB+=VB+ ( +: ( 8:HD8G@ ( W ( >=<9DXY+@ ( +, ( +:Z+?T ( ><?= ( D+(
VB+=VB+?=([=8:V<>B<:+* (&'%()*+,-.*%./##,.01 %'0%*'*%2/.3-'*%4%#'.*#'+0)5'* %
061,.)3-'*%'0%()(/+0)3-'**(0EG,G<:@()=8V:+*
;"&\)1.&02'()*(+,(Q);]#02'(1*A^*(345567*($+(=+>_=8H+(E+(DUBC>+=<:CYG+(>8=(?:(
[8G@V+8?(EUG:EGV+@(W(YG@+(+:(`?+@,G<:(E+(D8(:<,G<:(E+(a(Y8=`?+?=(b* (7,-.81' %
9:';0'*%'0%+,88/)**/8+'*9$%"'2/)8'%('%</%=,88/)**/8+''(>8H+@(LcKALJI*
d)$).20'( )*' (%#%.&'( )*' (eN).d'( "*' (N"#]#0%'( \* ( 345L47* ( 2VG+:]?+@,W ( 8 ( ,=++98:f(
+T>D<G,8,G<:(,<<D([<=(:<:(&$Â@>+VG8DG@,@*(!+0'*%('%=>&?@A%BCDB'(1?Y98G'(.:E+*
d)$).20'()*'(%#%.&'()*(+,(eN).d'("*(345LL87*(0T>D<G,8,G<:(Eg?:(V<=>?@(8=9<=_(><?=(
:<: ( @>_VG8DG@,+@ ( >8= ( E+@ ( =+`?h,+@ ( H?GE_+@ ( +,( E+@ ( =+`?h,+@( @_Y8:,G`?+@* ( G:(
!+0'* % (' % :!&@ % BCDD % E:./)0'2'80 % /-0,2/0)3-' % ('* % </8F-'* % 8/0-.'<<'*G %
1<:,>+DDG+='%>8H+@%LcMA4LK*
d)$).20' ( )*' ( %#%.&' ( )* (+,( eN).d' ( "* ( 345LL97* ( \_[G:G,G<: ( +, ( V<:V+>,G<: ( Eg?:+(
G:,+=[8V+ ( ><?= ( Dg+T>D<G,8,G<: ( E+ ( V<=>?@ ( 8=9<=_@ ( ><?= ( :<:AG:[<=Y8,GVG+:@ ( W ( D8(
>D8,+[<=Y+(2VG+:]?+@,(E?(>=<Z+,(2VG+:,+T,*(:!&(K43i7'(>8H+@(L5iAL4c*
d$j%%#1'(e*'(e.&&'(%*(+,(\)/$'(%*(345567*(k-+(:<l(=+><=,(<:(***m(F+=@?@(k$+,(?@(
:<l ( @++ ( B<l ( ***mW ( )?,B<= ( =<D+@ ( 8:E ( G:,+=8V,G<: ( lG,B ( =+8E+=@ ( G: ( =+@+8=VB(
8=,GVD+@* (?8( !+/('2)+ % H)*+,-.*' % /+.,** % H)*+)#<)8'*( 3/CD8:E ( +, ( !<:EG' ( 45567'(
>8H+@(45iA44I*
/)N%-0$$' ( $* ( 345Li7* ( ;<=>?@AG:[<=Y+E ( E+@V=G>,G<:@W ( 0:HDG@B ( F+=9@ ( 8:E ( ,B+G=(
V<DD<V8,+@(G:(@VG+:V+(89@,=8V,@*% ?8%I0-('*%'8%()(/+0)3-'%('*%</8F-'*( 3\_V?=_'(
45Li7'(>8H+@(MJAJK*
/)N%-0$$' ( $* ( O ( Q);]#02' ( 1*A^* ( 345L47* ( )( V<=>?@AG:[<=Y+E ( ,+T,A=+V<:@,=?V,G<:(
=+@<?=V+@([<=(D+8=:G:H(89<?,(,B+(D8:H?8H+(<[(@VG+:,G[GV(89@,=8V,@* ()8( !+0'*%('%
I-.,=!&&%BCDB'(2?XE+W(>8H+@(LLMAL4i*
/P$)&\' ( e* ( 3455I7* ( ^8,,+=:@ ( <[ ( +:H8H+Y+:,W ( EG8D<HGV ( [+8,?=+@ ( 8:E ( $4(
?:E+=H=8E?8,+ ( l=G,G:H* (?8( !8/<J*)8F % !+/('2)+ % K.)0)8F4 % =,80';0-/<)*'( %
L./2'M,.N*(3N8F+DDG(+,(0DDG@'(455I7'(>8H+@(KA4i*
/P$)&\' ( e* ( 345L47* ( \G@VG>DG:8=C ( .E+:,G,G+@W ( .:EGFGE?8DG,C ( 8:E ( V<YY?:G,C ( G:(
8V8E+YGV(EG@V<?=@+*(;8Y9=GEH+W(;8Y9=GEH+(#:GF+=@G,C(^=+@@*
Q);]#02'(1*A^*(+, ()#220&);An.$$02'( &*(345567*(R8=G89GDG,_(E+@(>+=[<=Y8:V+@(E+@(
<?,GD@ ( E+ ( %)$ ( +, ( H+:=+ ( ,+T,?+D* ( $+ ( V8@ ( E+@ ( >8,=<:@ ( D+TGV<A@C:,8TG`?+@*(
:!&%IM3L7'(>8H+@(LLAi4*
1)&.0o'(d*(345L47*()(V<=>?@A98@+E(@,?EC(<[(8EZ+V,GF8D(5*O%:<YG:8D(Y<EG[GV8,G<:(
G:(Y+EGV8D(0:HDG@B% * (?8 %=,.#-*P)8Q,.2'(%.'*'/.+6%/8(%<'/.8)8F%)8%I"R4%?**-'* %
/8(%/##<)+/0),8*%3!<?D,<:('0%/<'(45L47'(>8H+@(ciAL54*
158
c ATALA
�
!"##$%&'()*+),+)-.)!"##$%&'(),+)&+)/01203+)!"##$%%&"'(%#)$*+)&)#(,-)+)*./(0(%+$12
342%+$1 ( .")5$ ( &6- ( +7$ ( 3)6'6.)#8' ( 8*5 ( 9$5)#8' ( %#)$*#$% (/4-5 ( $5)+)6*3+)
56789:;<-=)56789:;<-)>?:@-9A:.B)C9-AA+
CDE#FGG%()H+)/011I3+)!6.J9:6K:.J);-A)JL9:.A)AL:-?.:M:NO-A)-.).96@6:K);-)M9P?.:Q9-A)=)
K- ) L6A ) ;O ) MP976. ) F!,"H+ ))* ( !#)$*#$% ( $+ ( &-6*+):-$%) /$-9. ) -. ) C6OKR56@6KK:-9()
011I3;)S-9?-K7P?.()T6<-A)00UR0V4+
CD>H"#()5()-.)SDGG%##%()C+)/01203+)5P9TP96)6?;)6L6;-7:L)W9:.:?<=)")LP?.96A.:@-)
6?6KBA:A ) PM ) 9-A-69LX ) 69.:LK-A ) :? ) 8:PKP<B ) 6?; ) K:?<O:A.:LA+ )<* (=6-1"%2)*&6-9$5(
-$%$8-#7(8*5 ('$8-*)*.()*(>!?/(<%%"$%(8*5(811')#8+)6*% (/YPOK.P? )$+(8'()01203()
T6<-A)2ZIR2U0+
,"'#F%,( ) S+ ) /01123+ ) %KJ7-?.A ) ;- ) .XJP9:- ) ;-A ) <-?9-A+ )@$A+6 ( B) [O:? ) 0112 ) \-?)
K:<?-]+
)^[email protected]`.P+?-._F?-;:.A_,6A.:-9_,6A.:-9a%K-7-?.A+X.7K b)
/5P?AOK.J)K-)20_1c_01243+
,%Y%d,DGG%( ) *+ ) -. )#"Ee>d( ) G+ ) /01123+ ) ,-TJ96<- ) 6O.P76.:NO- ) ;- ) A.9OL.O9-A)
K:?<O:A.:NO-A ) -? ) LP9TOA ) = ) K- ) L6A ) ;-A ) J?P?LJA ) ;JM:?:.P:9-A+ )=87)$-% ( 5$ (
C-8998)-$(0V()T6<-A)2V4R2Ic+
'"Y%,( ) "+) /01203+ ) CX96A-PKP<:L6K ) T6..-9?A ) :? ) 6 ) K69<- ) LP9TOA ) PM ) 8:P7-;:L6K)
69.:LK-A+ )<* (=6-1"%2)*&6-9$5 ( -$%$8-#7 ( 8*5 ( '$8-*)*. ( )* ( >!?/ ( <%%"$% ( 8*5 (
811')#8+)6*%)/YPOK.P?)$+(8'()01203()T6<-A)cVRf0+
'FHH$",#$"E()"+)-. )#%>S%G()'+)/011I3+)&XPA-)F;-6)&6A)#X:A()6?;)&XB)HP-A):.)
!6..-9g)"..9:8O.:?<)'L:-?.:M:L)&P9h).P)5:.6.:P?A+)DE@2F00=E;)T6<-A)42ZR404+
'FE5G"F,( ) *+( ) *DE%'( ) '+ ) H"G%d( ) ,+) /011c3+ )%?<K:AX ) LPKKPL6.:P? ) A.O;:-A= ) #X- ) D'#F)
9-TP9.+)i9:AX?67O9.XB)/%;+3()GP?;P?)=)5P?.:?OO7+
'&"G%'()*+)!+)/2UU1_011c3+)e-?9-)"?6KBA:A=)%?<K:AX):?)"L6;-7:L)6?;),-A-69LX)
'-..:?<A+)56789:;<-)=)56789:;<-)>?:@-9A:.B)C9-AA+
'&"G%'()*+)!+ )"EH) S%"i()5+)Y+) /011c3+)"L6;-7:L)W9:.:?<)MP9)<96;O6.-)A.O;-?.A=)
%AA-?.:6K).6AhA)6?;)Ah:KKA()'-LP?;)-;:.:P?+)"??)"98P9)/!F3=)>+)PM)!:LX:<6?)C9-AA+
#%>S%G()'+)/2UUf3+)!-.6R;:ALPO9A-)769h-9A)6?;)T9P8K-7RA.9OL.O9:?<):?)AL:-?.:M:L)
69.:LK-A+ )G6-H%761(6*(I)%#6"-%$(!+-"#+"-$(8*5(I)%#6"-%$(J8-H$-%()"5G)2UUf()
!P?.9-6K+
#%>S%G( ) '+( )5",G%##"( ) *+ ) -. )!D%E'( ) !+ ) /2UUU3+ ) "? ) 6??P.6.:P? ) ALX-7- ) MP9)
;:ALPO9A-RK-@-K)69<O7-?.6.:P?):?)9-A-69LX)69.:LK-A+)>0=E+)T6<-A)221R22I+
#%>S%G( ) '+( )'FHH$",#$"E( ) "+ ) -. )#FH$",( ) H+ ) /011Z3+ ) "O.P76.:L ) LK6AA:M:L6.:P? ) PM)
L:.6.:P?)MO?L.:P?+)>JFE?;)T6<-A)214R221+
#>#FE)"+()e,D''!"EE)S+()S"G"F'%)"+()i,"FS)D+)/011U3+)"O.PO9);O)T9P[-.)'L:-?.-`.)=)
J.O;-);-A)769NO-A)K:?<O:A.:NO-A);O)TPA:.:P??-7-?.);-)Kj6O.-O9);6?A)K-A)JL9:.A)
AL:-?.:M:NO-A+)K6"-*L$%(E)*.")%+)M"$(5$(=6-1"%+)GP9:-?.+
#>#FE()"+)-. )e,D''!"EE()S+()J;:.-O9A)/k)T696:.9-3+)"O.PO9);O)LP9TOA)'L:-?.-`.)=)
;-)K6)LP?A.:.O.:P?);jO?)LP9TOA);jJL9:.A)AL:-?.:M:NO-A)k)KjJ.O;-);-A)769NO-A);O)
TPA:.:P??-7-?.)-.);O)96:AP??-7-?.+)C9-AA-A)>?:@-9A:.6:9-A);-),-??-A+
159
c ATALA
�

F13-1011 - Association for Computational Linguistics

Transcription

Documents pareils