Deliverable 6: German national report
Transcription
Deliverable 6: German national report
Project no. 518040 Project acronym: NEWS Project title: NETWORK ON ETHNICITY AND WOMEN SCIENTISTS Instrument: Specific Support Action Thematic Priority: Science and Society Deliverable 6: German national report Due date of deliverable: 31st March 2007 Actual submission date: 30 April 2007 Start date of project: 1st January 2006 Duration: 24 month Organisation name of lead contractor for this deliverable: ULB, Genre & Migration Project co-funded by the European Commission within the Sixth Framework Programme (2002-2006) Dissemination Level PU Public PP Restricted to other programme participants (including the Commission Services) RE Restricted to a group specified by the consortium (including the Commission Services) CO Confidential, only for members of the consortium (including the Commission Services) X NETWORK ON ETHNICITY AND WOMEN SCIENTISTS Deliverable 6: State of the art report - Germany Dr. Parminder KAUR BAKSHI-HAMM April 2007 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 Acknowledgements: NEWS, although a small research project, is timely and significant in the German context. Personally it provided me with an opportunity to return to research work after 10 years of effort and exclusion. For the completion of this research I would like to thank especially my husband, for his endless support and concrete help, and my two little daughters who made do at several lucnhtimes, just with yoghurt. Thanks also to Prof Lutz Hornke for hosting this project at his Institute when it needed an organisational base. Parminder Bakshi-Hamm Page 4 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 Table of contents 1. National situation/background ............................................................................................ 6 1.1. Migratory and colonial history........................................................................................ 6 1.2. Socio-demographic profile............................................................................................ 10 2. Women’s position in sciences .............................................................................................. 17 2.1. Women scientists targeted............................................................................................. 18 2.2. Women scientists in the public sector ........................................................................... 19 2.3. The national and local levels......................................................................................... 19 3. Data and statistics on women scientists ............................................................................... 20 3.1. Sources and variables available..................................................................................... 20 3.2. Obstacles and limits of statistics ................................................................................... 20 3.3. Statistics overview on education ................................................................................... 21 3.4. Statistics overview on academic and research employment ......................................... 24 4. Structure of the higher education and research system ........................................................ 27 4.1. Professional hierarchy in higher education ................................................................... 27 4.2. Professional hierarchy in research................................................................................. 28 4.3. Rules and practices of recruitment ................................................................................ 29 5. Studies on Women Scientists ............................................................................................ 31 5.1. Quantitative Information ............................................................................................ 31 5.2. Resutls of the Electronic Survey ................................................................................... 32 6. Policies, measures and programmes.................................................................................. 36 6.1. Good practices............................................................................................................... 36 6.2. Bad practices ................................................................................................................. 36 7. Existing academic/scientists networks .............................................................................. 37 8. National specificity ........................................................................................................... 37 9. Recommendations ............................................................................................................. 37 Page 5 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 1. National situation/background 1.1. Migratory and colonial history In Germany, as in other countries, migration - caused by labour shortages or the quest for a better life, by religious prosecution or political enforcement - has changed the structure of the population over centuries, constantly forming new ethnic minorities who are exposed to potential discrimination by the dominant population. Many of the migrational groups of past centuries are now fully assimilated into the German society, e.g. more than 40,000 Huegenots who escaped France in the 17th century, or about 150,000 Polish workers who stayed in Germany after working (under quite discriminatory conditions) in the mines and factories of the Ruhr region during the period 1871-1914. While for these groups, migration has resulted in the complete effacement of their ethnic identity, others groups have kept to their traditions and culture for centuries. Today, there are three regionally localised national minorities in Germany, who are legally protected under the Council of Europe's Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities (Federal Ministry of Interior, 2004). • Approximately 60,000 Sorbs, living in Saxony and other parts of Eastern Germany • About 60,000 Frisians at the Western coast of Germany • An estimated number of 50,000 Danes in the area of Flensburg in Northern Germany In addition, there are about 70,000 Sinti and Roma living in Germany without any distinct regional clustering, who are also protected under the framework convention. The Sinti and Roma are among those minority groups who became victim to the extremest form of ethnic persecution under the Nazi regime. The most prominent victim group during that time was the German Jews, who by expulsion and extermination were decimated from about half a million Jews in the nineteen-thierties to under 15,000 Jews in 1945. As a direct consequence of the territorial changes after World War II, by 1949, about 12 million displaced people of German origin had resettled from Eastern European countries into Germany. While these migrating people faced many difficulties at that time, they are by now fully integrated into the mainstream society. However, resettlement into Germany continued after 1949, forming the group of so called 'late repatriates' (Spätaussiedler) which will be looked at below. In 1950 there were about 500,000 foreigners living in the Federal Republic of Germany, which was roughly 1 percent of the population. In December 2006 the number of foreigners in Germany was approximately 7.3 million or 9 percent of the population. The cumulative immigration to Germany between 1950 and 2005 amounts to about 36,5 million people, while the number of people who emigrated from Germany totals to about 26,5 million people, leaving a net immigration of 10 million (Statistisches Bundesamt, 2006d). The influx of migrants into Germany was not steady and homogenous but proceeded in various phases relating to different groups: • 'Late repatriates' Germany allows all people of German origin (their German roots sometimes dating back several centuries) from East and South-East European countries to resettle in Germany, as their German origin was the cause of obvious discrimination after World War II in those countries. The resettlers immediately receive German nationality; Page 6 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 however, this does not automatically mean that this group of migrants blends more easily into German society than other migrants, even with regard to their command of the German language. In numbers, between 1950 and 2005 nearly 4.5 million resettlers came to Germany, thus forming 12 percent of all immigrants (Bundesverwaltungsamt, 2006). Most of the resettlers came from three countries: Poland, the former Soviet Union, and Rumania. It is also remarkable, that only one third of the resettlers came during the time of the Cold War, but two thirds later. The peak year for immigration of resettlers was 1990, a year marking the end of the Cold War, when nearly 400,000 people arrived. Today the numbers of resettlers are drastically declining, and 2006 was the first year, in which less than 10,000 resettlers entered the country. • Refugees The German constitution (“Grundgesetz”) grants politically persecuted refugees a right to asylum. Germany has also signed the UN Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees. Since 1953, approximately 3.1 million people have applied for asylum in Germany (Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, 2006a). The most prominent ethnic groups among the applicants are Kurds from Turkey and Iraq, as well as Albanians and Roma from Serbia and Montenegro. Before 1977 the number of asylum seekers did not contribute substantially to the total number of immigrants; the annual number of applications for asylum usually stayed well below 10,000, and the total number of applications before 1977 was merely 130,000. However, the following 10 years, 1977-1986, saw a drastic increase in applications for asylum to a total of more than 520,000. The largest group of asylum seekers during this period came from Turkey after the military coup in 1980. The collapse of the Soviet Bloc, and moreso the breakup of Yugoslavia caused a further rise in applications, and Germany became the most sought-after destination for asylum seekers in Europe. In 1992, 438,000 people applied for asylum in a single year. As a consequence, the constitutional right to asylum was limited to people who entered Germany directly from the country in which they were persecuted, in accordance with the so called Dublin Convention of the EU member states. By the end of the 1990s, the yearly application numbers had fallen below 100,000 again and since 2000, France and the UK receive more applications for asylum than Germany. In 2006, just 21,029 applications were submitted. In 2006, political asylum according to the German constitution was granted to only 251 applicants, which is just about 1 percent of all decisions (while the long-term average lies at 8 percent). However, another 1,097 applicants were recognised as refugees in the sense of the UN Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees. The average duration of the decision procedure for an application is 22 months (Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, 2007). • Eastern European Jews After the breakup of the Soviet Union, Germany started to facilitate the immigration of Jews who wanted to leave that area because of growing antisemitic discrimination and economic pressure. Quotas were allocated, and between 1991 and 2004, about Page 7 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 220,000 Jews came to Germany (S. Haug, P. Schimany, 2005). In fact, today 90 percent of the active members of Jewish communities in Germany are immigrants from the former Soviet Union. Although Jewish immigrants are mostly highly qualified (an estimated 70 percent have a university degree), unemployment rates are higher than 50 percent. • Migrant labourers The economic boom of the early 1950s encouraged the German government in 1955 to take up an offer of the Italian government to sign a recruitment agreement for migrant workers (“Gastarbeiter”), which became a model for similar agreements with Greece and Spain (1960), Turkey (1961), Morocco (1963), Portugal (1964), Tunesia (1965), and Yugoslavia (1968). In 1973 the number of migrant workers from these countries had risen to 2.6 million or 11.9 percent of all gainfully employed people in the Federal Republic of Germany. About 23 percent of the migrant workers came from Turkey, nearly 18 percent from Yugoslavia (Bundesministerium des Inneren, 2005). The economic recession and the 1973 oil crisis led to the cancellation of all recruitment agreements. Nevertheless, the 18 years of migrant worker recruitment have laid the foundation for the major part of the foreign population in Germany. The subsequent immigration of family members accounts for new arrivals of 50,000 to 80,000 people per year, and every year up to 100,000 children are born to foreign parents in Germany (Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, 2006b). While the stop on mass recruitment of foreigners is still in effect for most sectors of the labour market, the demographic situation and competition with other industrially advanced nations induced initiatives to attract highly qualified workers from abroad. Between 2000 and 2004, about 19,000 IT (Information Technology) specialists were permitted to work in Germany (Zentralstelle für Arbeitsvermittlung der Bundesagentur für Arbeit, 2005). Since 2005, all highly qualified migrants who receive job offers with yearly salaries above 85,000 € or as professors or researchers in leading positions, are allowed to settle in Germany. • International students German universities are increasingly interested in attracting international students. In 2004, about 186,000 students from abroad studied at German universities; among them 8.3% came from China, 6.9% from Poland, 6.2% from France, 4.8% from Spain, and 4.6% from the Russian Federation (Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, 2006). • Illegal immigrants Most estimates assume that there are around 1 million illegal immigants in Germany (S. Worbs, M. Wolf, P. Schimany, 2005). People who stay illegally in Germany are usually from one of three groups, which are in the order of their presumable size - one, people from Eastern Europe who work illegally in Germany although they pretend to be here only on a short term basis; two, relatives of legal immigrants who do not return to their country of origin after a visit to Germany; and three, unsuccessful asylum applicants. The one aspect in which the migrant population in Germany differs dramatically from that of most of its Western neighbours is in the absence of the colonial connection. The relatively Page 8 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 short-lived, inglorious colonial experiments during the years 1885 to 1917 in present day Namibia, Tanzania, Cameroon, Togo, and other countries have had no statistically significant effect on the population in Germany. The migrant population in Germany is most predominantly European/Mediterranean, and people of Asian, African or Caribbean origin have tended to be a rarity, though this too is gradually changing. While there were several occasions which brought larger groups of non-European migrants to Germany (e.g. migrant workers from Vietnam contracted by the GDR in the early nineteenseventies, many nurses coming from a number of Asian countries to counteract workforce shortages in the German medical sector, refugees from several African or Asian ‘hot spots’ such as the boat people, the largest fraction of Germany's black population (estimated several hundred-thousands) has its origin in relations of Afro-American soldiers and German mothers during the occupation of Germany after World War II (M. Sephocle, 1999). Recent years have seen a broad change in laws and regulations applicable to migrants in Germany. The partially conflicting motives for the revision of the legal statutes were: stricter regulation of immigration, European harmonisation, improving integration of migrants, counterbalancing the effects of demographic developments, and better preparation for the challenges of globalisation. In addition to important EU treaties, like the Schengen Implementation Convention (in effect since1995) regulating border controls, or the Convention determining the State responsible for examining applications for asylum lodged in one of the Member States of the European Communities - Dublin Convention (in effect since 1997), the three most important new German laws relevant to migrants are: z Amended Nationality Act in effect since 1 January 2000 (Bundesgesetzblatt, 2007) – While the main principle for aquiring German nationality used to be nationality by descent, the amended law introduces nationality based on the place of birth. It also reduces the length of residence in Germany required for naturalisation from 15 years to 8 years. z Immigration Act in effect since 1 January 2005 (Bundesgesetzblatt, 2004b) – This is the first ever comprehensive German legislation regulating all aspects of immigration, dealing with residence permits, humanitarian immigration and asylum, labour immigration in the context of highly qualified and self-employed people, and the integration of immigrants. For the context of this report, two points are especially relevant: one, that foreign researchers with expert knowledge and professors can obtain a permanent settlement permit without any waiting time; and two, foreign students are allowed to stay in Germany for one year after successful completion of their studies in order to look for an employment. A drafted revision of the Immigration Act was agreed upon by the German cabinet on 28 March 2007 (Bundesministerium des Inneren, 2007). This revision takes into account new EU directives and is especially relevant for asylum seekers whose applications have been declined (they are now allowed to stay in Germany if they manage to find a job), the immigration of spouses (who now have to have a minimum age of 18 years and must prove basic knowledge of the German language), and formulates new rules about collection of data for securtiy purposes. Most importantly Page 9 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 in the present context, it implements the EU directives 2004/114/EC about the mobility of non-EU students within the EU and 2005/71/EC about admission rules and right of residence for non-EU researchers. z General Act on Equal Treatment, in effect since 18 August 2006, (Bundesgesetzblatt , 2006) – This law is a consequence of the European anti-discrimination initiative formulated in various EU directives and is meant to protect against (among others) racially or ethnically motivated discrimination in the field of employment and areas of everyday life. 1.2. Socio-demographic profile Until the year 2005, official German statistics, gathered by the Statistisches Bundesamt (Federal Statistical Office), Wiesbaden, did not use ethnicity or migrational history as a parameter. In fact, there is hardly any statistical data available, which compares within the population of Germany different groups with migrational background. Interpreting the constitutional postulate that “no one may be prejudiced or favoured because of his sex, his parentage, his race, his language, his homeland and origin, his faith or his religious or political opinions” (Article 3(3)) as a reason not even to ask for the persons background, has clearly led to difficulties in monitoring and proving unequal treatment towards these groups. Thus, for many years the most comprehensive source of data about migrants in Germany is that which has been collected for half a century in the Central Register of Foreigners (Ausländerzentralregister). However, these numbers include only migrants who are not German nationals – and thereby does not say anything about late repatriates, naturalised migrants, or children with one German parent. The following table presents figures taken from data published by the Federal Statistical Office (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland, 2006a). It should be noted here that statistical information on migrant and minority populations in Germany is scarce, exists only in a raw and general form, and does not lend itself to analysis. The tables presented in this report have therefore been extrapolated from the various sources cited in this text. Table 1: Foreign population on 31.12.2005 by citizenship and age groups Age Nationality Gender Total Under 15 European males Union 15 – 20 20 – 25 25 – 35 35 – 45 45 – 55 55 – 65 Over 65 Average age in years 1 132 931 95 381 44 417 71 163 223 965 240 965 201 838 153 620 101 582 40.7 females 1 011 717 89 995 43 502 83 108 240 182 201 526 159 967 118 601 74 836 38.8 87 919 154 271 464 147 442 491 361 805 272 221 176 418 39.8 272 184 122 634 123 124 374 717 290 235 140 981 192 918 126 581 35.1 255 375 115 640 139 380 364 309 251 860 180 171 180 989 99 434 34.9 both 2 144 648 males 1 643 374 Other Europe including females 1 587 158 185 376 Page 10 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 Turkey Northern Africa both Central Africa Australia and Oceania No or 226 015 35.0 8 682 26 996 15 837 5 585 4 865 4 775 34.3 females 44 306 6 540 3 133 5 649 12 699 6 754 5 149 2 683 1 699 32.0 121 842 13 630 6 839 14 331 39 695 22 591 10 734 7 548 6 474 33.5 males 43 371 4 847 2 197 3 834 11 863 14 151 4 924 1 270 285 32.5 females 25 586 4 903 1 348 1 783 8 223 6 921 2 028 311 69 29.0 both 68 957 9 750 3 545 5 617 20 086 21 072 6 952 1 581 354 31.2 males 18 706 3 173 1 137 2 425 6 385 4 054 1 214 215 103 28.1 females 13 272 3 103 1 043 1 696 4 323 2 433 475 124 75 25.4 both 31 978 6 276 2 180 4 121 10 708 6 487 1 689 339 178 26.9 8 986 1 627 705 623 1 568 3 118 1 124 148 73 31.2 7 518 1 644 683 748 1 900 1 575 558 287 123 28.6 both 16 504 3 271 1 388 1 371 3 468 4 693 1 682 435 196 30.0 males 62 606 3 872 1 708 3 803 10 280 16 705 12 205 6 732 7 301 42.7 females 48 187 3 573 2 010 3 791 9 041 11 189 7 166 4 806 6 611 41.8 110 793 7 445 3 718 7 594 19 321 27 894 19 371 11 538 13 912 42.3 males 21 988 2 389 1 724 2 714 6 736 4 524 2 233 1 077 591 32.4 females 47 075 2 438 2 028 4 350 15 447 13 471 6 128 2 272 941 35.3 both 69 063 4 827 3 752 7 064 22 183 17 995 8 361 3 349 1 532 34.4 males 155 528 29 116 10 879 16 272 40 790 31 073 15 618 6 696 5 084 30.7 females 113 234 26 196 8 979 12 082 26 393 19 666 10 696 4 969 4 253 29.5 both 268 762 55 312 19 858 28 354 67 183 50 739 26 314 11 665 9 337 30.2 128 007 22 190 7 219 11 245 31 612 32 554 16 508 4 630 2 049 31.6 females 156 184 21 389 5 935 11 074 42 146 45 099 22 014 6 178 2 349 33.4 both 284 191 43 579 13 154 22 319 73 758 77 653 38 522 10 808 4 398 32.6 males 130 196 17 677 7 380 15 559 40 998 26 256 13 494 5 703 3 129 31.6 females 140 079 16 487 6 808 18 461 47 622 26 984 13 254 5 987 4 476 32.1 both 270 275 34 164 14 188 34 020 88 620 53 240 26 748 11 690 7 605 31.9 males 5 235 350 178 378 1 426 1 219 773 437 474 39.4 females 4 922 308 291 446 1 280 1 064 660 491 382 38.5 both 10 157 658 469 824 2 706 2 283 1 433 928 856 39.0 males 35 961 9 025 2 850 3 534 7 155 5 660 3 415 2 028 2 294 30.8 South-east males Asia Eastern and Central Asia 321 152 373 907 3 706 both Western Asia 542 095 7 090 females South America 527 559 238 274 262 504 739 026 77 536 Southern males Africa Northern America 3 230 532 April 2007 males both Western Africa German Report Page 11 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 unknown nationality females German Report April 2007 24 952 8 331 2 265 2 064 4 083 3 008 2 140 1 199 1 862 28.7 60 913 17 356 5 115 5 598 11 238 8 668 5 555 3 227 4 156 29.9 3 493 799 473 446 209 318 266 489 792 548 693 433 422 699 381 202 254 664 36.4 females 3 262 012 444 672 196 005 288 786 791 274 600 215 413 476 329 978 197 606 35.6 both 918 118 405 323 555 275 1 583 822 1 293 648 836 175 711 180 452 270 36.0 Germans males 36 846 162 5 502 1012 270 4872 194 9834 211 265 6 420 119 5 614 4274 331 043 6 301 737 41.7 females 38 836 022 5 229 6532 159 9792 103 5504 060 166 6 167 378 5 517 9714 481 258 9 116 067 45.0 both 43.5 both Total males foreigners 6 755 811 75 682 18410 731 7544 430 4664 298 5338 271 43112 587 49711 132 3988 812 301 15 417 804 Source: Statistisches Bundesamt (2006) Ausländische Bevölkerung, Fachserie 1 Reihe 2, 2006 and Bevölkerungsfortschreibung, Fachserie 1 Reihe 1.3 The predominance of European foreigners in Germany is clearly visible, although a larger part of them comes from non-EU countries. The 5 most important former countries of origin are Table 2: Foreign population on 31.12.2005 Most frequent origin Turkey males females both former Yugoslavia Italy former Soviet Union Poland 937 581 826 460 1 764 041 males 499 974 females 463 027 both 963 001 males 319 136 females 221 674 both 540 810 males 207 710 females 300 139 both 507 849 males 152 653 females 173 943 both 326 596 Source: Statistisches Bundesamt (2006) Ausländische Bevölkerung, Fachserie 1 Reihe 2. The first three countries in the above table were the most important for labour migration of the nineteen-sixties (and therefore have a relatively low female proportion), whereas the other two became important after the end of the Cold War and are the main source of present immigration to Germany – with a relatively high proportion of women due to marriage migration (marriage of foreign women to German men). The average age of the foreign population at 36 years, is noticeable lower than the average age of the total population, which is 43.5 years. This is a clear sign that migration leads to a rejuvenation of the population in Germany. Page 12 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 The percentage of women is lower in the foreign population (48.3 percent) than in the total population (51.1 percent). This is mostly because of the higher proportion of men among labour migrants. There are only two migrant groups where the female percentage is clearly higher than in the total population – among people from South-East Asia (55 percent) and from South America (68.2 percent), and this can be explained with the significant numbers of women from the Philippines, Thailand, and Brazil who come to Germany due to marriage migration, that is marriage of foreign women to German men. Another remarkable fact about foreigners in Germany is their extremely unhomogenous distribution within Germany. The proportion of foreigners in the Western German states which formed the Federal Republic of Germany before 1990 is 10.1 percent, while it is only 2.4 percent in the Eastern German states of the former GDR. Also, there is a clear concentration in big cities like Berlin, Frankfurt, Hamburg, Cologne. The percentage of foreigners is highest in the Rhein-Main area around Frankfurt, where the record percentage of 31.1 percent is found in the city of Offenbach (Die Zeit, 4 May 2006). Not surprisingly, second-generation migrants form a constantly growing fraction of the foreign population. Table 3: Foreign population on 31.12.2005 Percentage of second generation Foreigners born in Germany Foreign population Nationality Percentage European Union 2 144 648 407 033 18.98% Other Europe including Turkey 3 230 532 822 538 25.46% Outside Europe 1 380 631 155 729 11.28% 6 755 811 1 385 300 20.51% Total Source: Statistisches Bundesamt (2006) Ausländische Bevölkerung, Fachserie 1 Reihe 2. As for the residence status of non-EU foreigners living in Germany, there is a clear division between European and non-European migrants; the majority of European, but less than a third of non-European migrants hold a permanent residence status. Table 4: Foreign population on 31.12.2005 by residence status Nationality non-EU Europe including Turkey outside Europe Gender Total Permanent residence Temporariy residence Permission or leave population title title to stay No permission or leave males 1643374 1002206 60.98% 496336 30.20% 64011 3.90% 80821 4.92% females 1587158 900074 56.71% 568048 35.79% 57313 3.61% 61723 3.89% both 3230532 1902280 58.88% 1064384 32.95% 121324 3.76% 142544 4.41% males 717494 216518 30.18% 339198 47.28% 85592 11.93% 76186 10.62% females 663137 222544 33.56% 341104 51.44% 47354 7.14% 52135 7.86% 1380631 439062 31.80% 680302 49.27% 132946 9.63% 128321 9.29% both Page 13 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 Source: Statistisches Bundesamt (2006), Wiesbaden, Ausländische Bevölkerung, Fachserie 1, Reihe 2. Nearly two thirds of the foreigners living in Germany have been in the country for more than 8 years and would therefore be entitled to naturalisation according to the new Nationality Act (Bundesgesetzblatt, Bonn, 2007). The next table shows the twenty countries of origin of which the largest number of people acquired the German nationality in 2005 (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland, 2006c). Table 5: Naturalisations 2005 Gender Male Total Female Both 59923 57318 117241 thereof Turkey 17870 14791 32661 Serbia and Montenegro 5163 3661 8824 Poland 2110 4786 6896 Russian Federation 2084 2971 5055 Iran 2444 2038 4482 Morocco 2238 1446 3684 Ucraina 1519 1844 3363 Afghanistan 1717 1416 3133 Israel 1485 1386 2871 Libanon 1123 846 1969 Sri Lanka 1087 857 1944 Bosnia-Herzegowina 840 1067 1907 Rumania 532 1257 1789 Italy 842 787 1629 Greece 700 646 1346 Pakistan 836 485 1321 Croatia 562 725 1287 Vietnam 631 647 1278 Macedonia 573 536 1109 Syria 601 460 1061 Source: Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006c) Einbürgerungsstatistik. In Germany, in between the complete censuses, which happen about every 10 years, the Federal Statistical Office organises an official yearly survey of 1 percent (i.e. more than 800,000 people) of the population, called a microcensus. Following statistical rules, a number of representative sampling districts are selected in which all households and persons are interviewed. The microcensus question programme consists of a fixed standard (age, sex, citizenship, family and household context, place of residence, employment, job search, child at preprimary age, educational qualifications, sources of subsistence, level of the individual and household net incomes, amongst others) and a yearly changing supplementary programme. It is legally compulsory to answer most of the questions. Page 14 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 A new law makes provision for including questions on migrational background of the interviewees, which for the first time makes it possible to collect on a large scale data about German nationals who are immigrants or children of immigrants (Bundesgesetzblatt, 2004a). The first microcensus according to the new rules was conducted in 2005. The results of this microcensus and analyses have not been fully published yet, but it shows clearly that studies about the effects of migration into Germany should not be confined to foreigners, but must also involve Germans with migrational background, a group that has numerically superceded the foreigners living in Germany. It makes sense to classify people with migrational background broadly into four groups: foreigners who immigrated into Germany (1st generation), foreigners who were born in Germany (2nd and 3rd generation), immigrants who are now German (1st generation), and Germans who are children of immigrants (2nd generation). A more detailed breakdown of the microcensus data shows the absolute and relative sizes of these groups (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland , 2006). Table 6: Various population groups with different migrational background 2005 Thousands Persons with migrational background Percentage 15332 18.60% .....Foreigners 7321 8.90% ..........1st generation 5571 6.80% ..........2nd generation 1643 2.00% ..........3rd generation 107 0.10% .....Germans 8012 9.70% ..........1st generation 4828 5.90% ...............late repatriates 1769 2.10% ...............naturalised 3059 3.70% ..........2nd generation 3184 3.90% ...............late repatriates ...............naturalised ...............by birth ...............one German parent 283 0.30% 1095 1.30% 278 0.30% 1528 1.90% Persons without migrational background 67133 81.40% Total population 82465 100.00% Source: Extracted from the data provided by the Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland on the Micorcensus 2005. The participation of people with migrational background in the German labour market can be seen in the following table. Table 7: Gainful occupation, microcensus 2005 with migrational background Occupation Foreigners 1st generation women 2nd generation men without migrational background Germans women 1st generation men women 2nd generation men women men women men full time 507 1360 128 266 616 1251 161 256 8058 part time 522 196 65 33 523 109 83 39 6092 1203 none 1689 1298 601 656 1334 994 1307 1337 20439 15885 Page 15 of 38 15456 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 Source: Extracted from the data provided by the Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland on the Micorcensus 2005. According to the data of the Bundesagentur für Arbeit (German Job Centre) there were 1123 thousand foreign men and 659 thousand foreign women employed subject to social insurance contributions in 2006 (Bundesagentur für Arbeit , 2007). At the same time, 326 thousand foreign men and 281 thousand foreign women received unemployment benefits. This means that foreign men constitute 7.8 percent of all male social insurance contributors and 12.9 percent of all unemployed men, while these numbers are 5.5 percent and 12.2 percent, respectively, for female foreigners. The only job sectors, in which foreigners are overrepresented are the hotel and restaurant industry, while they are especially under-represented in the sectors of banking, public administration, and education. The table below shows the educational level of the various population groups derived from the microcensus data. Table 8: Level of education and migrational background, microcensus 2005 (numbers in thousands) with migrational background Level of education Foreigners 1st generation school certificate women 2nd generation men without migrational background Germans women 1st generation men women 2nd generation men women men women men total still in school 2718 2853 792 953 2473 2354 1548 1626 34589 32544 211 237 468 520 227 230 1157 1197 5185 5394 lower secondary 1238 1437 225 316 1503 1443 228 266 22749 19214 upper secondary 663 693 73 91 529 518 146 145 5840 7273 no secondary 582 455 26 27 200 149 17 18 532 468 unknown 25 32 15 14 284 194 university degree (absolute) 314 365 10 27 203 250 37 41 2678 4253 university degree (relative) 12.5% 13.9% 3.1% 6.2% 9.0% 11.8% 9.4% 9.5% 9.1% 15.7% Source: Extracted from the date provided by the Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland on Mikrozensus 2005. The last line shows for each group, the percentages of people who hold a university degree, calculated in relation to the number of people who have finished school, i.e. total number minus the individuals in the “still in school” group. The comparison of these percentages is quite revealing: The average in the total population is 12.1 percent. Within the population without migrational background, there is a drastic gender imbalance, which can be traced back to the older age groups, where traditional gender roles probably stopped many women from going to university. Among the first generation migrants these age groups are underrepresented. While there is a clear gender imbalance, it is not as drastic as one might expect. Also, the percentage of university educated foreign migrants is larger than the percentage of university educated people in the total population, indicating that migration of highly qualified people, including foreign students at German universities, starts to show statistically significant effects. However, the numbers for the second generation groups with migrant background are alarming, where the percentages of university graduates drops below the national average. This is also true for second generation members with German nationality, but for them at least there is no gender imbalance. However, second generation members with foreign nationality reach even lower proportions of university education – and there is a Page 16 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 striking gender imbalance. Second generation women migrants are only half as likely to finish a university degree as second generation male migrants. This probably implies a case of amplified multiple discrimination against female foreign second generation migrants in Germany. It is also obvious from the data that multiple discrimination takes effect primarily after secondary school, as there is no such drastic imbalance in the number of secondary school certificates. 2. Women’s position in sciences In international comparisons about the representation of women in research, Germany is usually clearly below the average. For instance, in the year 2003 the EU overall proportion of women among all researchers at universities was 35 percent, while it was only 25 percent in Germany (European Commission , 2006). However, the last decade has seen a considerable increase in female percentages at all levels of university research and academic staff positions. Universities have institutionalised equal opportunities representatives for women, and there are support measures for female researchers established at university level, as well as special support programmes and grant schemes for women who want to follow an academic career. The federal government has set up a special unit “Women in Education and Research” at the Ministry for Education and Research (Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung, 2006b). In the period 2001–2006, the federal and the state governments maintained a special programme “Equal Opportunities for Women in Education and Research” with an annual budget of about 30,000,000 Euro. Particular emphasis was placed on increasing the number of female professors, which rose from 6.5 percent in 1992 to 13.6 percent in 2004 (Bund-Länder-Kommission zur Bildungsplanung und Forschungsförderung , 2006). As for the newly filled professorial positions in 2005, 20.5 percent of the applicants, 22.6 percent of the shortlisted candidates, and 23.2 percent of the appointed professors were women. In spite of all the progress this has to be seen in relation to the fact that, by now, more than half the students are female. It is also important to note that there are huge regional differences as well as differences between subjects, and that there are many universities where the proportion of female professors is well below 10 percent. An issue which has been recently picked out for statistical analysis is the co-relation between academic career and having children. In Northrhine-Westfalia, Germany’s largest state, a new study (Auferkorte-Michaelis, Nicole, et.al, 2005) has shown that 78 percent of the female (and also 71 percent of the male) junior scientific staff at universities do not have children. This is much higher than the corresponding numbers for the general university educated population in the relevant age group (50 percent for women and 45 percent for men) and indicates that a university career in Germany is very difficult to combine with children. While this is not a gender issue alone, it should certainly be taken into consideration when looking at the situation of migrant women at German universities. Nearly in all subject areas, support networks for women have been set up, and there is a national centre for equal opportunities for women and men in the area of science and research, Center of Excellence Women and Science, CEWS in Bonn. According to its website CEWS, “is the national node for the realization of equal opportunities for women and men in the area of science and research in Germany. CEWS serves as think tank for this field of policy, stimulates thinking, initiates alteration processes for which it provides scientific support, and actively co-organises the required transfer processes between science and politics. . . . As a Page 17 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 knowledge and research-based service institute, CEWS services are available to scientists, universities, research groups, scientific organisations, and political panels” (See http://www.cews.org/cews/en/profil.php). However, in all these programmes, studies, and initiatives, the problems of minority groups within female researchers have, until now, not been focussed on. 2.1. Women scientists targeted Women working in all fields and subjects of academic research will be included in the description of the situation in Germany. However, sometimes it will be instructive to look especially at those disciplines which traditionally have a low percentage of women, e.g. engineering or natural sciences. In the German context the division into the three categories migrants, refugees and ethnic minorities does not seem to be the best classification for tracing different typical patterns of the problems of minority women: Refugees, as long as they have no approved resident status, will not normally have a chance to follow an academic career anyway, but once their status is approved, they will not easily be distinguishable from other migrants. So also for the recognised national ethnic minorities (Sorbes, Frisians, Danes, Sinti, and Roma) it will neither be viable to find enough cases nor is there any indication that the difficulties of women from these groups are markedly different from those of the German majority since there is no practical way of identifying members of these groups. Instead, there are two subgroups where even a brief glance at the statistical data suggests that amplifying effects of multiple discrimination are in action. A) Second generation migrant women who do not hold German nationality – The microcensus data citied in Section 1.2. shows clearly that already at the stage of university degrees, women of this group are much more underrepresented than what one would expect by a simple multiplicative effect of gender and migrational imbalance. Therefore it is likely that for this group there are also special problems in accessing the academic job market and in following a research career. B) First generation migrant women from outside Europe or North-America – Among the highly qualified immigrants coming to Germany from outside Europe, women are drastically under-represented – much more drastically than one would expect from the proportion of women working in academic jobs in those countries. For instance, in the Indian IT sector the female percentage is currently estimated as 24 percent, but only 8.2 percent of the Indian IT experts attracted to Germany by a special programme between 2000 and 2004 were women [Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, 2006; NASSCOM, 2006). Similar disproportions can be found in the applications for grants to visit German universities. This leads to the hypothesis that there is some form of amplified multiple discrimination that also deters women from these countries from taking up an academic career in Germany. For comparative reasons a third subgroup is expected to show very different circumstances: Page 18 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 C) Second generation migrant women who are German nationals – This group is expected to be more integrated into the majority society, and it is interesting to analyse whether the situation for women from this group mirrors the situation of German women without migrational background. 2.2. Women scientists in the public sector This study is confined to women with a regular employment contract at universities (Universitäten, Technische Hochschulen, Fachhochschulen) or public research institutes, in particular Max-Planck Institutes, Fraunhofer Institutes, and Research Centres of the Helmholtz- and the Leibniz-Gemeinschaft. In 2006 there were 103 general and technical universities as well as 172 universities for Applied Sciences (polytechnics, Fachhochschulen) in Germany with an academic staff of around 49,000 people. In some German statistics where the term “universities” is used in a general way, it also includes 104 colleges of art, administration, pedagogy, or theology, which do not strictly correspond with the target group of this study, but sometimes cannot be separated. There are about 80 Max-Planck Institutes (for Pure Sciences) with 124,00 employees, 56 Fraunhofer Institutes (for Applied Sciences) with roughly the same number of employees, 15 large scale Research Centres of the Helmholtz-Gemeinschaft with 25,700 employees, and 83 smaller research centres of the Leibniz-Gemeinschaft with 13,700 employees. About a third of the employees of theses institutions are researchers. The gender statistics shows that the female proportion is mostly somewhat lower than at universities, although the last decade has seen a remarkable increase (see table 18 below) Since there are merely scattered statistical numbers available with respect to the situation of foreigners at research centres, the data presented in Section 3 is on universities only. 2.3. The national and local levels With the recent change in the German constitution in July 2006, regarding the organisational responsibilities in the Federal Republic of Germany, the sole competency for the German university system has been put in the hands of the 16 German states (Bundesländer). Therefore the 16 state governments have to be the prime addressees for suggestions on how to improve policies in order to counteract potential discrimination, and it is therefore pertinent to look at the situation of minority women in research in each state separately. However, the Federal Government still determines the general policy in the field of Research and Technology, and it finances important support programmes. Also there are several mechanism in place which guarantee a certain harmonisation of all state policies. On their side, most German states have initiated rules and procedures which aim at more autonomy of the universities. This means that all concrete measures for supporting female researchers from minorities have to be implemented at university level. It also means that already now there are likely to be considerable differences for the target groups of this study between different universities. Page 19 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 3. Data and statistics on women scientists 3.1. Sources and variables available On legal base, the Federal Statistics Office and its counterparts in the individual states, every year gather detailed data from universities and other institutions for education and research. Processed excerpts of the data are published in comprehensive compendia like the Bundesforschungsbericht (Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung, 2006a), the Report on Education and Training by the Federal Commissioner for Migration, Refugees, and Integration (Informationen der Beauftragten der Bundesregierung für Migration, 2005), and the Report on University Personnel by the Federal Statistics Office (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland, 2006f). While these statistics are based on information from personnel departments and students registries, the other potential data source are census results such as the yearly microcensus (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland, 2006e). 3.2. Obstacles and limits of statistics All the above mentioned published statistics give gender relations for most of its results. In all the statistical data collected by the statistical offices from universities, the nationality is the only variable from which it is possible to infer the migrational status of people. However, even the nationality does not seem to be a variable which is consistently collected by the personnel offices as they show high numbers of “unknown nationality” in the statistics of university employees. Unfortunately, most of the employment data published does not specify nationality at all. This is quite different for student numbers, as the educational situation of foreigners is a prevalent topic by now. There, however, not all numbers are analysed by gender. The rarity of employment data specified by nationality and gender shows that the danger of combined effects of multiple discrimination in this area has not even been acknowledged yet. As mentioned earlier, it would be interesting to analyse data by migrational background. It is of course impossible to conclude from the nationality whether a person was born abroad or is a member of the second generation, or belongs to the group of late repatriates, or has been naturalised, or has parents who migrated to Germany. All this information is now, in principle, available through the results of the microcensus 2005 (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland, 2006e). However, there is a serious limitation regarding the usefulness of the microcensus for the purpose of this study; since it involves only a 1 percent sample of the total population, it is by definition useless for statistically meaningful statements about population groups with less than 5000 members. Nevertheless, if one does not ask for too detailed specifications like break-downs by country, microcensus data will still give new insights into the situation of minority women in research. It is very difficult to obtain local statistical data about the nationality of the university employees directly from the personnel offices of universities because of data protection rules and reservation towards unusual requests for statistical analyses. Page 20 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 3.3. Statistics overview on education The general statistics of educational levels in the various population groups has already been depicted in the last table of Section 1.2. The following table shows the relative distribution of highest secondary school certificates obtained by school leavers in the year 1995 and in the year 2005 – for Germans and for foreigners (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland, 2006b) . Table 9: Percentage of school leavers 1995 within population groups Total all Germans male female all Foreigners male female all male female Without secondary certificate .................... 8,8 11,1 6,4 7,7 9,8 5,4 19,7 23,2 15,8 With lower secondary certificate................ 27,4 30,4 24,3 25,7 28,9 22,3 43,8 43,9 43,8 With intermediate secondary certificate...... 38,9 36,5 41,4 40,1 37,8 42,6 26,8 24,2 29,8 With polytechnic entrance certificate.......... 0,8 0,7 0,8 0,8 0,7 0,8 0,8 0,7 0,9 With university entrance certificate............. 24,1 21,3 27,1 25,7 22,8 28,9 8,8 8,1 9,7 Table 10: Percentage of school leavers 2005 within population groups Total all Germans male female all Foreigners male female all male female Without secondary certificate .................... 8,2 10,2 6,0 7,2 9,1 5,3 17,5 21,0 13,7 With lower secondary certificate................ 24,8 28,0 21,5 23,1 26,5 19,7 41,7 43,0 40,2 With intermediate secondary certificate...... 41,6 40,1 43,2 42,6 41,3 43,9 31,4 28,2 34,9 With polytechnic entrance certificate.......... 1,3 1,2 1,4 1,3 1,2 1,4 1,4 1,2 1,5 With university entrance certificate............. 24,1 20,5 28,0 25,7 21,8 29,6 8,8 7,3 10,4 Source: Statistische Bundesamt Deutschland (2006) Bildung und Kultur – Allgemeinbildende Schulen. The different levels of secondary education in Germany are called Hauptschulabschluss, Realschulabschluss, Fachhochschulreife and Allgemeine Hochschulreife (Abitur). The table shows that foreign children living in Germany are three times less likely to obtain a university entrance certificate than German children, but the gender proportion within foreigners is by now similar to that of Germans: The female percentage is in both cases 56 percent. The following table shows the female proportions in German universities at various stages for all students, for German students, for all foreign students, and for foreign students who went to school in Germany (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland, 2006f): Page 21 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 Table 11: Female percentages within student groups in 2005 Total Germans Foreigners Foreigners from German schools Newly enrolled 49 48 52 49 All enrolled students 48 48 50 45 Exams passed 50 50 47 45 Source: Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006) Personal an Hochschulen - Daten zum Hochschulpersonal, Personalstellen und Stellenäquivalente sowie Habilitationen an deutschen Hochschulen im Berichtsjahr 2005. Obviously relatively fewer women than with a university entrance certificate actually take up a university course – this is true for Germans and foreigners. Foreign students from abroad who start at German universities have a clearly higher female percentage. While female students are more successful than male during their courses in general, this does not seem to be true for foreign students, as one can see from the proportions in passed exams, and this might be an indicator of special difficulties which students from this group experience (although there might be other explanations like a time delay in the increase of foreign female percentages). More detailed numbers about the origin of foreign students at German universities who went to school in Germany can be seen in the following table: Table 12: Foreign students from German schools at German universities in 2005 Origin Total male female female perc. Total 58 907 32 393 26 514 45,0% EU non-EU Europe Africa America Asia selected countries Greece Italy Poland Croatia Russian Federation Turkey Brasil United States Afghanistan China India Iran Japan Korea Vietnam 17 640 28 573 2 041 1 052 8 762 9 271 15 904 1 470 543 4 794 8 369 12 669 571 509 3 968 47,4% 44,3% 28,0% 48,4% 45,3% 3 303 3 184 2 882 3 705 2 127 15 342 141 438 610 1 329 405 1 586 390 1 221 834 1 863 1 799 1 231 1 996 1 010 9 045 66 227 423 681 279 974 127 531 488 1 440 1 385 1 651 1 709 1 117 6 297 75 211 187 648 126 612 263 690 346 43,6% 43,5% 57,3% 46,1% 52,5% 41,0% 53,2% 48,2% 30,7% 48,8% 31,1% 38,6% 67,4% 56,5% 41,5% selected regions Source: Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006) Personal an Hochschulen - Daten zum Hochschulpersonal, Personalstellen und Stellenäquivalente sowie Habilitationen an deutschen Hochschulen im Berichtsjahr 2005. Page 22 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 The various types of exams taken by foreign students at German universities in 2005 can be seen in the following list, broken down separately for men and women by country of origin. Table 13: Foreign students by type of exam passed – All foreigners and 10 most frequent countries Total China ................................................................. Turkey ............................................................... Poland .............................................................. Russian Federation .................................... France .............................................................. Greece .............................................................. Austria .............................................................. India ................................................................... Korea ................................................................ Bulgaria ............................................................ All foreigners ... Turkey ............................................................... China ................................................................. India ................................................................... Austria .............................................................. Greece .............................................................. France .............................................................. Poland .............................................................. Morocco ......................................................... Russian Federation .................................... Italy ..................................................................... All foreigners ... China ................................................................. Poland .............................................................. Turkey ............................................................... Russian Federation .................................... France .............................................................. Bulgaria ............................................................ Korea ................................................................ Greece .............................................................. Ukraine ............................................................. Italy ..................................................................... All foreigners ... Diploma School Polytechnic (equivalent Doctorate teachers' Batchelor exam to master) exam Men and women 2 290 881 2 069 899 1 229 698 1 087 521 888 466 825 459 804 345 794 36 746 568 705 364 Master 348 104 139 185 81 113 89 199 133 58 83 14 23 43 29 15 1 1 2 221 701 173 168 214 134 282 13 18 65 156 64 85 48 23 20 31 21 5 124 684 218 120 142 61 70 42 524 21 92 10 286 Men 1 294 524 1 078 384 669 27 504 183 433 234 396 205 386 198 382 126 380 162 373 134 3 556 439 4 372 1 118 3 961 62 201 154 53 68 37 69 13 98 75 23 4 6 4 3 3 10 483 83 13 216 88 108 58 219 60 119 40 73 13 22 9 13 26 13 16 12 162 337 462 26 28 29 32 11 41 23 12 515 4 595 Women 1 212 497 843 500 775 375 707 359 492 261 441 246 441 373 392 225 332 189 309 133 2 195 90 2 618 591 2 426 147 70 42 87 44 29 41 45 25 82 11 60 20 39 2 1 23 13 25 138 115 218 108 106 33 13 46 61 43 83 59 24 32 10 70 1 11 13 11 347 88 56 101 32 61 12 42 31 15 11 217 1 361 349 1 754 527 1 535 23 732 5 691 Source: Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006) Personal an Hochschulen - Daten zum Hochschulpersonal, Personalstellen und Stellenäquivalente sowie Habilitationen an deutschen Hochschulen im Berichtsjahr 2005. The female percentage among all passed doctorate exams is 38.3 percent, which is not too different from the 39.8 percent for German students. A typical distribution with respect to different disciplines is shown by the local numbers of PhD exams at the RWTH Aachen, one of the 10 biggest German universities with a special focus on engineering and related subjects (RWTH Aachen, 2006). Page 23 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 Table 14: PhD exams at RWTH Aachen in 2005 Germans Discipline Total Mathematics and Natural Sciences Foreigners Female 159 Architecture Total 55 Female 51 23 6 3 0 0 26 1 4 0 136 13 18 5 Georesources and Materials 78 18 24 9 Electrical Engineering 43 3 11 1 Arts and Humanities 22 13 3 1 Civil Engineering Mechanical Engineering Business Administration and Economics 17 8 3 3 Medicine 211 106 8 8 Total 698 220 122 50 Source: RWTH Aachen (2006) RWTH International – Internationalisierungsreport 2006. 3.4. Statistics overview on academic and research employment The most complete table about employment statistics at German universities which contains nationality as well as gender data can be found in the personnel statistics for academic staff of German universities compiled by the Federal Statistics Office (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland, 2006f): Table 15: Academic staff at German universities in 2005 Foreigners Total Germans Nationality unknown regular employments Contractual basis without contribution to social all Professors security total Men and women State Baden-Württemberg ......................... 37 128 32 970 168 3 990 2 842 367 1 148 Bayern ............................................. Berlin ............................................... Brandenburg .................................... Bremen ............................................ 35 029 19 258 4 092 3 456 31 436 17 572 3 686 3 175 197 5 1 - 3 396 1 681 405 281 2 537 1 100 258 240 306 148 41 46 859 581 147 41 Hamburg .......................................... 8 609 8 132 - 477 400 49 77 Hessen ............................................ Mecklenburg-Vorpommern ............... 17 953 4 281 7 293 4 058 9 820 5 840 218 691 164 63 22 149 54 Niedersachsen ................................. 19 132 16 932 743 1 457 1 107 113 350 Nordrhein-Westfalen ........................ 45 161 41 055 84 4 022 2 959 399 1 063 Rheinland-Pfalz ................................ Saarland .......................................... 9 609 4 054 6 456 2 947 2 750 761 403 346 265 279 41 18 138 67 Sachsen ........................................... Sachsen-Anhalt ............................... 13 711 6 579 12 643 6 157 - 1 068 422 731 320 90 38 337 102 Page 24 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 Schleswig-Holstein .......................... German Report April 2007 5 567 5 209 - 358 312 38 46 Thüringen ......................................... Total 6 567 240 186 6 137 205 858 1 14 535 429 19 793 334 14 539 48 1 827 95 5 254 Type of university General or technical university ........ Pedagogical university ..................... Theological University ...................... Art college ........................................ Polytechnic ....................................... College for administration ................. 183 839 1 712 464 9 491 41 264 3 416 155 357 1 657 434 7 875 37 550 2 985 11 291 433 2 396 415 17 191 55 30 1 183 1 318 16 13 536 32 16 480 467 8 1 207 4 8 374 233 1 3 655 23 14 703 851 8 Women State Baden-Württemberg ......................... Bayern ............................................. Berlin ............................................... Brandenburg .................................... Bremen ............................................ Hamburg .......................................... Hessen ............................................ Mecklenburg-Vorpommern ............... Niedersachsen ................................. Nordrhein-Westfalen ........................ Rheinland-Pfalz ................................ Saarland .......................................... Sachsen ........................................... Sachsen-Anhalt ............................... Schleswig-Holstein .......................... Thüringen ......................................... Total… 10 543 10 415 6 819 1 378 1 034 2 704 5 676 1 468 6 251 13 930 2 996 1 368 4 646 2 268 1 850 2 163 75 509 8 892 8 895 6 148 1 215 945 2 511 2 208 1 379 5 485 12 370 1 894 925 4 233 2 120 1 732 2 008 62 960 64 64 4 3 123 2 175 18 927 289 4 666 1 587 1 456 667 163 89 193 345 87 591 1 542 175 154 413 148 118 155 7 883 1 048 944 411 95 81 151 262 50 402 972 103 124 238 111 94 109 5 195 69 46 32 10 8 11 12 3 23 79 9 6 16 5 4 9 342 539 512 256 68 8 42 83 37 189 570 72 30 175 37 24 46 2 688 Type of university General or technical university ........ Pedagogical university ..................... Theological University ...................... Art college ........................................ Polytechnic ....................................... College for administration ................. 59 820 770 88 3 210 10 935 686 49 452 736 82 2 550 9 530 610 3 727 135 735 69 6 641 34 6 525 670 7 4 824 24 164 180 3 176 1 107 58 - 1 817 10 6 361 490 4 Source: Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006) Personal an Hochschulen - Daten zum Hochschulpersonal, Personalstellen und Stellenäquivalente sowie Habilitationen an deutschen Hochschulen im Berichtsjahr 2005. The female proportion is 35.7 percent of all foreign academics with a regular employment contract, and 14.6 percent among foreign professors at German universities. Comparing this to the overall numbers for Germany cited in the introduction to Section 2, which were taken from the She Figures (European Commission 2006), 13.6 percent female professors and 25 percent female academic staff, one can certainly not state that female proportions are lower for foreigners than for Germans. However, these numbers might not be too meaningful in the present context, because the dichotomy “German” and “foreign” is clearly very simplistic. It is quite likely that many of the female foreign researchers come from the EU or have established their academic careers in the EU or America before they arrive in Germany. There is also no way of distinguishing Page 25 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 visiting academics from those with a permanent position at the German universities. Finally, PhD students at German universities are counted as employees of the university. All these factors tend to misrepresent situation, and information on the potentially disadvantaged groups (A) and (B) mentioned in Section 2.1 is not really accessible in this way. The data of the microcensus 2005 (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland, Wiesbaden, 2006e), has been analysed in ths paper with respect to differences between first and second migrational generations, both foreigners and Germans. The microcensus gives the numbers of PhD students (which is of course different from, but related to, the number of succesful PhD exams cited above) and a group category of job titles labelled “professors, researchers” which should come quite close to the total of the academic staff at universities and publicly funded research institutes, although it may include some staff of industrial research departments too. The table below depicts the proportion of PhD students and of researchers within the total population as well as in the first and second generation migrant groups, and the female percentages in each case. The microcensus provides information on how many researchers work on temporary contracts. As a caveat it should be mentioned that the statistical errors in the second generation data can be relatively high because of the smallness of the sample. Table 16: Proportions of PhD students and researchers according to the microcensus 2005 Total population perc. within group 1st generation mig. fem. perc. perc. within group 2nd generation mig. fem. perc. perc. within group fem. perc. PhD students 0.09% 40.89% 0.19% 41.90% 0.08% 36.67% Researchers 0.67% 41.50% 0.57% 42.24% 0.21% 35.98% ...with temporary contract 0.17% 42.42% 0.27% 37.75% 0.06% 45.92% Source: Extracted from the data provided by the Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland on Microcensus 2005. These numbers suggest the following tendencies: - The proportion of PhD students within first generation migrants is higher than in the total population. This can be explained by students who came to Germany especially to do a PhD. The percentage of women PhD students is slightly higher for immigrants than for the total population. - The proportion of PhD students within the second generation is comparable to the proportion in the total population. However, the female percentage is considerably lower. - Immigrants are not drastically under-represented among researchers (which is related to the increasing importance of foreign students and highly qualified immigrants), but they are mostly on temporary contracts. - The second generation migrant group is drastically under-represented among researchers. Page 26 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 . 4. Structure of the higher education and research system 4.1. Professional hierarchy in higher education Traditionally, a typical career at a German university would have progressed along the following steps: • After obtaining a university entrance certificate from upper secondary school the student enrols for a university degree. Many courses do not have any admission restrictions, for others one has to apply to the university or to a central allocation office. The criteria for deciding about applications are school results, social factors, waiting times, and others. Foreign students have to prove the equivalence of their school certificates to the German one, and in most cases sufficient knowledge of the German language. • Most courses take about 5 years where the final year is often used for writing a dissertation. The final degree is called Diplom for mathematics, science, and engineering, Magister for arts and humanities, and Staatsexamen for pedagogy, law, and medicine. • If a professor agrees to take over the function of a supervisor, the student can start with a doctoral thesis. The cooperation beween supervisor and PhD student is normally very close. Apart from working at the topic of the thesis, the PhD student does not necessarily have to sit in lectures or follow courses. Most PhD students finance their living not through grants but through regular research employment at the university – mostly on a part-time basis. These jobs are formally not different from the jobs of postdoctoral employees. For this reason, those PhD students are practically seen as members of the academic staff, rather than students. As already mentioned, they are counted as academic staff in all statistics, and they are also included in the target groups for this study. The duration of working at a PhD thesis is normally between 3 and 5 years. • There are a few, but not many, permanent jobs in non-professorial positions at universities (in particular there are practically no permanent lecturer positions). However, the majority of non-professorial positions are temporary and meant as intermediate steps in the further career towards a professorship. Typically, it is expected that people who want to follow such a career spend several years at universities abroad. The final step before one can apply for a professorship is normally a Habilitation, a postdoctoral lecture qualification advocated by a professorial supervisor and granted by the university faculty based on a thesis which sums up extensive own work and publications in a special area of expertise. In practise the requirement of a Habilitation makes postdoctoral researchers strongly dependant on their advocate. • After the Habilitation the researcher can apply for a professorship. There are essentially two types of professors, normally named by their salary grades: W2 (former C3) professors (the lower grade) and W3 (former C4) professors (Chairs or directors of institutes). One can apply for a W3 professorship without being a W2 professor, but many W2 professors will want to get W3 positions. In each of these steps, the female percentage among the researchers goes down, so that at the Page 27 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 end presently just 10 percent of the top positions are held by women. The numbers represent a typical gender pyramid. Table 17: Female percentages in academic career stages – 2005 total foreigners W3/C4 professors 10% all professors 14% habilitations 23% academic staff (employed and contracted) 33% 39% PhDs exams 40% 38% students 48% 50% university entrance certificates 56% 56% 15% Source: Extracted from the data provided by the Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland on Microcensus 2005. While this table vividly presents the unequal conditions for women in an academic career, it is not appropriate for substantiating amplified problems for foreign women. The statistical figures ought not to lead to the assumption that the problems faced by foreign women are qualitatively similar to those of German women. It is more likely that while there are common issues for women of different backgrounds, nevertheless there are minority groups among foreign women who do experience amplified problems which result in even lower female percentages. In the course of the ongoing Bologna process of harmonising higher education within the EU the typical research career described above is about to change in at least two points: the first is that the 5 year course length leading to a Diplom/Magister/Staatsexamen will be split into a 3 year Bachelor course and a 2 year Master course, and the second one is the replacement of the Habilitation by introducing new temporary positions as Assistant Professors as qualifying step for a professorship. It has been speculated that the introduction of Bachelor degrees might be negative for women, as it introduces one more step into the career at which the female percentages could shrink another time. The abolition of Habilitations might have rather a positive effect, since it should decrease the power of the presently male dominated faculties in the decision about who qualifies for a professorship. In any case both changes should have positive effects for foreign researchers as they simplify the international acceptance of academic degrees. 4.2. Professional hierarchy in research The situation at research institutes (see Section 2.2 for number of employees) is not drastically different from the situation at universities, which is not surprising as typical research careers are not confined to one or the other type of institutions. Page 28 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 It is very common that the top staff of research institutes also teach as professors at universities, and that they recruit research staff for the institutes from their students. On the other hand, the intermediate level staff of research institutes often want to obtain a Habilitation and therefore have to cooperate with a university faculty. There are no published numbers about the female proportions among the foreign staff at research institutes. However, for comparison of the gender relation to the situation at universities the following table is useful (Bund-Länder-Kommission zur Bildungsplanung und Forschungsförderung, 2006).The employees are categorised by salary grade – W3/C4 for the directors of institutes, W2/C3 for a lower professorial level, 15-14 TVöD for senior nonprofessorial staff, and 12 TVöD for junior non-professorial staff. As one can see, at the top level, the under-representation of women is still quite noticeable, with the negative record in the technically oriented Fraunhofer institutes and somewhat more favourable impression of the smaller institutes of the Leibniz-Gemeinschaft with a high representation in humanities. Table 18: Female percentages of employees at public research institutes 2005 MPG* S (W3/C4) 5.9 S (W2/C3) 21.8 BAT I (I-Ib), 15-14 TVöD 24.3 BAT II a, 12 TVöD FhG* 1.5 WGL* HGF* All institutes 6.4 3.5 4.9 11.9 9.8 18.7 16.3 7.5 18.9 18.2 29.0 21.4 45.5 23.4 32.3 PhD students 40.2 31.9 48.1 43.2 42.7 Overall 32.0 20.9 35.2 25.7 28.0 * MPG means Max-Planck institutes, FhG Fraunhofer Gesellschaft, WGL Leibniz Gemeinschaft, and HGF Helmholtz Gemeinschaft, the four large associations of publicly funded research institutes in Germany mentioned in Section 2.2. Source: Bund-Länder-Kommission zur Bildungsplanung und Forschungsförderung (2006) Frauen in Führungspositionen an Hochschulen und außerhochschulischen Forschungseinrichtungen. 4.3. Rules and practices of recruitment As public employers, universities and the above mentioned research centres have been following formal equality rules concerning gender for more than a decade, as required by respective state laws. Equal opportunity measures for the disabled date back even longer. While discrimination on grounds of various characteristics is nominally condemned by the constitution, for a long time there was a lack of concrete regulations and measures against discrimination. The recent General Act on Equal Treatment (Bundesgesetzblatt, 2006) may have given a new impetus to the way in which equality can be put into practice. However, the law is too new to judge its effectiveness. Gender equality is institutionalised at all universities through an equal opportunities officer or commissioner (Gleichstellungsbeauftragte). It is obligatory to advertise posts in a gender Page 29 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 neutral way and to include a paragraph encouraging women to apply. The inclusion of a similar phrase encouraging disabled applicants is legally even more binding. The equal opportunities commissioner has the right to monitor all staffing procedures. Female applicants who were not considered for a job have a right to compensation if a man who had no better qualification for the job was taken. In reality, it is often the case that for junior and intermediate positions like those given to PhD students and junior postdoctoral researchers such formal recruitment procedures are not taken very seriously, as the professors concerned often formulate the job requirements very specifically tailored for some candidate whom they have picked out already beforehand among their students or by recommendation of colleagues. Where this happens, the equality procedures can be easily negated. The filling of professorships is regarded as a far more sensitive matter. Most universities have committed themselves to shortlist at least as many female as male applicants – if there are enough female applicants, and the interview panel is supposed to consist of an equal number of men and women. The statistics of recent years (Bund-Länder-Kommission zur Bildungsplanung und Forschungsförderung, 2006) show that these measures do have an effect. Table 19: Filling of professorships 1997 – 2005 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 62,731 61,622 61,698 71,756 70,689 8,108 8,464 9,159 12,230 14,460 12.9 13.7 14.8 17.0 20.5 6,172 5,593 6,078 6,744 5,627 women 903 869 967 1,200 1,269 female percentage 14.6 15.5 15.9 17.8 22.6 2,073 1,730 1,492 1,616 1,088 women 326 262 236 291 279 female percentage 15.7 15.1 15.8 18.0 25.6 men and women applications women female percentage men and women shortlisted men and women appointed Source: Bund-Länder-Kommission zur Bildungsplanung und Forschungsförderung (2006) Frauen in Führungspositionen an Hochschulen und außerhochschulischen Forschungseinrichtungen. The percentage of women among the shortlisted candidates is consistenly higher than the female percentage among all applicants, and the female percentage among the actually apointed professors is again higher. The increase of that percentage over the last years is quite remarkable. Nevertheless, the percentage still does not come close to mirroring the proportion of women among the students. Also it must be noted that the number of professorships to be filled decreases constantly – and this means that the improving ratio of newly appointed female professors will have only a muted effect on the percentage of women among the all Page 30 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 present professors. There are no similar statistics on the proportion of migrants among applicants on professorships. Now that the General Act on Equal Treatment requires all employers (public and private alike) to ensure not only equal treatment of women and men during all recruitment procedures, but also to rule out racially or ethnically motivated discrimination, it is likely that at least some of the measures already established in the gender context will be put into action also in regard to migrational minorities. Already now some university administrations have adviced their staff to avoid in job advertisements all formulations that could be regarded as a disadvantage to non-German applicants – like language requirements which are not absolutely necessary as German language is in fact one of the greatest hinderance for migrants in Germany, which makes the situation here quite different from countries like France or the UK, where large migrant groups are native speakers of the local language. The new Immigration Act (Bundesgesetzblatt, 2004) has generally simplified the procedures for foreigners who want to work in Germany. People from outside the EU do not have to apply for a separate work permit through the Job Centre any more, but the type of resident status determines already whether a person is allowed or not allowed to work in Germany. People from within the EU have the same rights as Germans on the job market anyway – with the exception of members from those countries which joined the EU in 2004, who still have to apply at the Job Centre for a work permit. Nevertheless, German bureaucracy, especially in the Civil Service, has a reputation for being unduly fastidious, and while there might be no mandatory obstacles towards giving a job to a foreigner, the actually or assumed higher effort necessary on the side of the employer or the employee might have an off-putting effect. Most senior ranks at German universities and research centres, in particular professors, are Civil Servants with a special legal status, called Beamte. By federal and state laws, Beamte must normally be German or nationals of an EU member state. Well-founded exemptions are explicitly possible, and if a university faculty wants to fill a vacant professorship with a foreign candidate, exemptions are always granted. But the fact itself that a foreign applicant is treated as an exception from a rule can be seen as a disadvantage in the recruitment process. 5. Studies on Women Scientists 5.1. Quantitative Information Research on migrant groups in Germany is remarkably gender blind and is still very much restricted to the stereotype themes of migration and cultural identity. There are some studies that address the issues of discrimination in education and the labour market, but they tend to concentrate on the performance of migrant children in schools and the problems young people face in the labour maket, without focussing on a particular profession or sector (see Bibliography). One study that does look at highly qualified migrant women, Intellektuelle Migrantinnen – Subjectivitäten im Zeitalter von Globalisierung (Intellectual Women Migrants – Subjectivities in the Era of Globalisation) by Encarnación Gutiérrez Rodríguez, but it is a theoretical discussion of the tension between constructions of ethnicity and gender. No studies on women scientists with minority or migrant background, and their position in academic or research organisations could be identified in the course of this project. Page 31 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 5.2. Resutls of the Electronic Survey In order to collected some quantitative information on women scientists of minority or migrant backgrounds in Germany, an electronic questionnaire was designed and the women’s networks were asked to forward this questionnaire to the women from target groups or to send the names and contact details of the women concerned and then these women were contacted directly. (For the English and German versions of the electronic questionnaire, please see Appendices 1 and 2). From over 50 electronic questionnaires sent to networks and individuals, only 10 women scientists of migrant or minority background sent back a completed form. The pariticpants were assured complete confidentiality. The women scientists answering the survey had Russian, Polish, Serbian, Taiwanese and Turkish backgrounds, and only two of them were born in Germany and although 4 of them now have a German nationality. The age range of these women was from late 20s to early 30s, and those in the 20s were likely to be PhD students. All but 3 of the women were married, and of these 3 had children – two women had one child and one had two children. The 3 women who had been born in Germany had done their first university degree in Germany, the rest had completed their intial university education in their countries of origin; however, they were all fluent in German. The range of subjects covered by these women included Physics, Metallurgy, Galvanotechnic, Neurology, Pedagogy, Law, Sociology and Housing. All the 8 women working in Germany had temporary contracts; of the other two, one had a permanent contract and the second had a Professor post, and they both had these positions in their home countries. All the women expressed a great commintment to their disciplines and said that they had discovered from very early in their lives an interest in their subjects and had followed it through. Most women mentioned both family and academic superiors and colleagues as sources of support in their careers. Six women reported as having expereinced problems both due to gender and ethnicity, while an additional one mentioned having faced difficulties due to gender and another one only due to her foreign or migrant background. This is interesting because it indicates that women who are aware of the issues of race and gender discrimination are prepared to speak about them and can equally well distinguish between them, although it is a complex issue. Among gender discrimination, the two women with children referred to incompatibility between professional life and motherhood, and pointed to the lack of childcare facilities in Germany, especially for foreign women who do not have their family in this country. One of these women said that the time for which the university meetings were fixed did not take into account her responsibilites as a mother. The fact of having a child was often indirectly referred to in job interviews and employers seemed ot be more concerned thie person’s domestic situation rather than her competences. Having a child also restricted the women’s chances of travelling to other countries as a visiting academics, and one of these women believed that gender discrimination was likely to be more intense when one applied for higher level jobs. Other women mentioned having experienced sexist comments from their colleagues and superiors, not being taken seriously by the men who they worked with, and being assigned work that was not challenging enough and conveyed the low expectations of their bosses. The women who had made a career in physics and engineering expressed how their interest in scientific and technical subjects was not encouraged although they were the best pupils in their class. As to discrimination or disadvantages arising from coming from another cultural background, Page 32 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 one woman academic summed it up as follows, “It was sometimes difficult to get access to information. In the beginning the whole system was unfamiliar and I constantly had the feeling that I did not know something, but I did not what that was, that I had missed something, or did everything wrong . . . Nobody was interested in what I did or asked how I could use the knowledge from my (home country) in Germany. They tried to push me to research on migrant issues instead of mainstream ones.” Lack of access to information and the feeling of being excluded from the working culture was mentioned by other women too. Another woman said that her work was always received with scepticism beause she came from a non-EU country. In the job market, she had the impression that those with German nationality were given preferential treatment intead of selecting on the basis of qualifications, and the interviewers expected perfect knowledge of German although this was not clear in the job advertisement. Some of the women also remarked that their qualifications from their countries of origin were devalued in the perceptions of their colleagues. When describing positive experiences, all women mentioned help from colleagues or seniors, which is not surprising because professional success is deeply connected with a supportive working environment. Three women identified gender discrimination as playing a significant role in their careers and another 3 found discrimination due to their migrant background to have been more evident; one woman said that race and gender discrimination magnified each other. All the women believed that their knowledge and experience of a culture outside Germany gave them a different perspective on their subjects and fields of work, and two women also said that their disciplines would benefit from a female point of view. A couple of women were conscious of being role models for others in their community. Three women aimed to have a university career, 2 in the private sector and the rest were equally open to both public and private sectors. As to what kind of services would be useful for women scientists with a migration background, the suggestions included – information and counselling services to give women guidance on procedures and career possibilities, networks that provide access to academic and research institutions, awareness raising among professors and heads of organisations, working towards chaniging attitudes, career development training for minority women, support in dealing with domestic difficulties, information on access to funding and availability of grants for minority groups, and initiatives for girls from minority groups at the school level to encourage them to pursue higher education. Page 33 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 References: Akman, Saro, Oktober 2005) Migrationshintergrund und Geschlecht bei Bewerbungen in Personalführung, 72-75. Akman, S, Gülpinar, M, Huesmann, M und Krell, G (2005) Auswahl von Fach-und Führungsnachwuchskräften: Migrationshintergrund und Geschlecht bei Bewerbungen in Personalführung, 72-76. Auferkorte-Michaelis, Nicole, Metz-Göckel, Sigrid, Wergen, Jutta, Klein, Annette (2005) Junge Elternschaft und Wissenschaftskarriere. Wie kinderfreundlich sind Wissenschaft und Universitäten? in: Zeitschrift für Frauenforschung und Geschlechterstudien, Heft 4, pp. 1423. Bundesagentur für Arbeit (2007) Analyse des Arbeitsmarktes für Ausländer, Februar 2007, Nürnberg. Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge (2006a) Migrationsbericht des Bundesamtes für Migration und Flüchtlinge im Auftrag der Bundesregierung (Migrationsbericht 2005), Nürnberg. Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge (2006b) Migration, Asyl und Integration in Zahlen, Nürnberg. Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge (2007) Pressemitteilung 0001/2007: Zugang von Asylbewerbern im Jahr 2006 nochmals gesunken, Nürnberg. Bundesgesetzblatt (2004a) Gesetz zur Durchführung einer Repräsentativstatistik über die Bevölkerung und den Arbeitsmarkt sowie die Wohnsituation der Haushalte, Bonn. Bundesgesetzblatt (2004b) Gesetz zur Steuerung und Begrenzung der Zuwanderung und zur Regelung des Aufenthalts und der Integration von Unionsbürgern und Ausländern, Bonn. Bundesgesetzblatt (2006) Allgemeines Gleichbehandlungsgesetz, Bonn. Bundesgesetzblatt (2007) Staatsangehörigkeitsgesetz in der im Bundesgesetzblatt Teil III, Gliederungsnummer 102-1, veröffentlichten bereinigten Fassung, zuletzt geändert durch Artikel 2 Abs. 1 des Gesetzes vom 19. Februar 2007, Bonn. Bundesministerium des Inneren (2004) Zweiter Bericht der Bundesrepublik Deutschland gemäß Artikel 25 Abs. 2 des Rahmenübereinkommens des Europarats zum Schutz nationaler Minderheiten, Berlin. Bundesministerium des Inneren (2005) Zuwanderungsrecht und Zuwanderungspolitik, Berlin. Bundesministerium des Inneren (2007) Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Umsetzung aufenthaltsund asylrechtlicher Richtlinien der Europäischen Union, Berlin. Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (2006a) Bundesbericht Forschung 2006, Berlin. Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (2006b) Frauen in Bildung und Forschung, Bonn. Bundesverwaltungsamt (2006) Aussiedlerstatistik seit 1950, Köln. Bund-Länder-Kommission zur Bildungsplanung und Forschungsförderung (2006) Frauen in Führungspositionen an Hochschulen und außerhochschulischen Forschungseinrichtungen, Materialien zur Bildungsplanung und Forschungsförderung Heft 136, Bonn. Page 34 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 European Commission (2006) She Figures 2006 – Women and Science Statistics and Indicators, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg. Gölbol, Yeliz (2007) Lebenswelten türkischer Migrantinnen der dritten Einwanderergeneration : eine qualitative Studie am Beispiel von Bildungsaufsteigerinnen, Centaurus, Herbolzheim. Haug S., Schimany P. (2005) Jüdische Zuwanderer in Deutschland, Working Papers 3/2005, Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, Nürnberg. Hummrich, Merle (2002) Bildungserfolg und Migration: Biographien junger Frauen in der Einwanderungsgesellschaft, Leske + Budrich, Opladen. Hummrich, Merle (2006) Zwischen Familie und Schule? Rekonstruktionen von Biographien bildungserfolgreicher Migrantinnen in Gender und Globalisierung, Hrsg. Renate von Bardeleben und Patricia Plummer, Stauffenburg, Tübingen. INBAS GmbH (2006) Lebensentwürfe junger Migranntinnen im Berufsorientierungsprozess. Quantitative und Quaslitative Erfoschung ihrer Lebenssituation bezogen auf die Stadt Offenbach am Main, Offenbach. Informationen der Beauftragten der Bundesregierung für Migration, Flüchtlinge und Integration, Herausgeberin (2005) Daten-Fakten-Trens: Bildung und Ausbildung, Berlin, in Zusammenarbeit mit dem efms – Europäisches Forum für Migrationsstudien, Bamberg. National Association of Software and Service Companies, NASSCOM (2006) in Highlight – Women in IT, Ofner, Ulrike, Akademikerinnen türkischer Herkunft - Narrative Interviews mit Töchtern aus zugewanderten Familien, (Bisher unveröffentlichte) Dissertation, FU Berlin 2002 Rodríguez, Encarnación Gutiérrez (1999) Intellektuelle Migrantinnen – Subjectivitäten im Zeitalter von Globalisierung, Leske + Budrich, Opladen. RWTH Aachen, 2006, RWTH International – Internationalisierungsreport 2006, Dezernat für Internationale Hochschulbeziehungen und Dezernat Planung, Entwicklung und Controlling, Aachen. Schmidt-Koddenberg, Angelika und Sclich, Christina (Feb 2006) Intekulturelle Kompetenz als Resourcen für die Berufswahlorientierung von Mädchen und jungen Frauen mit Migrationshintergrund, Katholische Fachhochschule Nordrhein-Westfalen. Sephocle M. (1999) “Afro-Germans and National Identity”, in L. T. Hopkins (ed.), Who is German? Historical and Modern Perspectives on Africans in Germany, American Institute for Contemporary German Studies, Baltimore, pp.43-54. Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006a) Ausländische Bevölkerung, Ergebnisse des Ausländerzentralregisters, Fachserie 1 Reihe 2 – 2006, Wiesbaden. Statistische Bundesamt Deutschland (2006b) Bildung und Kultur – Allgemeinbildende Schulen, Fachserie 11 Reihe 1, Wiesbaden. Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006c) Einbürgerungsstatistik, Wiesbaden. Statistisches Bundesamt (2006d) Lange Reihen – Wanderungen Deutschland 1950 – 2005, Wiesbaden. Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006e) Mikrozensus 2005, Wiesbaden. Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006f) Personal an Hochschulen - Daten zum Hochschulpersonal, Personalstellen und Stellenäquivalente sowie Habilitationen an Page 35 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 deutschen Hochschulen im Berichtsjahr 2005, Fachserie 11 Reihe 4.4, Wiesbaden. Troltsch, Klaus (2002) Migranten und Migrantinnen in Deutschland - ein Vergleich zu Bildungsbeteiligung und -chancen junger Erwachsener mit Migrationshintergrund, Heft 8, BiBB, Bonn. Westphal, Manuela (2004) Migration und Gernderaspekte: Feminisierung internationaler Migration, Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung, Berlin. Worbs, S., Wolf M., Schimany, P. (2005) Illegalität von Migranten in Deutschland, Working Papers 2/2005, Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, Nürnberg. Zentralstelle für Arbeitsvermittlung der Bundesagentur für Arbeit (2005) ZAV-Jahresbericht 2004, Bonn. 6. Policies, measures and programmes There are no concrete policies relating to migrant and minority groups in employment, although there are some moves to develop such policies and procedures following the introduction of the General Act on Equal Treatment in August 2006. 6.1. Good practices The one area in which Germany, to some extent, has well developed policies and measures, is with regard to gender equality. Although the measures for gender equality are not flawless and have not necessarily achieved the desired results, there may be sense in linking gender equality with equality for migrant and minority groups. The most persuasive argument for doing this would be to use the structures that already exist in the service of all underrepresented groups – women and minority groups. Secondly, the effort to overcome racial and ethnic discrimination is likely to give a fresh impetus and added strength to intiatives for women’s equality. Finally, and most compellingly, combining various forms of discrimination provide for ways of better understanding the relation between various different factors of discrimination rather than seeing gender or race or ethnicity in isolation from one another. This is clearly required as in the case or scientific women with migrant or minority backgrounds. The good practices that exist with regard to gender equality, and can also be considered with regard to minority and migrant women are: i. Collection of statistical data and monitoring of the data; ii. Establishment of profession specific networks with their particular newsletters; iii. Measures and initiatives such as mentoring programmes, training workshops and conference; iv. Resources for research funding. 6.2. Bad practices Recruitment in German universities and research organisations, while formally correct, is not a transparent process and mechanisms for investigations or complaints of unfair treatment are unwieldy. The equality commissioners and officers are not always full-time posts, and Page 36 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 therefore people responsible for ensuring fair recruitment are either not involved in the complete process or are too short of time to monitor the process. The one level where the equality procedures are strictly applied is in the recruitment of professors, but these understandably are not likely to affect the majority of migrant or minority women. Moreover, the equality commissioners have more advisory roles rather than enforcement powers. The various steps of recruitment – from job description, advertisement, selection procedures, interviews and appointment - are not necessarily monitored or regulated. As a consequence, there is significant scope for informal decisions in recruitment and appointment and the sense of public accountablity in this area is relatively weak. The university system is obviously patriachal, even in its everday discourse where PhD supervisors are officially referred to as “PhD fathers”. Professors and chairs of institutes still have it in their individual discretion to give small jobs and temporary research posts, and hold the power to make or break careers. Then there are many jobs, particularly to do with the Beamte status such as teachers and professors, where there is an explicit or implicit age limit. Age discrimination clearly affects women more harshly than men in that it does not provide for career breaks, and in the case of migrant or minority women, does not take account of time lost in mobility. 7. Existing academic/scientists networks As part of the project, all the women’s networks mentioned in the Directory of Networks of Women Scientists 2003, published by the European Commission were contacted for information on migrant or minority women’s networks or contacts to migrant women professors. This was supplemented by internet search and networks mentioned on the NEWS website. No migrant or minority women’s professional networks were identified. Only two women with migrant backgrounds in professorial positions were located – Prof Aylâ Neusel, a first generation migrant who has retired as professor from the University of Kassel; and Prof Anita Bose-Pfaff, Professor at the University of Augsburg, and at nearly retirement age. Prof Neusel is a Professor of Architecture, is a first generation migrant from Turkey, who studied in Germany. She went through the German system smoothly and successfully, which she attributes to her good command of the German language and her relationship to her German husband. Prof Bose-Pfaff is a Professor of Economics and daughter of an Indian freedom fighter and an Austrian mother. She is therefore a second generation person with migration background. 8. National specificity 9. Recommendations i. Development of a comprehensive policy on equality for minority and migrant groups in employment; ii. Commitment from all German universities and research institutes to comply with a strong equality policy; iii. Obligation to collect statistics according to categories that are meaningful for people Page 37 of 38 NEWS project - Deliverable 6 German Report April 2007 with migrant or minority backgrounds at national and institutional levels, and setting of targets in the framework of these statistics; iv. Establishment of a transparent recruitment process with an objective investigative and complaints procedure embedded in it; v. Giving responsibility to equality commissioners not only for gender but also for race and ethnic equality; vi. Provision of necessary resources and powers to the equality commissioners to make them effective in their work; vii. Provision of relevant training and awareness raising measures for the equality commissioners and for senior staff at the universities; viii. Relaxation of age (age discrimination is forbitten by the European directives, then it should be comply with anti-discrimination law) and qualitfication conditions that are not essential to the job; ix. Inclusion of migrant and minority women in the women’s professional networks that already exist and the support provided by them; x. Making research grants available to women returning to research or academic careers after a break due to having children; xi. Development of more research on issues of discrimination in relation to specific groups; xii. Change in the working practices at universities so as to make them friendlier to the lives and priorities of women. Page 38 of 38