Critical Perspectives – Ottawa 2015

Fifth National Conference
Critical Perspectives: Criminology and Social Justice
Cinquième Édition de la Conférence Nationale
Criminologie et justice sociale : perspectives critiques
Université d’Ottawa / Pavillon de la Faculté des sciences sociales
120, rue Université
28 et 29 mai 2015
University of Ottawa / Faculty of Social Sciences Building
120 University Private
May 28-29, 2015
Pour souligner la cinquième édition de la conférence, l’évènement se déroulera cette
année sous un thème général : Le passé, le présent et l’avenir de la criminologie critique
au Canada. Des panels et des activités spéciales sont organisées pour célébrer cet
anniversaire. Il s’agit d’une occasion privilégiée pour les participants qui souhaitent
échanger sur les enjeux et les défis de la criminologie critique au pays.
Celebrating its fifth edition, the conference will be organized this year under the general
theme Past, Present and Future of Critical Criminology in Canada. Panels and special
events are organized to celebrate this anniversary, offering a great opportunity for
participants to share their views about the stakes and challenges of critical criminology
in Canada.
Organizing Committee / Comité Organisateur
Deborah Conners
Aaron Doyle
Maritza Felices-Luna
Lara Karaian
Jennifer Kilty
Maeve McMahon
Justin Piché
Bastien Quirion
Prashan Ranasinghe
Diana Young
Financial support / Soutien financier:
Université d’Ottawa / Département of criminologie
Université d’Ottawa / Faculté des sciences sociales
Carleton University /Department of Sociology and Anthropology
Carleton University / Department of Law
Carleton University / Institute of Criminology and Criminal Justice
The conference is free and open to the public.
No registration required, but please sign our e-mail list.
La conférence est gratuite et ouverte au public.
Aucune inscription n'est requise, mais prière d’inscrire votre nom sur notre liste e-mail.
Updated program information will be posted here:
Une version révisée du programme est disponible sur le site suivant :
http://sciencessociales.uottawa.ca/crm/details-evenement?id=1168
Critical Perspectives Critiques - 2015
-1-
SOCIAL EVENTS / ÉVÈNEMENTS MONDAINS
Opening Night Reception – Réception d'ouverture
Mai 27 from 7 p.m. to 10 p.m. – le 27 mai de 19h à 22h
Avant-Garde Bar / 135 Besserer St. / Ottawa / (613) 321-8908
Everyone is invited to our opening night reception inaugurating the Fifth annual "Critical Perspectives:
Criminology and Social Justice" conference jointly organized by criminologists from Carleton University
and the University of Ottawa. The reception is co-sponsored by the Journal of Prisoners on Prisons and
the Criminalization and Punishment Education Project.
Vous êtes cordialement invités par le Journal des prisonniers sur les prisons ainsi que le Projet
d'éducation sur la criminalisation et la répression à une réception pour inaugurer la cinquième édition
de la conférence "Criminologie et justice sociale : perspectives critiques» organisée conjointement par
les Départements de criminologie à l'Université Carleton et de l'Université d’Ottawa.
Conference Closing Night Event – Soirée de clôture de la Conférence
Artists For Justice : Open Stage & Art Exhibition
Les Artistes Contre La Répression de L’état : Scène ouverte et exposition d’art
May 29th at 7:00pm -- 29 mai à 19h00
Café Nostalgica, 603 rue Cumberland, Université d’Ottawa -- (613) 562-5800 x3000
Everyone is also invited to the conference closing night party and open-stage arts event, organized by
the Criminalization and Punishment Education Project. Come raise a beer or glass of wine. The event will
feature musicians, poets, visual artists and others. Come for dinner and a drink and support local artists!
Wheelchair accessible. Anyone interested in joining the open stage or contributing artwork can contact
Adina [email protected] / 613.875.8881 / www.facebookwww.cp-ep.org.
Vous êtes cordialement invités à la soirée de clôture organisée par le Projet d'éducation sur la
criminalisation et la répression où des musiciens, poètes, artistes visuels etc. partageront avec nous
leurs œuvres sur une scène ouverte. Si vous voulez participer en présentant un numéro sur scène ou
une œuvre d’art, veillez contacter Adina [email protected] / 613.875.8881 / www.cp-ep.org.
Fernwood Publishing
Please visit the Fernwood Publishing book display in the Lobby of the Social Sciences Building. Fernwood
Publishing publishes critical books that inform, enlighten and challenge. We believe in books that
challenge the status quo and imagine new ways forward.
Vous êtes invités à visiter le kiosque de Fernwood Publishing dans le hall d’entrée du Pavillon des
Sciences sociales. Fernwood Publishing publie des ouvrages critiques qui ont pour but d’informer,
d’éclairer et de remettre en question.
Critical Perspectives Critiques - 2015
-2-
THURSDAY, MAY 28, 2015
Room FSS 1006
May 28 2015
Thursday
28 mai 2015
Jeudi
8.30 -9.30 am
9.30 – 11.00 am
11.15 – 12.45 pm
Room FSS 7003
Room FSS 5027
Prison Tourism in Canada: On the
Production, Communication and
Consumption of Penality (Part I)
Women, Stigma and Identity /
Femmes, stigmates et identité
Sex Work / Travail du sexe
Break / Pause
Break / Pause
Break / Pause
Prison Tourism in Canada: On the
Production, Communication and
Consumption of Penality (Part II)
Current Research on Miscarriages
of Justice: Investigation, Evidence
and Compensation
Crimes in Media / Crimes dans les
média
OPENING CONFERENCE / CONFÉRENCE D’OUVERTURE
TITLE TO BE ANNOUNCED
HOWARD SAPERS
CORRECTIONAL INVESTIGATOR OF CANADA
ENQUÊTEUR CORRECTIONNEL DU CANADA
Policing and New Technology /
Police et nouvelles technologies
Chair:
Policing and Social Control in an Era of New
Media
Christopher J. Schneider, Wilfrid Laurier
University
The Object(ive) Participant: Cellphone
Cameras and Police Encounters
Marcus A. Sibley and Michael-Anthony Lutfy,
Carleton University
The Rise of UAV Drones in Police Work:
Regulation, Application, Deployment and
the Impact of Unmanned Air Vehicles on
Policing in Canada, 1995-2015
Scott Thompson and Alana Saulnier, Queen's
University
Reclaiming Visual Sovereignty: A Critical
Look at Faces and Surveillance
Justin EC Tetrault, University of Alberta
11.00 – 11.15 am
Room FSS 5028
Break / Pause
Policing Dissent, Resistance and
Radicalization / Contrôler la
dissidence, la résistance et la
radicalisation
Critical Perspectives Critiques - 2015
-3-
Chair: Justin Piché, University of Ottawa
Tour Guide Styles and Penal History
Museums in Canada
Kevin Walby, University of Winnipeg
The Intersections between State
Punishment and Its Memorialization
Shanisse Kleuskens, University of Ottawa
Captor/Captive Representations in
Canadian Penal History Museums
Ashley Chen, University of Ottawa
Sarah Fiander, Wilfrid Laurier University
From Shame to Fame – ‘Celebrity’
Prisoners and Prison Tourism
Devon Madill, University of Ottawa
Chair: Kevin Walby, University of Winnipeg
Chair / président: Sylvie Frigon, Université
d’Ottawa
“Deadly
Women”:
Exploring
Media
(Re)Presentations of Women who Kill
from a Feminist and (Audio)Visual
Perspective
Isabel Scheuneman Scott, University of Ottawa
La performativité du genre en prison
: entre neutralisation et différenciation
Sophie Cousineau, Université d’Ottawa
Tell Me Everything: ‘Truth’ Discourse and
the Construction of the Confessional Sex
Offender
Adina Ilea, University of Ottawa
Breaking the Fourth Wall: An Exploration
into Engaging with Criminalized Women
Through Theatre
Elise Merrill, University of Ottawa
Chair: Maeve McMahon, Carleton University
Chair / président: Diana Young, Carleton
University
The Police and Marginalized Women: The
Case of Racialized Indoor Sex Workers
Menaka Raguparan, Carleton University
Risk Management Through Behaviour
Management at Strip Clubs
Tuulia Law , University of Ottawa
“Cause nobody wants to listen”: Hearing
the Voices of Women in Street-level Sex
Work in Edmonton
Laura Aylsworth, University of Alberta
Chair / président: Bastien Quirion, Université
d’Ottawa
Chair / président:
The Costs of Policing Summit Dissent:
Toward a Critical Political Economy of the
Toronto G20 Pacification Project
Nicholas Lamb, Carleton University
Symbolic Power and the Political Field: An
Analysis of Canadian Institutions Regarding
the Technologicalization and Militarization
of Contemporary Police Services in Canada
Zachary Andrei Leheniuk, University of Ottawa
Radicalization of Environmentalists:
Unmasking the Pacification in Canada
Christopher Howell, Carleton University
The Radicalization Industrial Complex?
Orientalism and New Landscapes of the
Security Imaginary
Jeffrey Monaghan, Queen’s University
Adam Molnar, Deakin University (Australia)
12.45 – 1:45 pm
Critical Punishment Memorialization in
Canada
Justin Piché, University of Ottawa
Prison Tourism Marketing, Networks and
Souvenirs in Canada
Alex Luscombe, Carleton University
Reflections of Penal Spectatorship on
Social Media
Matthew Ferguson, University of Ottawa
Carceral Relics as Social Darwinian
Narrative: Academic Tourism of the Penal
Other
Vicki Chartrand, Bishop University
Deborah Landry, University of Ottawa
The Ethics of Undercover Police
Operations: Perspectives of Criminal
Justice Officials on the use of the ‘Mr. Big’
sting
Jordan Bateman, University of Ottawa
Innocence Compensation: Private Law
Principles for Public Law Remedies
Myles McLellan
Similar Fact Evidence and Wrongful
Convictions: Can ‘bad characters’ be
innocent until proven guilty?
Sina Menz
Right to Silence: The Limits of Canadian
and Scottish Criminal Law
Kathryn M. Campbell, University of Ottawa
Frozen Justice: Visualizing Crime and
Criminal Justice in Canadian Crime Films
Steven Kohm, University of Winnipeg
James Gacek, University of Manitoba
La construction de la nouvelle autour du
fait terroriste : étude de cas de
l’évènement d’Ottawa en octobre 2014
Valentine Crosset et Masarah-C. PaquetClouston, Université de Montréal
The Injustice of Honour: A Canadian News
Media Analysis of the Shafia Murder Trial
Kelsey Burrow, University of Ottawa
(Re)Writing Criminals: Incorporating
Comic Books into Criminology Discussions
Michelle K Barron, Carleton University
DÎNER POUR TOUS (HALL D’ENTREÉE) / CATERED LUNCH (LOBBY)
Room FSS 1006
Room FSS 5028
The Bail and Remand Crisis and
Terrible Conditions at the Ottawa
Carleton Detention Centre: Causes,
Chair: Prashan Ranasinghe, University of Consequences, and Working For
Ottawa
Change
May 28 2015
Thursday
28 mai 2015
Jeudi
Negotiating Compassion:
Contemporary Issues around
Homelessness
1.45 – 3.15 pm
Domination, “Resistance”, and
Homelessness Masculinities
Dale C. Spencer, Carleton University
“Protecting People’s Ability to use Public
Places”: A Socio-Spatial Analysis of the
Ontario Safe Streets Act
Kristy Buccieri, Trent University
The Illegality of Homelessness in Ottawa
Anita Grace, Carleton University
The Materiality of Order and the Aesthetics
of an Ethic of Care
Prashan Ranasinghe, University of Ottawa
Critical Perspectives Critiques - 2015
-4-
Chair: Aaron Doyle, Carleton University
The Right to Reasonable Bail: Examining
the Use of Conditions in One Ontario Bail
Court
Diana Grech, University of Leeds
The Remand Crisis and Jail Crowding
Catherine Latimer, John Howard Society
An Ex-Prisoner’s Perspective on OCDC
Lee Chappelle, Canadian Prison Consulting
Community-Engaged Sociology and The
Ottawa Carleton Detention Centre: How
can we Work for Change ?
Room FSS 7003
Police Practices Under Surveillance
/ Pratiques policière sous enquête
Chair / président:
Policing Youth Outside the Metropolis:
Police Perspectives on Policing Youth and
Youth Attitudes Towards the Police
Gina Molleson and Rose Ricciardelli, Memorial
University of Newfoundland
Michael Adorjan, University of Calgary
Projet de loi 46 : Une réponse à quels
problèmes ?
Pierre White, Université d’Ottawa
Peaking Behind the Curtain: Accessing the
Backstage of Security Intelligence Threat
Assembly
Alex Luscombe
and Michael-Anthony Lutfy,
Carleton University
Lessons from Pickton : “It’s a Sociological
Room FSS 5027
Discrimination and Violence
Against Women / Discrimination et
violence envers les femmes
Chair : Lara Karaian, Carleton University
(Re)Presentations of Sexual Violence
Against Women: A Feminist Analysis of
Media Reports of Rape
Danica Ujevic, University of Ottawa
Partner Abuse Response Programs in
Ontario: What good are they?
Deborah E. Conners, Carleton University
Voices Unheard: The Invisibility of Women
in Policing Race in Canada
Andrea Anderson, York University
Aaron Doyle, Laura McKendy, Melanie
MacDonald, Nicoletta Michalopoulos, Chanel
Mrad, Nicole Robertson, Tracey Seed, Diana
Wade, and Megan Witkowski, Carleton
University
The Experience of Imprisonment in
Ontario: A Personal Reflection of
Conducting Research in Prison
Rachelle Larocque, Cambridge University
Issue?”
Patricia O’Reilly and Thomas Fleming , Wilfrid
Laurier University
3.15 – 3.30 pm
Break / Pause
Break / Pause
Break / Pause
3.30 – 5.00 pm
Challenges and Opportunities in
Policing Research
Financial and Political Crimes /
Criminalité financière et politique
Canadian Courts and the Charter of
Rights / Tribunaux canadiens et
Chartes des droits
Chair: Dale Ballucci, Western University
‘Two Steps Forward, No Steps Back’:
Today’s Welcoming of Academic Research
in Canadian Policing
Gregory R. Brown, Carlton University
Should Opinion Surveys be Used to Measure
Police Performance?
Remi Boivin, Université de Montréal
Corporate Security Creep and the New
Security Credentialism
Kevin Walby, University of Manitoba
Randy Lippert, University of Windsor
From Knowledge to Action? The Youth
Criminal Justice Act and use of Extrajudicial
Measures in Youth Policing
Hayley Crichton, Memorial University
Rose Ricciardelli, Memorial University
Liam Swiss, Memorial University
Laura Huey, Western University
Critical Perspectives Critiques - 2015
-5-
Chair / président:
La criminologie critique à l’épreuve de la
délinquance financière : Perspectives
foucaldiennes
Anthony Amicelle, Université de Montréal
Examining Endarkened Governance Texts
Through a Neofascism/Neocorporatism
Lens
Palmer Taylor, York University
John E. Deukmedjian , University of Windsor
Argent, violence, genre, racisme et
contrôle social paramilitaire à Monts de
Marie et au Golfe de Morrosquillo en
Colombie
Gabriela Manrique Rueda, Université de
Montréal
Unethical and Unlawful Behavior by
Pathological Financial
Institutions: Implications for Human
Rights and Social Justice
Stephen Schneider, Saint Mary's University
Chair / président: Bastien Quirion, Université
d’Ottawa
Le plaidoyer de culpabilité : une décision
libre et éclairée?
Chloé Leclerc et Elsa Euvrard, Université de
Montréal
Balancing the Extrem-ities: A Genealogical
Approach to Governance Through s.24(2)
of the Canadian Charter of Rights and
Freedoms
Garrett Lecoq, Carleton University
Les rapports de force lors des
négociations des plaidoyers de
culpabilité : Analyse du point de vue des
avocats de la défense
Elsa Euvrard et Chloé Leclerc, Université de
Montréal
The Surveillant Charter and Canada’s
Judicial War on Invisibility
Richard Jochelson, University of Winnipeg
Break / Pause
FRIDAY, MAY 29, 2015
Room FSS 1030
May 29 2015
Friday
29 mai 2015
Vendredi
Room FSS 5028
Room FSS 7003
Room FSS 5027
KEYNOTE SPEAKER / CONFÉRENCIER INVITÉ
POLICING ON CAMERA
KEVIN HAGGERTY
9.30 – 10h.30 am
DEPARTMENT OF SOCIOLOGY
UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA
10.30– 10.45 am
Break / Pause
Break / Pause
Break / Pause
Break / Pause
10.45 – 12.15 pm
Practicing Critical Criminology
in Manitoba: The Work of the
Manitoba Research Alliance
Regulation of the Body and Health
Issues / Régulation du corps et
enjeux de santé
Alternative Justice and
Mediation / Justice alternative et
médiation
Chair: Elizabeth Comack, University of
Manitoba
Fear ‘In Here’ and ‘Out There’: Coping
with Stress and Struggling with Stigma
in Prison and Community Settings
James Gacek, University of Manitoba
Governing and Resisting through
Community: Alternative Justice
Programs for Criminalized Women
Amanda Nelund, University of Manitoba
Social Insecurity in an Increasingly
Punitive Society: Public Support for
Neoliberal Policies
Jill Patterson, University of Manitoba
Criminology’s Time: Critical
Reflections on the Temporality of
Harm at the Assiniboia Residential
School
Andrew Woolford, University of Manitoba
Chair / président: Sylvie Frigon, Université
d’Ottawa
Policing Harm Reduction Spaces: Mapping
Drug Regulation in Downtown Ottawa
Lisa Wright, Carleton University
Legal Interpretation and Hermeneutics of
Jurisdiction in a Public Health Crisis in
Canada
Amy Swiffen, Concordia University
The Right to Die and Public Constructs of
the Body
Diana Young, Carleton University
Chair / président: Bastien Quirion,
Université d’Ottawa
La médiation scolaire au primaire :
limites et enjeux de l’implantation
Jennifer Grenier et Catherine Rossi,
Université Laval
“Locking Up Our Own “: Radical
Alternatives to Imprisonment for First
Nations Persons
Thomas Fleming and Patricia O’Reilly,
Wilfrid Laurier University
Les mutations propres à certaines
pratiques de médiation pénale au
Québec : signes de résistances
environnementales et de compromis
opérationnels?
Pascal Dominique-Legault et Catherine
Rossi, Université Laval
Pourquoi est-il si difficile de réduire le
recours à la prison? Une étude de cas
Mariana M. Raupp, Université d’Ottawa
Challenges in Reforming Prison
and the Penal System/ Défis de
la réforme des prisons et du
système pénal
Critical Perspectives Critiques - 2015
-6-
Chair / président: Justin Piché, Université
d’Ottawa
NPO Advocacy at Risk? Financial
Dependency, Demand for Service
Provision and Legislative Constraints in
the Canadian Punishment Sector
Victor Sokolov, University of Ottawa
Critical Positivists and Charitable
Sociologists of Deviance: Systems,
Persons, and the Critique of Canadian
Penal Habits in the 1930s and 1960s
Joel Kropf, Carleton University
Anti-terrorism, Criminal Law and
Prison in France Today: A Critical
Perspective
Gilles Chantraine, Université Lille 1
(France)
Jean Bérard, Université de Montréal
Double Alliances and 'Helping' in the
Penal Voluntary Sector
Abi Tsionne Salole, Griffith University
(Australia)
12.15 – 1.15 pm
May 29 2015
Friday
29 mai 2015
Vendredi
DÎNER POUR TOUS (HALL D’ENTRÉE) / CATERED LUNCH (LOBBY)
Room FSS 1030
Room FSS 5028
Room FSS 7003
Room FSS 5027
Critiquing the Critical:
Methodologies, ‘Experts’ and
‘Voice’
Stripped Down and/or Banished :
Law, Citizenship, Extradition and
Resistance
Regulation Through Space,
Territories and Infrastructures /
Régulation par l’espace, le
territoire et les infrastructures
Prisons, Prisoners and
Community / Prisons, détenus et
communauté
Chair: Diana Young, Carleton University
From the Margins of the Women's
Movement: Using Critical Criminology
to Centre Indigenous Feminist
Activism on Violence Against Women
in Canada
Jennifer Fraser, The Graduate Institute of
Geneva
Insider/Outsider: Researcher, Expert,
Spectacle?
Olga Marques and Adam Ellis, University of
Ontario Institute of Technology
Exploring Critical Criminological
Methods: Creating Space for
Indigenous Methodologies in
Criminology
Lisa Monchalin, Kwantlen Polytechnic
University
Chair: Prashan Ranasinghe, University of
Ottawa
Stripping Citizenship and Deporting the
Undeportable: This is the Case of Deepan
Budlakoti
Josh Hurschka, Carleton University
Deepan Budlakoti, Stateless Canadian
Researching, Organizing and Resisting
Statelessness
Claire Delisle, University of Ottawa
Maria Basualdo, OPIRG
Window or Aisle? Socio-legal Reflections on
Extradition Law in Canada, and its
Implications for Human Rights
Maeve McMahon, Carleton University
The Constitution of Secret Trials
Graham Hudson, Ryerson University
2.45 – 3.00 pm
Break / Pause
Break / Pause
3.00 - 4.00 pm
CLOSING PANEL / PANEL DE CLÔTURE
THE FUTURE OF CRITICAL CRIMINOLOGY IN CANADA / L’AVENIR DE LA
1.15 – 2.45 pm
CRIMINOLOGIE CRITIQUE AU CANADA
Chair: Aaron Doyle, Carleton University
SYLVIE FRIGON, UNIVERSITÉ D’OTTAWA
BRYAN HOGEVEEN, UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA
LAURA HUEY, UNIVERSITY OF WESTERN ONTARIO
ANDREW WOOLFORD, UNIVERSITY OF MANITOBA
Critical Perspectives Critiques - 2015
-7-
Chair / président:
The Pacification of Favelas of Rio de
Janeiro: A Neoliberal Twist to an Oldfashioned Intervention
Pier Angelli De Luca Maciel, University of
Ottawa
La police et le maintien de l’ordre
public au Congo Kinshasa (1960-1990)
Kakudji Mbavu, Université d’Ottawa
Testing Boundaries: Exploring Gang
Territories as Spatial Forms
Amelia Curran, Carleton University
The Logics of Logistics: Managing
Critical Infrastructures as National
Security
Tia Dafnos, York University
Break / Pause
Chair / président: Justin Piché, Université
d’Ottawa
Investigative Documentary as Critique?
Understanding the Role of Narrative in
the CBC Fifth Estate documentaries on
the Ashley Smith Case
Charissa Weir, University of Ottawa
Frontline Criminology: Incorporating
Personal Experiences into Graduate
Research
Samantha McAleese, Carleton University
How Long Will they be Forgotten?
Prisoners’ Relatives and Prison
Research
Gwenola Ricordeau, Université Lille 1
(France)
Female Masculinity: Its Influences on
Gender Norms, Prison and Recidivism
Rates
Victoria Ginsley, University of Ontario
Institute of Technology
Break / Pause